Play Therapy and Dramatherapy
compared
By Gail Atkins (Dramatherapist) and Nina Rye (Play therapist) Play Therapy and Dramatherapy have much in common. There are also some key differences in their theoretical frameworks, and what makes them different is not always easy to define, especially as there is much variation in the way different therapists work. To compare the two therapies, we have independently written about the same fictional child, “Joe”. Brief referral details are given below, followed by Nina’s account of how she would work with Joe, and then Gail’s. Nina works at Thurlow House, Tier III CAMHS clinic in King’s Lynn. Gail works at the Unthank Family Centre in Norwich. A version of this article was first printed in the Play Therapy Magazine, Spring 2010 and is printed here with their kind permission. Referral information
JOE, 8 years old, a Looked After Child Presenting difficulties: physically and verbally aggressive to children at school, also at home with the foster carers’ own children and the other foster child in the home. Verbally aggressive with the foster carers, and sometimes with school staff. Two fixed term exclusions from school. Poor concentration, some impulsivity, finds it hard to sit still for more than about 10 minutes unless he is playing an electronic game. Strengths: likes football and PE. Curious and enquiring if something takes his interest e.g. dinosaurs. History: Third foster placement since being removed from birth family 3 years ago. Prior to this he was the subject of a Child Protection Plan for a year on the grounds of emotional abuse and neglect. Foster home: foster carers Mary and Phil, Joe and two other non-related children in care – a 2 year old and a 6 month old baby.
School: no Statement, no learning difficulties identified. Social relationships: at school does not have a close friend but is friendly with a group of boys in his class and they enjoy having a ‘kickabout’ at playtime. Sometimes, they fall out with him because he tries to dominate the group.
The Play Therapy Approach
Joe was referred by Jenny, one of our Primary Mental Health Workers in the Looked After and Adopted Children’s Team. As soon as I was in a position to offer Joe an intervention at the CAMHS clinic I contacted his foster carers, Mary and Phil. Mary was able to come to the initial appointment at the clinic to meet me and discuss therapy for Joe. Mary had to bring the younger foster children with her as there was no-one she could leave them with.
I normally offer filial therapy as the treatment of choice for a child in foster care in order to strengthen the carer-child relationship and to minimise the effect of yet another professional in the child’s life. However, when I introduced the idea to Mary it quickly became apparent that Mary was not at that time in a position to make the considerable commitment that filial therapy demands. For instance, Mary could not envisage how she could set aside 30 minutes a week just for her and Joe, without the other children present. Phil was a long-distance lorry driver so his working week varied quite considerably. Wondering how Mary managed at all, I suggested that filial therapy might be an option for the future, but for now individual Play Therapy with Joe seemed best, and this would require her to bring him on a weekly basis at the same time and on the same day, and to stay on the premises. Once we had established that Mary could bring the toddler and baby with her, and that the session could be in school time, we were able to discuss Joe’s current difficulties and how Play Therapy might help. I followed my usual plan of offering an initial 8 sessions for Joe, with a review after he had been 6 times. I gave Mary an assurance that Joe could have more sessions if necessary and let her know that many of the children I work with have between 6 months and a year of therapy with me. Mary seemed relieved, although she was not sure whether Joe would still be living with them in a year’s time. Although there were these uncertainties, I judged that there was probably a sufficient desire on Mary’s part to “get Joe some help”, and I hoped that she would be able to bring him regularly. I made a mental note to ask Jenny to continue to support Mary while I worked with Joe. The next stage was for me to meet Joe, which I did by way of a play observation followed by a play demonstration. I noted that Joe tried to be on his best
behaviour, flashing me a big smile and saying, “let’s play” to the 2-year-old. Mary did her best to divide her attention between the fretful baby, the 2-year-old and Joe. The 20-minute play observation was enough to show that more than 10 minutes of sociable play was more than Joe could manage. He see-sawed between being a controlling “big brother” and a toddler-like rival. It was also obvious how hard he found it to share Mary’s attention when he felt at all uncertain. I noted that he called her “Mum”.
