Nothing prepares you for
becoming a therapist online.
In my case, the familiarity of working with families over many years, now harnessed to startling virtual reality by audiovisual technology.
The family who’d never met with me were booked to attend my studio. Street directions had been sent. A week later social distancing became the norm, and it was impossible they attend. It is of the essence that we offer our clients therapy, especially now. At this time.
I felt I could ‘come up to the table’ with this new unknown challenge of meeting through audio-video.
Most of us prepare our room for our clients. The preparations I make for seeing clients in my studio (hoovering the room, the stairs, clearing away clutter from the stairs, turning off the phone, ‘neutral-ing’ myself and the place, turning off my husband’s computer in the next room, shutting all doors, bringing in water in a jug and glasses, etc. etc.) are put in the shade by those I now have to think about in the case of being on screen. Several hours before the session, I’m nonplussed by how I can prop up my laptop to show my whole face instead of just my hair? It hasn’t mattered that much before on skype meetings with fellow professionals. But it does now. Cushions don’t seem to do it. Why does the laptop slip down? If I hold it in place, I can’t write at all. How do I stop my emails popping up during the session and being seen by my clients? My son who frequently holds conferences on zoom is helpful. I need to know how to ‘Host’. How to be the host… in this new age of growing universal goodwill, there’s something else biblical…
Five minutes before the agreed session time, I bring in my glass of water and shut the door on my session. It will be as close as possible to the norm.
Do I show my new clients my studio with its props, lined with books, to give a flavour of the work?
There is a messy start to this work, each screen person fiddling and settling and drawing up chairs. Once we’ve all begun to settle after the ‘hallo’ time, and have achieved the start of the family session, the child comes right up to the screen, goes away and picks up his pet rabbit
and
the
Unknown
in
momentous
times
Clients’ anonymity is maintained through an amalgam of examples. D-i-s-t-a-n-c-i-n-g
who lives in this spare room. Is this animal a transitional object which will replace my props?
Auntie Jude and I have already had a productive session last week during which Auntie relaxed noticeably, becoming more reflective. Now it’s a very different session with auntie and child. “Do you mean a mindmap?” the child asks when I suggest he write his name in the centre of his paper and draw round it. He goes off out of the room to find felt tips: another very different boundary which will need attention when we’ve established how we work together.
Jo Clarkson writes helpfully of children sometimes choosing to have their therapy privately in the car. In this case auntie and child are in a rather cluttered spare room. Recalling Irvine Gersch’s comment several years ago about therapy being possible in a school cupboard (a premise I challenged robustly) I reflect that looking into the clients’ own home space is another Rubicon we’re crossing…
Rabbit jumps around and pops up unexpectedly on the child’s lap. I can’t catch its name.
Wyatt finishes his artwork after the 10 or 15 minutes timing we’d agreed for it. Auntie had remained quietly waiting by him. His colourful, different shaped ‘spider legs’ are expressive. As he reads his added words aloud for me along each ‘leg’ a variety of feelings are evoked for him, and immediately he is able to talk about the subject which is most pressing and painful for him. He looks often at Jude; there is a warm closeness between them. It feels safe. As adults Jude and I have spoken and agreed, of course, about privacy and no interruptions, and the kind of session to expect with child and adult. There’s a warming feeling for me: though very early minutes, the atmosphere feels containing, good enough. However, I’m noticing that each of us will need to remember to address the other two in the room; a difficult concept for many ‘only’ children; indeed for many adults… But in this first session for the child the most important aim for me is to enable the child to feel comfortable to be talking with me; to begin to trust me. Beginnings are important: it feels worth using this technology. Winnicott, always so readable, writes of the concept of ‘good enough’ in respect of infant and mother. It’s of the essence of our own work.
On audio visual connections though, it is not always easy to catch what my client family say to each other. Every family has its own culture. And why would this family not talk quietly to one another at a time like this? I need to ask for repetition occasionally, once more than once. Speaking slower isn’t always easy when spontaneity is of the essence: children’s words can and do tumble out. This is something we’ll all need to think about, and it can be flagged up towards the ending of the session, or thought about next session. Working with groups, boundary setting is important and core to the work. But unlike in my studio where I hear what is said between family members, in this first session, we don’t need to get hooked on it.
