December 2016
The Forensic Arts Therapies Advisory Group (FATAG) held its 36th bi-annual Conference in Oxford on November 25th 2016. FATAG supports Arts therapists working in forensic and secure settings; it aims to promote safe and effective use of Arts therapies in secure settings, provide guidelines and information on the Arts therapies and seek recognition for our professional status and qualifications. This conference was an examination of the central role that Arts therapies play in the treatment of prisoners at HMP Grendon. A unique environment, Grendon has been dubbed ‘Britain’s only therapeutic jail‘ (Weale, 2001). It is a high security Category B prison for men who voluntarily engage in Therapeutic Community (TC) treatment. It is the only prison in the UK which is entirely dedicated to working with prisoners in this way. The structure of the prison comprises six separate therapeutic communities, each with around 40 residents. There are two specialist wings, one for men who have committed sex offences, and one ‘TC+’ Therapeutic Community for prisoners who have learning disabilities. The four remaining wings are for ‘mixed offenders’ – the majority of men have a personality disorder and are typically serving long sentences for violent offences. The clinical work is group work informed by psychodynamic principles. There are 12 Core Creative Psychotherapists (6 Psychodramatists and 6 Arts therapists – art therapists and music therapists), who work across all six TCs. The FATAG Conference programme comprised presentations from five different Arts therapists and comments from Grendon’s Governor, and its Head of Clinical Services; not arts therapists themselves, but witness to the effectiveness of the work within the prison.
Kate Rothwell, convener of FATAG since 2009 and art therapist at Grendon, gave an introduction to the day and to the uniqueness of this prison as a treatment centre with a radical structure and approach – small groups within each ‘wing’, communities which meet regularly and provide peer support and observation. Prisoners feed back to each other and can have the power to vote a prisoner out of the community if they are seen not to engage with therapeutic process. She explored some of the profound trauma that men arrive with and that many men had never discussed their offence prior to being at Grendon. The first presentation was from Simon Hastilow, an art therapist and senior lecturer at Roehampton University, who outlined how the TCs function to address offending, with a specific focus on sexual offending. He presented a case study of one man from the sexual offenders wing and elaborated on how the TC structure can serve the prisoners’ recovery – they engage in communities, have a voice, confront their offending and learn to reciprocally tolerate others. He also examined the risk factors of the community aspect of Grendon’s approach, in the relational quality of the prison, the attitudes and coping mechanisms which are present there. Lastly he explored the positive and negative impacts on the therapist working with this client group in this very unique environment and the ways Arts therapists can support each other in this work. Deryk Thomas gave a presentation outlining some of the challenges of developing art therapy within the newest community at Grendon. The TC+ community, known as ‘F wing’ is for prisoners with learning disabilities (LD). He discussed how learning disabilities is all too often a hidden problem within the prison population, with 20–30% identified as LD. He presented some of the ways this particular community is differently structured, with a multi-modal approach of shorter therapy sessions being held more regularly than in other wings. He too explored the impact of this work on the therapist and the weight of holding so many images for the men who created all manner of self-portraits and stories through their images.
Joy Chung, a recently graduated art psychotherapist, presented her experience of the journey of setting up art therapy in a mixed offender TC. She considered some of the typical presentations in the forensic clients and the major recurring themes which emerge through the therapy. Through her experience of the group she recognised that the men were able to explore the effects of their offending, both to themselves and others. She also encountered many challenges in the journey of establishing the group – tested boundaries, complex countertransference issues, the men’s reduced capacity to mentalise. She presented her own curiosity in the men‘s somatic responses and how this guided her work to focus on the present moment. When members of the group wanted to discard or destroy their images, Joy introduced an ‘Art Therapy Bin’, into which images could be thrown, but also retrieved. Something Review of the
36th Arts Therapies Forensic Conference in Oxford
Hosted by FATAG (Forensic Arts Therapies Advisory Group) on 25th November 2016
December 2016
unbearable or overwhelming in the moment could still be confronted at a later time; this seemed a very effective tool.
After a lunch break we reconvened to a more immersive session of music therapy and an exploration of how music therapy is used in the TC+ wing for men with learning disabilities. Pete McPhail demonstrated how music therapy relates to other forms of psychotherapy, how the interpersonal dynamics of the music therapy group relate to those of the small therapy group – this was particularly of interest within Grendon, where so much of the prison’s structure and focus is on community, peer feedback and group dynamics. We explored the way music therapy is introduced to the group, how the group makes sense of what is happening in the session and the role of talk and other forms of communication.
The final session of the day focused on the attempts to develop a future pilot model to evaluate the effectiveness of all the Core Creative Psychotherapies across five of the six TCs at Grendon. Questionnaires and evaluation forms had been designed and distributed to 36 men at 6-monthly intervals over the past year. The feedback is encouraging – most forms were completed and reflected engagement in Arts therapies, information about the initial attraction to the Arts therapies and the experienced benefits of them, specifically in relation to the prisoner’s offence. This preliminary work seems very positive, and the discussion after the presentation focused around the challenge to have such research commissioned and funded. There seemed an impatience in the room for published evidence of the effectiveness of Arts therapies and frustration that this process is so slow and investment so elusive. The work at Grendon is demonstrably positive and, if rolled out to other prisons, could be of enormous benefit; as ever the obstacle is funding, and the prevailing attitudes about punishing, more than rehabilitating, prisoners.
The last portion of the day was set aside for a plenary group meeting where questions were asked, reflections made and conversations started. The Dramatherapists in the room were naturally curious about the role Dramatherapy has to play
at
Grendon
(there
are
not
currently
any
Dramatherapists working there). The feeling was that it was welcome, though Psychodrama is very well established, having been a cornerstone of the Core Creative Psychotherapies on offer, and central to the therapeutic recovery work for the past 36 years. In the closing comments of the day, Kate Rothwell gave her heartfelt thanks for what was the last FATAG conference that she convened. Jessica Collier (art therapist) and Lorna Downing (Dramatherapist) have taken the reins from Kate Rothwell and will be convening the 37th FATAG Conference in June 2017. During Kate Rothwell’s tenure, she has worked tirelessly, given her time and energy and compiled and edited a book: Forensic Arts Therapies: Anthology of Practice and Research, which was launched earlier in the year.
Juliet Stephens
Reference
Weale, S. (2001) ‘Prison – the therapeutic way’, The Guardian, 2 February
December 2016
Organisation: Know Limits Ltd
Facilitator: Mandy Gutsell
• Dramatherapist • Degree in Child and Adolescent Psychiatry • • Certified Life Coach and Parent Coach for Teens • Certifed Organisational Relationship Systems Coach • • Completed Diploma in Creative Supervision • Offers Individual and Group Therapy – Individual and Group Supervision Where is it? Newhampton Arts Centre, Dunkley St, Wolverhampton WV1 4AN To download map go to: www.newhamptonarts.co.uk Why Mandy Gutsell?
I have been working as a dramatherapist, mental health nurse, lecturer, trainer and coach for the last 26 years. I teach on Mental Health Courses, work with Organisations to support their staff and run leadership courses on ‘How to be your true authentic brilliant self’. I run Dramatherapy and Coaching workshops and ‘Time Out’, for people to explore ‘Who they really want to be’. My philosophy and way of working is eclectic drawing on Carl Rogers, Elisabeth Kubler-Ross, Personality Enneagram profiling, Multi modal stress approach and coaching knowing that my clients have the answer already. Sometimes we just need a guide to help light the way for us. Includes all resources and materials provided. Free initial consultation and tutorials. Payment and subsidiary options possible. For more details contact:
www.knowlimitscoach.com contact form Tel: +44 (0)7951 229941