Stop Kicking: The Story of Lucy and Tracey

Stop Kicking: The Story of Lucy and Tracey

The Prompt, April 2016 · page 24-31

April 2016

Introduction

I wanted to write something in everyday language about the process of dramatherapy and the developmental transformations (DvT) model. A story that also contains the voice of the clients, both during the process and about how their lives have changed as a result. I also wanted to try using a storytelling format as a way for me as a dramatherapist to share my discoveries, and maybe even create some evidence for future practice.

This is the story. It is based on something that happened and was important. There were four of us involved. There was me, Dolmen, a dramatherapist working for a Child and Adolescent Mental Health Service. There was Pauline, qualified as a play therapist, and working as a Family Support Keyworker. Then there was Tracey, a mother, and her daughter, Lucy. We had an experience together that was moving and amazing. Between us we managed to change a relationship between Lucy and her mother that had been full of pain, anger, shame, violence, and rejected love, into a new relationship where each felt and expressed some love for the other, and stopped hurting each other so much. The story is worth telling simply as a celebration of their success, because it was hard work for all of us, which involved the risks of trusting each other, of facing up to painful feelings, and of possible, even probable, failure. Tracey and Lucy have both generously given their permission for this story to be told. Their names, and other names in the story, have been changed, of course, to maintain their privacy. Tracey’s Story

Tracey had been through so much as a little girl. Her mother seemed to hate her and her father was absent. Why did her parents see her brother as the golden boy, while she was the bad one? Over time, she began to live up to these expectations. As she talked to me twenty or so years later, as she neared 30, she recalled how horribly she behaved to her parents. As a result, she spent a lot of time in the care of her mother’s parents. Her grandmother was strict, but her grandfather was “a soft touch”. She told me she had been in a violent relationship with a boyfriend, Mike, from the age of 13 to 17. At 15 she became pregnant with his child, and was thrown out of the house by her parents. Her first child was Stop Kicking:

The Story of Lucy and Tracey

April 2016

removed by Social Services and adopted by another family. Mike was using heroin at this time. She had two more children with Mike, who were also removed. When she had her fourth child, Lucy, she was determined to keep her, and left Mike three weeks after Lucy was born. Tracey felt that for the first six months she bonded well with Lucy. She began to build bridges with her parents. But then her grandfather died – the one person who had seemed to have a soft spot for her – and she went to pieces and, in her own words, “was a rubbish mum”. At this time she met Rick, whom she described as a controlling man and a heroin addict. One day he took Lucy away from her, gave her to his parents, and restricted Tracey’s access to her. Eventually when Lucy was four, Tracey managed to get Children’s Services involved and brought her home. Tracey was pregnant with Rick’s child, and later had his son, Darren. Tracey bonded closely with Darren, but her connection with Lucy had weakened. Lucy began to act out, and Tracey struggled with her. History seemed to be repeating itself: the son was wonderful, and the daughter a problem who spent time with her grandparents. Tracey became involved with Tony, another controlling man; he was helpful with Lucy, sure enough, but in a way that made Tracey feel useless. Eventually Tracey became violent with Lucy – “I just threw her against the wall” – so much so that she contacted Children’s Services and begged them to help her with Lucy before she hurt her more. For two years Lucy was designated a Child at Risk. Tracey did not get on with the first social worker. Tony was seen as the responsible one, and was put in charge. Fortunately, Tracey felt she was able to accept help from the next social worker, Matt, and made progress in keeping calm with Lucy. Eventually she decided to ask Tony to leave. My First Meetings with

Tracey and with Lucy

By this time Pauline, the Family Support Keyworker, had become involved, and she asked me if I could help, as she thought Tracey might now be at a point where she was open to change. Without a man in her life, Tracey recognized that her choice of partner had contributed to her problems connecting with Lucy. But Tracey still had no idea what was going on in Lucy’s head. She could see the parallels between her own experiences and Lucy’s, but that did not seem to help her empathize. Ever since that original separation from her baby daughter, their connection had been broken. Pauline’s hope was that through dramatherapy, Tracey might be able to increase her attunement to Lucy. She had heard about my interventions with other families from her colleagues: Family Support Keyworkers who had invited me to use dramatherapy with families who had traumatic breaks in parent/child relationships.

