Dementia and SPECAL Outcomes that have Relevance to Clinical Dramatherapy

Dementia and SPECAL Outcomes that have Relevance to Clinical Dramatherapy

The Prompt, February 2018 · page 34-48

February 2018

‘But what’s so interesting in that is one sees that the brain cannot jump out of its own skull and that in the end every single form of observation and theory that is structured by the brain carries the limitation of the brain, for obviously there is something beyond which this instrument cannot become aware of by using the tools of this instrument.’ Brook (1996, p. 315).

‘The poetic and the veridical, the proven and the unprovable, the heart and the brain – like charged particles of opposing polarity – exert their pulls in different directions. Where they are brought together the result is incandescence.’

Lewis, Amini, Lannon (2001, p. 15). ‘I have never believed in a single truth… But I have discovered that one can only live by a passionate, and absolute, identification with a point of view… For a point of view to be of any use at all, one must commit oneself totally to it, one must defend it to the very death. Yet at the same time, there is an inner voice that murmurs: “Don’t take it too seriously. Hold on tightly, let go lightly.”’

Brook (1987 p. XII).

Extract

I have conducted a thirty-year ‘artistic inquiry’ with Pathfinder Studio into theatre making, for purposes of self-cultivation with the general public. I explore how some of the findings have resulted in outcomes specifically relevant to facilitating dramatherapy, where the form of dramatherapy embraces what Jennings calls ‘The Integrative Model’ (1990, p. 39). Here personal issues and work employing metaphor and dramatic fiction are amalgamated and both seen as important parts of dramatherapy practice. This research through Pathfinder projects was tested in my work as a dramatherapist and adapted to working with clients in adult psychiatry. PATHFINDER STUDIO’S

ACTION RESEARCH (1981–2013)

Outcomes that have Relevance

to Clinical Dramatherapy

Talk based on this essay given at the British Association Conference 2017

February 2018

Introduction

In Pathfinder projects (Mitchell 2012, p. 153) there were participants, members of the general public, who signed up for a project, wanting to enter into a process of self-development and who tended to be psychologically robust. In contrast, as a dramatherapist working in the National Health Service, the clients had been diagnosed with varying levels of psychopathology and included outpatients and inpatients. Pathfinder Studio began in 1981 following my work as a theatre director in the London fringe running the ‘The Off-fringe Theatre’. This led through an investigation of Stanislavsky’s dictum of ‘work on the self’ (Stanislavsky 1980) with professional actors, to a wish to explore the creative process with members of the general public under the umbrella of Pathfinder Studio and to also training as a dramatherapist. Pathfinder’s form of inquiry was action research, rather than academic inquiry, although there was theoretical study; prior to experiential learning I call this an ‘Artistic Inquiry’ (see Appendix). This all began with attending seven workshops/events led by different members of Grotowski’s Laboratory Theatre. First practically experiencing their ‘para-theatrical’ workshops, including an interview with Ryszard Cieslak and attending a ‘Meeting with Grotowski’, and mounting our own projects based on this work on the edges of Dartmoor or in Exeter in Devon (1981–1985). This led to an investigation of Anna Halprin’s work creating public rituals with the general public, including participating in a ten-day residential workshop with her in Switzerland, ‘Circle the Earth’ and a face-to-face interview in America. This research coincided with Pathfinder’s move from Devon to Lancashire, where we set up a number of workshops combining what had been learnt and continuing our studies into Halprin’s ‘art/life’ processes and ‘collective creation’ (1985– 1989). Halprin’s adaptations of ritual led to a survey of her sources, the native North American shamans, their rites of passage, and how the Human Potential Movement re-worked them, for example the Vision Quest, a week-long adventure in the wilderness on Skye in Scotland. This culminated in the study of Gabrielle Roth’s modern ‘Urban Shamanism’ (1988– 1992). Finally the Pathfinder Theatre Projects were influenced by the work of Paul Rebillot who combined in his ‘Theatre of Healing’ workshops, his synthesis of American experiential therapies alongside ritual practice from the native Indian traditions, with group process, myth and Gestalt (1987–2013). I am going to highlight the most significant factors from this investigation through Pathfinder Studio that have informed my dramatherapy practice. Each item could be critically examined in its own right. However, that is beyond the framework of this essay so each point is only noted in a concise manner. (For further details elaborating these ideas follow the references I indicate).

Safety

Pathfinder’s research highlighted the fundamental importance of making people feel safe. Whether physically, emotionally, mentally, interpersonally, or with the dramatherapy tools employed. This underpins the work when planning a session, delivering a task, or the moment to moment interventions when facilitating a solo structure. In my preparation to be dramatherapist and group leader of Pathfinder projects, two books by Irvin D. Yalom were seminal. In the first, The Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy, he points out a number of significant healing factors and the importance of what he calls ‘group maintenance’ (1970, p. 113). This means that the group leader is ever watchful to culture building and creating an ethos that nurtures the work towards the aims of the group. In the second, Love’s Executioner, Yalom advocates, amongst other gems, that in his view the core of the healing process is the therapeutic relationship, ‘It’s the relationship that heals…my professional rosary’ (1989, p. 91).

