February 2016
(This is the first section of a three-part article. The next two will be published in subsequent editions of The Prompt. Editor)
Short-term Individual Dramatherapy
employing ‘The Theatre of Self-Expression’ Working with Different Unconscious Archetypes and Conscious Aspects of the Psyche
In addition to our immediate consciousness, which is of a thoroughly personal nature … there exists a second psychic system of a collective, universal and impersonal nature which is identical in all individuals. This collective unconscious does not develop individually but is inherited. It consists of pre-existent forms, the archetypes, which can only become conscious secondarily…. (Jung 1936 Vol. 9, 87)
Perhaps it is easiest to introduce the idea of ‘self as a community of selves’ … Most of us have probably … found ourselves talking or acting as if we were two people rather than one. We talk sometimes of being in ‘two minds’ about something, part of you wanting to do one thing and a part wanting to do something else. Quite often we hear people talk of having to ‘battle’ with themselves, as if one aspect of themselves was in conflict with another.
(Mair 1977.130)
This essay is an update of a previously published chapter describing ‘The Theatre of Self Expression’ in individual Dramatherapy (Mitchell 1996). This work now benefits from a further twenty years practice in adult psychiatry. The last ten years has seen a pronounced shift in the NHS from medium or long term therapy to short term or brief work. Nevertheless I have found that the healing of psychological problems involves engaging a client in a number of different levels and modes of work:
Level One:
The Psychological
Level Two:
The Therapeutic Relationship
Level Three:
The Metaphorical
Level Four:
The Dramatic
Level Five:
Transitional Event
Level Six:
The Gears of Physis
Level Seven:
Endings
In this essay I will briefly describe each level, at the same time not forgetting that therapy is a live event between two people and does not necessarily follow a specific format. It is a unique process reflecting what the client brings to therapy and how the therapist employs their map of the therapeutic
process to attend respectfully to a client’s problems. So, although I will describe a schedule of work, it must always be remembered that it is a guide, like a mountain guide following a map while at the same time being
influenced
by
the
spontaneous
weather conditions and the capability of the person they are guiding.
Introduction
February 2016
I have found that first clients need to have an understanding of how their psychological processes operate and why this may lead to various difficulties and change. I use a framework which embraces archetypal psychology (Jung 1936, 1963, Hillman 1975, 1983, Stevens 1990, Goss 2015) with anthropology (Eliade 1989, Hope 1988, Turner 1982, Van Gennep 1960, Jennings 2012) and mythology (Campbell 1949, Rebillot 1993) to understand and work through the various states that occur during therapy. I believe there is both a conscious and unconscious level to human experience. Consciousness involves all that we are aware of during our waking life, including memories from our biography. The unconscious is quite different; it is an area that is beyond recall and contains many different kinds of experiences from the past, but it has a more powerful impact on our lives than our waking consciousness. Both
levels
of
consciousness
can
be
compared to an iceberg floating in the ocean. What you actually see is only the tip of the iceberg (consciousness), only a third of its mass is visible; two thirds are out of sight below the surface (unconsciousness).
Further to this, the unconscious has two entirely different domains, as psychologist Carl Jung (1936) has stated: the ‘personal unconscious’ that stores all of our personal memories, and the ‘collective unconscious’ which holds the archetypes.
Archetypes
Archetypes are inherited and have an influence on our life depending on how they are brought to light during childhood. Most of the archetypes are nurtured through ‘good enough’ parenting, education, friendships and institutions during our early years. Problems only occur when the archetypes are out of balance or have not been given attention and remain dormant.
In therapy we are often concerned with identifying and processing these forces that have a direct experience on how we feel about ourselves, go about our lives and search for contentment. There are two facets – one that is conscious and one that is unconscious (the archetypes). The conscious components I call Aspects.