When I first met Tracey, with Pauline, she was able to talk quite openly about what she wanted. She was thoughtful and had a wry sense of humour. I was encouraged when Tracey told me that her main goal was “to understand Lucy and have a better relationship with her”. It would have been understandable if her goal had been for Lucy to improve her behaviour, because Lucy would get furious with Tracey, and hit and kick her. Like her mother before her, Lucy had bonded with her grandmother, with whom she did activities like baking and crafts. And Tracey, like her mother, felt warm and close to her son, Darren. I felt daunted when I heard Tracey’s story. The history of traumatized children went back through the generations. When a young child’s need for feeling secure and loved has not been sufficiently met, the child can conclude that something is wrong with them, and that they do not deserve to be loved and valued. This feeling may have led to Tracey’s repeated experiences of emotional, domestic, and substance abuse. Maybe these were what love looked like to her. How could she imagine anything else?

April 2016

However there were also reasons for hopefulness: by asking Tony to leave, Tracey had given herself some space to think about Lucy and her needs. And amidst

each

of

their

dysfunctional

attachment to their parents, both Tracey and Lucy had experienced some positive attachment with their grandparents. Tracey had become closer with her own parents to the point where she now phoned her mother every day, and asked for help from her father. She had been able to accept help from Matt, her social worker, and had shown herself capable of a secure attachment to Darren. Pauline and I both felt that Lucy’s aggressive behaviour at home towards her mother was her response to feeling emotionally unsafe and misunderstood. If so, it seemed possible that her violent behaviour might decrease if she felt more emotionally contained and attuned to by her mother.

I met with Lucy, together with Tracey and Pauline. She looked curious to meet me. She was a lean, energetic girl, cheerful and friendly. She didn’t say a lot. When I asked her if there was anything she would like to be different in her life, she said no. When asked again, she said she didn’t like her mother, ever. She felt she wanted to like her mother all the time. And

she

said

she

wanted

to

try

Dramatherapy.

Very often when younger children have been traumatised, they do not have the words to talk about it to another person, as older people may be able to. Often they are able to use play, art, stories or drama to express something about their world. When a parent then witnesses this, it can sometimes help them to empathise more with their child, understand the reasons for their difficult behaviour, and “attune” to what the child needs.

We agreed to try two or three sessions with Pauline and me working with Lucy alone, and then to invite Tracey to join us. First Dramatherapy

Session: with Lucy Alone

We started our first session with a storymaking game. Lucy was immediately interested. In her story, a 13 year-old girl’s mother had died. The girl visited her father to ask him to bring her mother back to life, but he wasn’t home. Then her brother cast a spell to bring her mother back to life, for one hour. They all lived happily ever after. I felt excited by this story. Sometimes a first story can beautifully encapsulate the young person’s world, but it can be coded, somewhat like a dream. Even though I felt I had an idea what might be symbolized by Lucy’s story – the dead mother could be a depressed mother who is not responsive to the child; the father is emotionally absent; only the son can

bring

some

life

back

to

the

depressed mother. However I do not tend to try to interpret this symbolism to the child in my words, because I do not find that it is helpful. Instead I like to ask the young person which bit of their story grabs their attention the most. Often it is the bit of the story that doesn’t quite add up, where you want to say, “Hey, what was happening here?” In this case, Lucy was most interested in the part where the father wasn’t home. And so was I. This surprised me. I thought Lucy’s issues were all about mothers and daughters. This is another advantage in using creative

methods:

something

unexpected tends to emerge that the family had not mentioned.

A little bit about the background of how I work. I have trained and graduated at the

Institute

of

Developmental

Transformations (DvT), through its training course in the UK. DvT is well documented in the dramatherapy literature. It is a practice of encouraging play in an artistic medium, such as in drama, where a facilitator (playor) encourages a client (player) to begin to move, and the playor responds in actions to what is evoked for them. The player then responds in turn. Thus an improvised series of movements, actions, sounds and words develops into a scene. The player will unconsciously bring into the

April 2016

scenes images, roles, and actions that explore and attempt to make sense of their traumatic experiences and dilemmas. The

playor

uses

range

of

techniques in responding with their own action, sometimes drawing on what they know about the player’s background. The playor closely observes the player’s reaction to their own dramatic “offer”. If the player’s enthusiasm to play seems to reduce, even slightly, the playor sees that another dramatic image may work better, and tries something different. If the player’s energy level and involvement seems to increase, it is a sign to the playor to go deeper into that scene. The aim is to respond in the moment, even if it means transforming the scene into something new, rather than necessarily sticking with an existing storyline. Using her story as a starting point, I suggested we begin a scene where Lucy calls on the father and he’s out. Lucy goes to the front door and knocks. I decide to enact an absent father, so I hide behind the front door. I talk to Pauline in the role of my girlfriend, “Let’s keep quiet. She’ll go away.” I noticed that Lucy’s eyes got bigger. She looked involved. She walked away. The father and his girlfriend continued to talk. “What does she want? I can’t deal with her when she’s sad. I really can’t handle her at the moment.” Suddenly Lucy turned

around,

marched

back

and

started to shout to be let in. Her father lets her in, they argue, he tries to get away, and she chases him around the house. She is enraged with her father’s neglect, but in the play there is much pleasure and laughter.

Third Session: Tracey Joins Us in the Dramatherapy

After two sessions of Lucy playing scenes with Pauline and me, she wanted to invite her mother to join us. Lucy enjoyed welcoming her mother in, and confidently explained the rules of the playspace to her mother. She liked being the knowledgeable one. Lucy asked me to be her father, and Pauline to be her mother. We suggested that Tracey could watch the scene from the side. Lucy wanted me, as her father, to be in the pub, and for Lucy and Pauline, as her mother, to visit him. I decided to portray a dad who was drinking pint after pint, and getting drunk and irritable. Pauline picked up on this, and began to complain about the father’s drunkenness. We argued. Tracey commented from the side, with a resigned look, “It’s just like real life”. Lucy then got angry with her dad, and began to hit him energetically with cushions. Her dad protested, and threw them back at her. There was a lot of shouting, a lot of laughter. Although we were dealing with topics of substance abuse, neglect and anger, the absurdity of us both whacking each other with cushions seemed to transform the tragedy into something farcical. This may have helped Lucy to feel witnessed, and allowed a healing process to enfold. What

is

important

about

feeling

witnessed? We know that when a child is treated abusively within their family, they make certain assumptions because that is all they have known. They may assume that this is normal behaviour within a family. Or, as they realize that other families are different, they may assume that they are bad themselves, and that they deserve to be badly treated. This is why these children often grow up to form family relationships where they themselves are re-abused, and where they mistreat their children.

Even if the abusive family behaviour has stopped, the traumatized child is still left feeling angry, empty, or worthless. What therapy can offer is a space for the child to show to another person they trust, “This is what my world is for me!” and the other person can say or show to them, “What happened to you wasn’t okay, it wasn’t your fault, and you deserve something better!” And it can help for a parent to be able to see that too, and to show them that they will protect them from now on.

Using creative methods, a child can communicate about their world symbolically, without even knowing consciously that they are doing it. So for Lucy, it may be that she had not realized that she was angry with the men in her life who What is

important

about feeling

witnessed?

We know that

when a child

is treated

abusively within

their family,

they make

certain

assumptions

because that is

all they have

known.

April 2016

neglected her needs, who “weren’t there”, and who never gave her the feeling that she was a wonderful, amazing and unique person, deserving to be loved. And what a chance for Tracey to see, played out before her, how bad that experience was for her daughter. This is what being witnessed means. The energy of the physical engagement in DvT seems to amplify this process by bringing a directness and vividness to the scenes.

