June 2012
On the Tindouf Refugees Camp
“In 1975, at the apex of the conflict over what is now known as the territory of the Western Sahara, the Sahrawi “liberation movement”, the Polisario Front, established a number of refugee camps in South-Western Algeria, near the Algerian military town of Tindouf. On the 27 February 1976, the Polisario Front declared the birth of its “state-in-exile”, the campbased “Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic” (SADR). Since then, the Polisario/SADR has developed its own constitution, camp-based police force (and prisons), army and parallel state and religious legal systems (the latter of which implements a Maliki interpretation of Islam). A number of “national” Sahrawi institutions, such as the National Parliament and National Council, National Hospital and Pharmaceutical Laboratory, the National War Hospital and the Landmine Victims’ Centre, are all located close to the camps’ administrative capital (Rabouni), which, in turn, is some 25km from Tindouf and its military airport. Approximately 155,000 refugees are currently distributed amongst four major camps named after the main cities in the Western Sahara (Aaiun, Ausserd, Smara and Dakhla), and a fifth, smaller camp which has developed around the National Women’s School (called the 27 February Camp). The four main camps are headed by a Sahrawi governor (wālī) who is appointed by the Polisario Secretary General and President of the SADR (Mohammed Abdelaziz), and each camp is divided into a number of districts (dawā’ir, sing. dā’ira), with each district sub-divided into neighbourhoods (ahyā’a, sing. hay). Key administrative and managerial functions are completed by camp residents employed by the Polisario/SADR. […] Unlike refugee camps which are run and controlled by international organisations such as UNHCR, in the Sahrawi context, the Polisario/SADR is ‘the only authority with which camp residents have regular contact,’ as the Algerian government has ‘ceded de facto administration’ to the Polisario/SADR (HRW 2008: 9), enabling them to ‘manage their own civil society and social systems without interference’ (WFP 2009–2010: 7). Such high levels of self-management and the Polisario’s de facto control over the Algerian territory upon which the camps have been built, distinguish the Sahrawi camps from the majority of refugee camp contexts around the world.” Dr Elena Fiddian-Qasmiyeh
Departmental Lecturer,
Forced Migration Refugee Studies Centre, University of Oxford
An evaluation of a research project in the Sahara using
the Sesame approach to
Dramatherapy and the insights
gained for its introduction
in Singapore
June 2012
Our aims
q Build relationship and establish trust & respect (esp. with Translators)
q Understanding of the Sahrawis community q Work towards integrating our culture and practice q Introduce the importance of Play q Promote wellbeing of individuals Our methods
q Facilitate dramatherapy session in the three different
settings:
Special
Needs
Schools,
Landmine and War Victims Centre and the Juvenile Centre
q Observe the receptivity in each setting q Develop positive interaction between translators, key workers, participants and dramatherapists Our findings
q Communicating through physical expression bridges the language barrier
q Requiring commitment to instill trust with the Sahrawis
q Acknowledging how the values of their religious beliefs bring insights to their lives and culture Our prevalent themes
q Discrimination against the less privileged is apparent even amongst the displaced Sahrawi individuals and families
q Insufficient professional knowledge to enable the caregivers/key workers enhance the situation for the less privileged
q Collaborate with relevant parties to improve the environment of the refugees with special needs and/or disabilities
Our research areas (refer to Fig. 1 p20) and team distribution
q Special Needs Schools (three to four in a team) at three districts: Smara, Auserd, and ‘27 February’ q The Chedid Cherif Landmine and War Victims Centre in the Rabouni refugee camp (two in a team)
q Juvenile Centre at Smara serving the four districts (as a group)
What went on in the research project? Castro Centre at Smara
Centre of Disabled at Auserd
Landmine and War Victims Centre at Rabouni Juvenile Centre at Smara
June 2012
The arrangement
Each facilitated dramatherapy session was between 30 to 90 minutes. Special Needs Centres lasted between 30 to 45 minutes (three therapists to five participants and with a translator) and Landmine and War victims lasted between 60 to 90 minutes (two therapists to one participant and with a translator). We did not facilitate any sessions at the Juvenile Centre but had discussions with the centre’s director in order to establish an understanding of the operative and legal systems. The third setting was originally at the Prison but after speaking to a former Judge of the Smara, we learned of a Juvenile Centre and so we changed it.
