A Joint BADth and Sesame Institute Research day – June 4th 2011
This was an exciting day introduced by Mary Smail, Director of The Sesame Institute, and Bruce Howard Bayley, Chair of BADth. It was very well
attended in view of the fact that many creative people find research very difficult to get their heads round. The day provided the chance to think about different research models in the struggle of present guidelines and retaining the integrity of creative practice.
There were four eminent speakers, Charla Givans (Into the Woods)
Madeline Andersen-Warren (Consulting the Oracle) Zoë Pool (Out of the Box)
Bruce Howard Bayley (The Nourishment of Research) As you will see from the titles it was a beautifully constructed day and that, to my mind, is the art of good research; how you set the scene, how you construct the context, how you explore the meaning, and how you reflect on meaning in the larger context of the profession in its creative and political environment. Charla Givans movingly presented her research journey “thus far into evaluation models with children and young people with depression. Her reflections focused on the honouring of process and on listening to the stirrings of the unconscious to support the work. Allowing and sitting with darkness, deadness and the unknown in research gives rise to the ability to articulate with visceral understanding. The same process can be said for the experience of depression, where the irrational, non-linear voice might also be needed in evaluating its effect.” Madeline Andersen-Warren
lovingly presented “The
Delphi Cycle as a form of consultative research. It is a qualitative method in which the prime objective is the reliable and creative exploration of ideas or the production of suitable information for decision-making. A wide range of topics can be explored and examined during the stages of the cycle”.
The major areas were
m Creating the research question
m The structures and stages of the cycle m Analysing the responses
m Co-operative enquiry
Zoë Pool enthusiastically presented excerpts from her PhD (2008), “a suite of therapeutic artefacts, Into Each Life…., which was presented in a wooden box. The study included programmes of music, imagery, poetry, metaphor and
participants’
reflections.
Zoë
explored how creative media (old and new) might facilitate and deepen lifeenhancing connections with ourselves, with others, and with something beyond ourselves”. Zoë’s PhD was the first successful study in the UK within the brief of Performative Social Science (arts-based social science). Through her work Zoë seeks to “liberate meaning from fixed assumptions”. Her PhD was presented within existing systems even as they challenged the status quo. Bruce Howard Bayley gave a wonderful talk about how the way we treat Research lands us in a place which can feel cold, clinical and more akin to Duty than to Joy. “However, while we are asked more and more to demonstrate the efficacy of our clinical practice (usually under the influence of political and economic forces) and to ‘sing for our supper’, as it were, it is well for us to see our Research, itself, as a large part of our Supper. It is where we can show to ourselves, and to the world, the variety of our dramatherapy Table–Buffet; what we have ‘cooked’, are in the process of ‘cooking’, the ‘recipes’ that we are exploring, even the recipes that did not turn out as well as we had hoped but from which we can learn what ingredients we could best utilize in the future. Research is our Nourishment and is of enormous importance in working towards both securing our ‘meals’ in the future as well as enriching and developing our theory and practice. This presentation was an invitation to view and review together the various faces of Research, at a variety of levels, which can sit, usefully and creatively, alongside RCTs and CORE and which we may be likely to overlook and miss seeing their whole nourishment value.” I have taken these excellent descriptions by the contributors because I cannot better them, other than to say each one had gifts to offer and each one also had gifts of being able to provoke all sorts of questions about the nature of what we do and how we do it, as well as how to bear witness to it in a way that convinces the onlooker who knows nothing about it and inspires them to support the good work!
I am sure there will be another research day, and especially if you feel you don’t quite understand what it is all about or have all sorts of doubts, it is on the cutting edge so don’t miss it!
Olivia Lousada
Mary Smail – Director, Sesame Institute and Bruce Howard Bayley – Chair,
BADth at the Joint BADth–Sesame
Research Day June 2011