March 2014
BADth Conference 2013
The conceptual synthesis
My therapist recommended I read A General Theory of Love by Thomas Lewis M.D., Fari Amin, M.D., and Richard Lannon, M.D. first published in 2000, which presented the science of emotions from a neurological perspective. In their report of the importance of the ‘limbic’ brain and how it interacts with the earlier ‘reptilian’ brain and later ‘neo-cortical’ brain, I found a conceptual revelation. Their premise that adult patterns of relationship are imprinted as a template in the limbic brain in childhood and that an individual seeks limbic resonance later in life explained why repetition of negative attachments become the norm, even though an individual, ‘neo-cortically’, cognitively, knew it to be negative. However, the power of the limbic brain over-rides knowledge in the neo-cortical brain. Further to this the individual feels affectively secure and safe in relationship that reflects early imprinting, whereas a relationship that offers something different can be experienced as too psychologically threatening. This neurological perspective I found in accord with Bowlby’s and Ainsworth’s position as well as Schore’s more recent psycho-biological studies within the discipline of Attachment Theory. But is it possible to make changes to so powerful early imprints in the limbic brain that unlike the neocortical brain is not open to rational discourse? According to Lewis et al, ‘limbic revision’ is possible. I quote: “Therapy’s transmutation consists not in elevating proper Reason over purblind Passion, but in replacing silent, unworkable intuitions with functional ones. Patients are often hungry for explanations, because they are used to thinking that neocortical contraptions like explication will help them. But insight is the peppercorn of therapy” (2001:179). Lewis et al, through their scientific studies bring the operation of change firmly into the biology of the human organism. This position is also rooted in modern scientific research as reported by Allan Schore who states: ‘A fundamental principle of my work is that any developmental theory must integrate psychology and biology… I have argued that no theory of human functioning can be restricted to only a description of psychological processes; it must also be consonant with what we know about biological structural brain development.’ (Schore 2012.1)
It reminded me of Teilhard de Chardin’s remarkable ‘The Phenomenon of Man’ (1965) where through careful analysis of the history of biology; he returned life of the ‘spirit’ back into the body and advocated the evolution of consciousness growing from those secular roots. This idea of the evolution of consciousness, taking place in this manner through biology rather than transpersonal intervention, had for me ‘limbic resonance’ and I began to inquire what methods might trigger “limbic revision”.
The philosopher’s stone?
In the spring of 2012 I was engaged in a personal ritual walking around Uluru (Ayer’s Rock), What if our knowledge of Healing is a Myth and
other Forces are at Work?
(This is the second part of an article based on the talk given by Steve Mitchell at the BADth Conference 2013. Part One was in The Prompt December 2013 pp.22–27 “I think that what we’re all seeking is an experience of being alive, so that our life experiences on the purely physical plane will have resonances within our most innermost being and reality, so that we actually feel the rapture of being alive.” Joseph Campbell (1989)
March 2014
experiencing the profundity of this location, when from somewhere the notion of a chain reaction arose in my mind. It was truly a moment of ‘Poiesis’! As something that was not there before, surfaced, and fell into place. My personally defined ritual traversing Uluru, the effort of this ordeal in the hot mid-day sun in the Australian outback (40+ degrees), the creative intention in me to complete this task, gave release to a force that I experienced as uplifting, and in this state the notion of Numinosity, Physis, and Poiesis operating as a triumvirate of fine actions imprinting new limbic revisions in the brain came into my consciousness. Previous to my visit to Oz I had been examining the Greek notion of Physis which is defined by the Oxford English Dictionary as: (1) the principle or concept of growth and change in nature, (2) nature considered as the source of growth and change (3) something that grows or develops. It was the Greek philosopher Zeno, who first identified Physis as the source of nature that strives to grow and perfect itself as an inherent psychological aspiration. It has been affiliated with Henri Bergson’s concept of “vital élan” as the essence of the life force. My evolving hypothesis is that Physis when triggered is an agent that materializes and is not only an uplifting experience, like a Peak Experience, but unlike that state, that is momentary and fades into diminishment, Physis has the power to change brain chemistry. Ernest Rossi, a therapist and researcher, gives certain validity to this view. He states: “Current neuroscience research implies that psychobiologically arousal during creative experience in psychotherapy as well as the arts, sciences, and spiritual practices can modulate gene expression, protein synthesis, and brain plasticity.” (2005 p.18). This alteration in previous ‘limbic’ and ‘neo-cortical’ patterning enables the functions I have outlined of Poiesis acting upon the psyche and creating new configurations that are chemically anchored in our brain chemistry and electro-patterns, provoking not only new cognitions but also deep affective well-being. Conclusion
