December 2012
The International Society for
Psychological and Social Approaches to Psychosis (ISPS) Conference
The ISPS conference, that took place at Aston University, Birmingham on 2nd and 3rd October, was a very rewarding experience for me as a dramatherapist. Working with the most vulnerable clients in an early intervention in psychosis team is both rewarding and lonely, and I view conferences as a way not to just improve my practice, but also bask in the warmth of being with others who share the importance of psychological approaches and understand the world we share. What I most liked and was most surprised by was the number of psychiatrists present. Their interest was encouraging and their perspective illuminating. I enjoyed sharing reflections and learning more from them. I also learnt from psychologists who are so much clearer about how to evidence therapy. Sessions were tightly presented and so much was achieved thanks to business-like professionalism. This was wonderfully balanced by the presence of people with experience of psychosis first-hand who managed to constantly remind us all why we were gathered together. At a time when all the talk at BADth is about finding a common language to communicate what we do, here was a perfect chance to try and explain to the most relevant audiences. What an opportunity! I really appreciated the balance of workshops and plenary sessions. All the latter were excellent. It was the first time I have had the opportunity to explore research methodology with music, art, and dance movement therapists and learn from those who are some steps ahead of me. I was inspired by the open invitation of cooperation by so many speakers. Particularly the hearing voices network. The chair Jacqui Dillon was a very inspiring articulate speaker who believes in fostering partnerships, and I’d encourage dramatherapists to consider approaching local hearing voices networks to see if there is an opportunity to work together providing dramatherapy groups for members, as I believe our methods can play a role in recovery. If anyone is interested in this please do let me know as I wonder if there is a way that we can also work together to better evidence what we do. Louise Combes
South West Region Dramatherapy
Research Day
Saturday 10th November 2012
A small gathering of about 12 people from the South West region met up in Exeter for a morning of two presentations exploring aspects of practice and research.
Kim Diment started the morning off with a talk entitled ‘Writing our bodies, writing ourselves’. The essence of this was to explore how, as Dramatherapists, we can quantify and evaluate practice and add to the body of research evidence, whilst simultaneously upholding Dramatherapy’s unique approach and process. This, as we are all aware, is an ongoing discourse within Dramatherapy. It is imperative that we are accountable and can demonstrate the worth of Dramatherapy, and in a language and figures which are acceptable by the people operating the purse strings – such as NICE and NHS – as well as for private practice. It is also important for our own standing as a professional practitioner to encapsulate the power and value of Dramatherapy and project it confidently into other, sometimes, sceptical, public arenas. There were no clear answers to this ongoing debate and indeed this was not the aim; rather, we explored how to marry traditional scientific measuring and language with the arts therapy form. Are the arts quintessentially too esoteric and ephemeral to be scientifically measure? Does the magic, the mystery, the alchemy hinder quantitative evaluation? Kim wondered if there is a case for making the actual process of Dramatherapy more explicit for all to share. There was a consensus of nodding heads from the audience which indicated we had all felt at some time when a student, somehow left outside of the ‘magic circle’ of qualified Dramatherapists, and not really knowing what goes on in an actual Dramatherapy
December 2012
session.
Maybe
there
is
shortfall
in
how
Dramatherapy is conveyed to the people outside this circle. Could documentation and evaluation of sessions be adapted depending on the audience to allow
for
more
in-depth
understanding?
Kim
reminded us that the arts tackle the inextricable, such as Stoppard’s play Arcadia, in which he explored the second law of thermodynamics, and the film 21 Grams that concerned itself with the immeasurable and inexplicable weight of the soul. Kim pondered on how Dramatherapy should be presented and represented. We looked at two paintings – Millais’ Ophelia which is full of clear, exact and exquisite detail and a Turner seascape, full of brooding, sea mist and faint outlines. For a client it might be about bringing into the light something from the mist; for someone else the clear and explicit is too overwhelming; perhaps too for commissioners.
As Dramatherapists we need to produce writing which is not winsome but is rigorous. Kim encouraged thought – we need to be true to the essence of the arts but that practising pragmatism in our writing might engage and encourage the people and organisations Dramatherapists want to attract.
A great example of a presentation of Dramatherapy in action complete with figures and percentages was by Domini Barry. She talked about her Dramatherapy work with women who are suffering from postnatal depression, titled ‘Behind the Mask of Maternal Bliss – findings from a Dramatherapy practise for mothers with postnatal depression’.
Domini has been working for ten years with mothers with postnatal depression (PND) and symptoms of PTSD (Post-traumatic stress disorder). She runs a twelve week Dramatherapy group where the mothers come with their babies, but the focus within the therapeutic space is on the woman and their role as mother. Over the weeks the women explore the expectations of motherhood, the journey through pregnancy, their personal birth stories and their self image. Domini has a creative arts tool bag which includes the use of visual aids through button sculpts and small object work, Russian Dolls which are packed with symbolism and metaphor, and paper and pens and sand tray work. Later in the life of the group she might introduce sculpt and action, but at the beginning she has found the women to be too self conscious and exhausted to use movement and embodiment. Photos are taken of the women’s individual work and taken home to share with partners; the feedback from this has been very positive.
Domini evaluates the groups with a mix of an NHS questionnaire which is used near the beginning of the group and at the end of the twelve weeks, together with collating comments and feedback from the women throughout the sessions. The questionnaires are reduced to percentages and presented as a chart. These statistics, along with an evaluation report, are submitted to the commissionaires and this is suffice; they do not quiz her about process. This seemed like a very clear example of how the science and the Dramatherapy process can meld to produce an outcome which informs the commissioners and yet keeps the integrity of arts therapies process. A little lingering mist may be not a bad thing! Domini also views the results of her work as putting Dramatherapy ‘on the map’ by adding to associated research into post-natal depression. Domini is also building up the profile of a depressed mother – this is ongoing work but she has started to find a connection between postnatal depression and not having maternal family living near by; and is also interested to find out if the sex of the baby correlates with a higher presence of PND/PTSD.
This was an interesting and fascinating morning – it provoked discussion and debate. Research is an issue which needs to be kept at the forefront of a Dramatherapist’s mind and practice – holding a regional research day like this is a great way to share and develop the issue. Thanks to Bea Scott for organising it. Alicia Humphreys
As Dramatherapists
we need to produce
writing which is not
winsome but is
rigorous.