Already, while the child searched downstairs for the pens, auntie Jude has reported that, yes, actually it has been a good week. She and her husband Uncle Howard have both worked at home, and Wyatt has been there with them in the house. Auntie says she has enjoyed it, being together in the house with all the family. Last session, the first for her alone, she recalled yes, there had been a time when she’d been able to relax on the family holiday, two years ago. Just to not do anything Rabbit jumps
around and
pops up
unexpectedly
on the
child’s lap.
I can’t catch
its name.
Every family
has its own
culture. And
why would
this family not
talk quietly to
one another at
a time like this?
but be. An alien concept in the case of so many high achieving adult clients. It’s a concept to bring in gently and regularly: just being, not striving… (Johanson & Kurtz 1991 p. 33).
After drawing, Wyatt brings in the strong feelings he is troubled by. “Hate” rears its ugly head. This is where the work will be. In her earlier session Jude has already indicated a significant life episode which I believe holds a key to Wyatt’s trail of pain. And we shall be working with life, death, love and hate in their multiple forms.
How “Work”? How can we Dramatherapists – of all the arts therapists – work in a good enough way when we’re sailing in new waters, when we aren’t in the same physical space as our clients? The juxtaposition drives imagination and resourcefulness. Music, for sure, will be included in future. The whiteboard facility looks possible, but only just. We could use ‘record’, though that goes against my grain, because like all of us, I make my notes afterwards, and it’s the feelings I am left with which are important: in this case, a sensation of tightness held in the chest. This young child has built up over his short life a good deal of that anxious feeling. (And my concern about using this new media has no doubt influenced my feelings too).
The 2-chair (Leigh et al, 2012 p.248) method suggests one of the possible future ways of working. The family will bring in two chairs next session. Flexible ideas for the future include asking the family to set up a sculpt with small animals, or natural objects. I could show these first or draw an outline of them, or photograph them. Building a scenario of a conversation between two children, where they find it difficult to be together might follow, how one of them can begin to say something to the other person, which might just be helpful for them both. Sometimes, after initial embodiment and play focussed sessions (Klein M. 1975/1991 p.134), when as therapists we have seen the manner in which the child plays ‘as they pass from play with toys to dramatization in their own person, and again to playing with water, cutting out paper, or drawing’ this dramatization with the two chairs and role reversal offers helpful, accessible ways forward. When clients, young and old, can try out ways of being and behaving with an imagined, projected other, we work with ego strengthening. Clients’ resilience strengthens when preparing for a difficult scenario where they’ll be able to face and cope with imagined scenarios.
The child tells me he loves singing. We shall bring in that opportunity. The work is in embryo…
Importantly, with this family work, enabling adult and child to take their time is at the heart of it. At this momentous time in history, ironically, and for my clients here, taking off the brakes, beginning to be with just being, with simple things, can be so grounding. The end of sessions involves clients allowing themselves kindness. Taking care, giving ourselves gentleness at this particular time this is something we all – universally – need.
Lauraine Leigh Klugman
References
Gerhardt, S., Why Love Matters: How affection shapes a baby’s brain Routledge 2004 p.174. Johanson G. and Kurtz R., Grace Unfolding: Psychotherapy in the Spirit of the Tao-te ching Making Peace Bell Tower 1991 p.33. Klein Melanie, Love Guilt and Reparation and other works 1921–1945 The Psychological Principles of Early Analysis 1926 Virago 1975 repr. 1991 p.134.
Leigh, L. (Klugman) Gersch, I., Dix, A. & Haythorne, D. et al: Dramatherapy with Children Young People and Schools: enabling creativity sociability communication and learning. Chs 1 & 24, p.248. Routledge 2012. Winnicott, D.W. (2003 {1958}) Through Paediatrics to Psychoanalysis Collected Papers The Observation of Infants in a set Situation 1941. p.67. London Karnac 2003.
The author would like to acknowledge supportive information from BADth re: BACP working with webinars, Jo Clarkson and Ditty Dokter. D
…we shall be working with life, death, love and hate in their
multiple forms.