And what about all this whacking each other with cushions? Is this really serious therapy? I believe it can be. There is something about the playfighting with cushions that reminds me of games that parents play with their small children. Children really enjoy such fighting, which can be like a kind of cuddling, and where part of the pleasure is in the child feeling trust that the big, powerful adult, who could easily crush them, will protect them from getting hurt. Sometimes the adult will do the chasing and be the strong one, and sometimes this is reversed and the child overwhelms their parent with their immense, imaginary powers. They can play at being allpowerful, and vent their destructiveness on the world, without really hurting anyone. Perhaps Lucy benefited from going back to this missed early childhood experience. Back in the session, I am now thinking about what is okay for Lucy in terms of physical contact, because she is not my daughter, and I am a man. I decide to pick up two large cushions, and try going up to Lucy and squeezing her between the cushions, as part of the playfighting. She laughs, shouts in protest, but seems to enjoy the feeling of being held. I shout too, and by keeping the appearance of a fight, it makes the physical contact more acceptable for Lucy. She lets herself fall to the ground, and be squashed under the cushions. More laughter. Then she jumps up, and throws a cushion at Pauline. I sense that the scene is transforming. She’s done with me, and I wonder if she wants a different kind of physical closeness with a mother figure. Pauline immediately senses what she wants, and starts to chase her. Lucy’s level of enjoyment seems to go up even more. As I watch, it looks to me like a game that a mother would play with her small child.

Up until now, Tracey has been watching from the side. This is not an unusual beginning in the parent’s first session. My hope is that Tracey will be able at some point to join the play.

Pauline is still chasing Lucy with two cushions, and suddenly Lucy falls over, clutching her ankle. The mood suddenly changes. The play stops. Lucy is crying, and says her ankle is hurt. Pauline and I settle down beside her to check her ankle. We both feel anxious. Tracey has not moved. We look over at Tracey, expecting she might intervene to check if her

daughter

is

okay.

She

looks

unmoved. We have left the playspace now, but I am aware that what is happening is important. Pauline and I both sense that Lucy would like to be looked after by Tracey. So we pick her up, and gently carry her over to her mother. Tracey tells us that Lucy is putting it on, as she always does. Despite this, we ask her if she can cuddle Lucy. She does so. Lucy lets herself be cuddled.

After a while, Lucy gets up, and walks a few paces, cries out and falls again, this time holding her shoulder. Pauline and I go to pick her up again. A ritual seems to have formed, a symbol she is creating for her emotional hurt, as a sign of distress for her mother. Lucy says she does not want to be carried. Tracey doesn’t move. Pauline asks Tracey to come over and cuddle her. Tracey moves over and cuddles Lucy. Tracey laughs, but continues with the cuddling. Lucy wriggles; she will not be comforted. I sense that this is difficult for Tracey, because her comforting is being rejected. We have reached the root of their attachment problem. Lucy desperately wants to be cared for by her mother, but rejects her; perhaps she does not trust that her mother will be able to do it, and she doesn’t want to be let down again. Tracey does not want to risk caring for Lucy, because she sees that she will be rejected yet again, being a reminder of many painful experiences for her. Lucy feels her mother doesn’t care, and Tracey feels that Lucy is not really hurting. They are both wrong. Lucy

feels

her

mother

doesn’t

care,

and

Tracey

feels

that

Lucy is

not

really

hurting.

They

are

both

wrong.

April 2016

I want to help Tracey find a way of successfully comforting Lucy. I remember singing to my children when they were upset. I ask if anyone knows a lullaby, hoping that Tracey knows one. Even though I could sing one, I know there’s no point in my doing the comforting, because Lucy needs her mother. Lucy

suggests

the

song

“Michael

Finnegan”, and sings to us about the wind blowing Michael’s bristles back into his chinnegan. Then silence. Tracey doesn’t know the song. The lullaby idea does not work. Lucy says she wants to go to the hospital. She is letting us know that she is not getting what she wants here. Then she changes her mind, and tells us that she wants her grandmother to collect her and take her to the hospital. Tracey appears to be feeling rejected, again. The mood feels quite serious, but I decide to try bringing us all into the playspace again, so that we can find another way for Tracey to support Lucy. So I suggest Lucy pretend to phone her grandmother.