The ten of us were divided into three teams and deployed to the Special Needs Centres in Tindouf Refugee Camp covering three districts, namely Smara, Auserd and ‘27 February’. Each team was attached to their designated school for three days. The number of children in these schools ranged from 20 to 68, from the ages of two to 28. The foci of these centres are to integrate these special needs children into the Sahrawi community and foster autonomy so that they are capable of basic activities of daily living (ADLs). Activities commonly offered by these centres include carpentry, sewing, sports, writing and reading (Arabic and/or Spanish). The first day was orientation (assessment of space and participants), discussion with the Director of the school and, meeting relevant staff (key teachers). q Introduction of Drama & Movement Therapy: our session’s general structure and intent, our approach highlighted especially on receptivity towards physical contact, and confidentiality & consent from participants
q Profile/history of schools
q Negotiation of space & number of participants for this research project
q Inclusion of relevant staff to participate so to foster
understanding
towards
Drama
and
Movement Therapy
q Learning of participants’ profile, including health and safety issues
June 2012
On the second and third day, each team set off to different schools to introduce, share and facilitate during these two dramatherapy sessions. At the Castro Centre (http://www.centrodecastro.com) at Smara, it was a struggle to cope with transporting their students to the centre: 27 children have to be squeezed into a Land Rover; some of these special needs children live some distance away from the centre. The centre has limited funds to maintain their current vehicle, which is in a deteriorating state of repair and has no fund to purchase a new one. At the Centre of Disabled (Centro de Discapacitados de Auserd) at Auserd, after the first dramatherapy session, the teachers reported that the children returned to their classroom with calmer and more relaxed behaviour. The teaching staff shared that they would like to gain more professional knowledge and acquire skills to guide their students better and more appropriately. From my observation, it is apparent that the centre values the teaching aids/materials donated. However, I feel that the teachers would benefit from training in how to use these materials appropriately in play activities. At the Jose Philip Centre at ‘27 February’ staff said that they did not get enough foreign support, probably because of their remote location. The staff informed the team that they were running out of ideas of how to support the children’s learning experience, and supplies/materials are also deteriorating. Therefore, they were delighted to have the opportunity and experience of participating in the dramatherapy session with the children and the sharing the session with the team. All three centres conclusively expressed that limited funding; isolation and public acceptance are their typical challenges they face. In addition, the deterioration of equipments/materials/vehicles would lead to a reduction in the number of special needs children that these centres could enrol. One centre suggested a sharing platform to encourage interaction among the special needs centres and the exchange of information, ideas, equipment and materials.
Through what process did
change take place during
implementation?
Chedid Cherif Landmine & War Victims Centre at Rabouni
(For males and females, age ranging from 18 to 85)
“Since Spain’s withdrawal from Western Sahara in 1976 and the ensuing conflict between Morocco and the Frente Popular para la Liberación de Saguía el-Hamra y de Río de Oro (Frente POLISARIO), Western Sahara’s territory has been contaminated with an unknown quantity of mines and explosive remnants of war. Although no full Landmine Impact Survey has been undertaken to date, a Dangerous Area Survey completed in 2008 by UNMAS and its implementing partner, Landmine Action, led mine-action experts to determine that Western Sahara is one of the most heavily mined territories in the world. Across Western Sahara, a defensive minefield is in place along more than 2,000 kilometres (1,243 miles) of earthen berm, dividing control of the territory between Morocco and the Frente POLISARIO. The area adjacent to both sides of the berm, as well as more than 200 other known contaminated areas throughout Western Sahara, constitutes a high threat to U.N. personnel and more than 10,000 Saharan nomads. This contamination is one of the factors impeding the repatriation of tens of thousands of Saharan refugees…
The
Saharawi
Association
of
Mines
Victims
(Associación Saharaui de Victimas de Minas) aims to physically
and
socially
supports
mine/ERW
(Explosive Remnants of War) survivors to help them reintegrate into society; it assists them in accessing health and rehabilitation services…. Several victims, especially young people, have expressed the need to experience a transformation from being passive victims to motivated, engaged individuals.” Cucinotta, G. (2011)
“Persons with disabilities are among the most vulnerable in the Saharawi refugee camps in Algeria. A continuing lack of adequate medical care and the absence of understanding about disability issues increased the vulnerability and distress of disabled refugees in the camps.
