Review of 30th FATAG Conference

Review of 30th FATAG Conference

The Prompt, February 2014 · page 25-30

March 2014

Review of 30th FATAG Conference

(Forensic Arts Therapies Advisory Group) held on 1st November 2013

The 30th bi-annual FATAG conference was held at the Charity Centre, Directory of Social Change in Euston, a warm and labyrinthian venue which nicely reflected the tone of the conference itself. Layered staircases inside led you through intriguing corridors and new heights were gained as you finally found the place you were looking for. The seams of charity and social change also underpinned the narrative of today’s two sensitive and thoughtful presentations. The morning presentation was entitled ‘The Good Enough Couple’ and focused on the containment of conflict and roots of creativity in a music and art therapy group for forensic patients with intellectual disabilities and mental illness. The paper was delivered by Trisha Montague, who has worked as a music therapist for the North London Forensic Service (NLFS) since 2003, alongside her more recent work providing 1:1 sessions as a psychodynamic counsellor, and James O’Connell who also works in the NLFS as an art psychotherapist, as well as within the Integrated Community Learning Disabilities Service in Enfield. The paper was based on their work together in the NLFS, a medium-low secure forensic setting, with a small closed group of three patients that has been running for two years. The idea to first run a joint arts therapy group came about four years ago, they candidly revealed, at least in part due to a strategically prudent effort to find new ways of engaging patients. This admission brought a topical perspective to their presentation; directly addressing the issue of the struggle to find funding for arts therapies in the current economic climate. But the introduction of a crossmodality psychotherapy group also calls into mind many deeper questions and possibilities. Much of the focus of the paper was on exploring the surrounding complexities and anxieties triggered by working simultaneously within two different modalities. The creative duality presented an interesting dilemma both for service users and therapists in the group – and in some sense provided a form of leveller in their therapeutic relationship, as both experienced feelings of not being ‘good enough’ in response to being asked to engage with two different art forms. Both Montague and O’Connell described concerns about the potential for splitting in the group, which had to be addressed in the way that it was structured. Any opportunity for splitting could be deeply disorientating for patients, particularly in a client group already vulnerable to psychic fragmentation, as they did not want to reinforce service users’ internal disintegration. To help contain these anxieties, both conceptual and therapeutic frameworks were constructed. Firstly, the importance of clear, constant variables, versus those that could be worked with more flexibly were decided between them. Perhaps the most important of these was the structuring of time, along with the allocation and delineation of space. The division of the session between music therapy, art therapy and group discussion was crucial. Sessions would begin with music therapy, which was facilitated using more directive techniques, such as body and vocal soundscape, drumming and paired instrumental work. After this, the group would move across the space to a different part of the room, where they would engage with non-directive art therapy which provided opportunity for reflection on feelings triggered by the musical intervention. The presentation was given flavour and brought to life by colourful creative excerpts, including both live musical recordings of clients playing together in the group and examples of patients’ artwork, which helped to give us a real sense of their process. As well as this, Montague and O’Connell shared a number of clinical vignettes which provided a fascinating insight into the development of trust in the group, both between facilitators and service users. The final musical excerpt played was from the most recent session, held the previous week, and demonstrated a much greater sense of flow and togetherness – indicating the progression in the group working and thinking collaboratively over time. The clinical vignettes were divided between both Montague and O’Connell, which provided a sense of integration in the presentation and demonstrated an insight into their ability to hold the split as therapists in the group. Both practitioners communicated a powerful sense of the despair and hopelessness which can be present when working in a forensic setting, as well as the dangers of this becoming overwhelming. Managing damaging projections from patients is a painful experience, but essential for the development and survival of a group. The pair’s reflections revealed the potential strength inherent in a shared holding process – along Morning Presentation

– ‘The Good Enough Couple’ and FATAG Business

March 2014

with the imperative need to trust each other, face uncomfortable feelings and talk honestly together. This frank discussion of the complex counter-transference that occurs in a secure, clinical environment proved especially illuminating; particularly within the context of a group run jointly by male and female facilitators. The parental projections and associations from patients can prove toxic, and there is ample opportunity for genderising. This raises important questions about giving service users permission to think about gender and what their fantasies may be about the relationship between therapists in a cofacilitation dynamic, as well as how therapy can offer a potential space to redress earlier experiences of family. The morning’s presentation strongly highlighted the benefits of working collaboratively and the therapeutic opportunities afforded by cross-fertilisation between art forms. This seems important in a profession which can feel very isolated, as we tend to work across multiple institutions and wards, which can lead to practitioners feeling split off. At a time when limited funding and increased public sector cuts could create competitiveness and potential conflict between modalities, this paper provided a poignant reminder of the importance of working together to create containing spaces for rehabilitation.