My theorem that Numinosity, Physis and Poiesis function within the human organism when engaged in psychological change is also similar to the metaphor of an individual going through the gears when driving their chosen vehicle. We choose our car, get in and turn on the engine. This equates to the choice of therapist and therapy. The car-driver moves off in first gear, and will then change up into second. This engine shift parallels a client achieving the necessary rapport with the Dramatherapist. The driver will now face effort or the wish to increase acceleration so changes up into third gear. This parallels the client’s endeavour and creative intention when facing the first hurdles engendered by therapy (often the appearance of the client’s Saboteur). As this is grappled with and if overcome fourth gear becomes possible. This gear, psychologically, represents the entrance of Numinosity: a fine human energy that can not only be viewed as increased motivation and determination to surmount overwhelming obstacles, but also the dynamics of Numinosity is a key to creating the circumstances for conscious transformation. The car driver is now ready to change gear once more, into fifth. This equates with Numinosity giving birth to Physis. A state which not only rekindles the resilience of a client’s ‘First Nature’ beyond what Campbell has called the learnt “thou shalts” of the developmental life span, but it also enables new pathways to be etched into the brain’s neurological “placidity”. The final sixth gear, which is activated by Physis, is Poiesis. This mechanism due to the changes created by Physis “calls forth something that was not there before” (Cox and Theilgaard 1987) and in so doing, enable what Lewis, Amini and Lannon (2001) scientifically advocate as ‘limbic revision’.
Finally, it must be said, that the evolving hypothesis I am attempting to outline here, defining the operations of Numinosity, Physis and Poiesis, are invisible. Similarly to the Eastern concept of the Tao, to name them, to try and pin them down, evades them! This is a situation that is scientifically and academically difficult, but in some way humbles our humanity into having to be open rather than closed or fixed, and to have the awareness of a ‘bent knee’ to the mysteries of nature that are still elusive to our present level of intelligence.
Case study
The client I am going to describe has given me formal written permission to present the details of her case, but also following codes of ethics I am going to refer to by a pseudonym Anna.
Anna presented in a powerful, very intelligent and formidable manner, but also in despair in her late thirties. She had been a high flier in her profession achieving the parental achievements that were now internalized as her Ego Ideals – Campbell’s ‘thou shalts’. Past achievements had included being a member of a government think tank; she had been respectably married and had a child; she had taught in schools and had been a Head of Department, before a series of devastating incidents suddenly “pulled the rug” from underneath her and she fell into melancholia. These included a significant bereavement, divorce and losing her job; she was no longer ambulant and had to walk on crutches. Now depressed, hostile, and angry, only the love for her child kept her from suicide. She felt alone, abandoned, helpless and without hope. She was also scathing about previous clinicians she had seen and dismissed, for what she viewed as their inadequate short-comings. The dramatherapy assessment became a testing experience for Anna. Normally I see a new client for an initial meeting, followed by four practical sessions where I gradually introduce them to action methods. The client commits to each session in turn before having to make a decision to engage in BADth Conference 2013
March 2014
dramatherapy treatment. This did not work for Anna. One problem was a need not to be rejected and the assessment sessions were exacerbating this difficulty. When this was voiced in our second session I think she was surprised when I suggested we throw-out the usual assessment procedure and make our minds up whether to proceed to the twenty sessions of treatment that day, adding that I would be happy to work with her, if she was with me. To my surprise she agreed to dramatherapy treatment. This flexibility with the assessment demonstrated ‘listening to her’ and my willingness to be flexible, collaborate rather than require her to fit in with my fixed procedure. This I believe was a significant factor, along with the fact that I also stood up to her “blustering” postures. It began to create that ