Announcements
Exciting news from Dudley
The Arts of Change Trust (The AoC) have recently moved headquarters to Dudley, from where they continue to provide counselling and therapy services across the West Midlands. They have also received a National Lottery grant enabling support for key workers at this challenging time.
Read the link below from the Dudley News.
https://www.dudleynews.co.uk/news/18611928.leading-therapy-charity-sets-new-home-dudley-town-centre/
Who are we?
We are a group open to all Dramatherapy supervisors and have been meeting three times a year since November 2007. Although this forum is London-based, it is open to all supervisors, newly-qualified or more experienced, from anywhere in the UK and beyond. When and where do we meet?
Our meetings are on Saturdays, and are currently on Zoom. At our most recent meeting, we decided to drop “London” from the title for the time being, as Zoom is not dependent on geography.
We have planned our next meeting for Saturday 31st October 2020 from 10.30am to 1pm. What do we do?
The meetings are an informal, supportive and very friendly affair, a free opportunity for a few hours CPD. The meeting is group led, opening discussion for current issues and ideas – all around the needs of the group on that day. We provide a confidential and free space to ‘meet up’ with colleagues, receive support and have simulating discussions. Bring your own snacks! How to contact us?
Our current administrator is Marianna Vogt. Thanks to Eleanor Zeal for holding this position for the last couple of years.
Please contact Marianna if you are a supervisor and would like a Zoom invitation to the next meeting at: contact form
Jane Jackson (on behalf of DSF)
The (London) Dramatherapy Supervisors’
Forum (DSF)
xwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvx xwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvxwxvx
Letters to The Prompt
To all BADth members,
This is a response to the recent update by the Executive Committee (Important Statement – Internal Investigation, 24th September 2020) which brought up questions and uncertainty in addition to thoughts I had after reading Jonathan Hirst’s piece in the August edition of The Prompt.
My main concerns are the compromise to impartiality and abandoning the Committee of Inquiry (COI).
The statement refers to an ‘interim internal exploratory and fact finding exercise’. Internal investigations, by their very nature cannot be impartial. It is not possible, particularly in an organisation as small as ours. It is also of concern that I, as a member of the Executive Committee during the period of resignations, have not been approached by anyone to contribute to the ‘fact finding’.
The statement also refers to an ‘independent audit’. I would like clarification regarding the remit of this audit; what does it involve and is the intention to replace the Committee of Inquiry?
At last year’s AGM both the outgoing Acting Chair and incoming Chair emphasised the necessity of making the BADth Executive Committee a safe place to be. As a former member of the Executive Committee (2016–2019) I was involved in finding a fair and thorough process to investigate several difficult events. The decision to hold a Committee of Inquiry was the result of time-intensive and focused work by the then members of the Executive Committee (some of whom are current Executive members) informed by the responses of the wider membership through the survey, regional meetings and correspondence. The rationale for holding a COI was never regarded as a means to punish but to acknowledge the difficulties, fully explore the background, identify the areas that need strengthening and take the opportunity to develop for the future good of our profession and members. Antonia Noble, (barrister) prepared the Committee of Inquiry Advice. I believe it was responsible and necessary to describe all the legal areas and possible outcomes. It does not indicate that these were the aims of the COI. At the AGM, Antonia agreed to participate in a webinar to answer questions from members on this subject but one year on, this has not been actioned.
I urge you to support a further call to uphold the original decision for the Committee of Inquiry. Avoiding the rigour of a thorough process will leave stones unturned, doubts and speculation will remain and prevent true reconciliation. The Committee of Inquiry may be an uncomfortable journey but, as therapists, surely we must recognise the need for this to happen before we have any chance of healing.
Elisabeth Burgoyne
Letters to The Prompt
Dear BADth Membership,
Following on from Jonathan Hirst’s very important letter prominently published in the last edition of The Prompt, I am moved to add one or two observations.
Literally moments after taking up office as Chairperson at last year’s AGM, John Hazlett Dickinson launched a glowing tribute to Alyson Coleman and invited the membership to join him in expressing deep appreciation of the work she had done and the qualities she had brought to her time as Chair. I found (and still find) myself reflecting on the importance of neutrality for anyone occupying the pivotal role of Chairperson. I wondered then and am still wondering now what this public demonstration of bias and cheer-leading meant for the chances of an objective, independently led inquiry into the procession of then recent resignations by Executive members ever happening. Just for the record, after only one year on the Executive, and though earlier than the others (Sept 2017), mine was the first in what was eventually to become a wagon-train of departures. When a plan was later formulated by the Executive to hold an inquiry I was officially notified that I would be invited to give evidence.
