The behaviour tells the story

The behaviour tells the story

The Prompt, June 2012 · by Kate Cairns · page 33-37

June 2012

The behaviour tells

the story

Children who have lived through trauma and lacked the environmental support needed for recovery will be different from their peers in many aspects of daily life. The disorders that follow trauma are so global in their impact that disorder becomes the new normality.

Children in this situation often say that they just want to be normal; what they mean is that they want to be like other children, children who have not been radically changed by traumatic stress, for in truth it is normality itself which has been distorted for traumatised children. For the child this experience of perpetual fear is seamless. One way or another it is the fear that produces the whole range of signs and symptoms we can observe. Hyperactivity: life in perpetual motion Sleeping patterns are disturbed, frequently with nightmares and night terrors. Children may be unable to get off to sleep, or they may wake up at irregular hours. Some children find it hard to go to sleep, but then are exhausted in the morning and find it hard to get up. Children may be constantly on the go, and constantly seeking a high stimulus environment, quickly becoming bored. Their attention will be limited, and carers learn to speak in short sentences. Concentration will also be difficult, as perceptual fields are attuned to threat, and both vision and hearing tune out from tasks which are not threatening. It is hard for traumatised children to see a page of print, when their peripheral vision is scanning the environment for threats. And they will lose the natural human preference for the human voice, as their hearing automatically tunes out non-threatening sounds. Hypervigilance is a symptom of traumatic stress, and it makes for very jumpy children who find it difficult to feel settled anywhere. In a new or strange setting, they will be scanning every aspect of the environment for potential threats, so any change to daily living patterns is exhausting for them. They cannot take it for granted that others are trustworthy, so that any accident, injury or illness may lead to a breakdown of the fragile structures of trust. I have seen children well established in placement who became terrified when carers needed to remove a splinter or wash a wound.

Dissociation: splitting up is sometimes not so hard

There are various defences the beleaguered mind may use to try to protect against the continuing stress injury. One which some children may already have in place as a result of their attachment experiences is the defence of dissociation. Whether it is an existing strategy, or newly discovered under the impact of the trauma, it is an effective defence to get through the immediate impact of the stress. Unfortunately it has longer-term effects which can be devastating to the personality.

The capacity to split awareness so that at least part of the self is kept safe through even the most painful and destructive experience means that humans are able to be very resilient. Unfortunately it also means that we can disintegrate and still function. We are self-aware beings, and we relate to our environment through our consciousness; when that consciousness splits apart the personality is radically fragmented.

Sometimes the splitting, although persistent, is purely trauma-related, the self creating a fragment to contain the trauma that will exist alongside the everyday consciousness but only be active when confronted with another traumatic event. People thus affected speak of entering a different type of consciousness, which they recognise as continuous with previous trauma-related consciousness but not continuous with everyday awareness. This is a relatively benign level of dissociation, although any dissociation at the point of trauma is a risk factor increasing the likelihood of disorder.

For others the impairment of ordinary functioning as a result of dissociation is much more profound. These are people for whom the separated parts of personality become as it were persons in their own right. These victims of disorder are likely to attract the label of dissociative identity disorder (DID). The outlook is particularly grim for children who dissociate in response to trauma, for

June 2012

they are much more likely to develop lasting disorders, and even more so for those for whom dissociation is already a fixed response to stress as a result of early attachment experiences.

Children who dissociate are not only difficult to engage in a real relationship, but also it is almost impossible to ascribe responsibility to people who cannot communicate between the different parts of their personality. These are children who are seen by adults to do something, are caught red-handed and who say with total innocence “but it wasn’t me!”. And they are so clearly convinced of their innocence that stable, sensible adults may still be left with the uncomfortable feeling that perhaps their own senses are letting them down.

Children do tell lies to save face in awkward situations, but children who dissociate tell the truth as they see it. It is the utter belief in their own innocence which can fracture the sense of reality of any adult trying to make sense of the situation. These fragmented parts of personality can be observed in everyday life for some children. It is disconcerting to be with children who may speak in different voices, like different foods, use a different vocabulary, have different habits and tastes and generally give the impression of living with several people at the same time all wrapped in one skin.

Again it is the social self that suffers most. It is in our relationships, the people we are in relation to others, that we need some sense of continuity, some assurance that there is a person there to know. The work of relating to others is complex and puzzling at best, and it becomes impossible if the other seems to have no steady centre to engage with. Avoidance of trigger stimuli: what you don’t know is there can’t hurt you

Avoidant children will avoid any thing, situation or person who may trigger the re-experiencing of traumatic stress. Since post-traumatic stress disorder leads to so many objectively neutral stimuli being experienced as triggers, this becomes an increasingly disabling aspect of the disorder.

