To what extent did we overcome
barriers and build bridges?
Arts therapies and Diversity CPD Day – June 18th 2011 Increasingly frustrated by the lack of access diverse groups are given to the arts therapies, it seemed timely to aim to create a forum in which arts therapists from different modalities could explore together the dilemmas people might be facing, perhaps more challenging during a recession, using the metaphor of ‘barriers and bridges’. Last year, art therapy group, ‘Art, Race and Culture’, held a day to bring together arts therapists to explore diversity. It was a flowing, organic ‘fusion’, which spawned the idea of making it an annual event. BADth’s ‘Equality and Diversity Sub-Committee’ committed to hosting it this year. We aimed to give each participant the opportunity to work through a modality that differed from their own training, to pool expertise, share good practice, make new connections and support each other, and find effective ways of communicating the relevance of arts therapies to funding agencies and employers. It seemed crucial to make the day accessible to as many arts therapists as possible by keeping the price low. The Gordon Wiseman Fund awarded the project £400. This grant, and the decision to hold the event in one hall, similarly to the previous year, enabled us to keep the costs as low as possible.
38 people attended, including 27 dramatherapists and 11 from various arts therapy, social work or educational backgrounds. There were 10 facilitators, representing
Art
Therapy,
Dance
Movement
Psychotherapy, Dramatherapy, Music Therapy and Systemic Therapy.
Several barriers arose in the months approaching the day, resulting in a series of telephone conferences and meetings, some of which felt inspiring and creative, others which felt disconnected and bewildering. The day itself mirrored the organizational process, ebbing and flowing between true connection, seemingly insurmountable barriers, and then back to a sense of bridge-making between arts therapists. Participants’ responses reflect this disparity. The Structure of the Day
The warm-up comprised a dramatherapeutic exploration of commonalities using sound and movement, followed by creative expression of barriers and bridges through Dance Movement Psychotherapy and Music, and concluded with Art Therapists’ invitation to
participants to choose and decorate a box, to represent their inner and outer selves, their willingness and resistance. Participants then chose two arts therapy workshops, with lunch in between. The day concluded with process work facilitated by a systemic therapist, feedback from the workshops, further reflection on ways of articulating the importance of arts therapies within a context of diversity to employers, and finally the creation of a ritual to express the learning of the day, utilizing the decorated boxes to create a bridge. I aim to explore the day through the comments of its participants, based on 38 evaluation sheets, and conclude with my own reflections. Main Benefits of the Day
Many people commented on the importance of connecting with the different modalities: ‘joined up working, experiencing and connecting with different modalities and exploring my own resistance.’
‘the opportunity to work with other arts therapies and to connect with other professionals, to be creative as a way to nourish and inform my work. To affirm and make connections in the art forms themselves.’ ‘meeting other arts therapists and listening to their stories. Keeping me rooted in my profession. Remembering.’
‘making connections to other arts therapists, playing and
experimenting
with
different
modalities,
playing with all four approaches, thinking about our values, resources and identity in all that.’ Many commented on feeling they had re-awakened their creativity and on feeling nurtured and nourished by the day.
The most useful thing:
The Dramatherapy workshop, which used Forum Theatre to explore diversity in the workplace was very well received:
‘ideas from Boal that I can carry back into my working situation.’
‘The sculpting and improvised scene work around oppressions. I found this very powerful and particularly valued the witnessing aspect of it too.’ ‘the reminder of the power of Boal, working with stimulating and creative people.’ The Dance Movement Psychotherapy and Art Therapy workshops were highly valued:
‘I enjoyed the Dance Movement Therapy workshop immensely. The teacher/leader was great.’ ‘I found the dance move workshop stimulated a lot of thinking for me and has helped me to think about my planning for insets in school around a workshop on connections, talking to others and sharing ideas.’ The box metaphor was appreciated: ‘I really enjoyed making my box. Having the opportunities to make contact with other arts therapists.’ ‘Making/thinking about boxes. Talking, thinking, working with others. Listening. Making something significant from scratch.’
‘The creativity. The theme. The coming together of our creations (the boxes) and having this as a thread throughout the entire workshop.’ Further points
‘Would have loved to have done all 4 workshops – that would have been perfect – instead of going away with a feeling of regret that I missed 2 important and inspiring workshops. Perhaps a day and a half next time. Loved having all modalities together. Thank you. More of them please.’ ‘Sharing experiences with others/organic work/ integrity/connecting-disconnecting-connecting.’
What could have been improved?
Having all 4 workshops in one space was a big issue for at least a third of the participants and a huge challenge for those with hearing difficulties. For others, the themes of ‘diversity’ were not adequately addressed. A number of the participants found the level of some of the workshops insufficiently challenging. Others would have liked more processing time and requested more such workshops:
‘Not sure all the workshops in one space worked quite as well as it could. Sometimes noise levels detracted from some focused work.’ ‘There was not much time for verbal reflection but then, maybe that was the point!’ ‘Maybe integrating more of how we may link our culture, diversity through discussion as well at the end. Connecting the experience with reflection.’ Overall, the response was positive: ‘A lovely day. Very nourishing and greatly appreciated – working in isolation means this day is even more relevant and helpful for supporting connections.’
Reflections
One dramatherapist viewed the struggle for space and difficulties hearing as symbolising something of the struggle that arts therapists often deal with on a daily basis. It’s always difficult to balance financial accessibility with available space. Perhaps this was a compromise too far, which had somehow worked last year, but which was constraining and awkward for many on this occasion.
This workshop revealed a thirst within arts therapists for exploring diversity issues, for collaborating with other modalities, for learning from each other. It also revealed a lot of outstanding work undertaken by arts therapists in this country and overseas, for which there needs to be a further forum for sharing. The whole group work, with its metaphor of creating bridges together, using individually created boxes was a powerful closing ritual. The statements created to support employers in understanding the importance of the arts therapies in working with a diverse population will provide a useful tool. Whilst the event illustrated that it’s not always easy for therapists of different modalities to work together, enduring connections were formed with a range of arts therapists and their professional associations. The Dance Movement Psychotherapy team have offered to organise the event next year. In Paulo Coelho’s blog of August 11th 2010, he uses the metaphor of a mountain, rather than a bridge: ‘Mountains are often seen from far off – beautiful, interesting, full of challenges. But what happens when we try to draw closer? Roads run all around them, flowers grow between you and your objective, what seemed so clear on the map is tough in real life. So try all the paths and all the tracks until eventually one day you’re standing in front of the top that you yearn to reach.’
http://paulocoelhoblog.com/2010/08/11/manual-forclimbing-mountains-3/ Much took place that was beautiful, interesting and full of challenges. Next time, perhaps differing paths will elicit fresh insights.
Many thanks for invaluable support from Bruce Bayley, Ditty Dokter, Gemma Gil, Rebecca Heather, Gillian Stott, to art therapists, Cherry Lawrence and Julie Watson for input into the planning and/or help on the day, to Heidi Jockelsen for her meticulous organization, to the facilitators, and to the Gordon Wiseman Fund.
Mandy Carr
BADth Equality and Diversity Sub-Committee Convenor