The Polisario authorities offer basic free healthcare for all Saharawis in each of the four refugee camps near Tindouf. The refugee camps’ health system
June 2012
consists of “regional hospitals” in camps and a referral hospital in Rabouni as well as a psychiatric hospital. Medical issues that cannot be treated in the camps are referred to nearby Tindouf, or more distant facilities if necessary. Medical facilities in the camps lacked resources, and services were dependent on international aid for medicines and materials. There was a lack of continuity of medical staff because qualified doctors and nurses work on a volunteer basis. Inadequate coordination between donors and humanitarian agencies contributing to the health system in the camps was reported in 2009. The Chedid Cherif Landmine and War Victims Centre in the Rabouni refugee camp continued to provide rehabilitation and socio-economic assistance to mine/ERW survivors, but faced challenges in providing services due to a lack of resources.” Landmine & Cluster Munition Monitor (2009) Chedid Cherif Landmine and War Victims Centre currently housed 150 registered wounded with severe physical disabilities (e.g. paralysis). While some with better mobility live in their own tents (homes) or those who stay in the centre live in individual wards and their family members are allowed to live in as their caregivers. In this setting, we applied the same three-day working framework and this time we worked in pairs with a designated translator. Prior to meeting our participants we were aware that we could employ a different approach due to their varied physical condition. Our consideration was affirmed after the initial meeting with the director of the centre and the visits to our participants. During the visits we had sensed a certain degree of resistance from a few participants towards creative and therapeutic works. Thus we readily adjusted our approach of introducing drama and movement therapy. Instead of facilitating a dramatherapy session with songs, music, dance, games and stories like we did with the special needs children, we had an informal discussion with our Landmine and War victims by way of introduction. In our conversation we discovered that their belief in healing stemmed from having a strong Islamic faith. This acknowledgment of their religious beliefs made us more sensitive in our approach – therapeutically and communicatively in our “cross-cultural encounters” (Krause, 1998:2) especially when we have the added difficulty of not speaking the same language. This newly gained perception of the Sahrawis’ lifestyle also highlighted that their religious beliefs had given them the strength to persevere in the direst living conditions on such harsh land. Hence integrated their religious values which had likely become their “second nature” that Bourdieu refers as “doxic experience” which “provides the illusion of immediate understanding, characteristic of practical experience of the familiar universe, and which at the same time excludes from that experience any inquiry as to its own conditions of possibility” (ibid, 1998:135 & 144). It had given me insights of the importance of religious beliefs in the lives of the Sahrawis. The illustration below is based on my personal reflection, perception and discussion in peer supervision: Critical review
The awareness of the great importance of religious beliefs in the refugee camp and the struggle of day to day living in a depleted and neglected environment for its inhabitants has realigned my perception towards this research project.
The limits to the findings
Having been involved in this sixteen-day research in the Tindouf Refugee Camp I have thought more closely on the role that I initially came to offer with a deeper reflection on how I could maintain a therapeutic presence without impinging on the culture. The displaced Sahrawis are deprived of the most basic needs of quality of air, drinkable water and nutritious food to sustain every family. The shortage of food echoes what Bourdieu (quoted in Krause, 1998: 113) says, “food is an archetypal medium for nurturing and care everywhere and because of these connotations food also tends to be a marker of cultural and class distinctions”. Krause further adds, “food is therefore an expedient medium for signifying ethnicity, ambition, status and taste” (113). The Sahrawis have no control over “choice and availability of food products” as their survival relies entirely on foreign aids (113). The global economic crisis has now affected the provision of foreign help and soon they will be deprived further of even modest living. Being helpless over the fate of your own entire population would definitely stir strong feelings – singularly and collectively to consciously and unconsciously.
