Adoption support that works for all (Department for Education)

← Consultations

What it was
Consultation
Run by
Department for Education
BADth responded
Tuesday 5 May 2026

BADth's response

BADth's answers as submitted through the Department for Education's online form on 5 May 2026. The form's tick-box ratings are not shown.

9. What support do you think helps to maintain or improve children’s and young people’s mental health and wellbeing?

A Multidisciplinary, Trauma-Informed Approach For adopted and kinship children, mental health and wellbeing are inextricably linked to early developmental trauma and attachment disruption. Support "works" when it is early, relational, and addresses the "whole child" across health, education, and community settings. Effective support must include:

1. Creative and Embodied Therapies (e.g., Dramatherapy) Many children struggle with "talking based" interventions because trauma is held in the body and the pre-verbal brain.

Reparative & Preventative: Dramatherapy offers a safe, attuned space to work through disrupted early relational experiences. Providing this early—particularly around school transitions and adolescence—prevents trauma from "re-surfacing" as crisis, reducing the risks of later substance misuse, psychiatric involvement, involvement in criminal justice, or the development of self-punishing behaviours and unsafe relationship patterns in adulthood. It is about shifting what might happen 'next' for the child, not just managing the present.

Agency and Identity: Unlike direct conversation, Dramatherapy allows for choice and creativity, helping children navigate the complexities of identity and "life story" at their own pace.

National Recognition: We note that in recent SEN debates, Dramatherapy and the Arts Therapies were repeatedly referenced as essential for children’s mental health and should be prioritised accordingly.

It is critical to distinguish Dramatherapy from drama teaching or 'activity-based' work. As an HCPC-registered psychological therapy, it utilises trauma-informed processes to reach pre-verbal experiences that are inaccessible through language alone. Without this understanding, the work is often misrepresented in commissioning decisions as a 'support activity' rather than the clinical depth intervention it is.

2. Relational Support for Parents and Carers It is impossible to support the child in isolation. Adoptive and kinship families face high risks of vicarious trauma and burnout.

We need skilled therapeutic work (such as Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy, Theraplay and systemic Dramatherapy) to help parents understand "blocked trust", “blocked care”, and develop attuned, therapeutic parenting. This maintains placement stability and prevents the "re-trauma" of placement breakdown.

These therapeutic interventions need to be in place early in the adoption process so that more intractable issues are prevented further down the line as children get older and challenging behaviours escalate.

3. Therapeutic Life Story work. Therapeutic Life story work is much more than the provision of a life story book; It is a challenging clinical process. Children have a need to meaningfully understand their story and make sense of their experiences. This can be a challenging and emotive process. The creative and embodied therapies are well placed to offer this, as the ‘distancing effects’ of the creative activities offered, make the review of the events more manageable. Adoptive parents also need support to enable them to reflect on the distressing experiences their children have had before they were adopted. This will enable them to then in turn support their children with highly charged emotional material.

4. Integrated Educational Support, including special educational needs & Neurodevelopmental Understanding Education is often a primary stressor for trauma-impacted children. Many of these children live with overlapping trauma and neurodevelopmental differences, such as Foetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder (FASD) or ADHD.

Decoding Behaviour: Current school systems often mislabel trauma-based survival responses—such as dissociation or hyper-vigilance—as "defiance" or "non-compliance." In line with recent national SEN debates, which have repeatedly highlighted Dramatherapy and the Arts Therapies as essential, non-optional components of mental health support for SEN pupils, we advocate for the integration of Dramatherapists within the school environment. This allows specialists to work alongside educators to "decode" these communications, shifting the school’s response from discipline to regulation.

Protection against Exclusion: We need predictable, emotionally informed school environments where dramatherapy is integrated as a critical protective factor against the disproportionately high rates of exclusion and suspension seen in this cohort. This includes access to appropriate teaching assessments and inschool personal assistance, alongside accessible, onsite therapeutic provision. By providing a clinical space within the same environment where children are expected to learn, they are better supported to process their traumatic histories, and school staff can be equipped to ensure schools act as a protective factor rather than a source of further disruption or exclusion.

5. Scaffolded Independence and Community Socialisation As young people move toward adulthood; they need support that bridges the gap between the family home and the community.

PALS (Personal Liaison) Services: Mentoring-based support that teaches life skills—such as using public transport or a gym—helps build autonomy and confidence for children who have historically felt unsafe in public spaces.

Peer Groups: Group work (social and therapeutic) reduces the profound sense of isolation and "difference" many kinships and adopted children feel, normalizing their identity and building social resilience.

6. Alignment with the NHS Long Term Plan Current effective practice shifts the focus from hospital to community and from crisis treatment to prevention. By funding a multidisciplinary "scaffold" around the family—utilising therapists, youth workers, and schools—we reduce long-term demand on public services and align with national health priorities.

Summary Effective support must be developmentally appropriate, relational, and long-term. When we address the neurological and emotional impacts of early adversity through a combination of specialist therapy and community-based "scaffolding," we move children from a state of survival to one where they can truly thrive in education and society.

10. Why does this support help?

As a community of Dramatherapists, we wish to respond to the identified need for specialist therapeutic support through the lens of our specific expertise. This support is effective because it addresses the neurological and relational roots of distress rather than focusing solely on surface-level symptom reduction.

