The
Bruce Howard Bayley
Award
Will Secretan was awarded funds from the BADth Bruce Howard Bayley Trust Fund in 2019. The Bruce Howard Bayley fund was used to support specialist supervision and provide arts materials for use in this pilot project that combined dramatherapy, ecotherapy and ecopsychology and we are delighted to be able to share his work and findings here. Becky Sheppard
Environmental Arts Therapy Pilot Group – Summary, background, methods, findings and conclusions
Summary of the Pilot:
The pilot consisted of twenty-four weekly group sessions that were spread over a sixmonth period. It was held in a specialist ‘woods for wellness’ venue on the Dartington Estate in south Devon called The Glade, which is managed by a Community Interest Company (CIC) called The Woodland Presents (www.thewoodland.co).
Seven adults with a variety of mental health presentations were referred into the group. All of the clients were considered to have ‘severe and complex mental illnesses’ and were being supported within the context of a ‘Step Four’ Secondary Care NHS Mental Health Service. They each had a brief individual assessment, a minimum of two sessions, before being invited to join the group. Of those seven individuals four went through with the group, completing the full course of twenty-four sessions. These four clients had varying diagnoses, including PTSD,
Borderline
Personality
Disorder
and
Psychosis. All clients in the group had histories of complex trauma.
The
participants
completed
clinical
outcome
measures prior to joining the group, as well as at the end of the group, and two participants agreed to complete a further round of outcome measures and recorded interviews eight months after the group was completed. The findings of these quantitative measures and the interview-based qualitative data collection are presented in this document.
Background:
The group set out to address the needs of individuals experiencing difficulties in connecting and coping with changes within themselves, their relationships and the world around them. It intended, in particular, to be helpful for individuals with severe and enduring difficulties around loss, coping with life-transitions
and
those
who
had
become
disconnected
from
society
(friends,
family,
employment, community) and themselves (identity, meaning, sense of purpose in life). The group also set out to address the problems of ‘nature-deficit disorder’ (the psychological response to being disconnected from nature), ‘solastalgia’ (emotional or existential distress caused by environmental change) and the conditions of depression and anxiety that are being increasingly reported in response to the global ecological crisis.
The group hoped to benefit many of our clients who struggle to engage with therapeutic interventions within the normal confines of our traditional clinical settings. Anecdotally, many clients feel more distressed in these settings or find the clinical environment to be stifling. Some clients report feelings of profound grief for their sense of disconnection
from
nature
and
also
report
alleviation of a wide range of symptoms of distress when in nature. This group set out to help support a group of adults with complex mental health problems to not only access nature, but to also engage in an evidence-based therapy whilst in nature, thus helping clients to increase their own available resources.
Methods:
The group was based on principles from ecopsychology and ecotherapy. Ecotherapy aims to improve psychological and physical wellbeing through engaging in psychotherapeutic activities in nature or with natural stimuli. Ecopsychology focuses on the relational interaction between humans and the natural world. The underlying philosophy is based on the idea that psychological distress, associated with life events, is magnified because of our disconnection from the natural world and that reconnecting with natural environments can in turn support us in managing our psychological distress. One particular model of Ecotherapy, Environmental Arts Therapy (EAT), was used as the foundation of this group. EAT uses principles from art psychotherapy and dramatherapy, such as storytelling, ritual, and role play, as well as art-making with natural materials. These techniques help to engage participants in an encounter with both themselves and the natural environment.
Findings:
Two quantitative outcome measures were used at the beginning and end of the group and eight months after the group was completed. These were CORE-34 and ReQol-10 (Recovery of Quality of Life measure). ‘ACE’ feedback forms were issued at the end of the group and an eight-month follow-up interview also took place, both of which provided a source of qualitative data.
Whilst all four group members completed the pre-group measures, only three completed the post-group measures, and two participated in the eight-month followup. Whilst this is of course too small a sample to be of any generalizable reliability, we hope that it gives a sense of the experience of these individuals.
Patients Pre-Group Post-group 8 month Pre-Group Post-Group 6 month Core-34 Core-34 follow-up ReQol-10 ReQol-10 follow-up Core-34 ReQol-10
Patient 1 15.9 5.3 15.9 38 60 27 Patient 2 22.6 4.7 10 28 58 48 Patient 3 8.5 – – 45 – – Patient 4 27.4 14.4 – 26 46 –
Of the three clients who completed the end of group outcome measures, all three have made ‘clinically significant change’, both in terms of the data collected from CORE34 and from ReQoL. Patient 1 and Patient 2 have both moved from being in the ‘severe’ range of the population to having CORE and ReQol scores comparable with the average for the general population.
Six months after the group was completed, two group members completed a further round of outcome measures. Interestingly, Patient 1 has returned to the same score given before therapy began, while Patient 2’s change remains ‘clinically significant’.
ACE Qualitative Feedback: All patients in the group ‘strongly agreed’ with the following statements:
• The venue for my appointment was satisfactory • Therapy helped me develop insight into my difficulties • I made progress with the issues I was seeking help for • Therapy helped me make changes in my life • I feel less distressed as a result of attending therapy • My clinician(s) was skilled or capable • Overall, I am satisfied with the help I received • I would recommend this service to family and friends if they needed similar care or treatment
In their own words:
Patient 1:
“I found this therapy really good, being outside in the woods gave it a different feeling, made it easier to understand and deal with problems”.
“I am able to trust again, being more open to others and their suggestions. Not being aggressive to others. Being able to look towards the future and understanding my problems”.
“[This psychological therapy should be] available to lots of other people with problems. The whole environment is fantastic, being outside makes a really big difference.”
“I found the whole experience really good, the two clinicians were fantastic. I think the experience would help a lot of others with similar problems. A really uplifting experience.”
Patient 2:
Six Month Follow-Up Interviews:
Patients 1 and 2 both took part in six-month follow-up interviews. Both reported that the impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic had taken a big toll on their lives in many different personal ways. This had, without a doubt, impacted their mental health and sense of wellbeing over the previous six months. Both reported, however, that the impact of the group on their lives was long lasting and had made a permanent positive effect on them. Both maintained that the group had changed their lives for the better and that it was the best therapeutic experience either of them had ever had during their long histories with mental health services. Both described the outdoor environment of The Glade and the creative techniques used in the therapy as the most important catalysts for change in the group.
Conclusions:
It is not possible for us to draw any generalizable conclusions from this pilot – the sample was of course too small to be considered empirically meaningful. Despite this though, the shift in CORE and ReQoL results from the beginning to the end of the group in all three returned forms was unusually large. The changes made for at least one participant remained significant six months after the group was completed, despite the impact of COVID-19. The qualitative feedback was exemplary. This group meets the standards expected from all other psychological therapies in terms of efficacy and further research may demonstrate that this group exceeds normal expectations. The environment in which the group was held was a significant contributing factor in the positive effects of the intervention and exemplifies the principles of a ‘psychologically informed environment’.
Will Secretan
“Environmental Arts Therapy is totally different from the hospital environment.”
“Huge changes in my life. I no longer feel shame and guilt about things I was too young to have control of. I feel calmer, much more positive about the future.”
“[Psychological Therapies could improve by] giving more people the chance of alternative ways of healing such as Environmental Arts Therapy. I had twenty [traditional talking therapy] one-to-one sessions before this and it did help a little, but I am sure I would have never progressed this far with more one-to-one or ordinary group therapy.”
“I feel so privileged to have taken part in this experimental form of therapy. I have formed bonds with the group. I have healed past trauma in ways I never thought possible. I understand that I am going to have bad times as everyone does, but I have the tools to cope better.”