She

phones

her,

and

Pauline picks up as her grandmother. “Sorry, Lucy, I can’t come to help you, I’m at work. I’m sure your mum can sort it out. Ask her.” Though Pauline is new to DvT, she understands exactly what is needed in the play. Tracey is looking worried, this is her first dramatherapy session, and she is in pretty deep. I say, “Tracey, you could try phoning a taxi to take her to hospital”. Tracey rings the taxi company. The playspace seems to be just barely holding. Pauline and I arrive as taxi drivers. We study Lucy and her injured ankle, and say that it is very serious, and she needs an ambulance. We turn into paramedics, and the three of us physically carry Lucy to the hospital. Then a doctor (that’s me) asks Tracey for a history of Lucy’s past injuries. I want to give Tracey a chance to show her concern as a mother for how her daughter has been emotionally hurt in the past. Tracey lists a number of accidents that Lucy has had. The doctor then asks about her emotional injuries. At this point Lucy reaches for her mother’s tablet, she is detaching herself. I can see that my acknowledgement of Lucy’s past psychological traumas has gone further than she can cope with at the moment. She has left the playspace. This is her safety net, so she can stay in control of what she is ready to process. At least we have been able to let her know that we know she has suffered traumatic events. It is time to end the session. They both say that they want to come again. We had a break for the summer holidays, but I phoned Tracey to talk about the session.

She

said

she

found

the

dramatherapy strange, and out of her comfort zone, but she was happy to do it if it helped Lucy. We discussed what the drama might have meant, and she noted that Lucy’s aggression towards her had diminished since the session. Following Up after the

Summer Break

At our first meeting after the break, about 6 weeks later, Tracey and Lucy told us about the changes they had noticed over the holidays. Lucy had been away a few days with a family friend, and for the first time in their memory, they had missed each other. There

were

no

hitting

or

kicking

episodes from Lucy – only one “big meltdown”, where Lucy had become angry and went to her room. I asked Lucy how she had managed not to hit out against her mother. She said that she did not want to get angry with her mum any more, because it made her feel she hates her mother. Tracey said that she had begun to understand what was going on in Lucy’s head some of the time. Lucy was beginning to understand that the family was now the three of them, and the grandparents were separate. Interestingly, Darren had been naughty sometimes, and Lucy had been in the good child role several times. Therapists are wary of miracle cures, flights into health that can be a way of avoiding difficult issues. Pauline and I were delighted to hear of these changes, but we felt cautious. After this session, Lucy told her mother that she did not need any more dramatherapy. We had a short meeting with Lucy, where she told us that she rated her relationship with her mother an 8 out of 10, where before it had been at a 1; and that now she loved her mother an 8 out of 10, where

April 2016

before it had been a 0. She thought the dramatherapy had helped. We agreed to meet again in two months time. Would these changes hold?

Well, they did. When we met again, even though Tracey said she felt like “crap” most of the time, being depressed, crying a lot, and missing Tony, she still felt that she had a better understanding of her daughter, and their relationship had significantly improved. I asked about how they sorted out their differences. They had an argument about once a week, with raised voices, but no hitting or shouting. When asked what had helped, Tracey said, “I watched her with you. I had to take that on board and be a stronger person, and not to be scared of her”.

For me working with the family was a moving experience. Lucy had a wonderful spirit and a sense of fun. Tracey also had a sense of humour, and great courage to take on something unfamiliar and challenging. I felt that they both had a lot of love for each other despite all that had happened. I am grateful to Pauline for having the imagination to call me in, as a kind of emotional plumber. Although Pauline had never worked with me before, or used this method, she intervened with sensitivity and accuracy. I think about all four of us having had our own personal life experiences that had brought us to this moment when our lives intersected. We joined together with our various skills and strengths to help each other with generosity and humour. We found a way to create change, instead of succumbing to fear, shame, embarrassment, and failure. This kind of work can often be effective, but it is rare for deep change to happen as quickly as it did for Tracey and Lucy. Usually the work takes a lot longer. I was surprised, and I wonder if somehow Tracey was ready for change, as a result of work she had already done herself, with Matt her social worker, and with Pauline. I hope that this story has been able to demonstrate and explain something of

the

benefits

of

creative

therapies, dramatherapy and DvT in particular. I am grateful to Lucy and Tracey for allowing me to share their story with you.

