Play Therapy and Dramatherapy
compared: Part 2
By Gail Atkins (Dramatherapist) and Nina Rye (Play therapist) The initial six sessions and the first review In the previous issue we began to tell you about “Joe”, a fictional child. We wrote independent accounts of imagined first meetings and plans for his therapy, dramatherapy in Gail’s case and Play Therapy in Nina’s. A version of this article was first printed in the Play Therapy Magazine, Summer 2010 and is re-printed with kind permission.
In this issue we take the story further, inviting you to note where the two modes converge and diverge. As both of us offered six sessions followed by a review, it is this beginning phase that we go on to describe here. First, a brief reminder of Joe: Joe is 8 years old and in his third foster placement. He is restless, impulsive, has poor concentration, and is frequently physically and verbally aggressive. He was emotionally abused and neglected in his birth family until being removed at age 5.
Play Therapy
I was in the playroom putting things in place when I heard Joe and his foster carer Mary arrive for the first session. Joe’s voice was loud, and Mary’s firm, as they were welcomed by a member of the admin staff. There were still a few minutes until the session was due to start, so I quickly went to my desk to review the main points in his file. I had already had three appointments with other children and needed to take a moment to refocus on Joe. Since meeting him a week ago I had rung his social worker, Jenny. Jenny would come to the first review. We had agreed a date that I had confirmed with Mary.
When I entered the waiting room, Joe was making something with Duplo at the table. He looked up and then back at what he was building. I greeted him, then Mary, and told him it was time to come to the playroom. Joe went on building, then suddenly jumped up and marched toward the door looking fierce. Almost before I could say anything he doubled back to tell Mary not to let anyone break up his building. I made a mental note that Joe’s behaviour so far confirmed my working hypotheses that he found transitions difficult, and that he wanted to control things and people. I also had in mind hypotheses of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) and Type C (insecure: ambivalent) attachment. I had not rushed into making a referral to the psychiatric team for an assessment for ADHD. I had discussed this with Joe’s social worker and Jenny (referrer from the Looked After and Adopted Children Team) and had decided to see how the first six sessions went and to discuss it at the review. One reason for this was that typical behaviours for ADHD and those for Type C attachment overlap considerably.
Three things stood out from Joe’s first session. The first was that he seemed to play out fragments from his whole history, from infancy up to the present. The second was how his ADHD-like behaviours were a lot less evident than reported elsewhere. The third was that Joe almost threw himself into role-play. In each of these things Joe was very much like many other children I had seen with similar histories. At the same time I could see that the abuse and neglect Joe had experienced had had a profound effect on him. Most children that I see display greatly reduced ADHD symptoms in the playroom, partly I think because they are getting consistent, empathic attunement, so they quickly sense that they do not have to work at being attended to. But Joe, for all his enthusiasm, could not keep to one idea for long. He struggled to keep to one story in his role-play, making changes every 30–60 seconds: “I’m a baby… No, pretend I’m the dad… no, an army man…” His story was “all there” but in hundreds of tiny fragments. I attributed this to the history of abuse as much as to any possible diagnosis. On the positive side, he did seem to have some organising strategies for his behaviour and his stories in the playroom.