From Pathfinder’s research I dare to disagree with this mentor, that the ‘therapeutic relationship’ is the factor that ‘heals’. I do agree that the therapeutic relationship is significant but only as a foundation. I consider that there is something underneath this that generates the possibility of a constructive alliance being built between client and dramatherapist and for me this is the concept of safety. When a client feels safe they can begin to venture forth and risk stepping into the unknown. I believe that it is in this marginal place that psychological change and healing can be located. Often clients do not feel psychologically safe and everything that follows is designed to ease that fear and make both the internal and outer world of the group a safer and safer place to be. When a client feels safe they can

begin to venture forth and risk

stepping into the unknown.

February 2018

Therapeutic Presence

To make things feel safe begins with how the clients experience the disposition of the dramatherapist as a person. This also underscores how the dramatherapist is experienced by professionals, who refer their clients for dramatherapy treatment. This finding from Pathfinder’s work, the need to reach for the qualities of ‘therapeutic presence’, became a core aim when teaching dramatherapy students how to facilitate at Roehampton. It requires going beyond the usual competences in drama, theatre, therapeutic skills, psychological understanding, supervision, and personal therapy, and reaching towards therapeutic presence. This state evolves from a triad of principal pathways: first, having the dexterity with particular techniques and methods of dramatherapy, but not a total reliance upon technical structures; second, a knowledge base that gives a theoretical understanding to the actions, choices and judgements made as a dramatherapist, but not an over dependence on cognitive or analytic conceptual frameworks that can over-distance the dramatherapist from the client; third, and most important, the experience of having trodden the therapeutic journey, travelled through the dramatherapist’s own dark night of the soul in their personal therapy (I would add, perhaps contentiously, within the modality you intend to practise i.e., dramatherapy).

When these three elements are balanced within a dramatherapist, then there can be therapeutic presence which holds, contains with humility, and also inspires the client to take the necessary risks they need towards meeting their goals. It will also reassure referring colleagues that their clients are safe in your hands. Model of Healing

The psychotherapist Petruska Clarkson introduced the concept of the therapist requiring their own internalized map of the therapeutic process. This means that as a therapist you must define your therapeutic orientation and ask yourself the question, how do you think people heal? The answer, Clarkson argued, will dictate how you work as a therapist. There are many theories, and everyone makes choices, resonating with certain ideas and feeling more distant about others. This is a natural process, but in facilitating an individual, group or workshop, to achieve the safety requirements in a session, in my opinion, necessitates the dramatherapist being clear about their philosophical and psychological understanding of human change. My position is humanistic but as I have written recently (Mitchell 2013/14, 2016, 2016a), from witnessing the process of change in both my theatre projects and dramatherapy work, I find current theories do not fully explain the subtle transformations that I see taking place within the psyche that mediate change. This has led me also to embrace Maclean’s neurological ‘Triune’ model (1990) that identifies three different brains: the reptilian complex, paleomammalian complex (limbic) and the neomammalian complex (neocortical) as part of my model of healing. Each brain has a different function but unfortunately they operate in an individualistic manner and do not always communicate well with each other “The trio intermingles and communicates, but some information … lost in translation … the sub-units differ in their functions, properties, and even their chemistries” (Lewis, Amini, Lannon 2001, p. 21). The reptilian, the oldest, controls the vital functions; the limbic controls emotions, memory and social centre of the brain; the neocortical is concerned with abstraction, imagination and consciousness. The dramatherapist, to effect change, needs to have an impact on the limbic as well as the neocortical brain. To make things

feel safe begins

with how

the clients

experience

the disposition

of the

dramatherapist

as a person.

February 2018

The Gears of Physis

This concept is a working hypothesis that evolved from witnessing psychological change over many years in both Pathfinder and dramatherapy work. It describes a dynamic process employing the ancient theories of numinosity, physis, and poiesis as well as the scientific concept of a vortex (see table).

Gear

Numinosity

Vortex

Physis

Poiesis

Action

Force

Void

Renaissance

Reconfiguration

Function

Dismemberment

Cessation

Restoration

Integration

Outcome

Fluidity

Uncertainty

Renewal

Consolidation

These become redefined agents that may alter neurological structures when stimulated, from what had previously been internalised during childhood and may be in conflict with what has been genetically given (defined as ‘first nature’). Hillman (1997, p. 9) argues that we are born with a psychological ‘Damien’ and if in life, we follow this inherited first nature, life unfolds harmoniously. However, if circumstances alter this innate path, we can become conflicted by what Campbell terms ‘thou shalts’ (1989, p. 154), learnt injunctions that can control our life. The Damien is then banished to the unconscious, but it is not inert and could give rise to damaging mental health problems. What I call ‘The Gears of Physis’ describes an intricate structured process of dramatherapy or ritual theatre, like the various gear shifts in a car, where a person engaging in such intentional work on the self can biologically and psychologically transform previously learnt childhood imposed messages, and in so doing return confidently to their inherited first nature. (For further details of how this functions, particularly in dramatherapy, see Mitchell 2013/14, 2016a, 2016b, 2016c.)