FATAG Business

After a quick coffee break to reflect and refresh, the conference continued with an outline of FATAG business. This commenced with a look at the distribution of art, music, dance and dramatherapists present in the audience. It was observed that there was a higher proportion of music and dramatherapists present than in previous years, which seemed to nicely reflect the themes of the morning’s presentation regarding collaboration. FATAG is one of the only groups which is made up of all four modalities from within the arts therapy sector and a brief discussion ensued about the differences and commonalities in the way we work. After this, apologies were given by those unable to make the conference, as well as announcements regarding the content of future conferences and a call for papers for forthcoming events. The creation of the new FATAG logo was discussed, along with the importance of promotion of the website. Papers from conferences may be uploaded to the website in future, depending upon any issues regarding copyright. An update was provided on ongoing efforts between BAAT and FATAG to create a separate forensics special interest group and devise new clinical guidelines for art therapists working in prisons, with the aim for these to be included in the current prison service guidelines. These would better outline art therapy practice in order to promote better understanding of how art therapists fit into the service. If practitioners would like to be involved in the development of this process, please contact Tobias Arnup on: contact form An open invitation was put out for people to attend Saturday Forensic Forums. These are held monthly in Hampstead on Saturdays from 10.30am-12noon and are fantastic for furthering CPD. The forum provides a reflective

thinking

space

and

advisory

group.

Practitioners are welcome to submit papers to present. Cost £10. For more details, please check out the website at: http://saturdayforensicforum.com or email: contact form

The next FATAG conference will be held on Friday 6th June 2014 and presentations will be research based, including a paper from Helen Short on the use of rap music with adolescents in music therapy and a presentation from representatives of the Philadelphia Association. The November 2014 conference will involve a series of film presentations and a call is currently being put out for any practitioners who would like to contribute films to this based on their client work.

Thanks were also given to Heidi Jockelson for all her hard work as administrator for FATAG. Roanna Bond, Dramatherapist

Afternoon Presentation

– ‘In and Out of Control’ – An exploration of Art Therapy within a Prison Based Programme – Shaun Wassall and Grahame Greener

Shaun Wassall is currently the Art Therapist at HMP Low Newton as part of the Primrose Service for female personality disordered offenders. He also offers Art Therapy within a Female Forensic Service in a hospital setting. The provision of Art Therapy over both sites was established by Shaun in June 2012. Shaun provides both group and individual Art Therapy. Grahame Greener is currently a serving Prison Officer at HMP Low Newton. He has been a Prison Officer for 22 years, with the majority of his career spent working with Female offenders. For the last 5 years, Grahame has been working on The Primrose Service, which is a programme that offers assessment and treatment to female offenders who are diagnosed with a dangerous and severe Personality Disorder (DSPD). The Primrose Service is the only female DSPD unit and is integrated within a prison population. Grahame’s work on the unit includes facilitating both groups and individual session.

March 2014

The Primrose Programme was founded in 2006, and is located within HMP Low Newton. The aim of the Primrose Programme is to “reduce the risk of harm posed by severely personality disordered female offenders”.

Art therapy at the Primrose Programme. The Primrose Programme has space for 12 women who agree to take part in the treatment programme. They first enter a 12 week assessment period, followed by a 16 week treatment needs analysis period and then they move into individually

tailored

treatment

programme.

Art

therapy is one of the 9 therapeutic services available. Shaun and Grahame (unless he is not on shift) co-facilitate an art therapy group. The group operates under a slow open format with the maximum number of woman being four at any one time. The group is reviewed every three months and there is a culture of the oldest members introducing the newest members to the group when they join.

Shaun’s challenges as art therapist Some of the challenges described were: introducing art therapy to the prison; co-facilitation between art therapist and prison officers; promotion of the service; adapting the service and disclosure, acceptance, scepticism and containing difficult clinical material. A challenge that repeated throughout the presentation was about how to enable the prison officers to think positively about art therapy. Grahame reminded us that you can’t make others change and some people will never be interested in thinking about art therapy. An art therapy workshop was set up for prison officers to get a closer look at art therapy. It had been timed by the prison officers to start late in the day so that they might be able to get off from work early rather than them being interested in finding out more. However, during the session they were totally engaged and after being asked to draw somewhere where they felt safe, two of the four prison officers were in tears. They had been able to connect with themselves through artmaking and had found the experience quite powerful. In the context of the prison, Grahame made some comments which capture important aspects that art therapy has to offer,

“Just because she has drawn it doesn’t mean she is going to do it!”

“Art Therapy allows the women to shout without making a noise.”

