Letters to the Editor

Letters to the Editor

The Prompt, February 2019 · by Marina Morgan · page 11-17

February 2019

Dear BADth Directors,

Following my resignation a few weeks ago, I feel it may be important to share my concerns with the wider membership of BADth, so this is an open letter giving the background to my resignation.

Alyson Coleman’s recent resignation as our Chair is a great blow to BADth. Alyson was focussed on promoting our members’ standing in the wider world. This is exactly what a professional organisation such as ours is there to do. Alyson had appointed a suitably experienced consultant to look at the way our organisation operates and recommend how we might work more effectively.

Change is always difficult, and I, along with the majority of the executive, fully supported Alyson in her efforts. However, there has been bitter opposition from a small number of people who seem deeply resistant to doing things differently. Fundamental flaws in the structure of our organisation are making positive change almost impossible to instigate.

Before graduating as a Dramatherapist, my professional background was in communications and project management. Following my appointment as a director, with support from the BADth board at the time, I had taken on the role of improving our organisation’s communication by developing our website. My offer to the current board of continuing to manage the last few weeks of the project has not been accepted. At the time of writing the project remains entirely within budget. I’d like to extend a huge personal thanks to Alyson Coleman for her tenacity, integrity and vision. I should also make it clear that Alyson will be completely unaware that I have written this.

I look forward to a statement from BADth as to the future of the organisation. I hope that it will include news that a suitably qualified consultant with no personal connection and complete independence from the board and employees will be appointed to examine our organisation and make recommendations for its future conduct. I sincerely hope there will be a time again where members are truly at the heart of everything BADth does, and ego, bureaucracy and politics can take a back seat for once and for all.

Amy Edwards

February 2019

I was quite dismayed to read of the three resignations in December’s edition of The Prompt.

In the Chair’s letter of resignation, Alyson mentions that she was stepping down because she was “unwilling to continue in this role at this time following recent changes within the organisation”. This nebulous statement is without any clarification of the reason for her resignation. In the Vice-Chair’s letter, he states, “I was finding it increasingly difficult to contribute productively within what, to me, felt like a prevailing climate of diffidence and resistance. It also became clear that I would not be able to ignore the strain on my personal and other professional commitments that the Vice- Chair role demands if BADth’s best interests are to be served to the highest standards.” I find this explanation rather confusing. In order to be nominated for the position of Vice-Chair, one needs to have been on the Executive Committee, which would have made clear the commitment needed for the Vice-Chair position. As with Alyson’s resignation letter, I find Daniel’s letter just as nebulous.

Neither letters of resignation provide any concrete information as to the reason for their resignations. Both the Chair and Vice-Chair ran for their respective office with the full knowledge of the responsibilities involved. Since the beginning of BADth, I can think of only two instances of a Chair or Vice-Chair resigning before the end of their term. This action is unprecedented, extremely unprofessional and irresponsible. Leaving BADth without a Chair and Vice-Chair, both at the same time and forcing the Executive Committee to ask a former chair to temporarily step in, projects an image of BADth of being an amateur, rather than a professional organisation.

It has taken several years of hard work, time and commitment on the part of all the previous Chairs, Vice-Chairs and Executive Committee Members to develop and establish a professional reputation for the field of dramatherapy and for dramatherapists. I consider the resignations of Alyson and Daniel to be a disservice to both BADth and to its members. As for the third letter of resignation, it was sad to read of Steve Mitchell having to step down from being a retired member of the Executive Committee. It would have been the first time that a retired dramatherapist served on the Executive Committee, which I would have thought would be a valuable resource for the Executive Committee Members. I find it very short-sighted that Steve, as a non-voting, retired dramatherapist, due to other commitments, was obliged to resign, as he was unable to take on between meetings, assignments which were ‘tasked’ by the Chair. «

February 2019

Steve has been a long serving member of BADth. He has worked as a dramatherapist in the NHS for over 25 years, he created the Ritual Theatre model of dramatherapy, as course leader, he developed the dramatherapy course at Roehampton, and has been a contributor and editor of several articles and books on dramatherapy. I find it surprising that the Chair and Executive Committee members would not welcome onto the Executive Committee, a person with Steve’s wealth of knowledge and experience of dramatherapy – especially when it is not stated in BADth’s Articles of Memorandum that non-voting members are required to participate in outside work. For myself, as a former Chair, I would have valued the presence of someone with Steve’s history of dramatherapy and would never have required a retired dramatherapist to be responsible for assignments between meetings. In my view, Steve’s invaluable contribution would have been, not between meetings, but at meetings.