Coherence

Pathfinder’s research into the art of structuring sessions revealed a significant factor concerning the need for coherence of tasks. This is what Stanislavsky called a ‘through-line’ in theatre which leads seamlessly towards the ‘super objective’ or goal in each aspect of the process, including philosophy of healing and physical tools (movement, voice, sensory work, building a character, improvisation and enactment). These are all consistent and evolve logically from one exercise to another. In so doing the unfolding of dramatherapy demonstrates lucidity with what Aristotle called a ‘unity of action’ in aesthetics, where inconsistency does not generate confusion or a sense of not knowing what to expect. If the ongoing work is constant with what has preceded it and relates to what has been introduced before, the group member will feel secure in what they are doing; it will have meaning and the tasks will be relevant to their quest for healing and change. A dramatherapist who facilitates an everchanging programme of different events may believe that they are nurturing a creative ethos, but in my experience this can create in clients’ insecurity rather than security. The process

February 2018

of dramatherapy is not easy. It involves delicate and sensitive issues from a client’s biography. Therefore what in dramatherapy is called the therapist’s task of ‘holding’ a client is not only the presence of the therapist but how they reveal the process of healing to their clients. Coherence, I believe, is a vital factor in achieving this aim and keeping the client on track.

Jo-Ha-Kye

But how can the dramatherapist bring about this coherence? Pathfinder’s research into the director Peter Brook’s approach to theatre production discovered that his ‘golden rule of theatre’ was founded on the Noh master Zeami’s concept of ‘Jo-Ha-Kye’ (Heilpern 1977, p. 128, Mitchell 1990, p. 15, Oida and Marshall 1997, p. 30, Zeami 1984, p. 20 and 2006, p. 85). I believe that this formula Brook employs in theatre is also the technical key to the art of structuring dramatherapy and creating the necessary coherence. It involves clarity of tasks, effortlessly evolving from one level of participation to another, what Rebillot named as ‘graduated challenges’ (Rebillot 1993). The concept of Jo-Ha-Kye also offers a key framework to the overall pacing of a group as well as the rhythm of moment to moment exercises and interactions (Mitchell 1990). The concept can be summarized in the following manner: Jo:

Introduction, beginning, establishing, in a slow rhythm. Ha:

Exposition, development, exploring complexity, in varying rhythms. Kye:

Denouement, climax, in a quick rhythm. I believe that when a dramatherapist employs this formula, structuring the work and skilfully timing their interventions when facilitating group or solo work, their clients experience a sensitive crafting of dramatherapy interventions that carry their work in the group seamlessly forward.

Organic Improvisation

Pathfinder’s early investigation into Grotowski’s para-theatre uncovered their notion of ‘organic improvisation’, which became a key factor in facilitating a ritual theatre form of dramatherapy (Mitchell 1992, p. 54). This is a form of open improvisation where the sensory perception in the actual moment is the stimulus for interactional responses, rather than playing a role with prescribed actions or external subject. In an organic improvisation the dynamic action evolves through an ongoing cascade of immediate responses to a present moment stimulus. This could be the life energy of a specific person, group or inspiration in nature, expressed through physical actions within a particular designated framework – thus the term ‘para-theatre’ – beyond theatre but related to it, as it is not a free for all, but similar to the discipline of structured spontaneous rituals. This concept in dramatherapy entails the facilitator responding to the ‘here and now’ dynamics of each and every moment in a nurturing way. This is achieved by following the energy, serving it, and being guided by it within the whole group, by observing the presence of the group and responding to it with appropriate culture building or maintenance structures. In solo ‘transitional events’ or ‘ceremonies of empowerment’, it is being mindful of perceptions of a client’s variable energy and offering them what Rebillot called ‘choice points’ rather than directing or imposing the dramatherapist’s formulation of what a client needs to process during a solo piece of work. Pathfinder’s

early

investigation

into

Grotowski’s

para-theatre

uncovered

their notion of

‘organic

improvisation’,

which

became a key

factor in

facilitating a

ritual theatre

form of

dramatherapy

February 2018

The Monomyth

Pathfinder’s inquiry into Rebillot’s ‘Theatre of Healing’ workshops (Mitchell 2012b, p. 129) found the significance of his reliance on Campbell’s conception of the Monomyth. I believe that this is equally important in a ritual theatre form of dramatherapy. Working with this over-arching theoretical blueprint, enables a client to fully understand the process of psychological change in this form of dramatherapy. I have found it makes sense to the clients not only on the level of how dramatherapy operates but also brings meaning and hope. It also represents a different perspective

based

on

anthropological,

mythological as well as psychological thinking, which is unique to dramatherapy rather than adapting the ideological traditions of psychotherapy. In so doing it met the aspiration of my quest to find a viewpoint that theoretically is unique to dramatherapy and not an adaptation of psychological theory associated with other disciplines of therapy.