Children may avoid certain lessons at school, or they may avoid school altogether. They may avoid lunches, or certain foods, or eating. They may avoid having baths, or going to the toilet, or going to bed, or getting up, or people in green cars. In short, anything at all that might ever have acted as a prompt to a hair-trigger sensitive limbic system may come to be the next object of avoidance. Remember that for avoidance to work it has to be internally explained so that the avoidant person never suspects that they are “not-thinking” about the trauma. These explanations will then be clung to with passion. “I hate that teacher”, “I felt ill”, “I forgot”, “I had to do something else”, and so on and on go the reasons why it was impossible for them just to behave like other children. And if it is pointed out that hundreds of others manage to go to the lesson each week whatever they think of the teacher, the response will be overt or covert distress. The children know that they are behaving differently from their peers. They want to be normal. It is their normality which is distorted, and that is deeply painful if they must confront it.

Transference and counter-transference: what doesn’t hurt you can

hurt someone else

Dissociation works as a defensive mechanism to enable the child to survive disintegration. Avoidance works as a defence by making it possible for the child to “not-think” about the experience. The phenomena of transference and counter-transference allow the child to survive by transferring to others in the social environment the now absent emotional experience. The child is able to live through dangerous times without having to feel the overwhelming emotions associated with disintegration, but also without losing the reality of those emotions. The child cannot feel their own emotions, but they can observe the emotional experience of others. The feelings come to be held, and often vividly expressed, in the other people who form the child’s social network and human environment. Traumatised children often seem to be surrounded by people who are extraordinarily angry or very sad. The impression, in terms of emotions, can be of the child as the unmoved centre of a raging storm. The immensely restricted affective range of the child, who can register little beyond terror or rage, is reflected in the heightened anxiety and anger expressed around them. First, in a process of transference, the child sees in us the absent other, the missing carer or the abuser, who would have been the object of strong feelings had those feelings not been excised by trauma. Then, through the power of counter-transference, we feel in ourselves the powerful feelings which are denied to the child. So traumatised children can come to generate quite irrational and unreasonable rage and misery in those who live and work with them.

Traumatic identity: defined by disaster Trauma shatters the core assumptions that define human consciousness. Survival requires that babies make certain assumptions about the world. These basic and necessary illusions that enable us to function are the assumptions that:

1. the world is benevolent

2. the world is meaningful

3. we deserve good things.

June 2012

Traumatic events rapidly unravel these beliefs. This leaves a vacuum in our most fundamental cognitive constructs about the world, and nature always abhors a vacuum. Human identity is founded on beliefs about ourselves formed as the environment reflects back to us an image of who we are. Once traumatic stress disintegrates the core of our personality, the busy mind quickly forms another set of beliefs more fitting to the world as we now perceive it to be. These new beliefs or schemas become the foundation for a new identity, which may be thought of as traumatic identity.

Traumatised people invariably develop temporary or permanent identity beliefs which are trauma-based. The resulting cognitive schemas have a pervasive effect on all other personal constructs. The victim of post-traumatic stress disorder may state and live out such beliefs as: “I have no control over my life”, “I am the sort of person to whom bad things happen”, “people who love me always hurt me”, and “I don’t deserve anything good to happen”. Children who hold core beliefs like this are not likely to have happy lives until the beliefs change. Yet our core beliefs structure our identity, and it is no small matter to change our sense of our own identity. In so many ways we work with children to enable them to form and retain a strong sense of identity, but here we actively invite children to let go of their identity as victim, and to search for a new sense of self. They will resist accepting the invitation. Memory disturbance

Traumatised children often have no memory of the traumatic events which have disrupted their lives. Sometimes they have fragmentary memories, but they are not able to have formed narrative memories of the events until after they have recovered from the trauma. This traumatic amnesia distresses the child, and we see children struggling to make sense of the gap in their thinking. Whilst on the one hand being avoidant of trigger situations, on the other, and confusingly for the observer, they may seek out situations which seem reminiscent of the past, apparently in an effort to reduce the painful self-doubt that plagues all of us when our memory lets us down. At other times children are unable to forget the trauma, or more usually certain sensory aspects of it. This hypermnesia takes the child into a perpetual inner world of tormenting images and experiences of the trauma as though it were happening in an eternal present moment. We can see the child present in body but absent in spirit, living in a perpetual daydream – although living nightmare would be a more accurate description of the experience. The child may be said to hear voices, which may be an uncontrollable inner replaying of the voices of abusers, or may be subject to visual images or overwhelming feelings which have no prompt in the present external environment but are internally generated.

The third type of memory disturbance after trauma arises from the reduced oxygen supply to areas of the brain, and particularly to part of the brain called Broca’s area. Ordinary memory relies on the formation of links and narrative, and without Broca’s area we are unable to create the narrative. The result is a distressing disturbance of short-term memory.