I have always believed that members are a reflection of their organization and that commitment is an important and necessary attribute for the success of any organisation. In the past, BADth has been fortunate to have had members who were willing to take on the commitments needed to make BADth both a valuable resource for its members, and to help BADth become recognised as a professional organization. I hope that this will prevail, so as to ensure the continued success of BADth. Stan Ratoff

February 2019

29th January 2019

Dear Exec,

I am writing in response to the recent resignations from the Exec and my concerns that so many members have resigned at the same time.

I am particularly shocked and saddened by Alyson’s resignation as I believe her input as Chair is invaluable and she has significantly improved the profile of BADth, both in the dramatherapy community and wider. I have noted a shift in the level of professionalism and clinical relevance of the conferences and colleagues have also expressed that they have observed this. These colleagues and trainees have not previously been members of the association but now feel that BADth is beginning to change and improve its status amongst the psychological professions and beyond and is therefore something that they now want to be a part of.

I know that Alyson brings with her a wealth of clinical experience as well as current research and educational expertise and with her commitment it has meant that I have seen BADth begin to level up with BAAT and BAMT as a body ready to advance our profession. I know that Alyson is very driven, grounded and self-reflective and therefore for her to be in a position to resign makes me concerned about what is happening amongst the Exec. I know that this would not have been a quick or easy decision for her to make. This raises some questions for me. What support, if any is in place for the Exec to reflect as a body? Is there group supervision, reflective practice or other opportunities to explore as professional therapists the organisational dynamics, and if not why not? As Dramatherapists working in any setting, if we came across a situation where there were more than 2 resignations of an Exec we would be asking these questions, and in particular be wondering about what was being acted out and not contained. In this current political climate this is even more relevant and I fear that in this situation there appears to be something unhealthy and damaging happening where there seems evidence of splitting and people leaving and remaining.

There needs to be greater transparency from the Exec about what has happened, as well as some reassurances around what might be happening to resolve the situation to enable Alyson to continue in post and ensuring that factors are being put in place to limit something like this happening again. Regards

Becky Hasnip

BADth member since 1999

February 2019

To the Editor of The Prompt

As the BADth supervision subcommittee we would like to inform BADth members that we have written to voice our concerns to the BADth Executive about recent events and resignations.

Rather than publish our communications here in full we feel it more appropriate to summarise them and we do so in the spirit of wanting to contribute towards some resolution to what we see as a very worrying situation. We also appreciate the current efforts in managing its complexity. We have really valued the excellent and exemplary service of the former Chair, Alyson Coleman and the recent and past Vice-Chairs, Daniel Stolfi and Laura Knight. We have called for further clarity and transparency so that the membership can be more fully informed about events leading up to the resignations. We have also asked if the former Chair and Vice-Chair might be asked to reconsider their resignations and if so, what would need to happen in order to enable them to do so.

From our particular perspective as a supervision subcommittee, we have appreciated the BADth Subcommittee days which have taken place over the past two years, organised by Alyson Coleman as Chair. A representative from each of the subcommittees had the opportunity to collaborate and share creative thinking together at these meetings. These were found to be invaluable, inspiring and creative and led to a sense of community and connection. We felt appreciated for the work that we voluntarily and willingly contribute to and for our Association.

Over the past 18 months as a subcommittee, we have also been updating supervision documentation, in readiness for what was an imminent redesign of the BADth website. As this has now been delayed, we have voiced our concerns to the BADth Executive that members are still accessing outdated information. One example includes, informing the membership of a recent decision to reduce the requirement of having a BADth membership to 1 year (as opposed to 3 years) in advance of applying to be on the supervisors’ register.

Finally, we have asked what support is being offered the former Chair and Vice-Chair who have resigned in these distressing times. We hope sharing our thoughts with the membership proves useful, highlighting some of the queries we have raised to aid transparency. BADth Supervision Subcommittee

Judie Taylor, Deb Haythorne, Alison Kelly and Jessie Ellinor

February 2019

Dear Madeline,

This is an open letter from the 14 members of the Creative Arts Supervision Training (CAST) 2018 cohort, in response to current circumstances within BADth. We request that this letter is shared with the Executive Committee and discussed at the upcoming executive meeting on February 2nd 2019. Please note that we have sent a copy of this email to Alyson Coleman and have also asked Jane Jackson to include this letter of support in the next edition of The Prompt. Given the recent spate of resignations amongst the Executive Committee, and in particular Alyson Coleman’s resignation as Chair of BADth, we are writing to express our concern regarding the lack of transparency around the reasons surrounding the departures and the limited information that has so far been made available to the membership. We request that an extraordinary general meeting is called, as soon as possible, where this information is made available. We suggest an open forum format, where the opportunity is given to those who have chosen to resign and the current board of executives have a structured space to voice what has happened, with a chance for the membership to respond and have input into how we move forward as both a community and a professional body. We felt compelled to write to you, as the first cohort of students that have been led through the Creative Arts Supervision Training diploma (CAST), since it has moved to the Royal Central School of Speech and Drama, by Alyson Coleman (RCSSD). We feel as a group, we are in a unique position to reflect on and share our experience of Alyson’s leadership qualities. She has led us with energy, vision, commitment and above all, immense integrity. We also wish to bring attention to the vast amount of work she has done for dramatherapy as a profession throughout her proactive tenure as Chair, including a creative and innovative film for the Allied Health Professions, securing SAGE as publishers for the BADth Journal, and delivering two dynamic and inspiring national conferences, the first of which included the presentation of findings for the significant research project completed by Dr Emma Ramsden and the ambitious Mass Observation Day study. These are only a few illustrative examples specific to dramatherapy, of which there are many more.