What is the ‘Monomyth’? Joseph Campbell coined this term in his book, The Hero with a Thousand Faces (1949) taken from James Joyce’s Finnegan’s Wake:

‘The mythological hero, setting forth from his common day hut or castle, is lured, carried away, or else voluntarily proceeds, to the threshold of adventure. There he encounters a shadow presence that guards the passage. The hero may defeat or conciliate this power and go alive into the kingdom of the dark (brother-battle, dragonbattle; offering, charm), or be slain by the opponent and descend in death (dismemberment, crucifixion). Beyond the threshold, then, the hero journeys through a world of unfamiliar yet strangely intimate forces, some of which severely threaten him (tests), some of which give magical aid (helpers). When he arrives at the nadir of the mythological round, he undergoes a supreme ordeal and gains his reward. The triumph may be represented as the hero’s sexual union with the goddess-mother of the world (sacred marriage), his recognition by the father-creator (father atonement), his own divinization (apotheosis), or again – if the powers have remained unfriendly to him – his theft of the boon he came to gain (bride-theft, fire-theft); intrinsically it is an expansion of consciousness and therewith of being (illumination, transfiguration, freedom).’ Campbell (1949, p. 245).

In short-term dramatherapy a way of introducing the Monomyth is to employ a visualization that tells its story. This is followed by the group then collectively creating these figures, using masks, costumes and partners to animate a piece of ritual theatre depicting the essential narrative of the Monomyth (Mitchell 2016). For short-term individual dramatherapy, see Mitchell (2016b), that details how to incorporate working one-to-one with the archetypal figures in the Monomyth (wanderer, recluse, seeker, saboteur, orphan, warrior, threshold monster, hero, destroyer, and magician) when working in adult psychiatry with outpatients.

Warm-ups

In Pathfinder projects and dramatherapy practice an emphasis was given to building an ensemble through employing theatre exercises in a careful way alongside other activities that reflected on these tasks and sharing both personal and interpersonal process. These exercises included moving beyond role play to employing establishing a character through traditional theatre methods. These were facilitated in conjunction with an active visualization that incorporated eastern ideas concerning persona, ‘needs and drives’. The building of the ensemble, through exercises rather than game playing, as I consider the latter could be experienced as patronising, helped towards generating safe relationships and group cohesion. Additionally, in dramatherapy groups, and importantly in the over-all group agreements, along with confidentiality, punctuality and a no violence rule (and others), I included George Kelly’s notion of creating safe support systems before disclosing any personal issues from outside the group. Instead, the initial focus of sharing is the group’s joint experience of how the tools of the group impact upon them rather than disclosing external personal issues that might have brought them into therapy (Kelly 1955 Vol. 2. p. 116). This helped the groups develop a shared culture concerning the challenges of the structured tasks, building the necessary psychological identifications of similarities and differences between group members.

February 2018

Collective Creation

Pathfinder’s exploration of Anna Halprin’s work with the San Francisco Dancer’s Workshop, and with the Tamalpa Institute, demonstrated the importance of a group working collectively prior to having solo time to pursue individual concerns. The purpose of this ‘collective creation’ is twofold and builds on what Halprin called ‘resources’: first the practical skills in movement, voice, character, improvisation and dramatic expression, and second through this work further gain supportive relationships that then make it safer to focus on personal material in solo work that a client wants to transform. In a dramatherapy group where the ‘super objective’ of the work is to offer clients later individual space, prior to doing this I have followed Halprin’s guidance and always work collectively before individually. In long term groups I ask the participants to dramatize a story they all know and in short-term groups this collective task can be constructively achieved through dramatizing Campbell’s ‘Monomyth’ (Mitchell 2016). Transitional Events

This structure takes place after the collective work in the group and involves each client (as ‘animateur’) creating their own solo ritual. I call this rite of passage a ‘transitional event’. I use this term in psychiatry rather than the word ‘ritual’ as this can be an emotive word, a concept that has a number of different meanings for clients, colleagues and managers. In the overall structure of the group and theme of the Monomyth, the transitional event represents what Rebillot in his workshop ‘The Hero’s Journey’ and Campbell called the ‘Supreme Ordeal’ (Rebillot 1993, p. 159). Rebillot’s work was based on Campbell’s notion of rite; it is a process of initiation that has a secular aim rather than a meeting with the divine. In Pathfinder projects I adapted Rebillot’s format, combining it with Cieslak’s more open para-theatrical ‘experiences’ (Mitchell 1992, p. 56). In a clinical mode, for health and safety reasons, this has a more formal framework that is facilitated by the dramatherapist, who in collaboration with the animateur structures the Event (Mitchell 2016a, 2016b, 2017). It offers a psychological and physically safe template but also enables the client to truly make the choice of what is explored and how they want to go about that exploration. Ceremony of Empowerment

