Letter to The Prompt
Response to the Chair’s and Vice-Chair’s reply to my letter in the June edition of The Prompt
I am pleased that we have now established that the minutes of Executive meeting, 2nd February, 2019 are a true record and that it was agreed that a Committee of Inquiry should be established.
Reports from Forensic Accountant and Auditors Report
In response to your questions relating to securing the Forensic Accountant’s report, this action was advised in barrister Antonia Noble’s advice about the constitution of a Committee of Inquiry:
… there are various strands of evidence that the committee would be likely to wish to consider: Professional advice / reports: forensic accountant (section 26, p 6).
The information provided in the report was taken from minutes of Executive Committee meetings and I forwarded any further information to her on request. She was not known to any person connected to BADth in any capacity. Surely it is clear from the job title ‘forensic accountant’ what their remit would be.
It is maybe more important to note the comments made by the auditor of BADth’s internal inquiry:
‘In particular there were two broad types of scenario which had caused some degree of conflict: 1. Contracts being arranged with individuals/companies with close ties to members of the Executive. There appeared to be circumstances when Executive members engaged parties close to them and it was not necessarily clear whether these close connections had always been disclosed to the rest of the Executive. 2. Contracts being arranged which were not approved by the Executive. There appeared to be some circumstances whereby a supplier had been engaged and there was little or no evidence of the Executive approving the appointment. Further, there were circumstances whereby an engagement for a project had been approved but the contract appeared to take far longer than expected and there appeared to be little feedback to the Executive on the progress of the engagement.’
I can only repeat that awarding contracts to individuals with ‘close ties’ without declaring a conflict of interest is a serious matter. If the circumstances are deemed to be unclear, then they need to be further investigated by an external body so the matter can be closed.
I am pleased to note that the current Executive has continued the practice of declaring potential conflicts of interests, which was introduced in February 2019.
Further comments
Thank you for uploading the document about bullying onto the members’ area of the BADth website. I did not receive a direct response to my comment about allegations of bullying within the Association. Until they are fully investigated by an external body, and all parties are involved, then these accusations must remain allegations rather than fact. A Committee of Inquiry would allow the matter to be settled. I remain unclear about the full rationale for constructing a disciplinary procedure and whether other profession associations have adopted this procedure.
Madeline Andersen-Warren