We also wish to highlight the work she has done towards a more cohesive and collaborative approach to working with the other arts therapies professions and her work to raise the visibility of all arts therapies professions. This in particular has been highlighted by the music therapists within the CAST cohort and reflects a wider feeling amongst our colleagues from other modalities. This has been demonstrated not only through her work with CAST, but also as the co-representative for BADth on the Arts Therapies Committee. Through this role, she has been instrumental in shaping the joint approach for the arts therapies, reflecting her commitment to advancing the arts therapies as an Allied Health Profession. She has approached issues facing arts therapists on both a strategic level and has also offered support on an individual level to arts therapists facing challenges, reflecting her commitment to dramatherapy and the wider arts therapies on a professional level and her integrity, commitment and compassion on a personal level.

February 2019

Those among us who are BADth members request that more information is also shared around the update and finalisation of the BADth website. As newly qualified supervisors, we wish to be added to the supervisors register, and having an updated website for our professional body is an important reflection of our professionalism.

As we set out as supervisors in our arts professions, we are all hoping to establish and model trusting, congruent, contained and informative relationships. In a climate of political dissonance and societal unease, we feel it is imperative that as a profession we find a way of working through challenges and difficulties by communicating clearly and with transparency around what has happened so that we can move forward, as a community that is supportive to all members. Finally, it is our strong and emphatic wish that Alyson Coleman be re-instated as Chair of BADth.

Yours sincerely

C.A.S.T. 2018

Sophie Spinoza

Music Therapist

Peter Darby-Knight

Dramatherapist

Melanie Beer

Dramatherapist

Noelle Adams

Dramatherapist

George Theodoropoulos

Dramatherapist

Nikki Disney

Dramatherapist

Kate Heath

Music Therapist

Larissa Sherman

Dramatherapist

Sharlotte Rayner

Dramatherapist

Lynn Cutts

Dramatherapist

Ellen Taylor

Dramatherapist

Nancy Lund

Dramatherapist

Heather Williams

Dramatherapist

Marina Morgan

Dramatherapist

More posts

edition Diary Dates

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 32-33 DIARY DATES 2023 January 2023 Closing date for the BADth Gordon Wiseman Trust Fund. Details in Members’ area.…

The Prompt – final

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 22-31 Dear Jane, As a long-standing supporter of the publication, I write this open letter to thank you for…

people-caused climate destruction A Farewell Scenario

The Prompt, December 2022 · by EXCLUSIVE TO ARTS THERAPISTS · page 17-21 A FAREWELL SCENARIO 1996–2022 Scenario Arts in Personal Development was founded in…
account android arrow-alt-circle-down arrow-alt-circle-left arrow-alt-circle-right arrow-alt-circle-up arrow-down arrow-left arrow-right arrow-up author bars behance blogger bluesky buffer caret-down caret-left caret-right caret-square-down caret-square-left caret-square-right caret-square-up caret-up cart-menu-1 cart-menu-2 cart-menu-3 cart-menu-4 categories chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right chevron-up clock close comments cookies copyright coupon-discount date-modified date-published discord double-arrows-down double-arrows-left double-arrows-right double-arrows-up dribbble envelope-open envelope eye facebook fax flickr foursquare github gmail google-drive grid-view hashtag hollow-ring homepage instagram ios level-down-alt level-up-alt line link linkedin list-view login logout long-arrow-alt-down long-arrow-alt-left long-arrow-alt-right long-arrow-alt-up mastodonmedium messenger mobile-menu mobile phone pinterest place qq quote-left quote-right quotes reading-time-hourglass reading-time-stopwatch reddit rss scroll-to-top search shazam shopping-bag shopping-cart side-panel-opening-2-left side-panel-opening-2-right side-panel-opening-left side-panel-opening-right skype slack small-arrow-down small-arrow-left small-arrow-right small-arrow-up sms snapchat soundcloud spinner spotify stackoverflow sync telegram threadstiktok times-circle tinder trello tripadvisor tumblr twitch twitter viber vimeo vine vkontakte website wechat whatsapp windows wishlist xing yelp youtube zoom