April 2014
I have spent many years working with combat veterans. I have used different approaches to suit individuals, never having believed in the ‘one size fits all’ approach. I have found Eye Movement
Desensitisation
Reprocessing
(EMDR) (Shapiro and Solomon, 2010) to be particularly effective for addressing crippling flashbacks and managing pain. However I have often incorporated creative strategies, influenced by my dramatherapy background. I use more clearly identified dramatherapy as part of my PhD studies with veterans. SEEFaR CBT (Lahad, Doron and Press, 2010) has played a part for some, assisting them to reshape their memories and address the future. Turner’s Model of Crisis (Turner, 1967) has provided structure for the veterans’ journey of exploration. The use of texts such as ‘Waiting for Godot’ (Beckett et al., 2006) and ‘The Odyssey’ translation (Armitage, 2010), together with the Communiwell (Casson, 2005) and 6 Piece Story-Making (6psm) (Lahad, 1992) have taken centre stage. Sometimes I find myself caught between professional roles – Nurse/Dramatherapist/Farmer.
Sometimes it feels to me as if they are all interchangeable. That’s another story. In the last two years family and friends have been laid low with serious illness, at death’s door, dying. When I have felt embarrassed at having missed another dead-line, my PhD Supervisor, Ditty Dokter, has remarked ‘Life happens.’ She patiently encourages me to do what I can, when I can.
Life does happen and mixed with this has come new life. I almost delivered my newest grandson (an unplanned home birth on the farm). I was relieved when the paramedic walked in, as was my brave daughter-in-law. Later I realised the paramedic used to come to the farm for birthday parties when he was an infant! My most recent loss was that of my dear wise younger brother after many years of disability arising from an injury sustained at work. I have drawn parallels with ‘Waiting for Godot,’ the waiting and the flashes of humour within a hopeless situation. I have reflected on what my own personal Odyssey is. At times I have certainly felt shipwrecked and then recognised the ‘kindness of strangers.’
I tread the line (and the double professional registration fees etc.) as a Registered Nurse and Dramatherapist. I was thankful for my nurse training when my brother needed the most intimate of care delivered by me, his wife and son because some nurses at the District General Hospital failed to deliver even the simplest level of compassionate care to him and others. There were some simple acts of kindness, for example when equipment failed to infuse medication and a Charge Nurse in Accident and Emergency stood for 30 minutes delivering glucose through a large syringe. Other incidents underlined my own role ambivalence and that made me feel ashamed to be a nurse. For instance, when a doctor requested a patient be given an extra pillow only to be told by a newly qualified Registered Nurse ‘we ain’t got none’ (university education?!) So, what has this to do with dramatherapy? What can creativity offer when meeting with illness, pain and fear? Where are the Arts? I think they can be part of that essence that makes us human. It does not matter what culture you belong to, whether you have cognitive impairment or your age. Each of us has within our souls, an innate creativity. It may be suppressed or denied but it is there.
When my brother was alone and told there was no hope – a matter of days, he was desperate to return home. He called us, highly distressed at how the news had been broken. We were informed that it would take time to arrange his discharge as the weekend was approaching. He required special transport so it would take time to get approval and arrange. Time was not on our side. We withdrew to the waiting area (offstage). A creative response was needed in terms Journeying
on
What can creativity
offer when meeting
with illness, pain and
fear? Where are the
Arts? I think they can
be part of that
essence that makes
us human. It does not
matter what culture
you belong to,
whether you have
cognitive impairment
or your age. Each of us
has within our souls,
an innate creativity. It
may be suppressed or
denied but it is there.
April 2014
of flexibility, improvisation and rehearsal of the ‘what ifs.’ I stepped out of a hopeless, defeated role into a confident, problem-solving one. I negotiated a private ambulance, once I explained the circumstances; they were able to agree to provide this over the weekend, with no enhanced charge.