As Joe entered the playroom each time I reminded him, “This is your special time in the playroom. You can do almost anything you want to in here. If there is anything you may not do I will let you know.” Joe always went to the snack, stuffed the biscuit into his mouth, drank thirstily, and then ate the sultanas, already starting to move around the room. Joe found the crate with the role-play toys in his first session and went straight for the guns and knives. Energetic and confusing stories tumbled out, of robbers, policemen, SWAT teams, babies and dads. I took what cues I could to play my roles, not trying to slow him down but doing my best to keep alongside and be “in” each jagged fragment with him. At this early stage in Joe’s
therapy there was no resolution to anything, but rather a series of betrayals and injuries. About half way through the 60-minute session Joe would move to the sand trays, usually heaping dry sand into the hoppers of both the sand wheels to keep them spinning. Sometimes he played with the wet sand too, making tunnels, driving the bulldozer or dumper truck, and giving me orders. My role was to allow the play to happen, to be with him in the experience as fully as I could, and to make empathic and congruent reflections. These were based on what was happening, and informed (when possible) by what I knew of his circumstances and history. I also needed to set limits, as when he tried to climb up the shelving at one end of the room to get something attractive but out of reach (another child’s craft work): “Joe, the shelves are not for climbing. That’s one of the things you can’t do in here. You wanted to touch that (object), maybe paint it. You can paint something you make….” Faced with a “no” elsewhere, Joe had a coping strategy of using a “winning smile”, or if that did not work, of getting angry and having a temper outburst. In the playroom he still used the smile, but when that did not deflect me from the limit, he showed his anger symbolically by hammering pegs into holes on the toy workbench or else kicking the foam football. My empathic reflections about his anger and disappointment, together with the provision of suitable equipment, meant that Joe did not need to escalate his expressions of anger into harmful or destructive behaviour. He loved hitting and kicking! Here he could do both, gaining a calming effect from safe physical activity while having his feelings named.
By the time I met with Joe’s carer and social worker for the first review there were several well-established themes in his play. I used these as the basis of my feedback to them. In line with my usual practice for children of Primary school age, Joe was not present at the review meeting. At the start of the play therapy session before the review I said, “Joe, I expect you know that I am meeting with Mary and Jenny tomorrow. You will be at school. I wonder if there is anything you want me to tell them… Anything you don’t want me to say… I can tell you a bit about what I will say to them…”. Joe threw me a quick, anxious look, and then acted as if I had not spoken. I acknowledged his anxiety and let him know that he could tell me or ask me about it later. I began to remind him that I would not be giving details of his play, but would say what I thought I had learned about him in the playroom – but Joe cut across this by shooting me and ordering me to “Play!” At the “5 minute warning” of the end of the session, I mentioned the review again, saying that we would be talking about whether he should come for “lots more” or “just a few more” times. Joe ignored this too. I said I hoped he could come for “lots”, and he gave a tiny nod.
Mary and Jenny were keen to hear about Joe’s play therapy. Neither had availed themselves of my offer of phone contact in the interim, so this was the first they had heard other than a brief reassurance that he had engaged well. I outlined Joe’s main play themes, which I had named “Powerful vs. powerless”, “In/out of control”, “full/empty”, and “injury vs. restitution”. I explained that these themes ran through every session and gave an overview. In role-plays, Joe played the allpowerful aggressor, while I was the powerless recipient whose efforts at self-defence were all in vain. In some activities, such as sand play he enjoyed the feeling of being “in control” and yet obviously struggled to achieve it. His “full/empty” play seemed eloquent of his previous emotional and physical neglect, as did his play about injury, which was full of stories of danger. As yet there was no “restitution” or rescue. As I talked about these themes, Mary contributed her own experience of Joe, for example of how he still crammed food, and sometimes hid it in his bedroom. I was able to explain that some of Joe’s play was regressive, using Erikson’s theory as a developmental framework. His use of paint, for instance, was messy and sensory, linking to the toddler stage. I made sure to mention that I had needed to set a few limits and Joe had kept to these. I explained what would happen if he broke a set limit: first I would remind him and warn him what would happen if he did it again. Then if he did, I would enforce the consequence – either the end of play with that item, or (where that did not fit) the end of the session. The consequence was not a punishment, but a result of his choice, and it would be presented as that to Joe. It was a useful review because the three of us were able to reflect together on Joe’s inner emotional world. We agreed that play therapy sessions would continue for at least 6 months, subject to reviews every 6 sessions or so. School had rung Mary to say that Joe had taken a biscuit from another child’s lunchbox, and to say that his behaviour had got worse, if anything, since therapy started. Mary asked if I could speak to his teacher and I said I would phone and offer to meet her. Sometimes an extended phone call suffices, but where there might be incipient hostility, I prefer to visit in person if possible. Meanwhile Jenny, Mary and I agreed to keep in touch about any new developments. I was pleased to note Mary’s genuine concern for Joe and that the placement still seemed reasonably secure. As we closed, Mary asked if she should tell Joe anything about the meeting. His worry would be that we had talked about how “bad” he was. We discussed a simple straightforward message from both of us: that we agreed with him, that he should come of “lots more” times, because he was “doing well” in play therapy. If he wanted to know more we could say how I had told them that he played exciting stories about danger, and being strong. There was a lot more that we could have
talked about in the review, but having run out of time, we had to end there.
