A Letter to Sage Publications Ltd
Below is a copy of a letter I have written to SAGE Publications Ltd that I thought might be of interest to BADth members. It is regarding a chapter on Dramatherapy that SAGE have published. I don’t think you need to read the chapter to get the gist of my concerns – the letter should be self-explanatory. I simply wanted to share with you the kind of misinformed information on Dramatherapy that is in print. Many thanks to the Dramatherapy team at the London Borough of Sutton for their involvement, and Anna Seymour and Bruce Bayley for supporting me in re-drafting the letter.
Jane Jackson
Dear Sir/Madam,
I am writing to express serious concerns about a chapter entitled ‘Arts: Drama Therapy’, by Andy Worth in Key Concepts in Learning Disabilities, edited by Pat Talbot, Geoff Astbury and Tom Mason, Sage 2010.
I am a Dramatherapist who has specialised in working with adults with learning disabilities, and Editor of The Prompt, Newsletter of the British Association of Dramatherapists. I have consulted with a number of Dramatherapists including colleagues from a specialist Dramatherapy Learning Disability team who have shared their thoughts about the chapter. There are some fundamental problems with this chapter which need to be addressed: (i) There is a confusion between Arts in Health and Dramatherapy which are fundamentally different interventions.
‘Arts: Drama Therapy’ focuses on the kind of projects that are delivered through Arts in Health programmes, and is informative in this respect, but is superficial in terms of actual Dramatherapy work that takes place with this client group. Arts in Health projects may be therapeutic, but therapy is not their explicitly stated or agreed aim, and they are not delivered by Dramatherapists.
The Case Study on page 12 is based on a drama group in Cheshire, not a Dramatherapy group. Outcomes of the work may have been therapeutic, but the process was not Dramatherapy. I refer the author back to The British Association of Dramatherapists definition quoted on page 9 – that Dramatherapy involves ‘the intentional use of the healing aspects and theatre within the therapeutic process.’
Worth states, that ‘Drama therapy relies upon action as opposed to words as a means of providing the stimulus for entertainment, movement and turn taking.’ Pg 11. Why is entertainment on this list? It certainly isn’t an aim of Dramatherapy. Worth also speaks about the importance for people with a learning disability to ‘be able to display social competence’. Again, this is not a main aim in Dramatherapy, and the phrase ‘social competence’ sounds like normalisation. (ii) There is virtually no reference to the Dramatherapy literature on learning disability. Extensive reference is made on page 10 to the work of Ian McCurrach and Barbara Darnley but they are not writing about Dramatherapy. Their book is about creative expression through drama that may be therapeutic, but is not intended to be therapy.
There is one reference to the work of Sue Jennings (p11), citing her as an influence in this field, but without mentioning Dramatherapy. Sue Jennings is a respected and renowned Dramatherapist, and author of many books on Dramatherapy, so it is surprising that the only reference to her work is from one of her earliest writings, Remedial Drama published in 1973. As well as the brief mention to Dramatherapy with People with Learning Disabilities by Anna Chesner, other Dramatherapy references specific to this client group could have been found in: ‘Dramatherapy with People with Learning Disabilities’ by Jocelyne James in Dramatherapy Clinical Studies, edited by Steve Mitchell, Jessica Kingsley Publishers 1996. ‘An integrated model of dramatherapy and its application with adults with learning disabilities’ by Anna Chesner in The Handbook of Dramatherapy, edited by Sue Jennings, Ann Cattanach, Steve Mitchell, Anna Chesner & Brenda Meldrum, Routledge 1994. ‘Poetry in Motion: Drama and Movement with People with Learning Disabilities‘ by Jocelyne James in Discovering the Self through Drama and Movement: The Sesame Approach, edited by Jenny Pearson, Jessica Kingsley Publishers 1996.
It appears that this misunderstanding about the differences between Drama and Dramatherapy has come about because the author of this chapter is not a Dramatherapist. There are many Dramatherapists in the country who specialise in working with people with learning disabilities, and I wonder why one of these was not approached to write this chapter from first-hand experience. (Andy Worth is a Registered Nurse Mental Health, a Registered General Nurse, and a Health Facilitator within the Cheshire and Wirral Partnership NHS Foundation Trust). (iii) There is a serious editorial error.
Drama Therapy written as two words is used in the US; in the UK it is written as one – Dramatherapy. This book is edited by people working in the UK, the writer of this chapter is also based in the UK, yet, even though The British Association of Dramatherapists is quoted, Dramatherapy is written as two words throughout the chapter. The author states that “Drama Therapy is simply(!) a fusion of drama and therapy” (page 10), which is exactly why the two words are fused together, to emphasise that they are not separate in the work. However the use of ‘simply’ here is a reductive comment on a practice which is both subtle and complex in its thinking and practice, drawing on the understandings of psychotherapy and psychological practices and the aesthetics, history and practices of drama and theatre. This chapter is naïve, inaccurate and misleading, demonstrating a lack of insight and knowledge of Dramatherapy work with this client group. If there is a second edition of this book, then this chapter should be re-written from the perspective of a Dramatherapist, or at the very least some thorough research be undertaken by the author. Otherwise the title should be changed to make it clear that what is being to referred to is Arts in Health practice. I look forward to your response.
Yours faithfully,
Jane Jackson
Editor The Prompt, Newsletter of the British Association of Dramatherapists Cc
Dr Bruce Bayley, Chair, The British Association of Dramatherapists Dr Anna Seymour, Editor Dramatherapy, The Journal of the British Association of Dramatherapists