October 2012
Seven Dramatherapy supervisors from the London and South East area gathered for our most recent meeting on Saturday 29th September, in our lovely venue near Baker Street. Our informal meeting involved not only sharing supervision issues, but also sweet and savoury nibbles, fruit, tea and coffee.
We set an agenda based on what individuals wished to discuss, and then had a time of introductions, as not everyone knew each other.
The items for exploration that morning included an update on the potential for the next National Supervisors’ Day; making a therapy/supervision “will”; charges for supervision and sliding scales; the use of movement and body work in supervision; supervision of a short-term group for non-arts therapists; discussion on the handover of responsibility in overseeing the LDSF e-mail account. Finally, we made a date for our next meeting – Saturday 26th January 2013, from 10am (for a 10.30 start) till 1pm. Any BADth and/or Sesame registered supervisor in the London and South East who is not currently on our e-mail list, and would like to be added, please contact contact form and we hope to see you at the next meeting.
Jane Jackson
The London Dramatherapy Supervisors Forum (LDSF)
FORENSIC ARTS THERAPIES
ADVISORY GROUP
Arts Therapies Forensic Conference, London Monday 7th November 2011 – 9.30am to 4.30pm The focus of the conference was on research. There were fewer FATAG members in attendance than usual. For many, the reasons were that a Monday was not a good day but I also wondered if the topic had put people off. Throughout my training, I have had a sense that art therapists are quite frightened of the word ‘research’. It can feel a daunting process to undertake as it seems to be a relatively new idea within art therapy but the pressure is on to prove that we are worth the money we cost to employ. The underlying theme of the day seemed to be an encouragement to take on research as part of our job and that it can be very interesting stuff. As a profession we are slowly building a base of research and adapting the way we work in response to a changing job market. The day was positive and inspiring with presentations from three very different pieces of research at different points of their journey. I gained an understanding that research can be a creative process, using different research methods and evaluation techniques. The presentations helped to demystify and open up what research can mean. The first presentation was from Simon Hackett. ‘Process – outcome research’ using an experimental single-case study design to investigate the efficacy of Art Psychotherapy with adult offenders who have intellectual and developmental disabilities. He started by introducing the question “What is it within the therapy that works?” The aim of the study was to measure change, measure processes that support change and see if there is a link between outcome, process and theory. A literature search on ‘art therapy’, ‘learning disability (LD)’ and ‘offenders’ brought up three papers: McKenzie (2000), Manners (2005) and Rothwell (2008). Hackett went on to describe his “research smorgasbord”. The presentation contained a lot of new information, which was incredibly interesting but too much to hold onto to represent here, hinting at the amount of work it takes to plan and develop a research piece. His method was rigorous and he was able to produce qualitative and quantitative data. Psychology students, nursing staff and nursing assistants all collected different kinds of data which could be cross analysed to get a better
October 2012
understanding of why there would be a dip in a graph showing someone’s mood level, for example. His conclusions were: outcome research is a priority; it is possible to look at complex processes; we should not only be measuring that our patients are getting better but that we should also be looking at what it is within the therapy that works; let data tell the story. Presentation number two was from Angeles Fiallo Montero. Her research was part of her MA, completed September 2011. ‘Acceptance Dance, an inquiry into the process of Dance Movement Psychotherapy (DMP) with young people in custody’. This presentation aims to give an insight and introduction of DMP in Young Offender Institutions (YOIs). It was a qualitative study of 4 boys in a group aged 16–18 who were serving life sentences. The presentation explored the range of responses to the therapy and there was an interactive section for the conference attendees which helped to visualise what DMP can be. After 14 weeks of therapy the participants each had an interview with planned questions to get feedback. The two very different presentations being in juxtaposition provided difference and contrast and showed different strengths in each. For example Hackett’s use of graphs in illustrating change was powerful alongside Fiallo Montero’s connection with the humanness of a DMP encounter. It made me wonder how can we think about using graphs without losing the human quality that makes this research held as so important. A short interlude for a business meeting continued some trains of thought about how arts therapies can contribute to the wider picture not just through research but by perhaps inviting people to FATAG conferences to support people in understanding what it is that the arts therapies do and why it is so good. Some concerns were about confidentiality with the curious general public. It was suggested that perhaps one conference a year could be aimed at interested people and the other at the professions. It was noted that art therapies had been invited to other psychology conferences so could we return the idea? The final presentation of the day was from Stella Compton Dickinson and Victoria Sleight who are music therapists. ‘Developing “context specific” treatment’. Group cognitive analytic music therapy (g-camt): A mixed methods, controlled feasibility trail at Rampton high secure hospital. Stella talked of how she wanted to see if it would be possible to do some ‘hard science’ research within arts therapies so she followed already available medical research guidelines for her research. She has been working on this for 10 years, putting such a lot of time and energy into it and it is still awaiting completion. Cognitive analytical therapy (CAT) techniques were used in the research alongside music therapy. What they do have now is a highly approved research project. The two groups were matched from a research point of view to a range of demographic data; due to randomisation they were not matched from a therapeutic clinical point of view, thus they were challenging groups to run, but this made for rigorous research methodology. The final presentation by Stephanie Turner was unfortunately cancelled. ‘Seeing Insecurity. An exploration of the witnessing act in Dramatherapy with male offender-patients’. “This presentation concerns the first ever dramatherapy intervention in a high secure forensic facility in Scotland. It aims to illuminate the research and therapeutic journey undertaken during my final year clinical placement with a male forensic population, juxtaposing the mirroring and reflective function of therapy with the surveillance tasks of security. Stephanie Turner has a background in theatre and applied theatre practice. She qualified as a Dramatherapist in 2010 having completed her MA in Dramatherapy at Roehampton University.” The day was brought to a close in a plenary by sharing some thoughts and questions that were raised: What can we do day to day if we do not have research support? Is research helpful or harming to patients? Arts therapies need to be developing research. Is research about keeping our jobs? How we brand ourselves is important; we cannot be seen to be being precious. Getting patients to think cognitively is very different to art making. Getting people to think is what arts therapies can do when patients cannot. Linking in to neurology is important.
The research presented was the beginning of longer journeys into the subject area where more research is needed to continue the discussions and improve validity.
Rose Hall, Trainee Art Therapist References
McKenzie, K. (2000) Working with sex offenders who have a learning disability.
International Journal of Art
Therapy 5:2 pp. 65–69
Manners, R. (2005) “It must be an honour to drive.” Issues of difference, loss of normality, power and disempowerment. M. Res. Thesis. London: Goldsmiths Rothwell, K. (2008) What Anger? Working with Actingout Behaviour in a Secure Setting in Art Therapy and Anger ed. Liebmann, M. Jessica Kingsley Publishers: London
October 2012