'Bottom-Up' Regulation vs. 'Top-Down' Strategies Standard "top-down" interventions (such as CBT or strategy-based talking therapies) rely on the pre-frontal cortex—the part of the brain responsible for reasoning, planning, and language. However, for adopted and kinship children:

The Developmental Gap: Early trauma often disrupts development in the "lower" brain (the brainstem and limbic system), which governs survival instincts and emotional arousal.

The Limitation of Talk: If a child is in a state of hypervigilance or "survival mode," they cannot access their pre-frontal cortex to "think" their way into calm.

The Creative Arts Therapy Solution: Dramatherapy works from the bottom up. It meets children at the developmental stage where the trauma occurred. Through rhythm, movement, play, and symbol, we "backfill" developmental deficits, helping the central nervous system learn to regulate through experience rather than instruction.

Repairing Attachment through Co-regulation Just as babies learn to regulate through the presence of a regulated adult, older children with attachment trauma require co-regulation.

Our interventions use mirroring, modelling, and complete acceptance to create a sense of psychological safety.

By using non-verbal and symbolic communication, we allow children to explore complex themes of loss, neglect, and identity in a way that feels safe and gives them back a sense of autonomy.

The Role of the Family: Supporting the Relational Environment Effective support cannot be delivered to a child in isolation; it must address the family as the child’s primary relational environment. This includes psychoeducation, systemic therapy, dyadic therapy, and parenting groups. This is critical for several reasons:

Biological Co-regulation: Regulation is not a skill children learn in a vacuum; they learn it through being with a regulated adult. Because many adopted and kinship children have an "avoidance of being parented" due to early attachment rupture, the caregivers themselves can become frequently dysregulated. Clinical evidence suggests that a child’s progress is significantly hindered if their primary caregivers are in a state of chronic stress or vicarious trauma.

Understanding Adaptive Responses: Therapeutic support helps parents and carers reframe "challenging" behaviours as adaptive survival responses to early trauma. Without this professional support, there is a risk that families may default to standard behavioural or punitive approaches. In the context of developmental trauma, these traditional methods can inadvertently compound the child's trauma and increase the sense of fear.

Addressing the Cycle of Blame and Shame: Many families in the adoption and kinship cohort experience profound, unprocessed feelings of blame, shame, and a fear of failure. If professional input is not delivered with extreme sensitivity and respect for the lived experience of the carers, it can exacerbate these feelings.

Preventing Placement Breakdown: The primary goal of skilled work with parents is to help them remain empathic and attuned while managing deeply distressing behaviours. By supporting the parents' own emotional regulation and understanding, we reduce the risk of the "burnout" that frequently leads to placement instability and crisis.

Professional Standing and Clinical Rigour It is important to distinguish Dramatherapy from "activities" or basic life-story work.

Allied Health Professionals (AHPs): Dramatherapists are Health and Care Professions Council (HCPC) regulated Allied Health Professionals. As recently highlighted in Parliamentary debate (Hansard, April 2026), AHPs are essential to the delivery of community-based mental health support.

Tier 2 Intervention: Unlike practitioners of shorter, strategy-based courses, Dramatherapists undergo rigorous Master’s-level training, including their own mandatory individual therapy and ongoing clinical supervision.

Clinical Depth: We work safely with unconscious processes and complex trauma. We strongly advocate that Dramatherapy be recognised as a Tier 2 Psychological Intervention, sitting alongside other high-level psychological therapies, rather than being grouped with lower-tier support services.

The Long-Term Economic and Social Case Without this deep-level, trauma-informed support, the risk of long-term "failure to thrive" is high. By addressing the whole-brain/whole-body impact of trauma early, we reduce the likelihood of these young people requiring high-cost crisis intervention, hospitalisation, or involvement with the criminal justice system in adulthood. This aligns directly with the NHS Long Term Plan’s commitment to moving from reactive treatment to community-based prevention.

Dramatherapy should be viewed as a preventative, complementary intervention that supports rather than replaces existing services. Its value lies in improving early engagement, reducing crisis escalation, and supporting those who do not respond well to talking therapies. Wider benefits include improved educational outcomes, reduced exclusions, and lower pressure on acute mental health services. The strongest case is for early investment that reduces long-term system demand and cost.

11. What could be improved about this support?

As a professional body of practitioners, we have identified several critical areas where the current structure of adoption and kinship support—specifically through the Adoption and Special Guardianship Support Fund (ASGSF)—needs urgent reform to be effective and sustainable.

1. Ending the ‘Assessment vs. Therapy’ Funding Trap Current funding structures often fail to distinguish between the cost of identifying a need and the cost of meeting it.

The Issue: We have seen cases where a child’s entire annual allocation is exhausted by a single specialist assessment. This leaves the family with a clear diagnosis but no funds available for the actual therapeutic work for another year.

The Improvement: Funding should be ring-fenced for follow-up therapy so that assessment does not become a barrier to treatment. A child should not be left waiting in a state of identified need simply because a funding renewal is several months away.

2. Review of the Fair Access Entitlement (FAE) Cap and the Funding Gap: The current £3,000 Fair Access Entitlement (FAE) cap is clinically insufficient for children with significant developmental trauma. In practice, this level of funding typically covers around 20 sessions, often delivered over a sixmonth period, creating a damaging “six months on, six months off” cycle of care. Recent reductions in fair access funding, alongside wider SEN budget constraints, further undermine the integrated therapeutic and educational support these children require.

The Clinical Risk: Mandated breaks in therapy mirror many children’s early experiences of relational rupture and abandonment. Instead of focusing on trauma processing, therapists must spend the end of each funding block managing anxiety about separation, and the start of the next block repairing the loss of trust caused by the enforced interruption. Consistency is the clinical foundation of safety; when therapy is disrupted by annual caps or reapplication processes, it is not merely a practical gap but a reenactment of earlier experiences of inconsistency and loss. This can be deeply destabilising and risks undoing months of therapeutic progress.

The Educational and Developmental Impact: Without ringfenced, consistent funding, the baseline of educational and therapeutic support remains insufficient for children with Foetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder (FASD) and complex trauma. Dramatherapy should not be understood as a “topup” to core provision, but as a fundamental component of enabling these children to access their right to an education.

The Economic Argument: Apparent shortterm “cost savings” achieved through capped or interrupted provision are ultimately more expensive. When therapy is delivered with sufficient intensity and continuity, it can support lasting repair and increased stability. Conversely, repeatedly cycling children in and out of services prevents them from reaching the traumaprocessing phase, increases longterm dependency on statutory systems, and raises the risk of placement breakdown and escalation into highercost interventions.

3. Provision for Parental Support and Consultation Under the reduced cap, therapeutic consultations for parents have dropped from an average of eight sessions per year to two.

The Impact: Parents now have significantly less access to specialist guidance on the impact of trauma, attachment patterns, and the role of play in repair. Our members report an increase in placement difficulties and carer burnout as a direct result of parents feeling unsupported and unequipped to manage complex behaviours at home.

4. Integration into the ‘Team Around the Child’ There is currently no provision in the budget for Dramatherapists to attend professional meetings, such as safeguarding, EHCP reviews, or Team Around the Family (TAF) meetings.

The Contradiction: The government’s intent to move services from hospitals to the community is undermined if community-based therapists are excluded from the professional network.

The Solution: As Allied Health Professionals, Dramatherapists often hold the deepest psychological understanding of the child. Funding must allow for therapist attendance at key meetings to ensure community support (schools, youth clubs, etc.) is integrated and trauma-informed, preventing the fragmentation of care.

5. Addressing Geographic and Systemic Inequity

Consistency of Access: Support currently varies significantly by location. In some areas, such as Cumbria, providers can no longer afford to offer Adoption and Special Guardianship Support Funded work because the £3,000 cap does not cover the true cost of a full year of therapy (which includes parental support and reviews).

Proactive vs. Reactive Support: Currently, support is often only available once a family reaches a crisis point. Improvement is needed to offer proactive support at predictable stress points, such as school transitions or the onset of adolescence.

6. Redefining Outcome Measures Current measures often over-prioritize short-term symptom reduction. We recommend a shift toward measures that reflect the child's lived experience, focusing on:

Relational security and felt safety.

Emotional integration and identity development.

The pace of the child, rather than the pace of a funding cycle.

Data and Lived Experience voices: Evidence suggests dramatherapy supports emotional regulation, trauma processing, engagement with services, and social connection, especially for people who do not engage well with verbal therapies. Lived experience highlights its value in enabling safe, indirect expression, identity development, and improved relationships. This supports combining outcome data with co-produced lived experience evidence to understand impact.

Conclusion

It is not our view that a child who has been adopted should spend their entire childhood in therapy. Rather, we advocate for the right intervention at the right time, delivered with enough clinical depth to allow for lasting transformation.

Limiting support through arbitrary financial caps is clinically counterproductive; it forces practitioners into "maintenance" work rather than the deep, transformative work required to resolve early trauma. To truly improve support, the fair access amount must be reviewed to ensure that funding allows for sufficiency of treatment. When a child is given the space to complete a meaningful course of therapy at the appropriate developmental stage, they are far more likely to achieve the resilience and stability needed to thrive without ongoing service involvement.

Strategic investment in intensive, time-appropriate support now will significantly reduce the likelihood of the child requiring crisis-driven public services throughout their adolescence and adult life.

12. Proposal 1: Develop a baseline offer of parenting support and training at the point of adoption and kinship care. Do you agree with this proposal?

While we support the creation of a predictable and consistent foundation of support for all adoptive and kinship families, our agreement is qualified by the need to ensure this "baseline" does not become a barrier to—or a replacement for—specialist clinical intervention.

Validation vs. Intervention: A baseline offer is vital for normalizing and validating the experiences of parents and carers within a trauma and attachment framework. Helping families understand that "challenging" behaviours are often adaptive survival responses is a necessary first step. However, a baseline offer of workshops or online modules cannot replace direct access to a trained therapist who knows the child’s unique story and presentation.

The Risk of Diluting Specialist Support: We have concerns that a "one-size-fits-all" baseline may inadvertently lead to a "gatekeeping" system where families must exhaust universal parenting programmes before being granted access to specialised Allied Health Professional (AHP) support. For many children, their needs are complex from the outset, and delaying specialist Dramatherapy can lead to an escalation of needs that a baseline offer is not equipped to handle.

Joined-up Therapeutic Thinking: The proposal mentions "joined-up" support. In our clinical experience, when a child is receiving individual Dramatherapy, the most effective "parenting support" is direct therapeutic consultation with that same therapist. This ensures a cohesive approach where the parent and therapist are thinking together about the child’s specific symbolic language and relational progress. A generic baseline training cannot offer this level of tailored, clinical integration. Effective play-based dramatherapy interventions where the child and parent are seen in the room together (dyadic dramatherapy) also provides the parent with the ability to see their child’s internal world through play experiences as well as build a more a positive attachment relationship through pleasurable play experiences and increase the resilience in the parent/child dynamic.

