October 2016
October 2016
I work as a dramatherapist and an artist. I know that art offers both a means of personal empowerment, social awareness and even, in the right conditions, of psychological change. How then should theatre use its power to connect? Should theatre tell stories that raise social consciousness like Brecht suggested – by breaking the illusion of theatre and helping audiences to become more aware of their society? Or could theatre, as the visionary dramatist Antonin Artaud dreamed, do something else, and become a kind of magical crucible for shifting the substance of consciousness itself, revealing the unknown worlds beneath our fragile and limited sense of our individual ego. Artaud’s dream was bolstered by the fertile currents of irrationalism; listing them shows some of the key movements in our contemporary culture – the birth of psychoanalysis, the idea of a collective unconscious, more contact with ritual art from nonwestern cultures, surrealism, the psychedelic booms and happenings of the 60s and 70s, postmodernism’s ongoing project to dissolve both the idea of the self and the fantasy of modern progress. During this time, the theatrical avant garde created some of the most exciting and challenging approaches to art-making of the modern and postmodern era. One of these was Jerzy Grotowski’s intense and sustained attempts to hi-jack acting and use it to create powerful, paradigm
shifting
collective
experiences
structured around mythico-theatrical communions of intense emotional states. Theatre, Grotowski famously said, was an encounter. An encounter between actor and witness, myth and self, between play and audience, between oneself and another. Grotowski’s reverence for encounter placed it at the heart of creativity – in the ambiguity of meeting another, stripped of defences, something creative and rejuvenating could take place. Simon McBurney’s “The Encounter” incorporates something of Brecht‘s social consciousness and Grotowski‘s fearless examination of intense states and weaves them into a deeply affecting and illuminating piece of theatre that lives long in the memory, but also poses disturbing questions, not only about its subject matter but also about whether it inadvertently perpetuates the problems it critiques. McBurney takes an openly Brechtian approach at first, starting off with the familiar, a man in everyday clothes, standing on a mostly empty stage that contains only a few bottles of water, some video tape and a large microphone in the shape of a head talking about his daughter‘s bedtime ritual. By the end of the play he has inaugurated a startling piece of theatre, a lucid and convincing account of the destruction and exploitation of the Amazon and its people, that takes in the fragility of the western idea of the self, the possibility of telepathy, the horror of neo-colonialism, culminating in a savagely powerful psychedelic ritual. Yet despite the play’s ferocious intelligence and creative power, the play also stands on the edge of some dark and uneasy questions about neo-colonialism, and its hidden role in art and culture as well as “out there“ where the destruction continues. Does “The Encounter” inadvertently act as a piece of colonial appropriation, using the exotic Amazonians to sell seats, like a modern day Victorian explorer, a kind of freak show for privileged western audiences to gawp at?
McBurney begins innocently enough, dressed in everyday clothes with an everyday persona, asking the audience to place headphones on their heads to demonstrate the binaural effects of the microphone, which allows him to begin to loop the technology, conversing with a recording of his own voice, interweaving recordings from different times with his own voice, dialoguing with a recording of himself and his young daughter, playing with his live voice and recordings in ways that demonstrate how at ease we have become with the idea of linear time as something disrupted by our personal recordings of the past. Time, recording and narrative will become key themes in what follows – isn’t time just a story that we agree to share? What is the cost of our desire to capture every aspect of our own lives and other The Watch and the Camera
or Can Theatre Save the World?