Aspects
An Aspect is a part of our waking consciousness, like an inner sub-personality and there are many of them (Rowen 1990, Roth 1989, Mair 1977, Mitchell 1997). They are a facet Active Dramatherapy
This mode gives emphasis to exploring personal material through action methods which include: visualization, animation, personification, transitional events, and debriefing them verbally. Explicit Dramatherapy
This mode gives emphasis to exploring literal issues in the client’s world by employing symbolic representations. Sitting-down Dramatherapy
This mode gives emphasis to exploration through the imagination and processing issues verbally.
Points of Urgency
This mode gives emphasis to pressing psychological predicaments which need immediate attention.
Combinations
This mode is an amalgamation of the above modes of Dramatherapy.
Before outlining each level I wish to note that the facilitation of Dramatherapy can involve five different modes of work shown in the table. The appropriate mode will be determined through collaboration between the client and Dramatherapist at assessment and what follows will be adapted to meet the process of therapy this decision dictates.
As a Dramatherapist I belong to the school that believes in the mode that Jennings has identified
as
‘The
Integrated
model’
(Jennings 1990.39). This combines the drama with specific psychological connections within a client. Here I address some of the implications of this perspective. Level One: The Psychological
February 2016
Often prior to therapy the archetype of the Wanderer has been in control with its conscious aspect, the Explorer, guiding someone’s behaviour. The Explorer looks through various life experiences for a resolution to inner conflicts – this may have included solo adventures, religious or philosophical aid, or hoped for solution through relationships. It is only when this exploration has exhausted itself that someone realises that they need professional help. The origins of this archetype first described a person who withdrew from civilisation to pursue a solitary spiritual way in the desert. However, I believe it also applies to the non-conformist who may become a recluse as a result of a refusal to play cultural or psychological imperatives. Its conscious aspect ‘The Recluse’ can feel driven to be a social isolate and have a great sense of not ‘belonging’ as well as a fear of people, societies traditions and conventions. On the other hand the First Nature of a person’s gene pool may give them inherited characteristics that create a preference to a life of solitude. Someone commencing therapy usually begins with the archetype of the Seeker, and at a conscious level the aspect of the Searcher dominates their motivation for help. Rather than following the path of the Wanderer / Explorer exploring external ways to become free of their problems, they are now motivated to search in therapy into their own personality and seek an inner transformation to their difficulties. Usually a client rationally, emotionally or physically is in some form of distress and they are searching for answers to their rational blind-spots, emotional blocks, or physical limitations (these could be sexual). This distress may manifest as symptoms of known mental health problems. Often these symptoms are the previous result of an unconscious solution to primal pain and rather than comforting someone only makes their lives even more complicated. Once therapy starts, another archetype and aspect are awakened. This is the Saboteur. The Saboteur has a specific job to stop any change taking place and to maintain the status quo, even though this may not be comfortable! The conscious aspect of this unconscious archetype is a Critic that fills our head with reasons and ideas why we should not proceed or how we ‘should really live in the world’. Why does this happen?
