as Self-Presenter What would an imaginal

as Self-Presenter What would an imaginal

The Prompt, August 2016 · page 18-23

August 2016

What would an imaginal

based evidence based

practice look like?

A reflection on the politics and philosophy of evidence based practice and dramatherapy What position should dramatherapists take on the issue of evidence based practice? The issue seems unlikely to go away with the insertion of those three words into multiple policy documents, government research directives, seeping into clinical and educational settings and now fallen into common parlance, even used on Radio 4 as a means to advocate for the best for patient. On the face of it, there doesn’t seem much to object to – after all, who could object to basing their practice on what evidence suggests would be the best thing to do? Yet this question shows the rhetorical power of the use of language – as if to argue against evidence based practice would be to argue against evidence itself. I wonder if as arts therapists we may sometimes feel sensitive to the unmade argument that our practice may be based on something entirely imaginary. After all, who would trust an imaginary based practice, and what would that even look like? Well, in fact it might look quite a lot like evidence based practice, because evidence based practice itself is based on a set of fiercely held and passionately defended convictions that create the basis for imagining the world. Music therapist Kenneth Aigen writes:

“Rather

than

being

dispassionate

analysts

of

facts,

scientists

are

passionate advocates for particular theories; these theoretical commitments strongly influence how facts are construed.”

(Aigen, 2015)

Here we see something that we instinctively know – a worldview has to be imagined before it can be proved, and that this process of imagining often forms a lens, like that of a contact lens that the eye itself cannot see. Aigen suggests that it is not the idea of evidence that we need to oppose but rather the idea of what constitutes evidence. Proponents of evidence based practice have taken the word “evidence” and shackled it to a particular view of the world. They base this worldview on their creation of a hierarchy about what constitutes evidence. Thus “evidence” refers to knowledge gained only by certain methods. Researchers must take an objective as possible view to eliminate personal bias and place their pre-existing theories to the test. At the top of the pyramid of evidence lies randomised controlled trials (RCTs) in which two identical groups are found, one is exposed to a treatment and the other not. In this way, one could measure the difference

between

the

two,

and

discover

whether

say

dramatherapy

clients fared better than a similar group who had nothing. Again, this may seem like a reasonable way of finding out if something works or not.

But below the surface, we might begin to have

reasonable

doubts.

After

all,

random control trials were designed to test pharmaceuticals, not the healing potential

of

art

and

relationship.

Everyone’s body, we might reasonably “evidence”

refers

to

knowledge

gained

only

by

certain

methods.

August 2016

assume, will work in pretty much the same way. But dramatherapy works with the mind, the emotions, the imagination and how these become embodied relationally. These most definitely do not work in the same way for everyone. Furthermore, dramatherapy wishes to not just “do” something to its clients but to help them to become empowered within the therapeutic relationship. A dramatherapist wants their client to become more aware of how their own perceptions shape their world, and to help them imagine who they have been, who they want to be, and what stands in their way.

Aigen writes: “To understand perception requires us to understand how we act upon the world, not just how the world acts upon us.”

In fact, dramatherapists have much to offer the debate about the interaction between

embodied

perception

and

action. Social scientists coined the word “reflexivity” used to describe taking yourself into account in order to understand a situation. However, reflexivity means not just reflection on your self as an individual, but reflection on the wider sources of thinking. In this sense, reflexivity calls for closer understanding of the philosophy and the politics of knowledge and how they affect your thoughts and choices as an agent in a given situation. For example, my status as a white heterosexual middle class man elicits a response from whoever I am with based on our shared sense of what this means between us, whether or not we consciously acknowledge it. Dramatherapy in theory should be good at accessing this kind of reflexive knowledge and often we do within clinical supervision.

Much evidence based practice involves eliminating uncomfortable complexities like this, attempting to understand the whole world as a set of processes to be discovered, categorised and analysed. The brain seems quite good at this and loses itself quickly in abstract problems to solve. For example, I work with children affected by family alcohol and drug problems.