Multi-Disciplinary Teams: Dramatherapy works best across an integrated system including primary care, CAMHS and adult mental health services, education (including SEND), and community settings, with self-referral where appropriate. Delivery should span preventative, targeted, and clinical levels. Effective implementation requires embedding dramatherapists in multidisciplinary teams with supervision, governance, trauma-informed practice, and flexibility for local context.

Adoption as a Lifespan Journey: We welcome the focus on "key life stages." Adoption is a lifelong process, and the support needed at age 5 is fundamentally different from the support needed at age 13. Dramatherapists are uniquely trained to work across this lifespan, adapting to the developmental age of the child. We advocate for a clear "route through" from the baseline offer through to specialised, individualised support as and when it is clinically deemed necessary.

Defining "Evidence-Based": We urge the government to be transparent about the "evidence-led" criteria used for these programmes. There is a risk that "evidence-based" becomes synonymous with "manualised" or "psychology led" programmes (such as DDP-informed training) at the expense of creative arts therapies that have deep roots in attachment and relational repair but are delivered by smaller professional bodies with less commercial research funding.

The Pre-Placement Foundation: The "baseline" journey must start at the moment a person decides to become an adoptive parent. Transparency regarding potential challenges and the full spectrum of support available must be built into initial preparation programmes. Furthermore, during the matching and introduction phases, the baseline offer must address the extreme delicacy of transitioning to a new family. It must account for the often-hidden traumas associated with what may appear, on the surface, to be a "positive" move for all involved, ensuring parents are braced for the complexity of the transition from day one.

Summary: A baseline offer should be the beginning of the journey, not the destination. It must exist as part of a tiered system where specialised, AHP-led therapeutic interventions are readily available and integrated into the family's long-term support plan.

13. Proposal 2: Strengthen peer and community support for adoptive parents and children.

We strongly welcome this proposal. Reducing isolation and building relational resilience through community networks is essential for the long-term stability of adoptive and kinship families.

The Role of Dramatherapists in Community Groups: Dramatherapists are uniquely positioned to facilitate these networks. Unlike "peer-only" groups which can sometimes risk trauma-escalation without professional containment, Dramatherapists can offer therapeutic community groups. These use creative action, storytelling, and group play to normalize the adoption experience, build social skills, and strengthen identity in a way that feels safe and inclusive.

Addressing the Funding Gap: While the profession has long seen the value of this work, the current funding landscape (specifically the ASGSF) has historically prioritised individual clinical interventions over group-based or community provision. Many practitioners have attempted to launch initiatives—such as therapeutic theatre groups or community-based relational spaces—but have been unable to secure funding. To make this proposal successful, the funding model must explicitly recognize and support group-level professional facilitation.

Beyond "Just a Chat": For many adopted young people, traditional peer support can feel exposing or difficult. Community-based Dramatherapy offers a "side-by-side" approach where relationships are built through shared creative activity. This aligns perfectly with the goal of developing "soft skills" and "self-advocacy" mentioned in the Adoption UK case study, while providing the clinical safety net of a trained Allied Health Professional (AHP).

Integrating the "Team Around the Family": Strengthening community support allows for the "scaffolding" of a family outside the home. Dramatherapists working in these community settings can act as a bridge between the family, the school, and social care, ensuring that the child’s community environment is as trauma informed as their home environment.

Summary: This proposal opens the door to a much more diverse and responsive range of interventions. We recommend that the implementation includes clear pathways for professionally facilitated therapeutic groups to ensure these networks are robust, safe, and clinically informed.

14. Proposal 3: Provide proactive support for adopted and kinship children at key life stages, such as transitions to secondary school.

In our clinical experience, transitions are one of the most significant "bugbears" for adopted and kinship families. We frequently see children "unravel" as they move between school years, and even more severely when moving between school sites (e.g., primary to secondary, or secondary to college).

Addressing Dysregulation: For children with histories of trauma and attachment disruption, change is often experienced as a threat to safety rather than an opportunity for growth. This leads to profound dysregulation as they struggle to navigate new environments, routines, and peer groups. A proactive, directed intervention during these windows is essential to prevent a child's internal distress from escalating into a full placement crisis.

Supporting Parental Anxiety: We recognize that parents often feel particularly anxious during these times. They anticipate the "unravelling" and often feel unequipped to manage the heightened dysregulation at home. Proactive support should include therapeutic consultation for parents to help them provide the specific co-regulation their child needs to navigate the transition.

The Unique Role of Dramatherapy: Dramatherapists are specifically trained to work with the inbetween spaces of transition and change. Through creative action, play and metaphor, children and young people are supported to “rehearse” the changes they are facing, allowing fears, losses and uncertainties to be explored safely at a symbolic level. This builds a child’s internal capacity to manage change, rather than relying solely on external strategies. Dramatherapy also supports children and young people as they navigate developmental change and evolving identity, using structured, meaningful processes that help experiences of change to be understood, integrated and carried forward.

Expanding the Scope to College: We particularly welcome the inclusion of transitions to adulthood. The move from secondary school to college is often overlooked but represents a massive shift in autonomy that can trigger early abandonment fears. Directed therapeutic support at this stage is vital for ensuring these young people remain in education and training.

Willingness to Contribute: As a professional body of Allied Health Professionals (AHPs), we are willing and ready to contribute to the design and delivery of these interventions. We believe that integrating Dramatherapy into transition toolkits and workshops—and offering it as a targeted intervention—will significantly improve outcomes for families at these critical junctures.