The Saboteur does not become activated until later in the developmental cycle of an individual. It actually starts its life in another form, as another archetype, that of ‘Protector’. of our consciousness, different from a role that is a social construct. Roth called them ‘ego characters’ to identify their individuality that we employ to inhabit a role. On the one hand they help us navigate our way through life events, while on the other they can impede our ambitions. These conscious Aspects are connected to their archetypal root and can have a powerful impact on our lives. In this section I am going to note how they manifest when someone engages in the therapeutic process. Archetype even leads the client to consider therapy. The names for the Archetypes come from Pearson (1991), Campbell
(1949)
and
Rebillot
(1993)
whereas I have named the Aspects, but clients often employ their own definitions. Archetype: The Wanderer
Aspect: The Explorer
Archetype: The Hermit
Aspect: The Recluse
Archetype: The Seeker
Aspect: The Searcher
Archetype: The Saboteur
Aspect: The Critic
The Process of Dramatherapy
February 2016
If a child has a traumatic experience and there is no external carer to keep them safe, the personality compensates by arousing the internal archetype: the Protector. The Protector’s function is to guard the growing child from re-experiencing the original pain. Imagine an infant who is left by an open fire and is attracted to exploring the flames. An infant’s primary way of meeting their curiosity is through touch, so the infant will reach out, putting their fingers in the flames, only withdrawing them, burnt, when experiencing the pain of the fire. Had an external carer been present, they would have stopped this action and the infant would have avoided getting hurt. Sadly, humans are slow learners, and this same situation can repeat itself, until something inside the infant takes place and an internal Protector is formed. The infant now knows that fire can hurt and any future interaction with any sort of fire is avoided through the shield of their internal Protector. This continues into adulthood, as the rest of the personality grows healthily, apart from fire which is avoided. The child grows into adulthood and, apart from the particular area of the wound, in my example of fire, which also becomes an adult fear of fire, the remainder of the personality may grow quite normally into an independent functioning adult. However, if the now adult moves into a flat that has a gas cooker, the Protector will still not allow them to go anywhere near it: in this moment the Saboteur is born and the person becomes conflicted over a wish to use a gas cooker but due to their fear of fire is unable to do so. In other words the Protector has distorted and become the Saboteur because its ‘over-protection’ is sabotaging a person’s ability to respond to this situation which is not damaging. In my example to make clear how the Protector turns into the Saboteur I have employed a practical example to make my point. This same process also happens to anyone experiencing any form of psychological difficulty that injures them. A similar kind of psychological conflict arises in therapy, when embarking on the journey of change. As soon as the therapy begins to go anywhere near difficult issues the Saboteur begins to stir and will try to stop the process. The Saboteur is similar to a pet dog, which lies comfortably in their basket, asleep until they hear something that could threaten their safety, outside, an ear will cock-up to monitor the sound. If this sound comes closer, like someone walking up a path to the front door, the dog will start to growl. If this visitor knocks on the door the dog is up and barking, ready to repel all who may enter. The Saboteur is similar, lying inert within the personality until it spies any form of danger to the equilibrium, even if that equilibrium is distorted and out of balance… “better the fear you know than the one that you don’t”.
Therefore after the first phase of therapy that usually involves the client telling their story to the therapist, this can disturb the Saboteur, who may do everything it can to disrupt the process. The Saboteur has the ability, the power, to make someone feel physically ill, to intensify negative thinking or generate a whole number of tricks to create what in therapy is called an ‘impasse’. This can lead to the awakening of a further archetype. This archetype represents the agony of a younger self. Children experience their emotions intensely and even though we may physically be an adult, and rationally mature, the emotional intelligence, though in most matters quite mature, in some areas of our personality can be driven by very young feelings that create distress. These feelings of anguish, feeling totally alone, abandoned, possibly betrayed by those closest to us, is an awful psychological place, with intruding critical thoughts that heaps on the sense of desolation.
