Evaluating our Practice

Evaluating our Practice

The Prompt, August 2016 · by Susan Lawrence
Before · page 11-14

August 2016

Evaluating our Practice

– Valuing ourselves and proving our worth

A Reflection on the BADth CPD Day, London 7th May 2016 Facilitated by: Susan Lawrence

Before you begin to read this review I would like you to fill in the blank; Evaluation is

Here are some of the questions I entered the room with on the 7th May 2016. What do I really think about the ‘necessity’ that is evaluation? How does evaluation fit into my practice?

What do I really think of something that can come across as clinical, box ticking and something I am ‘told’ I have to do?

How does it fit in with the creative and the art of Dramatherapy? Can evaluation and art every really meet?

I knew there was a massive part of me that enjoyed evaluation; it being the same part of me that enjoyed seeing a good grade on my essays or being told that my shoes are very nice… Yet I also realised that this self-gratification part can never be the sole purpose of evaluation … to prove the therapist’s worth, to prove that the model works. This style of thinking can sometimes become the rationale for assessment; a process of box ticking and providing proof for funders that this stuff works. It can seem at odds with the work of the creative, the creative which thrives in the “not knowing” and trusting instinctual reactions.

Susan began by creating active evaluations for us, things we could draw on the wall and imagine with symbols and things we could pass around and make statements about as a projection. These are all methods that enter my current practice. Habitually, I see these as tools for the people I am working with to express themselves. Susan demonstrated the use of these ‘games’ as evaluation tools to measure the distance travelled when done at the beginning and end of practice. Expanding this thinking is to believe that statements in clinical reports such as “I observed….” can be quantitative method of evaluation used as professional judgement. She asked; How we can raise the status of observational as a professional evaluative assessment?”

What language do the funders need to hear?

What is the validity of what you are measuring?

What are the Outcomes – measured in goals, milestones and steps. ?

August 2016

Going into a session with realistic outcomes for a group is the start of the assessment process. Knowing what it is that we want to measure is sometimes a challenge when working with the oblique. Yet expectations around the overall goals of the group are important processes and can be a joint process between the therapist and client. Is it only when we know collectively what the goal of the work is, that can we truly work out what we are assessing?

Midway through I would like to ask you again;

Evaluation is

We were given 3 documents to consider within the group: Psychlops – measuring mood and function

SDQ – measuring client, parent, teacher responses Images, words and feelings/faces and emoji’s

All 3 have advantages and disadvantages as tools (I would encourage anybody to become acquainted with a wide variety of clinical assessment tools to enable you to find the best fit for the work you are doing). All 3 tools measure the beginning middle and end and measure the journey. These tools can be seen as the sole function of assessment for the company and funders. The question is how can we then utilise these sheets to be used alongside the client, or the referrer/carer, so that they can see and measure their own journey? ‘Psychlops’ goes some way to achieving this through its reflections from the client on what brought them to the room. The benefit of universal clinical tools is that they’re meaningful for funders. It became apparent on the training day that as Dramatherapists we are currently missing joined up thinking regarding tools and assessments. On the day this developed into a wider discussion on how we as therapists prove our worth with the model we are using. Too often, we speak about how difficult it is to grasp our work due to it basking in the realms of the unknown and the creative. When working in this way it can feel difficult to fit into a clinical tool. However, I would argue that our creativity and empathy can make any tool fit if done alongside a client. What we are really speaking about is feeling uncomfortable with assessment and I wonder, in some part, if there is a fear of doing this level of work. We know Dramatherapy works, we see it every day, yet there is something that prevents us coming together as a collective and sharing our results to gather further evidence-based practice. In using universal assessments funders can see the value of our work in conjunction with other methods. We cannot prove our worth, measured against other models, unless we are prepared to come together and work together. At the time of writing this review, we are in the midst of Brexit or Bremain (and by the time you read this we will know which one we are). I realised in a way it’s a bit like the Europe question; are we better working in isolation and only proving our own worth or will we be better together working to create our own ecosystem within Dramatherapy. Doing this needs to start with us, out there in the field, sharing case studies and information into a centralised port. Can training centres and Universities work together to develop centralised assessment tools that can be used alongside other assessment tools within placements? This is not to say that we need to have a one-size-fits-all assessment tool and that our

August 2016

sessions need to be full of boxes and questions which would create the loss of flow and creativity. Rather, we should not fear adding assessments which are universal, creative and specific to the work. Yet it’s also about asking what we can create that is quantitative; that we can all measure, and what we create personally that is qualitative and creative within the groups needs. It’s about sending through the stuff we do know, sharing case studies and tools and discussing what works and does not work. Although the answer is that there is no perfect tool at present, and possibly never will be, our industry needs something that offers more certainty in proof within the subtleties of our work. There is an importance for our collective voice in an industry that is becoming more and more set on evidence-based practise. We need to work towards valuing ourselves and our work by being able to say – “hey this works and there are some things that are fluffy and uncertain but here is what we do know…” If we work together it reduces a sense of isolation, which can compound our work. We may be the only Drama or Arts therapist on our team, but how can we connect with each other and feed into the great work we are all doing? Where does that great work and evaluation that is already out there, that we are already doing, feed into a bigger picture? And the biggest thing our group got on the day? Well, as in group therapy sessions, it was about being together and connecting, realising we are not alone; our feelings of frustrations and self doubt are not just in us but in others too. How did we come to this conclusion? How did we evidence this? How did we evaluate the strength of this session? We did it creatively through image and movement. Susan created a head, heart, dustbin and bag and we were asked to make a statement from each section. Proof that knowledge and creativity can co-exist. This is a call to arms to both ourselves as individual practitioners and BADth to begin collecting this work together. It is a call to arms to BADth to create a website that looks at evaluation that brings together the different strands of Arts for Health, Education, Forensics, and training and CPD to look at this issue. There is a fantastic range of data and work already being done but how can we expand on what is already there? How can we offer an online place for sharing evaluation tool kits and outcome measures that we use in our work? How can we offer a quick and easy space to upload case studies and evaluations in specific fields of work? Its time to decide; do we work together to increase our visibility or shy away from the big evaluation monster that asks us to work from a place of certainty. Ask ourselves; What it is like to know when we work in a place of not knowing? When working with the oblique how to we define a structure? How is the not knowing impacting on our work?