Joe was too restless to sit down to hear about play therapy so, while Mary sat to one side and gave the baby a bottle, I played with the 2-year-old and Joe. I managed to tell Joe a bit about play therapy by saying things like, “Next time you come it will be just you and me in here. Mum will be in the waiting room”. Joe showed signs that he might become absorbed in sensory play, but he was too anxious to settle. He frequently looked over at Mary, and sometimes went up to her and was “nice” to the baby. Joe was less controlling of the 2-year-old while I played with them, perhaps because I was reflecting the feelings and thoughts of both children. I wondered what Mary made of this. My style was obviously different to hers and I think this made it hard for her to sit and observe. After they had left, I cleared up the play room hoping that enough of an alliance had been made to carry us through the first few sessions. I also noted that I had better try to squeeze in at least a phone call, if not a visit, to Joe’s teacher, as Mary had expressed considerable concern about his recent behaviour in school; also a phone call to Joe’s social worker. I anticipated the familiar struggle to do enough work with the system surrounding the child, leaving messages with the social worker, school and home and trying to return their calls between appointments. Joe was a child in need of “holding” in a network of caring adults who would communicate with each other. For a time, I would be part of that network, and would also have my unique role of offering therapeutic containment in the playroom.
Dramatherapy Approach
Joe was identified by his social worker, Jenny, as a child who might benefit from therapeutic work, and he was referred to the Family Centre for Dramatherapy. For children with early-life trauma or attachment difficulties, Dramatherapy can offer a space to explore their feelings within a safe, containing environment. Often, such children have experienced a profound lack of emotional containment and they are frequently overwhelmed by their very powerful feelings. Because Dramatherapy has the capacity to work in all developmental phases, children are enabled to revisit and process their early experiences, with the therapist offering containment of the nature that would be experienced in a secure attachment relationship. To prepare for work with Joe, I read the consultation and referral documents, his recent care history, and spoke with Jenny. Then I contacted his foster carers, Mary and Phil, to arrange an initial meeting. Mary attended with the two younger foster children. While they played, we discussed Joe’s current difficulties, his history, and how he managed at home and at school. Mary was very concerned about Joe’s aggression, going on to say that at times, she found him unmanageable. Because a further placement change or breakdown would be extremely detrimental to Joe’s long term emotional well-being, it was clear that supporting Mary – as Joe’s primary attachment figure – in order that she could support Joe, would be an important aspect of this work.
I discussed the practicalities with Mary, and she understood the need to support the work with Joe by bringing and collecting him from sessions; we also agreed that we would speak on the telephone each week to share information – without breaking the confidentiality of the Dramatherapy sessions. Joe would be aware that we were doing this. I stressed the importance of Joe attending regularly, and we agreed an initial six sessions of Dramatherapy. I assured Mary knew that the work could continue as long as there was a need, and that she, I, and Jenny would review it after each six-session period. Furthermore, Joe – if it was appropriate for him – would also attend these meetings. Whether or not he attended, Joe’s views would be taken into account when we discussed either the continuation or termination of the work. Mary explained that she did not know how long Joe would be with her and Phil, and I assured her that even if he were to move on, the work with him could continue, and would in fact provide some containment for him during any transition to a new foster placement. The following week, we met again – this time with Joe and his social worker, Jenny. I had provided some drawing materials and dinosaurs for Joe to use while we were talking. It has often been my experience that when children are ready to discuss or share their life experiences, it is helpful for them to know that I, as their therapist, have an understanding of their history. Therefore, I asked Jenny to outline to us all – in terms that Joe himself could understand – what had happened to him in his past and why he was coming to Dramatherapy. While Jenny was talking, Joe was alert and listening but was playing with the dinosaurs, roaring loudly or distracting Mary when the material being mentioned became uncomfortable for him to hear.
To
explain
the
non-verbal
nature
of
Dramatherapy, I reflected his response to him, and talked about what the sessions would be like: that we would use our bodies and voices but not talk too