Children whose short-term memory is poor are frustrating to live with. Ask them to go upstairs and perform a simple task, and by the time they have climbed to the top they have forgotten what it was you asked them to do. These are children who never have the right kit for school, cannot remember changes to routine timetables, forget appointments, and always fail to bring home the vital letter seeking permission for them to go on that school trip they have been looking forward to.

Loss of short-term memory is so distressing that children almost always cover up. They feel stupid to find such difficulty with tasks that their peers perform with ease. They feel critically unreliable and therefore unsafe. Then they dissemble: “Someone stole it”, “Nobody told me”, “I didn’t want to go anyway” and so on in the hope that if they are convincing enough no-one will notice they are different. Learning difficulties

Children who find it difficult to think, to construct narrative and meaning and to remember are obviously going to struggle more than their peers when it comes to learning. Yet the global disorders which follow trauma have an impact on learning which goes even deeper than these disruptions of cognitive functioning. For learning is a holistic process, involving the whole person in changing and adapting to our developing understanding of the world in which we find ourselves. The entire bio-psycho-social injury which is the result of trauma has a destructive effect on the capacity to learn.

Traumatised children may be diminished in their capacity to learn physically, finding co-ordination and balance difficult and possibly having problems with spatial awareness and laterality. They are likely to have difficulties with cognitive skill development in the areas of language, the creation of meaning, making sense of numbers and so on. They are almost certain to have difficulties with socially based learning, whether it is co-operating in classroom groups or undertaking learning which relies on empathy and an understanding of the inner world of others, such as understanding literature. Finally they are sure to have difficulties with learning based on emotion; emotional numbing and the loss of the capacity for joy will put all aesthetic appreciation, response to beauty and delight in living out of their reach. These will be experiences which they can observe in others but never share. It is frustrating for children to be at school with their peers who can do with ease so many activities that for

June 2012

traumatised children are difficult. It is frustrating for schools to cope with children who may be obviously intelligent but who find it difficult to learn and difficult to manage school as a social setting. The results of these frustrations are vividly displayed in the statistics on the educational attainments of children in the public care system. Here is a group of children who might be expected to be among the most traumatised in the population; they are vastly over-represented in those excluded from school, and are shockingly under-represented in those achieving good, or even average, results at key examinations. These are children whose learning needs are not being met in the education system.

Aggression against self and others

Terror begets aggression. The inner state of the victim of post-traumatic stress disorder is physiologically one of permanent terror. Self-harm is common. Sometimes this is related to the altered sense of identity after trauma, which creates self-loathing. Children may harm themselves because they hate themselves.

Other children may become addicted to the self-generated painkillers which go with trauma. Then they may hurt themselves as a way of getting a fresh dose of opioids. These children often say that they only feel normal when they are cutting or otherwise hurting themselves. This is the language of addiction, and it should alert us to the possibility that they have become dependent on their own self-generated chemicals. Many victims of trauma become dependent on substances, and this is often a form of selfmedication to ease the pain of permanent physiological arousal.

Aggression and violence against others is also common. Primed for fight as well as flight, perceiving harmless things as threats, exhausted with constant vigilance, traumatised children are both irritable and unpredictably violent. At best they are uncomfortable companions, and often they are downright frightening to be with. Carers and schools often put aggression and violence at the top of the list of challenging behaviours they find most difficult to cope with.

Efforts to achieve control

It is important to human beings to have a sense of being in control. For most children this sense comes through a gradual development of self-control, as they become able within secure attachments to regulate stress, shame, impulse and rage. Even when this self-control has been achieved, however, post-traumatic stress disorder destroys it. People who previously could manage their own physiological responses, emotional experience and behaviour are deprived of this ability by the gross physiological changes arising from unprocessed trauma. Being in a permanent state of high stress arousal prevents self-control. Since a sense of control matters, children who cannot achieve self-control often become very controlling of others. This has the added bonus of making them feel safer, since other people are part of the environment and everything about the environment seems threatening, therefore other people are a threat. Children may also be stuck, or have reverted, to the “magical thinking” of early childhood under the impact of trauma. They then feel that they have to be in control of everything or it will stop working. They may believe that they can predict or control the future, or that they are responsible for the safety of others, which can be assured by magical acts. One child had to perform six rituals at bedtime to keep his absent mother safe, another needed to stay awake until after midnight every night otherwise someone in the house would die before morning. Efforts to reduce dissonance

Safety is essential for people to be able to recover from trauma. Yet if we simply take a traumatised child and place them in a safe environment, after a while they start to feel crazy. Their inner experience is of being terrified. The outside world no longer matches their inner experience, for it is safe. When our inner world and our outer world fail to match we feel crazy. This is one of the most uncomfortable feelings for a human being; it is like being annihilated as a person.

