The NHS of the future: How
does Dramatherapy fit?
A BADth NHS subcommittee sharing practice event
Following on from the success of the 2018 event, the NHS subcommittee held its second sharing practice conference on 8th November 2019 at Barnet, Enfield and Haringey Mental Health NHS Trust, Chase Farm Hospital, North London. 21 dramatherapists attended the day. This in itself was an achievement considering BADth had no administrator at the time, and we thank everyone who booked, for their patience. Sarah Glickman, on her last day before maternity leave, did a brilliant job of hosting the day and making sure things ran smoothly.
Some participants had sent us examples of practice they were proud of, that were displayed across the room; others added their own on the day. These are the kinds of things we need to collect and have ready for the next time BADth is asked to contribute examples.
The day began with a really helpful presentation by Steve Tolan, NHS England AHP Lead for London, helping us to understand the impact of the NHS long term plan and the opportunities for arts therapies. It is ambitious, striking out for cultural changes with a joined-up approach to health and social care. In future NHS services will have to account for the social care costs of NOT treating people. Given we work with the hardest to reach service users this is a real opportunity to promote our value as engagers with those who can end up left to social care.
The challenge is to keep people away from services by promoting prevention and well-being in communities. There is an acceptance that current models of mental health services are not always working as well as voluntary sector services at peer support. This is a great opportunity for dramatherapists used to working in different organisations. Steve promoted the exciting idea that Arts therapists could provide vital support for staff, promoting self-care and team cohesion. This chimed with our conference experience last year where Dramatherapists reported running groups for staff to stop burnout.
The topic raised some frustrations from the floor about dramatherapy often not being thought about in plans in the NHS, and gave us food for thought about what we can do to help change that, both on the local and national stage, individually and as an association. Steve encouraged us to present our work, not just to each other, but to shout about every success through Twitter, create communities of interest, and present at national conferences outside of our own profession.
This chimed with the second sessions of the day. Louise Combes and Marina Morgan presented their journeys to national recognition of their dramatherapy work, which evoked great discussion. Louise noted that we are capable of collecting compelling evaluation data which demonstrates how we reach communities neglected by mainstream services. Marina’s work had been celebrated by the Advancing Health Care awards and beautifully demonstrated the power of working within community settings as now desired in the 10-year plan.
In the other room, Heather Williams shared her work with children who are dying or have experienced bereavement. This was both a touching and inspiring example of the positive impact dramatherapy can have on individuals and families. The audience strongly encouraged Heather to share her work further.
News from the Subcommittees
NHS
BADth News BADth News News from the Subcommittees
Before lunch, Sarah Glickman told us about her singing group, as a way into dramatherapy for patients on an acute inpatient mental health unit. We enjoyed singing “Stand By Me” together. There followed a short discussion about what constitutes dramatherapy, and the impact of calling groups something other than dramatherapy – with different views and experiences expressed. Perhaps something to return to at a future forum.
Lunch was an opportunity for catching up and getting to know new people.
After lunch Will Berisch-Secretan took some of the group off to the hospital garden for a session on dramatherapy outdoors. The rest of us stayed nice and warm inside, with a change to the planned programme, thinking about how we present examples of our good practice. Clare Hubbard shared the case study she was writing to submit for the NHS England publication on the role of AHPs in the NHS Long Term plan and received really helpful feedback from the group.
We then came together, in a creative session from Sophia Condaris, to think about our identity as dramatherapists within our organisations. It was useful to hear the perspective of Sarah’s new AHP Lead and an occupational therapist.
Some of our thoughts and experiences from Sophia’s workshop:
Perceptions from others
⊚Weird hippy s***
⊚Magical, odd, quirky, a unicorn, exotic
⊚Don’t open things up – dangerous
⊚Just for kids
⊚Be a tree
⊚Dramatherapists are greedy (for space)
⊚Other professionals looking for new things/envious
How do we feel?
⊚Patronised
⊚De-valued
⊚Hidden (or hiding)
⊚Is this play? Is it OK?
⊚Lack of confidence
BADth News BADth News News from the Subcommittees NHS
BADth News BADth News News from the Subcommittees What can we do?
⊚Write it down
⊚Own it
⊚Present at conferences
⊚Find a common/shared language as a bridge
⊚How do we relate to others?
⊚Can we articulate what we do?
⊚Can we use our medium and technology to share the story?
Our final session of the day was small table discussions on themes that had arisen from the day. Thinking about “What Next?”, participants were invited to move tables after 10 minutes, with a table host recording the contributions.
Evidence and evaluation
⊚How do you use information on EPR?
⊚Start with audits
⊚Use shared outcome measures across dramatherapy in the NHS. Start by sharing the measures we are already using
⊚Can the evaluation be more creative?
⊚It should be part of our usual process to ask service users for feedback (using their language) ⊚How do you do follow ups if discharging? Get client’s permission to send form out to them in 3/6 months
⊚Ask service users for permission to contact them in the future about their experience ⊚At the start of therapy, ask for consent to write about the work
Collaboration
Collaboration means making good relationships
Who with?
⊚Strategic/professional leads and commissioners
⊚Ourselves – a national picture of dramatherapists in the NHS ⊚Other arts therapists – common language
⊚OT and psychology colleagues
⊚Community third sector, charities
⊚Service users
How?
⊚AHP research forums
⊚Make ourselves more visible
⊚Continue to educate others
⊚Warming up collaborators to their role and maintaining warm up ⊚Role reversal with non-art therapy colleagues
Perceptions of Dramatherapy
⊚Own our difference from the mainstream. Love and be proud of our creativity. Rather than hide away, show others how to use metaphors and share our creativity so that we gain respect ⊚We need to improve our outward facing profile by producing evidence, data sets showing BAME diversity, attendance, track clients’ careers through other interventions and social changes over time where possible
⊚Voice the unsaid; point out that services can no longer discount difficult clients and these are who we can work with. If we celebrate our successes, reminding staff of client improvement, they will appreciate our efficiency as we work with those that cost the most money ⊚Differentiate ourselves very clearly from arts in health. Ensure people understand we are psychological by providing leadership and training; training in creative approaches to reflective practice
⊚Offer relational training at work, fun sessions for staff to help them unburden without “infantalising”
NHS
We closed the day by making connections with each other, in a dramatherapy way of-course.
Overall feedback from the day (out of 5)
Programme: 4.5 Presentations: 4.4 Venue: 3.8 Location: 3.5 Able to apply learning to my practice: 4.4
Comments included
More time was needed for some discussions; it would be nice to recognise commonalities and differences; enjoyed selection and choice of presentations; great to meet colleagues in similar work.
Suggestions for future topics
CAMHS specific topics; opportunities that exist; how we work with other professionals; difference between adult and child services; the national picture; looking to the future as dramatherapy evolves; ongoing topics covered today; continue with discussion of where arts therapies fit within services; collaboration; shared evaluation and data collection.
Thank you to all who came for making it a great day, to all the presenters who put themselves out there, and a special thank you to Sarah Glickman for co-ordinating and hosting the event.
Clare Hubbard and Louise Combes, on behalf of the NHS subcommittee
NHS
BADth News BADth News News from the Subcommittees