April 2015
Dear BADth Executive
I’m writing to offer some comment on the publicity/advertising campaign you have launched recently. I’m an experienced dramatherapist practising privately and also as a freelancer in the voluntary sector. Much of my dramatherapy work has been with asylum seekers and refugees, addressing issues of acute trauma, post traumatic stress, depression, anxiety, loss and ongoing crisis. I have worked with adults and children from diverse backgrounds and have also offered dramatherapy to trainee arts therapists including dramatherapists. For over ten years years I worked in television production, as a researcher and then as a director and have been a professional writer for nearly thirty years. Writing and directing work has included a range of drama for theatre, broadcast and non broadcast media including working on some promotional and training films. I also have extensive experience of teaching drama in secondary schools and film and tv production, acting skills and scriptwriting in both adult and higher education.
The purpose of setting all of this out is to underline the fact that the comment which follows is offered from a professionally informed position.
I should say at the outset I think this campaign is, and will prove to be, a waste of money – and I imagine quite a few thousand pounds went on this exercise. In my view what Bruce Howard Bailey and Mary Smail previously did by way of making a promotional video with John Bowtell, though obviously very well intentioned, looked and sounded too amateur, lacked formality and, crucially, failed to get across what dramatherapy is and how it works. Now, with the new campaign, it seems the pendulum has swung in terms of more polished production standards and still the target has been missed. I bet if you showed these new videos to a range of ordinary people in the street they would have little idea what dramatherapy is or how it operates after watching them. Whether they would be induced to try it after seeing them is also, I think, very doubtful. Both the videos and the posters in time-honoured ad (wo)man style attempt simply to hook customers but then rely on the customer educating him or herself further. True, some of the posters squash in broad stroke information and the BADth website and existing leaflets also offer some additional information about what media might be employed in sessions and yet I do think even when they have taken that additional information in (if they bother) people will be little wiser with regard to how the therapy actually works. ‘Puppets. masks, moving yes, yes – fine, I get that, but how exactly does that relate to my depression/anxiety etc etc?’ And how can all that arty mucking about, as some might see it, equate to ‘proper’ talking therapies? (Incidentally I’m noticing ‘talking therapy’ as a term is now entering every day, mainstream discourse).
The posters give the impression, to me at least, with that bold banner FOUND – (an idea borrowed directly from the disturbing film ‘Gone Girl’) – and its subversive spin on missing persons posters that dramatherapy is potentially a cure-all and perhaps a fast-acting one at that. Only one of the videos is cautious enough to restrict itself to a claim that dramatherapy can help. The posters also tend to suggest dramatherapy is primarily a group therapy and can easily be offered as such; that really does seem to be misrepresenting the facts. So a dramatherapist is like a busking artist on the beach at Brighton (I presume) who whatever the mask you as client choose to wear, will see right through and always be able to reach the real you. Really?! Or does he make you create and wear that mask and then get
April 2015
8”
his drawing of you wrong? Not such a silly question for the markedly autistic viewing this film. But you don’t have to be autistic not to be able or perhaps willing to penetrate the intended metaphorical conceit of the piece. The video really runs the risk of remaining first and foremost a somewhat self-satisfied piece of advertising. Indeed all four videos (albeit in contrast to the posters) are quite gender-weighted, middle-class in tone, content and positioning and culturally very narrow in scope, with perhaps the purely captioned one avoiding some of these serious shortcomings. In-jokes about the movies (some arguably outdated ones at that) and ‘moving’ grandiose Shakespearian soliloquising may simply reinforce people’s worst fears and prejudices about what dramatherapy might be and what kind of people it might be for. And if, as the strapline claims, ‘it’s not about acting’ (which of course sometimes it can be and is) then what’s that bloke doing centre stage in a theatre? I think the idea of commissioning an ad campaign is in itself questionable. I feel sure it would have been possible to make an accessible, engaging video piece which really reached out to all comers and spoke more eloquently, essentially, and illuminatingly about what dramatherapy (in its several leanings and guises) does and how it can be of help; modelling on the ever more popular notion of evidencing through vignettes, and artfully scripting image, music, dialogue and narrative would in my opinion be a fruitful approach to take. I feel sure just such a piece could have been created and offered out as a useful promotional, explanatory tool. I guess it will be argued that the posters offer mini short stories. But they are of the ‘abracadabra’/ ‘in one bound (s)he was free’ variety … inferring guaranteed recovery purely by dint of participation. I for one am not actually persuaded to use or recommend any of these videos or posters and I wonder how widespread the uptake will be amongst BADth members. I’ll be surprised if the campaign is effective – and by the way let’s please not mistake number of hits on Youtube, Twitter et al. for enlightenment about or engagement with dramatherapy. And so, finally, to the second reason I object to the idea of this campaign. It seems to me to be embracing an unmindful and unhelpful habit of these times, by rendering reductive and commodifying what is for many practitioners a cherished vocation and a dignified, profession – one which rests on many years carefully thought out theory and practice. True, CBT is a significant competitor and in many settings time-limited work is the order of the day. But BADth jumps on that bandwagon, misrepresents or distorts its essential values at its peril. Sell dramatherapy as a quick fix and that’s precisely what will be expected; then of course the clinical theorising and evidencing will come under pressure to get in line with that newly perceived ‘truth’, dramatherapy as fast therapeutic food will have arrived – the American Dream will have triumphed and the B in BADth might as well go play in the traffic. There is a difference between short term therapy, solution focussed therapy and dramatherapy offered out as some kind of woolly, magical panacea. And, God (or should that be Mammon?) forbid, perhaps there are potential clients out there for whom short term therapy will never be effective and for whom, regardless of such considerations, dramatherapy is not and should not be the appropriate modality.
My hope is that the issue of how dramatherapy publicly presents and promotes itself will now be the subject of discussion and evaluation by the wider membership both in the pages of The Prompt and during the plenary session of the forthcoming AGM. Yours sincerely and sadly,
Charlie Moritz