Dramatherapy
One of our business support staff phoned me to say that Joe had arrived. Before I went to the waiting room to meet him, I took a few seconds to breathe slowly, be mindful of what thoughts and feelings were with me, and what expectations I held about the session. Children who have experienced early trauma and abuse are often especially sensitive to other people’s feelings and expectations, particularly when they themselves are anxious and vigilant, as Joe often was. As I went into the waiting room, Joe looked up at me and quickly looked away, back to the board he was drawing on. He seemed unsure about how to respond to me and what was expected. I greeted him and his foster carer and we spoke generally about how Joe’s week had been. I asked Joe if he was ready to begin our session. As we walked down the corridor, I reminded Joe which room we would be in and how long our session would be. He was jumping and hopping, and I took the opportunity to reflect this back to him by wondering aloud whether he was feeling jumpy in his tummy. One of the containing aspects of dramatherapy is the use of ritual; a dramatherapist will offer or provide a ritual for a client to bring their material to and work within. I have found that children who have experienced abuse and neglect will often reject offers of structures. The ritual space that provides containment for some clients is experienced by these children as frightening and oppressive. They need to be in control in their sessions, therefore I work in a non-directive way and the rituals that are used are those that arise spontaneously from the child. As the weeks went on, Joe’s way of moving along the corridor and my reflection of it to him became the way he ‘told’ me how he was that day, and this became the ritual that started our sessions. Once we were in the room, I pointed to our agreement that I had pinned on the wall next to a calendar showing Joe’s sessions and his review; I reminded him that he could use whatever he wanted within the boundaries we had discussed. There were puppets, costumes, art materials and a sand tray with a range of small world objects. Like many other children in the first few sessions, Joe moved quickly between activities, starting and stopping as new things caught his interest, dropping things as he went, leaving a trail behind him and remaining watchful of me. While this behaviour is typical of children with ADHD, it is also typical of children with attachment difficulties and often becomes less pronounced as children feel less anxious in sessions. During his play, snippets of stories and roles emerged but he could not remain with any one activity for any length of time. As he played, I witnessed his stories and when he seemed to seek something from me, by looking at me or asking me to play, I reflected his story back to him or joined in his play, following his lead.