Dolmen Dolmikles

(For dramatherapists who are wishing to experience

and

explore

DvT,

see

dvtuk.org/intensive

for

information

about a DvT Intensive in Bristol from 23rd–26th May. It will be an enjoyable and accessible introduction to DvT.) When we met again, even though Tracey said she felt like “crap” most of the time, being depressed, crying a lot, and missing Tony, she still felt that she had a better understanding of her daughter, and their relationship had significantly improved.

April 2016

MARY SMAIL

at SOULWORKS UK

Aending the untold story Dramatherapy and Psychotherapy Training therapy/supervision for Dramatherapy/ Arts Therapy students and professionals Asseron Training/Self Esteem and Confidence building

Soul Direcon – spiritual support for life and around death

Sessions: South London – SW2, By Phone or Skype.

Psyche and Soma – Soul-making through the Sesame Approach 2016

P/T course for registered professionals. More informaon:

contact form 07931 348052

www.marysmailsoulworks.co.uk Charlie Moritz MA,PGCE,

PGDip (Dramatherapy)

Cert. Creative Supervision practising in Whaley Bridge, Derbyshire and city-centre Manchester. HCPC Registered Dramatherapist BADth Registered Supervisor Mob: 07751275907

contact form www.charliemoritz.co.uk

Individual and group dramatherapy. Individual and small group supervision. Dramatherapy for trainee dramatherapists. Creative/therapeutic workshops, particularly focussed round creative writing. Staff and team development. Particular experience in: Multicultural settings.

Educational settings.

Working with asylum seekers, refugees (adults, unaccompanied young people and children). Working with trauma and PTSD. Creative/therapeutic workshops. DEBORAH EVANS

Psychoanalytic

Psychotherapist

and Dramatherapist

Cambridge

20 years’ experience

Student/newly qualified

rates available

contact form www.cambridgedramaand

psychotherapy.co.uk

More posts

edition Diary Dates

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 32-33 DIARY DATES 2023 January 2023 Closing date for the BADth Gordon Wiseman Trust Fund. Details in Members’ area.…

The Prompt – final

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 22-31 Dear Jane, As a long-standing supporter of the publication, I write this open letter to thank you for…

people-caused climate destruction A Farewell Scenario

The Prompt, December 2022 · by EXCLUSIVE TO ARTS THERAPISTS · page 17-21 A FAREWELL SCENARIO 1996–2022 Scenario Arts in Personal Development was founded in…
account android arrow-alt-circle-down arrow-alt-circle-left arrow-alt-circle-right arrow-alt-circle-up arrow-down arrow-left arrow-right arrow-up author bars behance blogger bluesky buffer caret-down caret-left caret-right caret-square-down caret-square-left caret-square-right caret-square-up caret-up cart-menu-1 cart-menu-2 cart-menu-3 cart-menu-4 categories chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right chevron-up clock close comments cookies copyright coupon-discount date-modified date-published discord double-arrows-down double-arrows-left double-arrows-right double-arrows-up dribbble envelope-open envelope eye facebook fax flickr foursquare github gmail google-drive grid-view hashtag hollow-ring homepage instagram ios level-down-alt level-up-alt line link linkedin list-view login logout long-arrow-alt-down long-arrow-alt-left long-arrow-alt-right long-arrow-alt-up mastodonmedium messenger mobile-menu mobile phone pinterest place qq quote-left quote-right quotes reading-time-hourglass reading-time-stopwatch reddit rss scroll-to-top search shazam shopping-bag shopping-cart side-panel-opening-2-left side-panel-opening-2-right side-panel-opening-left side-panel-opening-right skype slack small-arrow-down small-arrow-left small-arrow-right small-arrow-up sms snapchat soundcloud spinner spotify stackoverflow sync telegram threadstiktok times-circle tinder trello tripadvisor tumblr twitch twitter viber vimeo vine vkontakte website wechat whatsapp windows wishlist xing yelp youtube zoom