The child cannot control their inner experience when in the grip of post-traumatic stress disorder. The only way the child can stop feeling crazy therefore is to make the outer world unsafe enough to make sense of the inner experience of terror. Traumatised children will make their world chaotic and dangerous in order to feel sane. Just when everyone around them is feeling that things are going well for them, they will press the self-destruct button. Psychosomatic and psychogenic disorders Children living with this level of permanent overwhelming stress may suffer a range of illnesses and ailments. Every body system and organ is affected by stress. The results of long-term exposure to traumatic stress can include headaches, breathing problems, digestive disorders, pain in the joints, backache and immune system disorders. Children also express their absent feelings through bodily changes, a process called somatisation. Thus when another child might feel excited, a traumatised child may produce an asthma attack or a headache, and what would be mild anxiety may appear as diarrhoea or indigestion. Children who have been victims of abuse, especially sexual abuse, may suffer health-related anxieties, even

June 2012

when they have no conscious memory of the abuse. They may be anxious about bodily functions, or the changes of puberty, and will need special care to be taken to provide them with good information and reassurance about their bodies, their developing sexuality, and their changing sexual identity. They may also suffer sexually transmitted diseases for which they will need treatment. Implications for practice

Avoidance is strongly associated with trauma. Every human being is vulnerable to trauma, and for many thinking about trauma can be overwhelming because of this vulnerability. Yet it is clear that we must move beyond this avoidance. We need there to be enough people who can face and hold on to the knowledge that children who have lived through overwhelming stress who have not yet been able to recover from their traumatic stress injuries are children who are suffering. Only then can we truly begin to alleviate this needless suffering, and to ensure that many more children and young people are able to achieve their potential.

A participant at a generally well-received training event on childhood trauma commented “If they think I’m going to change the way I do things just because of some little soand-so who can’t manage their own behaviour they’ve got another think coming.” My colleague who heard this was disappointed, but I felt that in the journey towards acceptance and the ending of avoidance and denial this was a positive step. For it shows a move from thinking “won’t” to thinking “can’t”. Once we recognise that traumatised children and young people, however challenging they may be, can’t manage their own thoughts, feelings or behaviour that is the beginning of seeing them in a new way. There is no moral justification for not helping a child who can’t manage something on their own. Especially when the behaviour is a message that the child is in pain. Kate Cairns

Author, speaker and trainer

Reproduced with kind permission from Cairns K (2002) Attachment, Trauma and Resilience: Therapeutic caring for children, London: BAAF

See advert on page 17.

More posts

edition Diary Dates

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 32-33 DIARY DATES 2023 January 2023 Closing date for the BADth Gordon Wiseman Trust Fund. Details in Members’ area.…

The Prompt – final

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 22-31 Dear Jane, As a long-standing supporter of the publication, I write this open letter to thank you for…

people-caused climate destruction A Farewell Scenario

The Prompt, December 2022 · by EXCLUSIVE TO ARTS THERAPISTS · page 17-21 A FAREWELL SCENARIO 1996–2022 Scenario Arts in Personal Development was founded in…
account android arrow-alt-circle-down arrow-alt-circle-left arrow-alt-circle-right arrow-alt-circle-up arrow-down arrow-left arrow-right arrow-up author bars behance blogger bluesky buffer caret-down caret-left caret-right caret-square-down caret-square-left caret-square-right caret-square-up caret-up cart-menu-1 cart-menu-2 cart-menu-3 cart-menu-4 categories chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right chevron-up clock close comments cookies copyright coupon-discount date-modified date-published discord double-arrows-down double-arrows-left double-arrows-right double-arrows-up dribbble envelope-open envelope eye facebook fax flickr foursquare github gmail google-drive grid-view hashtag hollow-ring homepage instagram ios level-down-alt level-up-alt line link linkedin list-view login logout long-arrow-alt-down long-arrow-alt-left long-arrow-alt-right long-arrow-alt-up mastodonmedium messenger mobile-menu mobile phone pinterest place qq quote-left quote-right quotes reading-time-hourglass reading-time-stopwatch reddit rss scroll-to-top search shazam shopping-bag shopping-cart side-panel-opening-2-left side-panel-opening-2-right side-panel-opening-left side-panel-opening-right skype slack small-arrow-down small-arrow-left small-arrow-right small-arrow-up sms snapchat soundcloud spinner spotify stackoverflow sync telegram threadstiktok times-circle tinder trello tripadvisor tumblr twitch twitter viber vimeo vine vkontakte website wechat whatsapp windows wishlist xing yelp youtube zoom