August 2012
The International Centre for Arts
Psychotherapies (ICAPT)
Launch of the Research in Arts Psychotherapies University Alliance
The following are extracts
from the talk given by
Dominik Havsteen-Franklin.
November 2011 saw the opening of the new arts psychotherapies centre for training and engagement with research: ICAPT. We have grown in reputation and have consolidated many of our initial findings based on the best evidence available to us. We have offered training to 80 post-qualifying students and will continue to offer training, placements and internships. Ratings so far have been excellent, getting better each time. On average trainees self-rated their skills and knowledge improving by an average of 24%. But this is only part of our vision towards developing better standards of practice for Art, Music, Drama and Dance Movement Therapies, evidence based practice and recognition of the excellent work that we do in the NHS.
Our vision is that all arts psychotherapists successfully have a scientific knowledge. This means in the way that we think about our work: evaluation, marrying technique with intuition, creativity with cause and effect and quantitative evaluation with qualitative understanding. In my experience of teaching and presenting at conferences, arts psychotherapists do not naturally think of themselves as scientists, not because we do not demonstrate a capacity to see things in a scientific way, but because of the historical anomalies that have left us feeling that the two are separate. I am talking about the first art therapists who threw caution to the wind. We needed the pioneers to make a radical break from the medical norms, but now we need pioneers to take steed and to look at the phenomenal research work that is happening in pockets of the arts psychotherapies communities – these are a new kind of adventurer.
A leading example is Professor Peter Fonagy who identified and continues to identify, through science, core agents of change in psychotherapy. I am also thinking about the late Tony Wigram who developed new methods for analysing the minutiae of musical dynamics, Professor Helen OdellMiller who has continued to pursue a similar commitment with her team in Cambridge, Professor Diane Waller who bravely helped to design the first ever large scale Randomised Controlled Trial in Art Psychotherapy. Also, Professor Helen Payne who continues to build and promote better models of dance movement practice especially for medically unexplained symptoms through scientific endeavour. Lastly, Phil Jones with his work with arts therapies with children with social, emotional and behavioural difficulties.
ICAPT recently saw the launch of its research initiative: ‘Research in Arts Psychotherapies University Alliance’. This alliance is being set up to help arts therapists prepare their ideas and submissions for PhD applications. So far we have nine Universities engaging in the scheme, offering guidelines and entry criteria as well as helping to link together research initiatives. We are interested in receiving people who are interested in doing research. We cannot fund PhDs but we can offer our support free of charge. We can also offer a clinical context in which to pursue the research.
The speakers during the evening included: Robyn Doran, Professor Peter Fonagy, Dominik Havsteen-Franklin, Anna Maratos and Professor Helen Payne.
Dominik
Havsteen-Franklin
August 2012
The idea that we are scientists should not come as a surprise if you think of the role of creativity in research. As Einstein once famously said, in “The Evolution of Physics”, To raise new questions, new possibilities, to regard old problems from a new angle, requires creative imagination and marks real advance in science. A good example of this is the German organic chemist, Friedrich August Kekulé von Stradonitz (7 September 1829–13 July 1896), who discovered the Benzene chemical structure based on a dream of a snake eating its own tail. At the same time as Braque developed the cubist painting method of looking at an object from relative positions, Einstein developed the theory of relativity. Any innovative scientific endeavour requires drama, enactment and vision.
We cannot say that there is an exact representation in the arts of the measured observation. However, there is good evidence to suggest that gaining access to non-verbal forms of communication informs an understanding of reality. Not simply what we observe to be true or not true, but new insights. My own PhD studies are on the processes of metaphor. Much like Kekulé, who discovered a metaphor for his chemical structure, patients often need to find a metaphor for what is happening in their world, their history and their future. It is arguable that metaphor precedes cognition and that metaphor is image based. Of course I speak as an art therapist, but images are not only the physical ones in front of us, they are also the less tangible ideas inside that can be brought into the open, can evolve and become new insights about peoples lives, feelings and thoughts through music, drama and dance movement. All arts psychotherapists share this and the inherent communication in common. We use different sensorial modalities to access and bring to life the inner world of the patient. The attunement to these processes by the arts psychotherapist who is versed in the arts language is what makes the difference. We attune ourselves through art, music, drama, body movement.
Peter Fonagy so beautifully put at the launch of ICAPT, Because there is this, to my mind, overlap between what is most human in what you guys represent, as arts therapists, and what’s most human to me about any kind of mental disorder, that these two domains coming together in a therapeutic endeavour, informed by science, is going to be the next step change’. This might sound a bit ambitious to some. But we are standing in a place where ambition, creativity and vision are what makes our NHS Foundation Trust stand out. I don’t think that the establishment of a University Alliance for arts psychotherapies could happen in any other mental health trust.
The next step change is a vision that requires all of us to act together, to bring our
knowledge, resources and
capability to this single aim
of creating the foundation for
the future of arts psychotherapists working in mental health. This means that we
need
researchers,
PhD
supervisors
to
receive
students, academic advisors
and training programmes to
work together.
The alternative is that mental health loses something that is so important to patients – we know this from our patient feedback and surveys and interviews, such as the interview methods that Neil Springham has pioneered. I have not heard anybody who has experienced arts psychotherapies say that it was not helpful in their experience. It is up to us, not the patient, to tell the scientific community in exactly what ways. Right now it is particularly important to describe with clarity how it works, in practice and in theory. I can think of dozens of arts therapists that have said this very thing, including professors such as Helen Payne and Peter Fonagy here, and others such as Andrea Gilroy, Tony Wigram and Phil Jones. It is now time to make the difference, not only for the patient, but for the profession; where researchers and their projects that are happening now can be linked together; where the arts psychotherapies professions learn from one another, without becoming one another; where we build upon the research that is already out there. Equivalent professions have 10% of their practitioners going on to do PhDs. All psychologists have professional doctorates. If we do not respond to the situation as a collective force, we will be left behind, sadly, not because of the standards of practice, but because we need to offer transparency of process and a scientific perspective. We are playing a small part in this, helping students to prepare for doing PhDs through giving the time and placement setting to explore and consolidate their ideas before making an application. We also host and lead on a number of medical and psychological research programmes that often need support and will help the student to become better acquainted with the research world. We have a wide network of researchers, which we are using to develop our research database. As an NHS Trust why are we doing this? Because we stand to benefit through encouraging an inspirational research culture that feeds into our practice, builds bridges with the larger research community, strengthens our clinical outlook and involves service users in new developments. This project is a way forward for all of us. Dominik Havsteen-Franklin
For further information, see advert on page 27. Professor Peter Fonagy
August 2012
August 2012