Two or three times during the session he wanted to leave the room and find ‘something’ from the corridor but he was not able to specify what the ‘something’ was. It was possible that Joe was testing whether I would hold the boundaries of the session or that he was feeling overwhelmed by the intensity of the session. Because the room itself is an important containing aspect of the therapy, I reminded him that during sessions we stay in the room. However, he left the room anyway and stood near a sand tray in the corridor with his hands in the sand, glancing at me occasionally, waiting for my response. I stood by the door and waited, reminding him about the session boundaries we had agreed. I wondered aloud what he might be feeling and thinking until, after a minute or so, he returned. From this exchange, I believe he learnt that I would remain with his feelings without rejecting him or becoming angry or overwhelmed. I had recognised his need to control, and was able to allow this without the boundaries of the session being transgressed. After three sessions, Joe was able to remain in the room for the whole hour. When it was time to leave, I said goodbye to the room and the toys that Joe had played with and told them Joe would be coming again the next week. I also made some observations to the toys about how Joe had engaged with them, and in this way I was able to offer some reflections about Joe’s experience of the session indirectly without requiring or expecting a response from Joe. Joe joined in the goodbyes, naming the things he had engaged with most strongly. From then on, this became the ending ritual of our sessions. Over the next 5 sessions, Joe settled into some patterns of play. My role in his play was to contain his process; sometimes I was a witness, other times participant, and it was he who decided which and directed me accordingly. For him, I was either a container onto which he could project his feelings and confront them, or I could accompany him on his journeys into his inner world. When he cast me in a role, I retained the ability to step in and out of ‘the pretend’ in order to maintain my capacity to hold the session. When Joe worked projectively or in role and I played with him, I asked him to direct my actions and to give me the words to speak. This ensured that we stayed with his process and his material. Occasionally Joe would get frustrated by this and demand that I just played – I did, with the agreement that if I spoke or acted in a way that was incongruent, if I ‘got it wrong’ he would tell me, which he did, boldly – ‘NO, not like that!’. Joe would often begin in the sand, hiding and burying objects and finding them again. Sometimes he wanted me to find them, and sometimes he chose to himself.
Sometimes he would take on the role of a chief, and I would be the slave; his need to be in control could be both contained and played out in metaphor/story between ‘chief’ and ‘slave’, rather than in sessions between Joe and Gail. I referred to these sections of play as stories, the ‘chief and slave story’ and offering the possibility for his stories to be revisited, scripted, drawn or written down and read back to him. Like so many Looked After children, Joe needed to test me out, to find out if I was going to be an adult who rejected him if he showed me the parts of himself that scared others and sometimes scared himself. He played with puppets: the shows would be brief, noisy and aggressive and he told me to make scared noises when I was watching. I reassured him that however scary they were, I would stay with him and watch his stories. These puppet shows provided a way for Joe to be witnessed in telling the stories of his life, and he would tell me how to respond, projecting onto me feelings that were unbearable for him or giving me the response he needed to hear. When it felt appropriate, I would add my own emotional responses to his stories, allowing him to access some feelings he had perhaps not allowed himself to experience before and to enable him, if was able to, to see his story from a different perspective. Occasionally Joe would ask me to do a puppet show, and I would tell aspects of his story using information from his sessions. At times, Joe would interact with me in a physical or confrontational way, wanting to fight. I would offer him space to do this ‘in a pretend’: we could engage in ‘stage fighting’ where distance is maintained at all times between participants. As an alternative, I held large cushions for Joe to hit or kick allowing him to bodily experience his ‘fighting’ feelings but keeping both of us safe. Sometimes Joe would exhaust himself, punching and hitting and then rest on the cushions