The return to his home was a challenge. Where we had hoped he would find comfort, there was pain, confusion and aggression (out of character and due to the toxins building in his body and brain). 90% of communication is thought to be non-verbal. The first night was a struggle, nursing skills and experience were needed but other traits were important too: role assertiveness; bodylanguage; calming but confident use of voice, matching his to try and break in to where-ever the true essence of my brother remained; all were important aspects. These may have occurred without any dramatherapy experience, and certainly happened automatically. The out-ofhours doctor agreed if the situation worsened again he would come out and sedate him but thankfully that was not needed. I doubt if negotiating with out-of-hours NHS services as a Dramatherapist would hold as much sway as a nurse. Yet perhaps a creative response whilst accompanying others on treacherous journeys reaches parts other approaches can’t. The following day the District Nursing team and G.P. visited armed with morphine and a syringedriver. Other family visited. Those of us involved with the performance of the previous night had some fitful sleep, rehearsing our roles for the coming night. A Marie Curie Nurse was added to our company and due to arrive at 10 p.m. That evening my brother was more peaceful, resting but acknowledging us. I spoke with him about child-hood memories and mischief. I read poems that we both knew from that time. I recalled his favourite book, Enid Blyton’s ‘The Magic Faraway Tree’ and we spoke of characters from there: Moon-face, Silky and Saucepan Man – he smiled. I said I would read from the book the next day. His wife and son came in. I said they may want to play some of his favourite music. Initially they were going to put some on his ear-phones but I suggested they may like to sit with him to listen to it together. I exited and when I returned later to say goodnight before the Marie Curie nurse arrived, he and his wife were cuddling, and enjoying the music. There was to be no encore and he died suddenly a few hours later.
My thoughts are, that though medical knowledge and skills are important in managing illness and pain, there comes a time, when the soul searches for something more. I think we met in that liminal space. The arts transcend the burden of our earthly selves, lifting us to somewhere else. The interpretation of this special place will depend on our own spiritual beliefs and perhaps we should accept rather than try to analyse what it is. Many of us will have experienced that ‘something else’ that occurs during a therapy session with a patient. Something suddenly feels as if it has shifted for no easily discernible reason. Perhaps like a hidden door suddenly opening or a treasure that has been there all the time, manifesting. I think this is where dramatherapy can take us, if we let it.
My journeying continues, like others, I lose fellow-travellers along the way. Some, I may barely notice as they branch off somewhere else. Others, whether in the role of friends, family or patients never depart fully. There will be traces of them on the journey: a fleeting glimpse, a smell, a song or a story, a place in the heart. One day, turning a corner or entering a new play, there they will be.
I conclude this article with lines from my brother’s favourite songs. These were sung as part of the funeral service. There is plenty for Dramatherapists to consider in those rites of passage, whichever, if any religion: Lord of the Dance
I danced on a Friday when the sky turned black It’s hard to dance with the devil on your back They buried my body and they thought I’d gone But I am the Dance and I still go on! (Sydney Carter 1963)
End of the Line
Well it’s all right, riding around in the breeze Well it’s all right, if you live the life you please Well it’s all right, doing the best you can Well it’s all right, as long as you lend a hand (Traveling Wilburys 1989)
Linda Winn
My journeying
continues, like
others, I lose fellowtravellers along the way. Some, I may
barely notice as
they branch off
somewhere else.
Others, whether in
the role of friends,
family or patients
never depart fully.
There will be traces
of them on the
journey: a fleeting
glimpse, a smell, a
song or a story, a
place in the heart.
One day, turning a
corner or entering a
new play, there they
will be.
April 2014
References
Armitage, S., 2010. Homer’s Odyssey. Faber & Faber.
Beckett, S., Barrett, S., Burke, D., Rigby, T., Fox, Z., Tydeman, J. and Goodman, N., 2006. Waiting for Godot. Naxos AudioBooks.
Casson, J., 2005. THE COMMUNICUBE: further clinical developments of a new therapeutic method. Dramatherapy, 27 (3), pp.15–18. Lahad, M., Doron, M. and Press, I., 2010. Protocol for Treatment of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder: SEE FAR CBT Model: Beyond Cognitive Behavior Therapy. IOS Press.
Lahad, M., 1992. Story-making as an assessment method for coping with stress: six-piece storymaking and BASIC Ph. In S. Jennings (ed.) Dramatherapy: Theory and Practice 2. London: Routledge.
Shapiro, F. and Solomon, R.M., 2010. Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing. 2010. The Corsini Encyclopedia of Psychology. John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Turner, V.W., 1967. The forest of symbols: Aspects of Ndembu ritual. Cornell University Press.
April 2014
April 2014
April 2014
April 2014