A review of “The Encounter” by Theatre de Complicite at the Attenborough Centre for the Creative Arts, University of Sussex. 19th May
Review
October 2016
October 2016
cultures? What if everything was a story we tell ourselves – even the idea of a self? However, McBurney has a story to tell as well as ideas to throw out – the story of Loren McIntyre, who in 1969 got dangerously lost in the Amazon attempting to make “first contact” with the Mayaruna, sometimes called the Cat People for their habit of decorating their faces with whisker-like quills. McBurney takes on the role of McIntyre, and relates his story of encountering the strange looking people alone in the rainforest on a national geographic photo quest. Excited about making “first contact” he follows them into the dense rainforest. Increasingly lost, and unable to communicate with them, he becomes dependent on them for his survival. But when he finally reaches their village, something strange seems to be going on. They seem to be in the middle of a crisis, destroying their homes and moving on. Moreover, they seem disturbed and ambiguous about his presence. Waking up one morning he finds his watch and shoes burning. Although he needs his shoes to survive he feels more alarmed at the loss of his camera. He tries to rescue his shoes, and finds his camera high up a tree in the hands of a howler monkey, who rips it in two. The loss of his watch and camera sever his ties to his identity in the western world and from then on he is adrift in the world of the Mayaruna, unable to speak their language. The watch and camera seem to symbolise his (and our) obsession with ordering and capturing experience, time and material reality. But, in this moment of personal crisis, he reports something remarkable happened. He began to experience what he interpreted as telepathic communication from the leader of the tribe. This sets up the main thrust of the plot – that of McIntyre‘s narrative of how the gradual but increasing loss of his “civilised” frames of reference and forced immersion in Mayaruna life lead to the disintegration of his sense of self through physical hardship and the destruction of his sense of time. This disintegration increases in the face of the threats to his survival from hostile members of the tribe, parasitic maggots and his increasing awareness that the Mayaruna themselves are going through a moment of crisis of their own to do with their own powerlessness in the face of western colonialism and commerce – far from “first contact” he is one of many other white men with guns, roads, contracts and chain saws who brought slavery, death, sickness, loss of culture and dependence and about whom the Mayaruna are very aware of. Behind them other men would bring bureaucracy, welfare programmes, forced reliance on medical care for diseases they have brought, always underpinned by the threat of violence and the promise of a “better life”.
In contrast to this, the Mayaruna seem to have a deeper spiritual connection with their environment. At this point, several critics of “The Encounter” have criticised McBurney. Most critics drop in the phrase “noble savage”, but one review goes further, setting up “The Encounter” as a modern-day heart of darkness, in which the Mayaruna’s otherness is exploited to serve little other purpose than a projection for a western guilt trip.
Such criticism echoes Chinua Achebe’s famous attack on Conrad’s “Heart of Darkness” as a racist text. Achebe claimed that it was little more than Conrad’s demonising Africans as a way of expressing his own cultural self loathing. Linked to this is the charge by Christopher Innes against the theatrical avant garde of “primitivism”; that Artaud and Grotowski’s attempts to create a transformative theatrical language of dream, sound, image and ritual were little more than romantic backward glancing, a noble savage fantasy clad in western theatrical clothing. Anthropologist Michael Taussig has suggested that to animalise and destroy the “wild” exotic other and to simultaneously praise the wisdom of shamanic elders act as two sides of the same coin. The final act of domination that begins with the taking of the land closes with this appropriation of the culture’s secrets – what better way to complete the destruction and colonisation of a people than by stealing their magic and fetishising their elders? Thus tamed and made safe, they can be appealed to for healing and forgiveness, not even for acts perpetrated on them, but for our own narcissistic problems.
Is this a fair criticism of “The Encounter”? McBurney seems to try to anticipate this criticism through the way he structures and presents the story. McBurney inserts himself as the teller of the story into the story. He punctuates McIntyre’s increasingly fractured hallucinogenic narrative by playing “himself” dealing with the incursions of his 7 year old daughter as he prepares the show. The “McBurney” character is a half disinterested, distracted but kind dad, keen to get on with his work, and willing to “buy off” his daughter with crisps and stories. Her interjections allow him to make one of the more profound points of the
play,
that
of
the
relationship
between
consumerism, sentimentality and identity – that our consumerism is anchored to a large extent on our obsession with capturing and documenting our loved
October 2016
October 2016
ones on photos, videos tapes, and to create a seemingly solid sense of who we are. His placing this story allows him to present himself reflexively – he makes no Artaudian or New Age claims to use theatre to try and adapt the Mayaruna’s rituals for his own benefit – rather he presents the Dad character as a rather helpless anxious “western self” or “ego” that McIntyre finds so flimsy in the face of the terror of immersion in the Amazon. It seems clear by the end that McIntyre’s own sense of the Mayaruna is spectacularly eclipsed by his own descent and confrontation with “his” own cosmic unconscious; he cannot truly participate in their rituals because of his own preoccupation with his cultural shadow.
