June 2013
Theatre Review
The Empress
Swan Theatre, Royal Shakespeare Theatre,
Stratford-upon-Avon
This is a new play written by Tanika Gupta and directed by Emma Rice, that introduces us to several fascinating themes. The Empress is Queen Victoria who was also Empress of India and she is celebrating her Golden Jubilee. She is ‘given’ an Indian, Muslim servant, called Abdul Karim. He arrives on the same ship as an Indian ayah (nanny) Rani Das, who is abandoned by her employing family as soon as the boat reaches London. Apparently this was common practice for wealthy families to hire ayahs and then abandon them after the voyage, often forcing them into crime and prostitution.
The Empress is enchanted with her servant and bestows gifts and status on him, while he enchants her with stories and images of the ‘jewel in her crown’. The other palace staff and MPs loath Karim and eventually block the Queen’s plans for his advancement. This story, together with the film Mrs Brown, show us a hidden side to the Queen that is quite fascinating.
The stories of the ayahs take us into the plight of women but also the new attempts of philanthropy and social reform, and indeed the racism of MP selection!
I thoroughly recommend this play. It has wonderful colour, energy and ensemble acting that moves us from ship to palace to street with simple use of music, sound and projection.
Sue Jennings
Reviews
Reviews
June 2013
Shakespeare Beyond Doubt
Evidence, Argument, Controversy
by Paul Edmondson and Stanley Wells
2013, Cambridge University Press
A review
As some will know I have been researching the Shakespeare Authorship Question for the last six years and investigating evidence that supports the identification of Sir Henry Neville as the bard. This is a review of the latest book from the Stratfordian perspective. This book is an important contribution to the literature on the Authorship Question: indeed it aims to answer that question once and for all, to demolish the debate. Those people who have reasonable doubts that William Shakspere1 from Stratford wrote the works of Shakespeare are branded ‘deniers’ and ‘anti-Shakespearians’. The last word of the Introduction shows this book aims to end this ‘heresy’ (xiv).
The chapters by different scholars offer a rich mix and some are excellent while others do not shed any useful light. Particularly powerful is chapter 10 What does textual evidence reveal about the author? by Mardock & Rasmussen. They show that Shakespeare knew how to craft plays with many characters to be playable by small companies by doubling parts. Therefore, they say, he must have been a man of the theatre, an actor who knew his actors. There is ample evidence offered to show the bard collaborated throughout his writing with other writers and this is offered by Jowett in chapter 8, Shakespeare as Collaborator, as proof positive that the man from Stratford must have been the writer. Neither of these, however, actually is proof. It is evidence and the book offers the best evidence that can be gathered that William from Stratford was the bard. However what the authors do in their attacks on ‘amateurs’, scholars who are not employed in major academic institutions, is fail to see that science does not only rely on experts. Amateurs are vital in many sciences both historically and to this day, as when amateur astronomers spot asteroids and comets before the professionals. The Authorship Question is a series of hypotheses in answer to a genuine Authorship Problem. This problem did not start solely in the 19th Century as the academics in this book suggest but began in Shakespeare’s lifetime. In 1597 and 1598 Joseph Hall published Satires (Virgidemarium) in which he cryptically referred to the author of Shakespeare’s works by the name ‘Labeo’ which some have interpreted as pointing to Bacon. In 1598 John Marston also called Shakespeare ‘Labeo’ (in both Metamorphosis of Pygmalion’s Image and Certain Satires book 1). Thus from the 16th Century the identity of Shakespeare has been questioned. Wells dismisses evidence that does not fit the Stratfordian orthodoxy. William Dugdale’s 1653 drawing of the Stratford monument, showing a very different man, with no quill and his hands on a bag of grain (we know William hoarded grain in a famine) is dismissed as inaccurate but it was reproduced uncorrected as late as 1730 (Michell, 2000, 89). Science proceeds by hypotheses which are examined and disproven. I agree that Bacon, Oxford and 1 ‘Shakspere’ was how William and members of his family spelt their name. He never wrote the full correct spelling of ‘Shakespeare’, (see Pointon, 2011).
Reviews
June 2013
Marlowe are certainly not the hidden author of the plays. However to suggest that the many candidates proposed, by their sheer number, invalidate the whole Authorship Question, is not scientific. Kubus in Chapter 5, The Unusual Suspects, asserts that, “all these nominations are equally invalid: none has a greater claim than any of the others. Mathematically, each time an additional candidate is suggested, the probability decreases that any given name is the true author.” (50) I agree that wild guesses will not answer the Authorship Question. However to rubbish all is to miss what is a genuine discovery and Kubus is downright dishonest in his report of the case for Henry Neville. He seems not to have read the evidence that is pouring out in his favour: real documentary evidence of manuscripts, letters, notebooks. He gives a very brief, dismissive report of James’ work on the Sonnets’ Dedication and does not report other work by Leyland and Goding which corroborates, using a different method, James’ groundbreaking discovery (see: www.leylandandgoding.com). The authors of these chapters do admit that many of their views are in fact beliefs: Rutter acknowledges there is no evidence that William went to school: she states, “I believe” William was a grammar school boy (135). Her insistence that the grammar school education was entirely sufficient to explain all Shakespeare’s learning is asserted as a fact when it is now clear that Shakespeare could read Italian, French, Spanish and Greek. These were not on the curriculum at Stratford.
Wells provides a comprehensive survey of the references to Shakespeare to 1642. He claims all these refer to William from Stratford. In this he is not distinguishing those which refer definitely to William and those which refer to the writer. William was identified as an actor. Wells does acknowledge that none of the references to William Shakespeare in his lifetime “explicitly and incontrovertibly identifies him with Stratford-upon-Avon.” (81). Strangely he does not mention the Northumberland Manuscript, dated to 1596–7, which was the earliest document to identify William Shakespeare as the author of the plays Richard II and III. The manuscript was owned by Henry Neville (Casson, 2012).
The very fact that the bard was so secretive about his identity (unlike Jonson) is evidence that there is a legitimate Authorship Question. This book, the authors admit, will not be the last word.
John Christey-Casson
References
Casson, J. (2012) The Northumberland Manuscript Revisited, paper published on website: www.creativepsychotherapy.info
Michell, J. (2000) Who Wrote Shakespeare? London, Thames and Hudson Pointon, A.J. (2011) The Man who was Never Shakespeare, Tunbridge Wells, Parapress
June 2013