Art therapy was described as a point where the prison staff could be split and manipulated. There was a lot of difficulty where “the women would make good use of the session but go back to the wing and tell a different story”. A way that this has been overcome is by handing over the session in front of the women when they are brought back to the wing. This benefits the prisoner’s therapeutic process but also the staff’s understanding of what goes on in art therapy. Grahame’s challenges and perspectives as a prison officer

Grahame described a prison officer’s job as ensuring prison safety and discipline. He found that art therapy challenged the prison officer’s position because the process of art therapy can explore unsafe feelings which are acted out through art-making within the therapeutic relationship. Grahame’s dual role of thinking with his “discipline head and his therapeutic head” was suggested by an audience member as being like that of a parent where you are the one giving hugs and also instilling discipline.

The questions that were raised for Grahame were “What do you challenge? What is right and wrong? Who makes the decisions? Am I qualified? Can I comment? What if I say one thing that undoes what Shaun has said?” Case Study

Shaun described a clinical case study of his work with one of the prisoners. This enabled us to think together about the highly potent feelings that can be brought up in this area of work. It highlighted that supervision and group thinking is paramount for the survival of the art therapist, prison officers and the prisoners. Questions and comments

• What did they think about male facilitators working with female prisoners? Is it better with two males? They had not thought very much about it. Perhaps this was because it was such a common set up in a prison.

• Was there a loss of interest? Grahame suggested that in contrast to sewing groups that are put on for the women, art therapy was not only for the women but also about them, which supported continued interest. • It was important to have a safety valve whereby the therapist could recognise when a break was needed for the survival of himself or the prisoner. • Hate is very important.

• Survival is a valuable thing to experience. • To Grahame – How has art therapy changed or informed prison officers? It has changed the way he views prisoners. “They are just like me”.

March 2014

Plenary

Comments, words and thoughts from the plenary: • Visitors from Holland were welcomed. • How much can we trust each other? (between co-facilitators).

• How honest shall we be? Rupture and repair. • Politeness.

• Couples – same sex verses mixed sex couples. • It’s not often that prison officers get to say how difficult it is to do their job. Masculine verses feminine. Maternal but maybe not – gender transcends art. We (therapists) become a mythical being – male/ female/therapist.

• Curiosity.

Towards the end Marian Liebmann was congratulated for her OBE and she responded by quoting an African saying, “it takes a whole village to raise a child” which was a great way to end a day of sharing and thinking together.

Rose Hall, Art Therapist

Venue: 2 Northdown Street, Kings

Cross, London, N1 9BG. 3 mins walk from Kings Cross Stations.

March 2014

March 2014

More posts

edition Diary Dates

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 32-33 DIARY DATES 2023 January 2023 Closing date for the BADth Gordon Wiseman Trust Fund. Details in Members’ area.…

The Prompt – final

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 22-31 Dear Jane, As a long-standing supporter of the publication, I write this open letter to thank you for…

people-caused climate destruction A Farewell Scenario

The Prompt, December 2022 · by EXCLUSIVE TO ARTS THERAPISTS · page 17-21 A FAREWELL SCENARIO 1996–2022 Scenario Arts in Personal Development was founded in…
account android arrow-alt-circle-down arrow-alt-circle-left arrow-alt-circle-right arrow-alt-circle-up arrow-down arrow-left arrow-right arrow-up author bars behance blogger bluesky buffer caret-down caret-left caret-right caret-square-down caret-square-left caret-square-right caret-square-up caret-up cart-menu-1 cart-menu-2 cart-menu-3 cart-menu-4 categories chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right chevron-up clock close comments cookies copyright coupon-discount date-modified date-published discord double-arrows-down double-arrows-left double-arrows-right double-arrows-up dribbble envelope-open envelope eye facebook fax flickr foursquare github gmail google-drive grid-view hashtag hollow-ring homepage instagram ios level-down-alt level-up-alt line link linkedin list-view login logout long-arrow-alt-down long-arrow-alt-left long-arrow-alt-right long-arrow-alt-up mastodonmedium messenger mobile-menu mobile phone pinterest place qq quote-left quote-right quotes reading-time-hourglass reading-time-stopwatch reddit rss scroll-to-top search shazam shopping-bag shopping-cart side-panel-opening-2-left side-panel-opening-2-right side-panel-opening-left side-panel-opening-right skype slack small-arrow-down small-arrow-left small-arrow-right small-arrow-up sms snapchat soundcloud spinner spotify stackoverflow sync telegram threadstiktok times-circle tinder trello tripadvisor tumblr twitch twitter viber vimeo vine vkontakte website wechat whatsapp windows wishlist xing yelp youtube zoom