Summary: Moving from a reactive to a proactive model will save both placements and public funds. By intervening before a child "unravels," we ensure that transitions are managed as developmental milestones rather than traumatic events.

15. Proposal 4: Enhance plans to better meet children’s needs, setting clear expectations for families and services via Practice Guides.

We strongly support the move toward comprehensive, transparent, and regularly reviewed support plans. To ensure these plans are clinically robust and truly reflect the child's needs, we suggest the following enhancements:

Dramatherapists as Consultative Partners: Allied Health Professionals (AHPs) like Dramatherapists hold deep, longitudinal understanding of a child’s relational and symbolic world. We propose that therapists working with adoptive and kinship families should be involved in the planning and review process on a consultative basis. Their inclusion on consultation panels would ensure that services are developed with a sophisticated understanding of how to meet complex trauma needs effectively.

A Multi-Disciplinary Approach to Planning: We welcome the intent to move beyond "unnecessary medicalisation." Dramatherapy is inherently relational and community-based, aligning with the government’s vision for social-care-led support. However, to be "joined up," the "named practitioners" in these plans must include the child’s therapist to ensure the therapeutic goals are supported in school and at home.

Defining "Best Practice" and Evidence: While we support the use of Practice Guides, we caution against a narrow interpretation of "evidence-based" that relies solely on interventions explicitly named in the current NICE guidelines.

The NICE Gap: While Dramatherapy is not yet explicitly named as a standalone intervention in current NICE guidance for looked-after children, it is a primary delivery method for several core NICE recommendations, including attachment-focused interventions, therapeutic life story work, and trauma-informed care.

Equitable Evidence Recognition: Smaller professional bodies require more time and resource to submit evidence to NICE. We argue that children should not be penalised by a lack of service choice simply because an intervention is delivered by a smaller AHP group. Practice Guides must recognize the clinical rationale of trauma processing, emotional regulation, and symbolic play as valid evidence-of-need.

Empowering Kinship Families: For kinship care, the Family Group Decision Making process is an excellent step. Dramatherapists can offer specialised consultation during this process to help families understand the underlying trauma and "blocked trust" that may be driving a child’s behaviour, ensuring the resulting plan is truly responsive to the child’s internal state.

Summary: Standardizing plans is a positive step toward equity of care. However, "best practice" must remain inclusive of creative and relational therapies that meet the child’s needs where traditional "top-down" interventions may fail. We advocate for the embedding of Dramatherapists within the planning and consultation framework to ensure these plans remain clinically "live" and effective.

16. Proposal 5: Standardise needs assessments for adopted and eligible kinship children, and commission social care, health and education support based on their needs.

The intention behind Proposal 5 is welcome. A more equitable, evidence informed approach to assessing need and commissioning support for adopted and eligible kinship children is essential to improving outcomes and reducing variation in practice. However, care is needed to ensure that “standardisation” does not result in oversimplification, overmedicalisation, or pathway decisions being driven primarily by assessor background rather than the child’s developmental and relational needs.

Purpose and scope of assessment

Standardised assessment should be clear about what it is assessing and why. Assessments must move beyond categorising behaviour or assigning diagnostic labels alone, and instead focus on understanding a child’s functional needs, developmental history, relational context, and what support is most likely to promote recovery, stability and learning.

A robust assessment framework should explicitly consider:

early trauma history, including prebirth, acute and chronic trauma

age and developmental stage at which trauma occurred

neurodevelopmental difference or diagnosis (including autism and Foetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder, which disproportionately affect adopted and kinship cohorts)

the child’s emotional regulation, sensory and motor functioning, attachment patterns and capacity for safety in relationships

the wellbeing and support needs of parents and carers

Individual difference and trauma-informed formulation

While consistency in process is important, it is equally important to recognise that trauma is experienced and held individually. As trauma research makes clear, trauma is not defined solely by the event itself, but by how a child’s mind, body and nervous system register and continue to carry that experience, and what protective factors might be in place post trauma. The same event may be overwhelming for one child and not for another. Assessments therefore need to include clinical formulation, not just standard measures, so that difference is understood rather than flattened.

Professional knowledge and pathway choice

Multidisciplinary assessment teams are strongly supported, provided they have access to broad therapeutic expertise. Psychology led assessment can be highly effective when psychological intervention is indicated, but psychology should not be the default or sole interpretive lens. Children and families benefit most when assessors understand the full range of evidencebased interventions available across health, education and social care, including relational, attachment based and creative arts therapies.

Pathway decisions should be based on need and suitability, not simply on what services are most familiar to the assessor. This includes recognising when non-verbal, developmentally attuned interventions are more appropriate than talking based approaches, particularly for children with early developmental trauma or neurodevelopmental difference.

Commissioning linked to assessment

The proposal to link improved needs assessment with commissioning evidence-based provision is positive. To be effective, commissioning frameworks should allow flexibility so that support can be matched to the child and family, rather than forcing families into predetermined service models. Outcomes should focus on stability, wellbeing, learning and reduced escalation, rather than shortterm symptom reduction alone.

Conclusion

In summary, a standardised framework for assessment is supported, provided it:

allows for individual difference and clinical formulation

avoids overmedicalisation of trauma-related behaviour

is genuinely multidisciplinary and informed by a wide range of therapeutic disciplines

leads to flexible, needsled pathways rather than predetermined intervention hierarchies

Done well, this approach would support earlier, more effective intervention, strengthen permanence, and reduce escalation to crisis responses — including deprivation of liberty — by addressing need before pressure reaches breaking point.