The Ceremony of Empowerment enables the final phase of ‘The Gears of Physis’ to occur and takes place after a transitional event as a separate structure. Its purpose is to anchor fledgling changes through rational and affective cognitive definition. This process consolidates a renewal of previously repressed or suppressed inherited character traits. The fundamental difference between a transitional event and the Ceremony of Empowerment is that the former operates at principally a limbic level whereas the latter aims towards the neocortical bringing about a holistic change. A ceremony is designed to employ Jungian archetypal reinforcement to tap into the ‘collective consciousness’ and help ‘seal’ what has been uncovered through the action of poiesis. This mechanism enables the neocortical component of the brain to create new pathways biologically, chemically and energetically. In this manner the restoration of the essential self is grounded and stabilised, the action strengthens first nature, emboldens the animateur in maintaining their unique authentic selfhood.

February 2018

In the tribal rituals that marked life thresholds these were followed by ‘Ceremonies of Initiation’. Once the candidate(s) returned from their initial rite of passage they were separated from their community as part of the process of re-entry. In seclusion they underwent a number of activities as part of their initiation to prepare them for their new status. These pursuits might involve a number of ceremonial tasks that were either educative (a form of role rehearsal), or psychological enhancement to prepare them for their tribes conventions and beliefs. For example, initiation rites might focus on teaching the ethos of the communities’ spiritual tradition, practical skills associated with their new position: such as those of a hunter gatherer or warrior. The

Ceremony

of

Empowerment

in

dramatherapy can take two different forms. One employs the use of archetypal psychology the other is based on a para-theatrical composition (Mitchell 2017).

Threshold Time

In experiential work and in dramatherapy there can be a conundrum between two significant areas of work: structure and process. In a Pathfinder project we found it essential to give equal time to both. But how does this transfer to dramatherapy? To ease this dilemma I have developed the concept of ‘threshold time’ to enable a dramatherapist

to

incorporate

into

session these unplanned and impromptu ways of containing the work (Mitchell 2016).

Kelly (1955) has stated that a client undergoing change is likely to ‘loosen’ previously fixed constructs and at this time experience different levels of anxiety as their previous world view, that was impervious, is now thrown into question. This can have an upsetting impact on the otherwise secure psyche: stability is replaced with doubt, certainty with insecurity and heightened sensitivity to both primary and secondary psychic material. A client can enter a group session in a state that I associate with what Klein termed ‘a point of urgency’ full of affect and distressed (Klein 1932, pp. 58–59).

How does the dramatherapist respond to this when they have planned a thematic development for the whole group? This is a question that concerned me for many years.

My answer to this conundrum evolved from working for thirteen years with an inspiring colleague co-facilitating a group we called the ‘Experiential Group’. My co-facilitator, Maria Cornell, was a consultant psychologist, behaviourally trained, as well as a UKCP psychotherapist and we had both trained with Paul Rebillot. The group represented our synthesis of his work. However, we were opposites in technical accomplishment; Maria excelled at process whereas my strength lay with structure. However, over the years I came to acknowledge that it was vital to blend these components into an amalgamation rather than two separate entities.

This also resonated with my impressions of how Ryszard Cieslak had conducted the para-theatrical workshop I had attended (Mitchell 1992, p. 51), employing the technique of ‘invitations and propositions’ as a means of evolving work. It also seemed vital to me that a client had the space in their therapy to bring points of urgency to their group and these issues would be appropriately processed and contained in threshold time (Mitchell 2016).

Group Process

In a dramatherapy group or in a Pathfinder workshop there are two parallel processes taking place; the clients have their individual process and there is the group process. The dramatherapist needs to address both of these important factors of group life. The dramatherapist may enter a session with a plan, setting out how the progress of the thematic work will evolve, but this may need to be moderated by the life energies of the individuals in the group, giving rise to a group culture, which may also need to be addressed. How the dramatherapist …stability

is replaced

with doubt,

certainty

with

insecurity

and

heightened

sensitivity

to both

primary

and

secondary

psychic

material.

February 2018

approaches group dynamics will depend upon their orientation, experience and preferences, as well as the time available. I employ Rebillot’s model (Mitchell 2012b, p. 138) where the group express to each other feelings of either resentment or appreciation. By following this procedure it is safe and clears negative affect as well as celebrating the expression of positive feelings. Yet if time does not allow it may be necessary to find a collective experiential way to ventilate negative affect. Utilizing a group activity that will acknowledge privately any ‘here and now’ feelings, offers certain ventilation which will move them towards a transformed state. Facilitation

The Pathfinder Theatre Projects began by exploring the art of being a facilitator as indicated by Paul Rebillot and documented in Mitchell (2012a). In many ways what has been described in this essay is a development of this, a synthesis of running Pathfinder workshops and practising as a full-time clinical dramatherapist for nearly twenty-eight years. What has been found employing this form of dramatherapy is that a dramatherapist is a ‘facilitator’ crafting structure, process, people and time. It is important that the disposition of a dramatherapist while facilitating dramatherapy includes expecting the unexpected, at all times, never dropping their vigilance or ability to hold the group. From the overture (preparation) to the opening phase of the session or group, to navigating its various stages and closure, as well as immediately after, the dramatherapist needs to inhabit a readiness to respond appropriately to any surprises that may occur. This means the dramatherapist not only has to be technically prepared with their plan, but ready also to let it go, to use their experience in an impromptu manner and sometimes offer an activity in response to spontaneous group energy. Rebillot in his training workshops suggested that the facilitator needed to prepare a strategy of three different plans for every session as a resource to be ready to make adaptations depending upon the individual and group process. Further, the dramatherapist needs to be personally prepared through their own therapy for any transaction with a client whether that is related to a parallel process within their psyche or an interpersonal challenge of their competence as a facilitator of dramatherapy.

Boundaries

In the world of therapy a therapist is required to follow certain codes of practice that depending upon orientation are unquestionable givens. In the theatre there are no such rules, even though similar power issues and vulnerabilities can be present. Pathfinder, in offering projects that included explicit personal work alongside theatre-making, wanted to research this important feature. Unfortunately the inquiry is incomplete and only tentative statements can be made. For example, those who participated in the projects coming from a therapy background found safety in clear boundaries whereas those from a theatre background found them debatable and sometimes felt they limited their creativity. Quite early in the work we made a rule that physical intimate behaviour (sexual) was out of bounds, unless participants were in an existing relationship prior to the start of a project. The main reason for this was that when this had previously occurred, between two participants, it highlighted that there was not enough time in the duration of a project to process constructively the diverse and individual responses, and its impact on the group as well as on the artistic strand of the project.

February 2018

However, the problem with such a clause, as with the other rules, is that it can create an over authoritarian ethos that can work in the opposite direction to personal growth. Participants can feel their autonomy is restricted and that the organisation or leader is infantilising them, making them dependant rather than independent, self-responsible adults. At the same time there is a need for firm parameters to be in place to hold the varieties of both psychological and artistic development.

The other significant concern in terms of boundaries was experienced during certain social times during the residential periods. Occasionally the ensemble went out to eat together in a demarked recreational period as part of the work during a week-long residential. This sometimes could oil confusion concerning roles, particularly between a participant and the group leader. However, if an issue emerged it was always later processed in a ‘group clearing’ and there were not many such incidents.

The conclusions of the last ensemble were divided, the group leader leaning towards usual therapeutic compliance of observing boundaries whereas members of the group, particularly those who had been impacted by an issue, welcomed the opportunity to use these incidents as a catalyst to developing their own personal process. A tentative solution could be the importance that such incidents have time to be processed in the group.

In all other areas of the project there were few boundary issues and part of the possible reason for this was that the group process sessions and business meetings enabled any difficulties to be ventilated and honestly explored in an open and constructive manner. Conclusion

In this essay I have highlighted seventeen different but interlocking points. I believe that these transfer from the action research with Pathfinder Studio’s task of self-cultivation through theatre-making with the general public into illuminating the significance of certain procedures when facilitating dramatherapy working with an integrative model of dramatherapy. The points outlined here have been tested in clinical practice in adult psychiatry over the past two decades, offering clients a dramatherapy process that meets their immediate needs to be heard, ventilate feelings, experiment, contain, reflect, heal and change. However, perhaps most important of all, it helps me as a dramatherapist. These points act as my internalized map, a foundation which gives direction to the planning, as well as facilitating a dramatherapy session. In this way it supports me as the dramatherapist to be perceptually present to the moment by moment spontaneous phenomena that arise. This may necessitate changes to what had been planned and responding with an appropriate, unplanned intervention in either individual dramatherapy or in a dramatherapy group. Steve Mitchell

These points act as my internalized map, a foundation which gives direction to the planning, as well as facilitating a dramatherapy session. In this way it supports me as the dramatherapist to be perceptually present to the moment by moment spontaneous phenomena that arise.

February 2018

Bibliography

Brook, P. 1987. The Shifting Point: forty years of theatrical exploration (1946–1987). London: Methuen.

Brook, P., Miller, J., Sacks, O. 1996. In Contact with the Gods. Ed. Delgado & Heritage. Manchester University Press.

Campbell, J. 1949. The Hero with a Thousand Faces. London: Paladin Grafton Books. Campbell, J. 1989. The Power of Myth. Canada: Doubleday. Hills, C. 1968. Nuclear Evolution. London: Centre Community Publications. Hillman, J. 1997. The Soul’s Code: on Character and Calling. New York: Random House. Heilpern, J. 1977. Conference of the Birds: the story of Peter Brook in Africa. London: Faber and Faber.

Jennings, S. 1990a. Dramatherapy with Families, Groups and Individuals: Waiting in the Wings. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers. Kelly, G. 1955. The Psychology of Personal Constructs. Vol 2. Norton: New York. Klein, M. 1932. The Psychoanalysis of Children. London: Hogarth. Lewis, T., Amini, F., Lannon, R. 2001. A General Theory of Love. New York: Vintage Books. MacLean, P.D. 1990. The triune brain in evolution: role in paleocerebral functions. New York: Plenum Press.

Mitchell, S. 2017. Unpublished Monograph on ‘The Transitional Event & Ceremony of Empowerment’ (available by email).

Mitchell, S. 2016. ‘Ritual Theatre in Short-term Group Dramatherapy.’ The Routledge International Handbook of Dramatherapy. S. Jennings, C. Holmwood, ed. London: Routledge.

Mitchell, S. 2016a Gears of Physis: Sarah’s Tale: Manuscript of talk given at the British Association of Dramatherapy Conference 2016. The Prompt, dramatherapy newsletter. Mitchell, S. 2016b. ‘Short-term Individual Dramatherapy Employing the Theatre of Self Expression Working with Different Unconscious Archetypes and Conscious Aspects of the Psyche’. The Prompt, dramatherapy newsletter. Mitchell, S. 2016c. The Gears of Physis. Paper given at Annual Conference of The British Association of Dramatherapists, Cirencester. Mitchell, S. 2013/2014. ‘What if our Knowledge of Healing is a Myth and other Forces are at Work?’ The Prompt, dramatherapy newsletter. Mitchell, S, 2012a. ‘The Theatre of Self Expression: a Brief Introduction to the Theory and Practice of this Ritual Theatre Form in Clinical Dramatherapy.’ In Ritual Theatre: the Power of Dramatic Personal Development Groups and Clinical Practice. Ed. C. Schrader. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers. Mitchell, S. 2012b. ‘Paul Rebillot’s Modern Day Rites of Passage.’ Ritual Theatre: the Power of Dramatic Ritual in Personal Development Groups and Clinical Practice. Ed. C. Schrader, London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers. Mitchell, S. 2012c ‘Pathfinder Studio’s Quest for Self-cultivation through the “Rituals” of Theatre Making.’ In Ritual Theatre: the Power of Dramatic Personal Development Groups and Clinical Practice. Ed. C. Schrader. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.

February 2018

Mitchell, S. 1992 ‘Therapeutic Theatre: a Para-theatrical Model of Dramatherapy.’ In Dramatherapy Theory and Practice 2. S. Jennings, ed. London: Routledge. Mitchell, S. 1990. ‘The Theatre of Peter Brook as a Model of Dramatherapy’ The Journal for The British Association for Dramatherapists (Vol. 13, No. 1 Winter). Oida, Y. and Marshall, L. 1997. The Invisible Actor. London: Methuen. Rebillot, P. and Kay. M, 1993. The Call to Adventure: Bringing the Hero’s Journey to Life. San Francisco: Harper Collins.

Roth, G. 1989. Maps to Ecstasy: teachings of an urban shaman. San Rafael: New World Library.

Stanislavsky, K. 1980. An Actor Prepares. Trans. Elizabeth Reynolds Hapgood. London: Methuen (first published in Britain 1937). Wilson, C. 1957. Religion And The Rebel. London: Victor Gollancz Ltd. Yalom, I. 1970. The Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy. Third Edition. New York: Basic Books.

Yalom, I. 1989. Love’s Executioner. New York: Basic Books. Zeami, M. 1984. On the Art of No Drama: the Major Treatises of Zeami. Trans. Thomas Rimer and Yamazakaza Masakazu. Princeton N.J.: Princeton University Press. Zeami, M. 2006. The Flowering Spirit. Trans. W. Wilson. London: Kodansha

International.

I wish to acknowledge the assistance of two Pathfinder Associates in the composition of this essay: first Sue Mitchell who initially proofed my dyslexic script and second Diana Driver who edited the text for the dramatherapy conference. My grateful thanks to you both. However, as the author any error in contents or presentation is my responsibility.

February 2018

Appendix

Notes on ‘Artistic Inquiry’

What is an artistic inquiry?

It is a particular and dedicated form of search. It is parallel and as profound as both spiritual and academic inquiry, but different. Its means is the language or tools of craft as its primary manner of investigation. The product of an artistic inquiry is propagated through different mediums often depending upon an artist’s profession. It employs the arts to reveal a quest for revealing what is hidden in the enigmas of the natural world.

Artistic Inquiry is not accountable to human edifices, traditions and the fashions of particular times but to the ongoing progress of nature through the eons of time. Throughout the ages artists have engaged with the precepts of this form of discovery manifesting in their artifices their exploration of the human condition and revealing secrets of the cosmos.

This process differs from artistic work that has the primary purpose to entertain but concerns the work of different fields that strive to realise in an art form the verities and wonders of the world.

Artistic Inquiry has six stages:

O In its first stage it emerges into consciousness similar to Brook’s ‘formless hunch’ (1988, p. 3) which generates a vision. O In its second stage it can involve extensive preparatory study of the subject to give cognitive definition to the forthcoming creative task. O In the third stage its principal tool is ‘doing’ experimenting through applying craft. O The fourth stage is appraisal of work done, rigorously reflecting upon whether it meets its aspirations within a three dimensional concrete form. O The fifth stage can lead to a conscious re-shaping of the initial creation to meet the parameters of the motivating ‘formless hunch’. O The sixth stage is a phase of completion or a ‘work-in-progress’ and is disseminated as such.

Often an artistic inquiry involves exploring material outside the conventions of the known. It operates on the edges, outside the mainstream of convention. It is for this reason that society can at times be cautious of its products as these often examine or provoke challenge to the belief systems within the status quo. Bernard Shaw defined such individuals as ‘Artist Philosophers’. Peter Brook stated that in theatre it involved ‘a living human, search for meaning’. Jerzy Grotowski spoke of Holiday: a search for what was most essential in life, when speaking about its manifestation in para-theatre.

February 2018

February 2018

Organisation: Know Limits Ltd

Facilitator: Mandy Gutsell

• Dramatherapist • Degree in Child and Adolescent Psychiatry • • Certified Life Coach and Parent Coach for Teens • Certifed Organisational Relationship Systems Coach • • Completed Diploma in Creative Supervision • Offers Individual and Group Therapy – Individual and Group Supervision Where is it? Newhampton Arts Centre, Fircroft College, 1018 Bristol Road, Birmingham B29 6LH To download map go to: www.newhamptonarts.co.uk Why Mandy Gutsell?

I have been working as a dramatherapist, mental health nurse, lecturer, trainer and coach for the last 28 years. I teach on Mental Health Courses, work with Organisations to support their staff and run leadership courses on ‘How to be your true authentic brilliant self’. I run Dramatherapy and Coaching workshops and ‘Time Out’, for people to explore ‘Who they really want to be’. My philosophy and way of working is eclectic drawing on Carl Rogers, Elisabeth Kubler-Ross, Personality Enneagram profiling, Multi modal stress approach and coaching knowing that my clients have the answer already. Sometimes we just need a guide to help light the way for us. Includes all resources and materials provided. Free initial consultation and tutorials. Payment and subsidiary options possible. For more details contact:

www.knowlimitscoach.com contact form Tel: +44 (0)7951 229941

More posts

edition Diary Dates

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 32-33 DIARY DATES 2023 January 2023 Closing date for the BADth Gordon Wiseman Trust Fund. Details in Members’ area.…

The Prompt – final

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 22-31 Dear Jane, As a long-standing supporter of the publication, I write this open letter to thank you for…

people-caused climate destruction A Farewell Scenario

The Prompt, December 2022 · by EXCLUSIVE TO ARTS THERAPISTS · page 17-21 A FAREWELL SCENARIO 1996–2022 Scenario Arts in Personal Development was founded in…
account android arrow-alt-circle-down arrow-alt-circle-left arrow-alt-circle-right arrow-alt-circle-up arrow-down arrow-left arrow-right arrow-up author bars behance blogger bluesky buffer caret-down caret-left caret-right caret-square-down caret-square-left caret-square-right caret-square-up caret-up cart-menu-1 cart-menu-2 cart-menu-3 cart-menu-4 categories chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right chevron-up clock close comments cookies copyright coupon-discount date-modified date-published discord double-arrows-down double-arrows-left double-arrows-right double-arrows-up dribbble envelope-open envelope eye facebook fax flickr foursquare github gmail google-drive grid-view hashtag hollow-ring homepage instagram ios level-down-alt level-up-alt line link linkedin list-view login logout long-arrow-alt-down long-arrow-alt-left long-arrow-alt-right long-arrow-alt-up mastodonmedium messenger mobile-menu mobile phone pinterest place qq quote-left quote-right quotes reading-time-hourglass reading-time-stopwatch reddit rss scroll-to-top search shazam shopping-bag shopping-cart side-panel-opening-2-left side-panel-opening-2-right side-panel-opening-left side-panel-opening-right skype slack small-arrow-down small-arrow-left small-arrow-right small-arrow-up sms snapchat soundcloud spinner spotify stackoverflow sync telegram threadstiktok times-circle tinder trello tripadvisor tumblr twitch twitter viber vimeo vine vkontakte website wechat whatsapp windows wishlist xing yelp youtube zoom