In this state the Orphan feels through others’ acts that they have lost something that is a precious birth right and can be very angry about it, blaming friends, intimates, family, educators, government; any authority including God. The Orphan demands from others that they give them what they want, that they cherish, respect, accept them, in the manner they require and at the time they want it. They feel that it’s their turn to receive the love, the gifts, respect of others. They are intransigent. Anyone Archetype: The Protector
Aspect: The Guardian
Archetype: The Orphan
Aspect: The Troubled Younger Self
February 2016
who suggests that they need to do something about it can be forcefully rejected and will receive the sharp side of the Orphan’s tongue. Alternatively, the anger can go inside, where like an Exocet missile it will find the most vulnerable and sensitive areas of personality and inflame them, making the whole situation even worse. Lethargy can set in and the Orphan thinks “What’s the point” and this thought dominates the internal world. Where once there was motivation, the personality begins to shut down, and even their anger seems senseless and apathy descends upon them. This psychological fog can become the outcome of these feelings or alternatively other psychological symptoms: obsessions, phobic states, depression, deviant behaviour, addictions, loss of sleep, etc. All can arise as a screen to shut out psychological pain. The Orphan is the outsider, bitter, isolated and in a meaningless world that is against them. Fortunately, in most cases, this is not the only archetype steering their destiny, especially if the Seeker has brought the client into therapy. However, when the Saboteur arouses the Orphan it can certainly feel that the position is hopeless. It now takes very skilled work in therapy to alter this psychological conflict. The resolution to the impasse, its solution, is exploring other archetypes dormant in the unconscious. These can help and give hope, make amends for the omissions of childhood. This begins with attending to the following archetypes: The Caregiver, the Warrior and the Wise Person. However this needs to take place in a special environment that is safe both externally and within the transaction between the client and the therapist and this is called the Therapeutic Relationship. This archetype is concerned with love. Often a client will feel that in their past parental relationship, acceptance of them was based upon conditions that they could not meet or did not want to follow. The result of this is that this archetype may be depleted; a person has diminished self-confidence or finds it difficult to love as they do not love themselves. loss of this can have major implications to someone’s self-esteem and psychological ability to reach towards their goals in life. This is not to suggest that parents are necessarily to blame, parents on the whole are ‘good enough’ but they are not necessarily perfect for their children and this can give rise to later difficulties. In a constructive therapeutic relationship the client can begin to change these shortfalls and to begin to nurture the archetype of their Caregiver. This experience of care can not only inspire in the client the ability to absorb the therapist’s acceptance of their point of view but also invisibly commence a process that allows the client to start to think well of themselves. This can become like a snowball rolling down hill, collecting more and more snow. As the client feels that their therapist understands Before continuing with the unfolding of these important archetypes I want to loop back to the very start of therapy. Out there in the market place there are many different kinds of therapy. Each orientation can follow a completely different theory of change and codes of practice for facilitating that change. It’s a bit like selecting a house to buy. There are bungalows, town houses, houses in the suburbs and houses in the country.
The start of therapy is again similar to the structure of a house, this time building the house. It starts with creating the foundations. The foundations are important as they will have to hold securely whatever is built above them. The same is true of therapy with a professional therapist; the foundations of good, future therapy, are building a therapeutic alliance that feels psychologically safe, yet at the same time, has the possibility of collaboration and a rapport which can at times sustain challenge. The opening stages of therapy can involve clients sharing sensitive, delicate personal experiences, which can range from problems of communication, family issues, belief systems that include prejudices, jealousies, envy, guilt, shame, anger, obsessions, addictions, and depression, or to difficulties with various forms of physical or emotional intimacy. Therefore, feeling comfortable with the therapist and their form of therapy is essential. The creation of a good therapeutic alliance facilitates the emergence of another important archetype, which is fundamental to the process of change.
Level Two: The Therapeutic Relationship Archetype: The Care Giver
Aspect: The Idealised Parent
February 2016
their belief system, the safer they will feel to speak about significant areas of their psychological world. Thus the archetype of the Caregiver is central, enabling the conditions where constructive therapy can be built.
Another important part of the therapeutic relationship is that the client can experiment safely with the expression of delicate feelings experienced about the therapist. It is natural to have a variety of emotions about the therapist; some of these will be positive, which offer the opportunity to try out sharing these appreciations. In contrast the client may become irritated or even sometimes angry and rather than not expressing these feelings, the therapeutic alliance gives an opportunity to explore ‘venting your spleen’ and having these resentments acknowledged. Additionally, sometimes people believe that therapy has to be serious all the time. This is not true of all therapies and humour can also be very healing.
The therapeutic relationship also brings to life yet another important archetype and that is the client’s own inner Wise Person. This archetype is often obscured in the unconscious by more immediate difficulties or perceptions that they have no wisdom; sometimes it is kept hidden and top-secret from everyone. A common way of not recognising this archetype in ourselves is to project it onto someone else and see them as having the attributes we hold dear. This can happen in our contact with people we are attracted to, or with certain authorities or people we value as experts. This archetype can be placed (projected) onto the therapist, seeing him or her as having all the necessary qualities that are associated with the wise.