Fellow members may recall that prior to the new Chair taking office, I asked one or two questions at the last AGM. The last of these was ‘How do we ensure that the promised independent enquiry into the reasons for the series of Executive members resignations actually happens?’ In reply Antonia Noble, the barrister whose expert advice had recently been sought by BADth, said that as had already been decided it should indeed happen, and to ensure it did the membership simply needed to keep asking for it.
Hence the letter Jonathan sent, signed by eighteen other members, which was published in
regarding the enquiry. Instead, the present Executive has mysteriously chosen at best to delay and at worst to obstruct a fully independently led enquiry from taking place. I have not been approached since the last AGM about sharing my views and experiences. Whilst unsurprised, I am also clear that I will only contribute to an inquiry which is truly independently led; so far it looks like there’s precious little chance of that happening.
The membership has already expressed its wish for an independent enquiry to take place. The Executive is there to represent the Membership not to impose minority rule by diktat: its members have no elected right to do that. I know for a fact there are eighteen others who want that independently led enquiry to happen and feel sure that other BADth members would also like to know what really went on as determined by a fair, impartially led and managed investigation.
My advice with the next AGM rapidly approaching – dust off your DVDs, re-watch Spartacus, step forward and speak up!
Sincerely
Charlie Moritz
Letters to The Prompt
Dear Colleagues,
I write to fully support the thoughts expressed by Jonathan Hirst in the previous edition of The Prompt. I have deep concerns about the ways in which the serious issues which have arisen in our professional body have been managed. Far from being ‘transparent’, processes appear to be taking place with no clear explanation, communication or consultation with the membership.
The statement ‘specifically about the grievances and experiences of Dr Alyson Coleman’ provides a series of unsubstantiated assertions which do little to explain the actual circumstances of what occurred and further entrench existing divisions.
That the Executive chose to make an unequivocal statement about the role of one individual seems to me to be deeply unjust. As a professional body BADth should be upholding principles of fairness which recognise that we are a community engaged in a network of relationships in which each individual plays a part.
This is why adherence to the formality of constitutional documents and protocols exists – to keep us all safe. The faithful recording of meetings and decision-making and the discussion of conflicts of interest and ethics, should be at the core of our practices and made explicit to the membership.
Continual calls for an independent enquiry appear to have been ignored by the Executive. The setting up of ‘the working party’ and a clear statement of its remit was not communicated to members and as Jonathan Hirst rightly points out is fraught with conflicts of interest.
When are the membership to be informed of the outcome of the forensic accountants report which was commissioned by the BADth Executive?
There has been no response to the 18 members who were signatories to the letter published in the October 2019 edition of The Prompt calling for an independent enquiry. Are our views of no consequence to the Executive?
I am writing from a position of deep sadness and concern for the future of our professional body.
Anna Seymour
The Executive has received many communications in relation to its actions in proceeding with the investigation into the resignations of December 2018 and January 2019. Most of them have been supportive and congratulated the Executive for moving the association on in its business whilst not ignoring the need to examine the issues that arose for the association during that time. Please see the more detailed statement explaining our rationale.
The letters from three members that are published in this edition of The Prompt are done so as requested in the name of transparency. However, there are inaccuracies and assumptions contained in them that need to be corrected.
H The membership never voted for a Committee of Enquiry in the form detailed by the document written by Antonia Noble (COE Advice).
H The only elected officers during this period are the current Executive. H We have already spoken with some of the 18 members that two of the letters refer to and explained the situation. We are happy to speak with more. 18 members. The current membership of BADth is 760.
H If any of the authors wish to contact us in confidence about any matters that they directly experienced, please do so.
H The thanks expressed by the Chair at the AGM for the work of both Alyson Coleman and Madeline Andersen-Warren was well received. Why should this be seen as bias? It is courtesy. It would appear that Charlie Moritz already had a vested interest in thanks not being given. Why?
H We need to correct the mistaken idea that the Forensic Accountant’s report is a public document. It is not. It is illegal for us to publish it. It was commissioned by The Executive to shine light on the financial practice of BADth. We found the remit and focus of it to be narrow and selective and not what all members of the then Executive had envisaged. And so it was necessary to investigate that remit and those findings will be examined by the external auditors.
H The statement published about one member was the result of extensive investigation and negotiation in relation to that member’s experience. It informs the enquiry but is distinct from it, as it is in relation to a particular complaint. H We are convinced that our course of action is the most appropriate to heal and restore the effectiveness of the association, which is already happening, and although we acknowledge that there are differences, it is our experience that the vast majority of members are happy with our progress under the most difficult of circumstances. Members can see and experience the great strides we have made since September 2019. H There is still a great deal to do in terms of the restructure of the association so that it is representative of members, has professionalised financial and management processes, and is truly democratic.
The BADth Executive
Response from the BADth
Executive to letters