17. Proposal 6: Require clinical adoption support therapies to be compliant with NHS evidence standards. Ensure all interventions are well evidenced and assessed.

While we support the pursuit of high clinical standards and the need for interventions to be impactful, we have significant concerns regarding the narrow definition of “evidence” currently proposed. Relying solely on Randomised Controlled Trials (RCTs) and NICE guidelines as the gatekeepers for funding creates a partial and potentially misleading picture of what is effective for children with developmental trauma and complex attachment needs.

Randomised Controlled Trials (RCTs) are often positioned as the “gold standard” for evaluating clinical interventions. They are particularly strong at answering the question: “does this intervention work under controlled conditions?” However, in the context of dramatherapy as a clinical intervention, relying solely on RCTs provides a partial and sometimes misleading picture of the intervention as a whole. In our opinion, a broader, multimethod approach is needed in order to capture the full complexity of the practice.

Internal Validity vs Real-World Relevance

RCTs are designed to isolate cause and effect by tightly controlling variables and thus prioritising internal validity. While this is methodologically rigorous, it can significantly reduce relevance to realworld settings. Dramatherapists work in complex, dynamic environments — including schools, NHS services, specialist provisions, private practice and charities — where interventions are adapted in response to context, resources, developmental stage and relational need. These settings are difficult to standardise, and the resources required to run large-scale RCTs across them are often limited. As a result, valuable realworld and practice-based evidence risks being underrecognised or excluded from funding decisions.

Ethical and Practical Constraints

Many aspects of dramatherapy cannot be easily or ethically randomised. It is not appropriate to deny children therapeutic support in order to create a “no treatment” control group, so studies often rely on waitlist controls instead. Even then, ensuring adherence to a fixed intervention protocol is challenging. Dramatherapy is inherently relational, responsive and clientled, meaning sessions evolve in response to individual needs. This flexibility is clinically essential but sits in tension with the standardisation required in RCT designs.

Capturing Complexity and Meaning

RCTs tend to prioritise measurable outcomes such as symptom reduction. However, dramatherapy often facilitates change through symbolic expression, embodiment, play and relational safety, supporting shifts in identity, meaning making and relational patterns. These forms of change are complex, layered and deeply meaningful, but not always easily quantifiable or captured in existing psychometrically validated outcome measures.

Crucially, trauma is not defined by the objective severity of events but by the degree of overwhelm experienced by the child’s mind, body and nervous system. As Bessel van der Kolk and others have argued, the same experience may be traumatic for one child and not for another, depending on relational safety, developmental stage, protective factors and capacity for regulation. Interventions that work implicitly and non-verbally — through play, movement, image and metaphor — are therefore particularly wellsuited to trauma-affected children, even if the impact of such work is not immediately reflected in symptombased measures.

Qualitative, arts-based and phenomenological research methods, alongside service-user and lived-experience feedback, are better suited to capturing these dimensions of therapeutic change and must be considered legitimate forms of evidence.

Understanding How and Why It Works

RCTs can tell us whether an intervention works on average, but they are less effective at explaining how or why it works, for whom, and in which contexts. In dramatherapy, understanding the “active ingredients” and “mechanisms of change” — including relational safety, symbolic distance, coregulation and creative agency — is central to evaluating effectiveness.

Process research, realist evaluation and practicebased evidence are therefore essential complements to outcomefocused trials, illuminating the contextual factors that support change and helping services make informed decisions about suitability, timing and delivery.

Small Samples and Individual Variation

Dramatherapy is, to date, a relatively small profession, and practitioners frequently work with specific or marginalised populations, including adopted and kinship children with complex trauma histories. This makes it difficult to achieve the large sample sizes typically required for RCTs. Moreover, RCTs report average outcomes, which can obscure meaningful individual variation. Dramatherapy practice values individual, relational and developmentally appropriate change, which may not be fully captured through aggregated data alone.

Limitations and Bias in RCTs

RCTs are not free from limitations or bias. Publication bias means that studies with positive findings are more likely to be published, while funding constraints and selective reporting can further shape outcomes. Therefore, RCTs should not be treated as objective arbiters of value, but as one form of evidence with recognised strengths and limitations.

The Value of Multiple Methodologies

We believe that robust evidence for dramatherapy emerges through triangulation across multiple methodologies. This includes:

Randomised and non-randomised trials where appropriate

Qualitative research capturing lived experience and meaning

Case studies and service evaluations offering depth and contextual insight

Practicebased and realworld evidence reflecting routine clinical settings

Service-user and carer feedback informing questions of fit, timing and impact

Taken together, these approaches offer a more ecologically valid and ethically appropriate understanding of effectiveness for trauma-affected children than any single method alone.