The importance of the therapeutic alliance bringing light to the client’s own Wise Person is an important component in the whole process of healing. In its early stages, the therapist can carry or ‘understudy’ this quality for the client, that is actually within them, and then slowly returns ownership of their wisdom back to them. The Wise Person within often communicates not through rational language but through intuitive hunches that arise not from the ‘left’ brain but from the ‘right’ brain as this brain is connected to the core essential Self (see Schore 1994). The development of the therapeutic relationship, as well as enabling the security to nurture both the archetypes of the Caregiver and Wise Person, also gives space for the client to share the story of their life in a way that they really feel heard by the therapist. The developing rapport also offers time for the client to learn how the therapy operates. This can lead to an understanding which helps the client employ the tools the therapist has to offer, to shape their therapeutic adventure. The process of therapy is a quest for what the client is looking for. The therapist, as I have previously implied, is not the expert on how the client functions, and only the client can be their own expert. However therapists are trained and licensed to practice a particular form of therapy which during the early sessions they will skilfully facilitate, demonstrating the methods they use to enable the client to reach towards their Goals. This is why the therapeutic relationship is the key to the healing process, and it may continue to grow throughout the therapy and offer some significant insights on how the client relates to themselves and others. However it is only the beginning, an important one, but a prelude to creating the circumstances where other archetypes can be brought into the light, processed, and the very essential nature of the client can once more be enhanced, over time. I have stated that as the therapeutic relationship develops, the Saboteur will become concerned with what the Seeker is doing, and will attempt to create an impasse in a client’s wish to move forward. Therapeutic movement involves the client not only sharing their difficulties but also embarking on procedures to overcome them and this is called the ‘work’ in therapy; this may include experimenting with something new. When this happens it can feel awkward, clumsy or like wearing in a new pair of shoes that are different from your old comfortable pair, even though they are worn out and need Archetype: The Wise Person
Aspect: The Guide
Enlisting Archetypal Help
February 2016
The Warrior archetype in its conscious aspect is an Enabler; it is an initial step towards taking responsibility, expressing appropriate power, and asserting a client’s human rights. It has the wherewithal to shake off difficulties that hinder other parts of the personality and move towards pursuing personal goals. In the process of therapy, it offers an important resource which can intervene positively, shifting the impasse between the Seeker and Saboteur. The Warrior, when fully functioning, has the ability to stand-up to the Saboteur and can enter into a negotiation on equal terms. Where the Seeker might back off, or the Orphan feel immobilized, the Warrior stands its ground and fights the negative influences of the Saboteur with constructive strategies. However, due to past experiences, this aspect, the Warrior, is often dormant in the personality and in therapy needs to be brought into the light. This work can be done in a number of ways. For example, using rational methods of scrutinizing how these aspects and archetypes operate can be very useful, but I believe that there is a more powerful approach to them which I will describe in the next section. Steve Mitchell
Campbell, J. 1949. The Hero with a Thousand Faces. London: Paladin Grafton Books. Campbell, J. 1989. The Power of Myth. Doubleday. Clarkson, P. 1993. On Psychotherapy. London: Whurr Publications. Cozolino, L. 2002. The Neuroscience of Psychotherapy: healing the social brain. Second Edition. New York: W.W Norton & Company.