June 2012
So in these circumstances can psychological support be of value? I feel it can be. However the Landmine and Cluster Munition Monitor commenting on the value of the medical team’s contribution at the Landmine and War Victims Centre highlighted the need for “continuity” of provision. I believe this applies equally to the provision of dramatherapy. Although we should neither deny nor overestimate our therapeutic intent we need to tread carefully on cultural boundaries. Therefore it is crucial to remember that intermittent therapeutic intervention and involvement will not foster trust and respect in any setting, let alone in a community of forced migration. Time and money are the essential components to ensure the feasibility of any project. This particular project, however, requires that dramatherapists have an enduring dedication to surmount cultural differences and acceptance; perseverance to cope with the extreme living conditions that can tax one’s wellbeing; and strength for continuous self-reflection to enhance the understanding of shared human relationship in a politically challenged community. Krause has suggested in “cross-cultural” therapeutic work the therapist must abstain from challenging those characteristics in the clients’ “doxic experience” which was “instrumental in generating and maintaining” the
personhood
within
collective
environment (1998: 147). She further suggests, “it would be unthinkable that all such doxic and background experiences should be available for reflection and choice, for that would make continuous communication difficult if not impossible”. Her observation indicates a parallel process for myself over the course of this research as the interrelation and interdependence within family and wider kinship noticed in the camp mirrored mores and attitudes that I have been familiar with, since birth. I might not speak their language but I recognise these socio-cultural ideals that the Sahrawis adhere to.
However that does not mean I can fully comprehend their whole living context. I sensed that to establish trust with this close-knit community the dramatherapists would have to earn respect and demonstrate responsibility through experiencing the culture over a prolonged period. Therefore they can then be more empathetic towards the inhabitants’ “doxic experience” even if mutual understanding is communicated largely through physical expression. Throughout this research journey I endeavoured to place myself “both on the outside and on the inside while at the same time being or becoming aware of the limitations of either view” (Krause, 1998: 152). This mirrors the Sesame approach of staying nonjudgmental and the usefulness of self-regulation when encountering challenging aspects from self, participants and peers. This project has taught me that over the course of any research project, opencommunication, receptiveness and considerable attention to “contextual dynamics” will provide readiness to conduct critical “multisite evaluations” especially when the group is split into teams for the research (Donaldson, Christie and Mark, 2009: 116). These also ensure that the dramatherapists will best avoid the pitfall of entering an “elitist mode” and afford proper regard to “the values and voices” of those participants, relevant parties, and dramatherapy peers involved in a research project and particularly a cross-cultural one (Donaldson, et.al, 2009: 112 & 114).
Considerations to modify in the project Aside from political constraints in the refugee camp there were many basic infrastructures that the community
lacked.
Therefore
to
sustain
dramatherapy project and to stay effective, the “proximal or intermediate” outcomes should not be affected by changes in “organisational and social development” during the project (Donaldson, et.al, 2009: 114 & 117). It must be consistent with implementation to stay in line with its resources. The participants’ wellbeing is also closely dependable to the resources, particularly the regularity of sessions and continuity of dramatherapists and translators. Although the Sesame approach is recognised for its adaptability with individuals of varying conditions and also the provision of a therapeutic space, a core value of our work is confidentiality and thus the facilitation would only be appropriate if the allocated dramatherapists/translators continue to work with the same designated participants. This leads to a key issue that deserves elaboration: having translators in the therapeutic process appeared to impede the quality of moment-to-moment experience and I personally felt an impediment to meaningful attunement between the therapist and participant. Yet, can we really proceed without a translator? Or how long should we be working with a translator present and would it affect the therapeutic relationship when the translator leaves? If we remove the translator, is it too presumptuous to rely on non-verbal communication in seeking symbolic meaning? Yet, if we persist in having a translator present during therapy, how can we be assured that the therapeutic relationship with the participant is a safe and trusting one compared to the one where the therapist speaks the native language?