In fact, the myth that McIntyre really seems to be using the Mayaruna to project himself into is the Christ myth, a myth of suffering, betrayal, death, disintegration and rebirth. His story follows this template almost precisely. By the play’s end, McIntyre has accompanied the Mayaruna into their own attempt to “rebirth” themselves, to place themselves into a parallel time beyond the reach of neo-colonialism and death by destroying all their possessions. A play that so ruthlessly exposes the connection between the consumerism of the self and the destruction of the world cannot present a happy ending; we know of course that the neo-colonial, neoliberal project in the Amazon continues, as does the ambiguous veneration and neo-colonialism of their wisdom through things like the current ayahuasca tourism. McBurney has the grace to allude at the play’s conclusion to the present and continuing struggle of the Mayaruna for land rights in the Amazon and passes on a message from his own contact with their descendents to ask for them to be remembered as real.
McBurney raises important questions as to the connections between consumerism and what we consider our greatest virtue – our sense of connection to each other shown by our love for our children. He suggests this creates a kind of false ego, implying through the narrative that this ego is not impenetrable but relies on the culture that surrounds it to build its invisible cage of clocks, photos and individualism. McIntyre’s
descent
embodies
an
underlying
encounter with a deeper nature in a way that is not comforting or humanistic. Of course, “oneness with deeper nature” is the classic white western ego’s move to ignore the sphere of privilege and destruction and just ask everyone to both “like it” and “be like it” despite all its faults. “The Encounter” has little to really say about the Mayaruna – perhaps the “noble savage” barbs have some accuracy but I think in some ways that is to miss the point of the play. A disinterested “anthropological account” of the Mayaruna may be just as likely to misrepresent them through its tacit sense of the superiority of western knowledge systems – like McIntyre’s camera, the desire to “capture” the other has a colonial and grasping tone. At least McIntyre eventually leaves them relatively unscathed by his presence; well known Western anthropologists in the Amazon have a shocking record when it comes to the abusive effect of their studies on Amazonian people. The play evoked a great feeling of sadness in me at the desperation of the Mayaruna’s attempts to use their cultural mythology and ritual magic to avoid the toxic arm of white civilisation. Like “Heart of Darkness”, the Mayaruna as the exotic other often seem to act as a projection for the despair and collapse of the white male ego to crumble into in the hopes of a rebirth into a greater whole. Unlike “Heart of Darkness”, “The Encounter” seeks to place this collapse within a broader critique of contemporary consumerism, its colonial attitude to ordering time and capturing reality – the watch and the camera. In telling the tale, McBurney manages to do something quite astonishing – take the apparent safeness of the normal everyday white western man, the Dad trying to put his 7 year old to bed, and place it against a story that vividly relates how our limited sense of who we really are connects to destructive and coercive preoccupations with capturing experience, nature and time. Like Werner Herzog, who also used the Amazon as a backdrop to show the madness at the heart of the white western mind, he shows how liable our apparently stable constructions of self are to collapse in the encounter with a very different worldview shaped by immersion within a powerful environment rather than control of it. And, if that sentence suggests a scholarly preoccupation with abstract physical concepts then I really have not done the play justice – the visceral intensity of the play combined with its hypnotic use of binaural sound really do make you feel as if the disintegration of McIntyre’s flimsy western ego into psychedelic rainforest fever and Kurtz-esque despair is your own. As, perhaps, it is. It is an encounter I will not forget. Toby Chown
October 2016
October 2016
October 2016