One

reasonable

question

might be “how are children affected by family alcohol and drug problems?” or even “do the children of alcoholics become alcoholics?” But if we stop for a moment we can see that we cannot really answer this question definitively. There can be no way of amalgamating all of the children of alcoholics into one category and finding out a definitive truth about this – one that truly answers the question. We could take a different approach,

like

specialist

researchers

Forrester and Harwin, who ask us instead to think about a variety of generic cases – like an infant whose mother has been taking heroin, a 5 year old whose father and mother drink and who have violent arguments and a 12 year old sent to a public boarding school whose mother drinks every day.

Being given this narrative information immediately broadens out the sense of the problem, There is not and cannot be a “child of alcoholics” more like multiple occurrences of children and alcohol or drug problems with similar and different aspects. Language acts as a model of the world, rather than the world itself, and it constantly seduces us into believing that it is what it represents. When we fail to distinguish our models of reality from our experience of reality, we can easily fall prey to the hidden problems in the human psyche – the desire to use knowledge like a form of empire building, to establish and maintain privilege. I am reminded of a quote from the philosopher Emanuel Levinas about his fear for philosophy – that it was “tantamount to the conquest of being by man Language acts as a model of the world, rather than the world itself, and it constantly seduces us into believing that it is what it represents.

August 2016

over history.” One could quite easily substitute “philosophy” for “evidence based practice” and the same fear be expressed. Levinas suggests that at its heart, what drives this enterprise would be a process very recognisable within the therapeutic relationship – the desire to reduce the other to the same – the eradication of difference. This indeed lies at the heart of the dilemma of the therapist. We may be highly skilled at dealing with ambiguity, defensiveness and denial in our clients. The worldviews that we live within and encounter continue to operates on dysfunctional principles. There is no “safe space” outside of (or maybe even within) the therapy room, and we make a serious error if we think that we can keep all the phenomena of psychopathology within the therapeutic container – the splitting, the narcissistic wounds, the anxiety, the need for control – all these and more define the cultural mind we operate within. They reappear in our workplace, our social institutions, our relationships with colleagues or managers, our attempts to find funding opportunities. They define the debate about what constitutes evidence. Aigen says that a review of music therapy research showed that seeking the approval of medical professionals who held the key to the public acceptance of music therapy was the primary factor in determining appropriate research methods and focuses. Here we see a good example of how research not only investigates, but forms fields of power. The pragmatic need for acceptance also leads to a translation of the rich language of art into the narrow parameters of a preconceived notion of evidence. One irony about the current emergence of “evidence based practice” as an inescapable political necessity is that it has emerged anew despite decades of criticisms of it as philosophically naive and politically motivated – Nietzsche wrote in 1874 in criticism of the way research often finds what it wants to:

“When someone hides something under a bush and looks for it again in the same place, and finds it there as well, there is not much praise to such seeking and finding.” (Nietzsche 1874/1993: 50)

Subsequent decades saw attacks on philosophically naive scientism from social constructivism, feminism and postmodernism. That evidence based practice has become talked up as a “gold standard” within a range of social institutions – not just psychotherapy but also social work, eduction, healthcare – at precisely the moment in time that we witness a rapid new wave of liberalisation within all these sectors, does not seem a co-incidence. As our society has become increasingly pathologised, therapy can now look more like an opportunity to make money on a large scale. This means that psychotherapies and arts therapies face the challenge of companies looking to cherry pick “techniques” and then apply them to less qualified and less skilled workers at a cheaper salary. By arguing that the relationship is what matters, therapies have been able to resist the grinding attack of such technical-rational economics. The current installation of evidence based practice bypasses the particularity of relational therapy to discover “what works” as if this is something to be discovered That evidence

based practice

has become

talked up as a

“gold standard”

within a range of

social institutions

– not just

psychotherapy

but also social

work, eduction,

healthcare – at

precisely the

moment in time

that we witness a

rapid new wave

of liberalisation

within all these

sectors, does

not seem a

co-incidence.

