Fair deal:
legal representation in
fitness to practise cases
All Health Professions Council (HPC) registrants need to face the possibility of a fitness to practise complaint being made against them, and get the advice and representation they need if they do face proceedings. As the HPC approaches its eighth birthday, the Department of Health has announced that it will be renamed the Health and Care Professions Council to reflect its increasingly important role. The HPC already holds responsibility for over 250,000 registrants, and all of the signs suggest this number will grow.
It has received a steady increase of complaints about registrants, and last year received more from members of the public than anyone else, a trend that is likely to continue. Anyone can make a complaint to the HPC, with no time limit on how long after the event this complaint can be made. Of course the public must be protected, but it is important registrants too are getting a fair deal.
Case to answer
A registrant could find themselves before an HPC panel facing an allegation even when the identity of the complainant is unknown. Article 22(6) of the Health Professions Order 2001 allows the HPC to investigate complaints purely on the basis of information from a person who does not wish to become a complainant. This leaves the door open to proceedings based on hearsay evidence alone.
One would expect to contest such a claim successfully, but it takes an average of 15 months to conclude a complaint, and for registrants that could mean 15 months of severe personal strife. Complaints are initially considered by the investigating committee, which decides whether there is a case to answer. It needs to be satisfied that there is a realistic or genuine possibility that the HPC will be able to prove the alleged facts, that these amount to the statutory ground (e.g. misconduct) and that fitness to practise is thus impaired. This is considered privately and is paper based, and it is important for the registrant to provide a timely and effective response to the allegations.
Last year, the HPC dealt with 533 cases questioning fitness to practise, and in 57% of these the committee found a case to answer. Even if no case to answer was concluded, the committee can include learning points – guidance issued for the registrant to improve their practice. No appeal can arise from a committee’s decision to suggest learning points. If a panel decides there is a case to answer, the complaint will then proceed to a full hearing.
Burden of proof: balance of probabilities It is important to bear in mind that the burden of proof even when quasi-criminal allegations are made is always the civil burden of proof – on the balance of probabilities.
This low burden of proof is extremely worrying. The fact that this is consistent with other regulatory bodies is not a mitigating factor. If the HPC concludes that a registrant’s fitness to practise is impaired the consequences could be disastrous. A typical case could involve a registrant faced with an allegation of dishonesty. Such an allegation is serious and goes to the heart of someone’s integrity and reputation. In a criminal court, such an offence can only be proved if the jury are satisfied that they are sure. This means that if the defendant’s account might be right, they are entitled to be acquitted. The same allegation tried before an HPC tribunal need only be proved on the balance of probabilities – an adverse finding could be made simply on the basis that it is more likely than not that the registrant is guilty of the offence. Lack of legal representation
Given these high stakes, it is astounding that the majority of registrants who face such action either fail to attend hearings or have only a union representative to aid them. In most cases, registrants used union representatives as opposed to specially qualified lawyers. There is no doubt that union representation has its advantages, but as the tribunal develops it will rely more and more on case law and precedent, and registrants may benefit from union representation
working alongside specialist lawyers. With the potential of a devastating outcome, and the possibility of criminal proceedings, many do not have any legal representation at any stage of the process. It is difficult to know whether this is because they are unaware of the distinct advantages that this would confer, or whether perceived potential legal costs are a factor. In many cases, existing indemnity insurance does not extend to HPC representation. Many registrants are under the impression that their professional insurance will provide cover when in fact it is limited to claims of personal negligence. In all cases, the insurance cover provided should be checked.
Getting legal representation
Should a registrant need legal advice and/or representation, they will find that the cost of legal services does not necessarily have to be prohibitive. As a result of changes to the legal profession, registrants can now instruct barristers directly without the need to also pay for solicitors, thereby keeping costs down. There are also companies that provide advice and representation in return for a low monthly subscription. Whatever route is chosen, ultimately registrants should ensure that their representative is:
m Professionally qualified and regulated by the Bar Standards Board
m Experienced in health disciplinary regulation m Able to advise in initial stages as well as represent at the hearing.
Tanveer Qureshi, barrister specialising in professional regulation and disciplinary law
BADth WELCOMES THE FOLLOWING
NEW MEMBERS
Full members:
Kate Richardson, Dover, Kent
Student members:
Tim Fagan, Bradford, West Yorkshire Alice Liddell, Shepton Mallet, Somerset Lara Poole, Nottingham
Sophie Louise Brown, Irthlingborough, Northamptonshire (formerly Associate member)
Dramatherapy
Henley, Banbury, London
Lauraine Leigh
www.familytherapy.co.uk
www.stoptellingmetoeat.co.uk