Eliade, M. 1989. Shamanism: archaic techniques of ecstasy. (Trans.) Willard Task. London: Arkana. Gennep, A. van 1960. Rites of Passage. (T.) , M. and Caffee, G. Chicago: Chicago University Press. Goss P. 2015. Jung: A Complete Introduction. London: Hodder and Stoughton. Hillman, J. 1983. Archetypal Psychology: a brief account. Woodstock: Spring Publications, Inc. Hillman, J. 1975. Re-visioning Psychology. New York: Harper Perennial. Hughes, T. 1967. Poetry in the Making: a handbook for Writing and Teaching. London: Faber & Faber. Hope, M. 1988. The Psychology of Ritual. Shaftesbury: Elements Books Ltd. Jennings, S. 2012. ‘The Roots of Ritual Theatre: an anthropological perspective‘ in C. Schrader, ed. Ritual Theatre: the power of dramatic ritual in personal development groups and clinical practice. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Jennings, S. 1990. Dramatherapy with Families, Groups and Individuals: Waiting in the Wings. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
replacing with a new pair. This is why it is conscious work and without this new effort nothing can truly materialise except perhaps dependence on thetherapist; that is a negative unwanted position as it can stifle the whole endeavour of change. In many ways the whole aim of therapy is to help a client strive towards independence, self-responsibility and self-acceptance. It is by working towards these new values and exploring what impedes them that resilience can be rekindled and self-worth can emerge. But these have to be worked for. Therefore to counter the challenge of the Saboteur, and also honour the goal of the Seeker – the therapist will collaborate with the client to initiate another significant archetype that lays dormant in the depths of the unconscious: the Warrior. Archetype: The Warrior
Aspect: The Enabler
Recommended Reading
February 2016
Jung C. G. 1936. Collected Works Vol. 9. Princetown NJ: Bollingen. Jung, C.G. & Jaffe, A. 1989. Memories, Dreams & Reflections. New York: Vintage Books (originally published by Random House, Inc. 1963). Lewis, Amini, Lannon (2001). A General Theory of Love. New York: Vintage Books. Mair, M. 1977. The Community of Self. In D. Bannister, ed. New Perspectives in Personal Construct Theory. London: Academic Press.
Mitchell, S. 2016. ‘Ritual Theatre in Short-term Dramatherapy’ in S. Jennings and C. Holmwood, eds. The International Handbook of Dramatherapy. London: Routledge. Mitchell, S. 2013 / 2014. ‘What if our Knowledge of Healing is a Myth and other Forces are at Work’ in The Prompt, Dramatherapy newsletter. Mitchell. S. 2012. ‘Theatre of Self Expression: a brief introduction to the theory and practice of this ritual theatre form in clinical Dramatherapy‘ in C. Schrader, ed. Ritual Theatre: the power of dramatic ritual in personal development groups and clinical practice. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Mitchell, S. 1996. ‘The Ritual of Individual Dramatherapy’ in S. Mitchell, ed. Dramatherapy Clinical Studies. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers. Mitchell, P.S. 1997. ‘Personagrams: the exploration of our inner world through group sculpting’ in S. Jennings, ed. Dramatherapy Theory and Practice 3. London: Routledge. Pearson, C.S. 1991. Awakening the Heroes Within: Twelve archetypes to help us find ourselves and transform our world. San Francisco: Harper Collins. Rebillot, P. 1993. The Call to Adventure: bringing the hero’s journey into life. San Francisco: Harper Collins.
Roth, G. and Loudon, J. 1989. Maps to Ecstasy: Teachings of an Urban Shaman. Novato: New World Library.
Rowen, J. 1990. Subpersonalities: The People Inside Us. London: Routledge. Schore, A.N. 1994. Affect Regulation and the Origin of the Self: The Neurobiology of Emotional Development, London: Psychology Press. Stevens, A. 1990. Archetype: A Natural History of the Self. London: Routledge. Turner, V. 1982. From Ritual to Theatre: the Human Seriousness of Play. New York. PAJ Publications.
February 2016
RESTORING THE SOUL
An experiential workshop using story, play, metaphor and the arts to help you feel enlivened, enriched and reconnected.
There are times in our lives when, as therapists / carers our resources feel depleted. This workshop aims to replenish and reconnect to self. In a safe, creative environment, with laughter and play, we will introduce structures to help nourish you for the positive health of your professional and personal life. Saturday 5th March
10am–4pm
At COVO (5 Mins from Peckham Rye Station) £65
Facilitated by Yolande Anastatsi
and Susanna Kester
Please call 07980 578248 to book your place. (Spaces are limited)