June 2012
Relevancy to Singapore community I was intrigued by many factors in this research as it presents some relevance to the socio-cultural development of Singapore (the author’s home country). My participation in this research sponsored by the National Arts Council of Singapore has allowed me to gain insights of supporting the introduction of drama and movement therapy in Singapore, using creative measures therapeutically and appropriately. Most immigrants in Singapore are able to communicate verbally using either English or Mandarin, however there is a marginalised group struggling to communicate to the natives where misunderstanding and disputes could possibly occur. This might impede the progress of the country as division among the population will arise. Being a relatively small island, acceptance of differences is of utmost importance to the wellbeing of Singaporeans that the government keeps a vigilant watch. With my current understanding of the individual’s “doxic and background experiences” (Krause, 1998: 147), I may be able to motivate this marginalised group and the natives through dramatherapy to search for a common ground that will pave understanding towards social cohesion. Having interacted with the Sahrawis, I learned that without a common language, we must uncover what the respective party’s values are and attune to the context of Play with regard not only to the individual’s health and safety conditions but also their individual and collective roles in the society. Singapore has at least four major races, namely Chinese, Malays, Indians and Eurasians. Each race holds discrete religious beliefs which would require respect of the other’s differences to function as a society. The Sahrawis practise a common religion and I feel that the values of their religious teachings and rituals may have also cultivated an invaluable trait – diligence. As ritual is “certain repetition of similar interactions and patterns”, it provides the community a cultural identity and the individual’s personal pattern (Krause, 1998: 144). I believe that the usefulness of ritual helps a person to regulate one’s movement through consistent interactivity and establishes the confidence of self-reliance, which promote positive personal beliefs. The Sesame structure (focus/warm up/bridge in/ main event/bridge out/grounding) in a drama and movement therapy session suggests something The Sahara Research Team from Central School of Speech & Drama (London), 2010–2012 (Left to right)
First row: Alexandra G. Romanitan, Stella Medvedeva, Becky Finlay Hall, Izzy Harris, Abigail Pickstock, Heather Bremner and children from the host family Second row: Lee Wai Ying, Fiona Bird and Karen Griffiths
June 2012
similar and may elicit the individual’s willingness to participate and/or explore creatively. This familiar pattern will give the participant the confidence to make choices and determine how they respond to a challenging situation so that it will also encourage resilience. Singapore presents potential needs for creative therapy support as such creative and therapeutic support
offers
profound
effects
on
individuals’ wellbeing especially those with challenging physical, social and/ or emotional conditions who may also struggle to cope with self-image. In conclusion, I wish to use the experience of the Sahara project to develop my knowledge and skills with the people of Singapore of varying conditions in different settings, and to recognise and respect the different ethnic beliefs, thereby not denying the values of these beliefs that may offer to every individual.
Lee Wai Ying
(Wai Ying has continuing interest in researching how organisations influence the delivery of Dramatherapy especially in Singapore.)
References
Chatty, D., Fiddian-Qasmiyeh, E. and Crivello, G. (2010) ‘Identity With/out Territory: Sahrawi Refugee Youth in Transnational Space’ in Chatty, D. (ed.) Deterritorialized Youth: Sahrawi and Afghan Refugees at the Margins of the Middle East, Berghahn Books: 43. Cucinotta, G. (2011) ‘Mine-action Activities in Western Sahara’, The Journal of ERW and Mine Action, http://maic.jmu.edu/journal/14.3/spcl_rpt/cucinotta/ cucinotta.htm (accessed April 2012) Donaldson, S.I., Christie, C. A. and Mark, M.M. (2009) What counts as credible evidence in applied research
and
evaluation
practice?
USA,
Sage
Publications Inc.
Fiddian-Qasmiyeh, E. (2011) Protracted Sahrawi displacement: Challenges and opportunities beyond encampment,
http://www.forcedmigration.org/ podcasts-videos-photos/photos/27-february-camp (accessed April 2012)
Krause, I-B. (1998) Therapy Across Culture, London, Sage Publications Ltd.
Landmine & Cluster Munition Monitor (2009) ‘Victim Assistance’, Western Sahara, http://www.themonitor.org/index.php/publications/ display?act=submit&pqs_year=2009&pqs_type=lm &pqs_report=western_sahara (accessed April 2012)
June 2012