Existing RCT evidence base

To demonstrate our commitment to rigorous evidence, we highlight that Dramatherapy already has a growing base of RCTs and systematic reviews, including these about children:

Moula, Z., Powell, J., & Karkou, V. (2020). An investigation of the effectiveness of arts therapies interventions on measures of quality of life and wellbeing: A pilot randomised controlled study in primary schools. Frontiers in Psychology, 11, Article 586134. https://doi.org/10.3389/ fpsyg.2020.586134

McArdle, P., Moseley, D., Quibell, T., Johnson, R., Allen, A., Hammal, D., & LeCouteur, A. (2002). School-based indicated prevention: A randomised trial of group therapy. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 43(6), 705–712. https://doi.org/10.1111/1469-7610.00091

Ilievová, L’., Žitný, P., & Karabová, Z. (2015). The effectiveness of drama therapy on preparation for diagnostic and therapeutic procedures in children suffering from cancer. Journal of Health Sciences, 5, 53–58. http://dx.doi.org/10.17532/jhsci.2015.252

Rajabi, S., Nemati, F., & Narimani, M. (2013). Improving the quality of Farsi speech and the academic performance of Azeri–Farsi bilingual students through attending drama therapy sessions. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 40, 478 – 485. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.aip.2013.06.003

These are about other client groups…

Keisari, S., Palgi, Y., Yaniv, D., & Gesser-Edelsburg, A. (2022). Participation in life-review playback theatre enhances mental health of community-dwelling older adults: A randomised controlled trial. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts, 16(2), 302–317. https://doi.org/10.1037/aca0000354

Mechaeil, R., Graybow, A., & Cobham, P. (2009). Towards a purposeful ending: A study exploring the impact of dramatherapy on the quality of life of people suffering from dementia. Dramatherapy, 31(2), 27–34. https://doi.org/10.1080/02630672.2009.9689775

van den Broek, E. P. A., Strijbos, N., Vromen, J., van Duursen, S., Cousijn, J., Bosschaert, L., Zeegers, L., van Zeeland, G., Pouwels, S., van den Berge, M., Vallentin, R., Korsten, D., & Keulen-de Vos, M. (2021). A pilot study of arts therapy techniques to evoke emotional states in forensic patients. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 74, Article 101798. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aip.2021.101798

Conclusion

RCTs remain a valuable tool in healthcare research, particularly for demonstrating causal effects under controlled conditions. However, dramatherapy is a complex, relational and context-sensitive intervention, and its effectiveness cannot be fully understood through RCTs alone. A broader, inclusive and methodologically plural evidence base — incorporating clinical trials alongside qualitative, practicebased and service-user evidence — is required to ensure adopted children and young people receive support that is both effective and developmentally appropriate.

Recognising that trauma is fundamentally about overwhelm rather than objective severity, evidence frameworks must be able to capture relational, embodied and meaning making forms of change if they are to reflect the realities of children’s lives.

18. Proposal 7: Devolve Adoption and Special Guardianship Support Fund funding and responsibility to regional and/or local decision makers.

While we support the principle of "joined up" local services, we have significant concerns about how devolution would impact the consistency, quality, and variety of specialist therapeutic provision.

Risk of a ‘Postcode Lottery’: Central administration, despite its flaws, provides a level of national equity. Devolving funding to local authorities or Regional Adoption Agencies (RAAs) risks creating significant geographic disparity. Families in one region may have access to a full range of creative AHPs (Allied Health Professionals), while those in another may be restricted to whatever "in-house" services a local authority has the capacity to provide. Devolution must include a statutory requirement to offer a diverse range of AHP-led therapies.

The Threat to Specialist Choice: We are concerned that local commissioning may lead to "block contracting" for larger, generic services to save on administrative costs. This would dismantle the diverse market of specialist independent practitioners and smaller therapeutic agencies who currently provide highly tailored Dramatherapy. If local decision-makers prioritize "efficiency" over "clinical fit," families will lose the right to the intervention that actually meets their child’s specific needs.

Need for Ring-Fencing: If funding is moved to the Children, Families, and Youth grant, there is a severe risk that adoption and kinship support funds will be "absorbed" into crisis-driven statutory social care budgets. Unless this funding is strictly ring-fenced for therapeutic interventions, the proactive and preventative work we advocate for will likely disappear in favour of meeting immediate child protection crises.

Expertise in Commissioning: High-quality therapeutic commissioning requires a deep understanding of developmental trauma and the specific efficacy of different modalities (such as the "bottom-up" repair offered by Dramatherapy). Dramatherapy plays a unique role here, as trauma is often fragmented, non-linear, and held beyond words; it requires structured, symbolic, and embodied processes to integrate "split-off" experiences. We are not yet confident that all local or regional bodies have the clinical expertise to commission specialist therapies effectively without national guidance and standards. This risks unintentionally reducing choice for children with complex trauma. Guidance for commissioners must ensure that commissioners are trained to understand the clinical depth of the therapies, such as dramatherapy, they are tasked with funding

Conflict of Interest: We hold significant concerns regarding potential conflicts of interest within devolved models. There is a high risk of bias where the same organisations (Regional Adoption Agencies or Local Authorities) are responsible for both assessing a child’s need and commissioning or providing the service. If "in-house" services are prioritised for efficiency, families may be denied access to the specialist, independent Dramatherapy that best meets their clinical needs.

Case Study: Strategic Workforce Investment (The DREAM Together Evaluation)

The Evidence: We point to the recent evaluation of the DREAM Together project—a collaboration involving Anglia Ruskin University and a Regional Adoption Agency. This evaluation examined a two-year trauma-informed training programme specifically designed for adoption staff, utilizing Dramatherapy methods, reflective spaces, and supervision to improve organisational culture.

The Findings: The evaluation demonstrated that sustained, creative, and trauma-informed support for the workforce leads to:

Improved Decision-Making: Practitioners showed increased reflective capacity and empathy, resulting in more consistent and attuned decision-making for families.

Workforce Stability: The programme directly improved practitioner wellbeing, providing the emotional containment necessary to prevent burnout in high-intensity adoption work, thereby improving staff retention and reducing the high recruitment costs associated with turnover.