August 2016

rather than created. Once you “discover” what “works” then you can easily roll this out on an industrial scale. I see a direct connection between current uses of evidence based practice and the neo-liberalisation of public services. I would argue that dramatherapy’s strength and weakness lies in its identity as a borderland discipline – it exists on the borders of theatre and psychotherapy, of the body and the imagination, of the highly social and the deeply personal, of the mythic enactment and the kitchen sink drama. What I find missing in evidence based practice are the same things that therapy itself struggles with – the reality of social and economic privilege, the challenge to not reduce the other to the same, the power of imagination and the difficulty in interpreting it. As dramatherapists, we need to adopt an informed and critical perspective towards evidence based practice, and be ready and willing to articulate the evidence we do have to develop and explain our practice to non dramatherapists. In particular, our ability to tell stories and understand narrative, the uses of fiction and embodiment, all have strong cross-over areas with adjacent research disciplines. If we do use socalled evidence based research tools we should not accept them uncritically but understand how they fit into a larger social and cultural pattern and be able to interpret them as we might a client’s images. The challenges to the arts therapies in a technical rational scientistic culture, married to an aggressive neo-liberal economics that sees profit in places that were previously seen as public services, seem strong and daunting. However, I remember how during my dramatherapy training, my fellow trainees and I seemed frequently drawn to create personal pieces of therapeutic theatre in which a small, seemingly helpless person faced a larger apparently indestructible monstrous force and said “You have no power over me”. Dramatherapists, who constantly negotiate the highly permeable threshold between metaphor and experience, know that imaginal based practice may be what all therapists, regardless of theoretical orientation, practice anyway. The trick may lie in how to utilise this knowledge.

Toby Chown

References

Aigen, K., (2015). A Critique of Evidence-Based Practice in Music Therapy. Music Therapy Perspectives, 33(1), pp. 12–24. Forrester D. and Harwin J., (2011). Parents Who Misuse Drugs and Alcohol – Effective Interventions in Social Work and Child Protection. Wiley-Blackwell, Chichester. Levinas E., ed Sean Hand, (1989). The Levinas Reader. Blackwell, Oxford. Nietzsche F., ed Shact R., (1993). Selections. Prentis Hall New Jersey.

August 2016

August 2016

More posts

edition Diary Dates

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 32-33 DIARY DATES 2023 January 2023 Closing date for the BADth Gordon Wiseman Trust Fund. Details in Members’ area.…

The Prompt – final

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 22-31 Dear Jane, As a long-standing supporter of the publication, I write this open letter to thank you for…

people-caused climate destruction A Farewell Scenario

The Prompt, December 2022 · by EXCLUSIVE TO ARTS THERAPISTS · page 17-21 A FAREWELL SCENARIO 1996–2022 Scenario Arts in Personal Development was founded in…
account android arrow-alt-circle-down arrow-alt-circle-left arrow-alt-circle-right arrow-alt-circle-up arrow-down arrow-left arrow-right arrow-up author bars behance blogger bluesky buffer caret-down caret-left caret-right caret-square-down caret-square-left caret-square-right caret-square-up caret-up cart-menu-1 cart-menu-2 cart-menu-3 cart-menu-4 categories chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right chevron-up clock close comments cookies copyright coupon-discount date-modified date-published discord double-arrows-down double-arrows-left double-arrows-right double-arrows-up dribbble envelope-open envelope eye facebook fax flickr foursquare github gmail google-drive grid-view hashtag hollow-ring homepage instagram ios level-down-alt level-up-alt line link linkedin list-view login logout long-arrow-alt-down long-arrow-alt-left long-arrow-alt-right long-arrow-alt-up mastodonmedium messenger mobile-menu mobile phone pinterest place qq quote-left quote-right quotes reading-time-hourglass reading-time-stopwatch reddit rss scroll-to-top search shazam shopping-bag shopping-cart side-panel-opening-2-left side-panel-opening-2-right side-panel-opening-left side-panel-opening-right skype slack small-arrow-down small-arrow-left small-arrow-right small-arrow-up sms snapchat soundcloud spinner spotify stackoverflow sync telegram threadstiktok times-circle tinder trello tripadvisor tumblr twitch twitter viber vimeo vine vkontakte website wechat whatsapp windows wishlist xing yelp youtube zoom