- What it was
- Draft guideline or standards
- Run by
- NICE (National Institute for Health and Care Excellence)
- BADth responded
- Wednesday 16 June 2021
BADth's response
BADth's comments on the draft guideline, submitted on NICE's comments form in June 2021.
Comment 1: Guideline, page 49, line 4
Therapeutic interventions for promoting school stability and learning
HCPC Registered Arts Therapies have consistent evidence of therapeutic input reducing exclusion, improving learning outcomes, and improving attendance. Storing relationships with schools who have seen the benefits of arts therapies, have meant that sessions have been consistently funded via the Virtual School and Pupil Premium Plus for young people who are looked after. This funding stream is no longer available, and work is being funded via Clinical Commissioning Groups, though they require further evidence that commissioned services such as CAMHS approve the work -very few CAMHS services have arts therapists on their teams, but what we are seeing is that schools consistently refer for Art and Drama therapy as they see the effectiveness with their pupils. Strong relationships between commissioned services, and service providers of Arts Therapies, are essential for this work to continue.
Trauma informed work
Arts therapies are by their nature trauma informed. Recommended by eg Bessel Van der Kolk, and the European Society for Trauma and Dissociation, arts therapists work with embodied trauma in a safe and attuned way, allowing children to stay within their window of tolerance and symbolically address frightening issues that may be hard to express directly, or that may have occurred pre-verbally.
Dramatherapists and related clinicians hold expertise in making sense of this powerful symbolic work with clients and with their carers, social workers and schools. Life Story work can be easily integrated into arts therapy sessions so that the child's major life events are addressed and made sense of, and creative responses can ground and help the child process the picture they are putting together.
Comment 2: Guidance (1.7.1 – 1.7.9), page 92, line 5
Interventions to support the stability of permanent placements
When delivered as a whole-network approach, working closely alongside Social Workers, Foster Carers, fostering agencies, and schools, Dramatherapy and arts therapies are extremely powerful as a therapeutic intervention with a young person when delivered alongside regular consultation with the network.
Children and young people who have survived complex trauma often do not have the language to process and make sense of what has happened to them. Their expressions of trauma are expressed behaviourally - for example through outbursts of anger, difficulty with peers; hoarding, stealing or lying behaviours; self harm; dissociation; or risk taking. This can be difficult for the adults around the child to make sense of and can lead to tragic placement breakdown.
Arts therapies enable children and young people to express their trauma, thoughts and feelings through symbol and play, and to find a language for this through trauma informed interventions. The therapist can then have a key role in translating and communicating this to the adult network to help them understand the child's needs and feelings and ways of meeting the trauma behaviours through sensory, trauma informed interventions. Experience is that this way of working enables placements to continue that were at risk of breaking down.
Guidance (1.5.12)
22
2
CAMHS waiting lists
Arts therapists working alongside CAMHS teams and other commissioned services, eg Action for Children, they can take a role in consultations whilst we providing long term 1:1 therapy for a child.
Guidance (1.5.15)
23
1
Dramatherapy and Arts Therapies can support identity and well-being. Attachment-trauma can impact the relationships that individuals have with others, making it difficult to trust and form healthy relationships throughout their lives. In the therapy room, this can act as a barrier to feeling safe with the therapy in the first instance. By utilising Dramatherapy as a Arts Psychotherapy when working with Looked After Children, the safety of metaphor rather than direct focus on the presenting issues can allow clients to feel more at ease in the therapy space.
Through the use of play, games, role, story and art work, the child is able to begin to build a trusting relationship and therefore begin exploring their life story by utilising creative techniques, which takes into accounts the unconscious and bodily experiences, which cannot always be accessed through words.
Dramatherapy offers a unique approach as a “bottom-up” and therefore more naturally inclined trauma-informed approach. Dramatherapy offers the Looked After Child to explore the relationship with the self, as well as the other significant relationships in their lives. The attachment-trauma of the Looked After Child can impact how they navigate the self’s body, which can often cause disassociation and lack of understanding around bodily sensations. Dramatherapy can therefore allow the Looked After Child to explore the bodily trauma by utilising movement-based techniques, which would work towards integrating both the trauma of the mind and body, and work towards a place of healing.
Legislation and documents
Consultations are a members' space: what is open, what is being asked, members' views and BADth's guidance for your own response. Sign in as a BADth member to see them and have your say.