calmer and more relaxed than before. In role play, there were characters which Joe played out. One of these was a roaring, stamping monster which Joe named ‘Claws’; in doing so, he created a separate entity, distanced from himself, that could be experienced in all its power and fury, without Joe himself being consumed by his feelings of rage or the shame that often followed his outbreaks of anger at home. Children like Joe have frequently not had the experience of having their feelings contained or named by an attuned adult. After Joe had been Claws, it was important to help him to de-role, to come back to being little boy Joe; to help him notice the bodily feelings of anger and the transition to calmness thus developing his capacity to name his feelings and eventually learn to contain them himself. During the first six weeks of work, Mary had phoned me several times to discuss aspects of Joe’s behaviour; she was particularly concerned that some of his difficult behaviours had escalated since starting therapy. From what I understood from my sessions with him, Mary and I were able to consider Joe’s responses and behaviour. From information that she provided, I was able to make some connections about some aspects of Joe’s stories. Through our discussions, we gained a better understanding of Joe’s inner world and from that, how he might respond to his outer world. Furthermore, our conversations allowed her a space to unload her frustrations and anxieties about Joe, and thereafter be more available to contain him when he was at his most challenging and confrontational. We had a review after the first six sessions. Children will their attend dramatherapy reviews if it seems appropriate, but in this instance we agreed that it would not be appropriate for Joe as he found such meetings anxietyprovoking. The review was marked on the calendar with only two sessions following it. I pointed this out to Joe and he looked at me with alarm. I reminded him that there was going to be a review with Mary and his social worker to talk about his dramatherapy and to decide what would happen next. I asked if there was anything he wanted me to say or not say; he did not respond but went to the sand tray and piled sand up over his hands. I let him know what I would be saying to Mary and his social worker, but again, he did not respond. I asked what he thought about having future sessions. He did not respond but I was able to reflect to him his alarm at only seeing two more on the calendar. I asked whether he would like to continue coming for another set of sessions, and he nodded in agreement. Mary and Jenny attended the review and we discussed Joe’s process in therapy. Jenny asked me whether Joe had been able to talk about his feelings; this remains a frequently asked question which I reframe in terms of what Joe is ‘telling’ us through his stories. This goes some way to bridging the gap between the expectation and the reality of what therapy with children looks like. I gave an outline of the main themes of Joe’s stories. I also spoke about different ‘aspects’ or ‘bits’ of Joe whom I had met, and which had been named in the sessions: ‘baby’ Joe, ‘monster’ Joe and Joe ‘the hero’. Mary shared her own experiences of Joe and fed back information that had come from school, and together we were able to explore Joe’s inner world. It was agreed that dramatherapy sessions would continue with reviews every 6 to 8 sessions, over a minimum period of 6 months. Mary agreed to feed this information back to Joe and I put new set of sessions on Joe’s calendar. Similarities and differences
The above accounts further illustrate our ways of working. A third section will follow as the case comes to an end. Meanwhile, we welcome feedback, thoughts and discussion.
*
+
“%”$” “$ # $$) $/ %”!!$
$$”‘%%”‘$%
‘ $%,’%’ &$&,
“$,
;A
:;C:>@ACB@B :AAC=B;CB<? 2 . %”!/%!$5&!&$!&/” 0″( !& ” “”‘$1 )”$%”#% $ %$% ” & “!&+ ‘!+ “$!!!”( !&%+”&$#+)”$%”#%+$/ %”!!$/ ” & )”$%”# %$% % #$%”! ! #$”%%”! (“# !& ‘%!##$”%$” !”( !&%+”&$#+!$ &$#+! “$$&” &&!*#”$&(“‘$!+&$”‘&””‘$%#&$’ ,&$”‘ ! !& )& ! !&$&”! ” $! ” $&( !’! “( !&, !, “, %!!, (“, %&”$+, (%’ %, #”&$+ ! $ %/ )”$%”# ) *#”$ $!& “”‘$- !(‘ ! $”‘# $%#”!%%&”&&””‘$) “$ &%%”&&(&%/)”$%”# %$%%”%$”‘#/ &%%’&”$#”#)&!)&”‘&#$”$! “( !& %+”&$#+ “$ $ &$#+ *#$!/ &% “$ & )”$%”#%$%” “)%.
=:&
!’$+<:;;
<A&$’$+<:;;
<A&$<:;;
<>&#$ <:;;
<C&+<:;;
<@&
‘!<:;;
;:&
‘+<:;;
<>&
‘+<:;;
“%& “$ & %$% ” )”$%”#% %. 7>::/ % $ &, %” $+ “” !%(%/
$ $’ &$#’ $”!’ “# !# $”” %## %”#( “( %”‘, %’/-..
$/ %”! !$ % ! “( !& %+”&$#%&, && %&$ $ &$#%&34,!!%$$/%%”$&%” “&$!”&$/ %”!1%)”$!&$&% “( !&,(“,%&”$+, )$&!!(%’ %)&!&#%+”&$#’&#$”%%/%”($ <?+$%*#$!)”$ !)&&$&(!#$”$ !$&%,!” )&#”#” %! &%/”%!!&!”$#+ !! ‘%!&!” ‘%””+/