Systemic Change: It facilitated a shift toward a culture of safety and collaboration within the agency.

Relevance to Proposal 7 (Funding & Devolution): This study provides a concrete warning against the "short-termism" of devolved funding. Systemic transformation of this kind requires a multi-year investment that spans beyond a single budget cycle.

The Risk: If funding is devolved to local authorities under immediate financial pressure, evidence-based strategic programmes like DREAM Together—which stabilize the workforce and improve the quality of care—are often the first to be cut in favour of "crisis-only" spending.

The Conclusion: Devolving the ASGSF without a mandate for long-term strategic commissioning risks dismantling the professional capability needed to support children with complex trauma.

The proposal to potentially reduce or devolve specialist funding contradicts the strategic shift outlined in the NHS Long Term Plan, which advocates for moving the focus from acute crisis treatment to community-based prevention. While we acknowledge that current local and national budgets are under unprecedented pressure, cutting preventative therapeutic care is a false economy. Sustained investment in the workforce and early relational support creates significant "cost-avoidance" by stabilising placements and reducing the need for high-cost emergency interventions later in a child’s life. Systemic transformation cannot be achieved through short-term, "sticking plaster" funding; rather, it requires the consistent application of specialist therapies available when needed and at those key transition times that address the root causes of trauma. To align with national health priorities and ensure long-term fiscal sustainability, the Department must recognize that proactive therapeutic investment is significantly more cost-effective than the multi-generational costs of placement breakdown and untreated developmental trauma.

A better way to save money may be to allow targeted group therapy where this is clinically indicated, combining expert led therapeutic facilitation with the peer support. Dramatherapy can be especially effective when delivered in a therapy group.

Summary: We cannot support this proposal without clear guarantees regarding national minimum standards, ring-fenced budgets, and the protection of parental choice. The priority must remain the child’s clinical need, not the administrative convenience of the local authority.

19. Proposal 8: Improving value for money to ensure every pound spent is used efficiently, sustainably and on families.

As a professional body representing clinicians, we prefer to remain within our area of core competence: the delivery of effective therapeutic interventions. However, we have significant concerns regarding the practical implementation of this proposal and its potential impact on service quality.

Financial Disparity and Risk: We are concerned about how this model would function across regions with vastly different financial health. In areas where local authorities are struggling significantly or are effectively bankrupt, there is a high risk that "economical" compromises would be made. This could lead to a "stretching" of funds that prioritises low-cost, generic provision over the specialist Dramatherapy children actually need.

The "Postcode Lottery": Devolving funds without a guaranteed, equitable formula risks creating a system where the quality of support depends entirely on a child’s location. We are unclear on how funding would be distributed between a bankrupt city and a wealthy neighbouring county within the same regional body, and whether this money would be strictly ring-fenced for therapeutic support.

Administrative Overload: Feedback from social work professionals indicates that larger regional management structures often lead to increased "admin bloat"—more meetings, more negotiations, and more bureaucracy. We are concerned that funds intended for direct therapeutic intervention will instead be absorbed by the increased costs of managing these complex regional tiers.

Long-Term Impact: Compromising the quality of the therapeutic offer to find short-term "efficiencies" has long-term financial and human implications that are rarely measured. If a child does not receive high-quality, specialised repair early on, the eventual cost to the state in terms of education and mental health support will be far higher.

Standardisation vs. Localisation: While the government aims for "joined-up" services, there is a contradiction in seeking national NHS-style evidence standards (as per Proposal 6) while simultaneously fragmenting the funding and commissioning of those services to a local level.

Conclusion: We cannot support this proposal without a clear understanding of how funding will be protected, how regional disparities will be managed, and how the DfE will ensure that administrative costs do not erode the budget for direct clinical care.

Legislation and documents

Consultations are a members' space: what is open, what is being asked, members' views and BADth's guidance for your own response. Sign in as a BADth member to see them and have your say.

account android arrow-alt-circle-down arrow-alt-circle-left arrow-alt-circle-right arrow-alt-circle-up arrow-down arrow-left arrow-right arrow-up author bars behance blogger bluesky buffer caret-down caret-left caret-right caret-square-down caret-square-left caret-square-right caret-square-up caret-up cart-menu-1 cart-menu-2 cart-menu-3 cart-menu-4 categories chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right chevron-up clock close comments cookies copyright coupon-discount date-modified date-published discord double-arrows-down double-arrows-left double-arrows-right double-arrows-up dribbble envelope-open envelope eye facebook fax flickr foursquare github gmail google-drive grid-view hashtag hollow-ring homepage instagram ios level-down-alt level-up-alt line link linkedin list-view login logout long-arrow-alt-down long-arrow-alt-left long-arrow-alt-right long-arrow-alt-up mastodonmedium messenger mobile-menu mobile phone pinterest place qq quote-left quote-right quotes reading-time-hourglass reading-time-stopwatch reddit rss scroll-to-top search shazam shopping-bag shopping-cart side-panel-opening-2-left side-panel-opening-2-right side-panel-opening-left side-panel-opening-right skype slack small-arrow-down small-arrow-left small-arrow-right small-arrow-up sms snapchat soundcloud spinner spotify stackoverflow sync telegram threadstiktok times-circle tinder trello tripadvisor tumblr twitch twitter viber vimeo vine vkontakte website wechat whatsapp windows wishlist xing yelp youtube zoom