To finish please fill in the following statement Evaluation is

Nikki Disney

If you care to share your answers on “Evaluation is…” for evaluation purposes, feel free to email them directly to me to correlate and disseminate the research of the impact of reading an article such as this! contact form ?

August 2016

Organisation: Know Limits Ltd

Facilitator: Mandy Gutsell

• Dramatherapist • Degree in Child and Adolescent Psychiatry • • Certified Life Coach and Parent Coach for Teens • Certifed Organisational Relationship Systems Coach • • Completed Diploma in Creative Supervision •

Offers Individual and Group Therapy – Individual and Group Supervision Where is it? Newhampton Arts Centre, Dunkley St, Wolverhampton WV1 4AN To download map go to: www.newhamptonarts.co.uk

Why Mandy Gutsell?

I have been working as a dramatherapist, mental health nurse, lecturer, trainer and coach for the last 26 years. I teach on Mental Health Courses, work with Organisations to support their staff and run leadership courses on ‘How to be your true authentic brilliant self’. I run Dramatherapy and Coaching workshops and ‘Time Out’, for people to explore ‘Who they really want to be’. My philosophy and way of working is eclectic drawing on Carl Rogers, Elisabeth Kubler-Ross, Personality Enneagram profiling, Multi modal stress approach and coaching knowing that my clients have the answer already. Sometimes we just need a guide to help light the way for us. Includes all resources and materials provided. Free initial consultation and tutorials. Payment and subsidiary options possible.

For more details contact:

www.knowlimitscoach.com contact form Tel: +44 (0)7951 229941 MARY SMAIL

at SOULWORKS UK

Aending the untold story

Dramatherapy and Psychotherapy

Training therapy/supervision for Dramatherapy/

Arts Therapy students and professionals

Asseron Training/Self Esteem and

Confidence building

Soul Direcon – spiritual support for life

and around death

Sessions: South London – SW2,

By Phone or Skype.

Psyche and Soma – Soul-making through the

Sesame Approach 2016

P/T course for registered professionals.

More informaon:

contact form

07931 348052

www.marysmailsoulworks.co.uk

Charlie Moritz MA,PGCE,

PGDip (Dramatherapy)

Cert. Creative Supervision

practising in Whaley Bridge, Derbyshire

and city-centre Manchester.

HCPC Registered Dramatherapist

BADth Registered Supervisor

Mob: 07751275907

contact form

www.charliemoritz.co.uk

Individual and group dramatherapy.

Individual and small group supervision.

Dramatherapy for trainee dramatherapists.

Dramatherapy group for trainees starting in

Manchester and/or near Derby Oct/Nov 2016

finishing July 2017.

Creative/therapeutic workshops, particularly

focussed round creative writing.

Staff and team development.

Particular experience in:

Multicultural settings.

Educational settings.

Working with asylum seekers, refugees (adults,

unaccompanied young people and children).

Working with trauma and PTSD.

Creative/therapeutic workshops.

More posts

edition Diary Dates

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 32-33 DIARY DATES 2023 January 2023 Closing date for the BADth Gordon Wiseman Trust Fund. Details in Members’ area.…

The Prompt – final

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 22-31 Dear Jane, As a long-standing supporter of the publication, I write this open letter to thank you for…

people-caused climate destruction A Farewell Scenario

The Prompt, December 2022 · by EXCLUSIVE TO ARTS THERAPISTS · page 17-21 A FAREWELL SCENARIO 1996–2022 Scenario Arts in Personal Development was founded in…
account android arrow-alt-circle-down arrow-alt-circle-left arrow-alt-circle-right arrow-alt-circle-up arrow-down arrow-left arrow-right arrow-up author bars behance blogger bluesky buffer caret-down caret-left caret-right caret-square-down caret-square-left caret-square-right caret-square-up caret-up cart-menu-1 cart-menu-2 cart-menu-3 cart-menu-4 categories chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right chevron-up clock close comments cookies copyright coupon-discount date-modified date-published discord double-arrows-down double-arrows-left double-arrows-right double-arrows-up dribbble envelope-open envelope eye facebook fax flickr foursquare github gmail google-drive grid-view hashtag hollow-ring homepage instagram ios level-down-alt level-up-alt line link linkedin list-view login logout long-arrow-alt-down long-arrow-alt-left long-arrow-alt-right long-arrow-alt-up mastodonmedium messenger mobile-menu mobile phone pinterest place qq quote-left quote-right quotes reading-time-hourglass reading-time-stopwatch reddit rss scroll-to-top search shazam shopping-bag shopping-cart side-panel-opening-2-left side-panel-opening-2-right side-panel-opening-left side-panel-opening-right skype slack small-arrow-down small-arrow-left small-arrow-right small-arrow-up sms snapchat soundcloud spinner spotify stackoverflow sync telegram threadstiktok times-circle tinder trello tripadvisor tumblr twitch twitter viber vimeo vine vkontakte website wechat whatsapp windows wishlist xing yelp youtube zoom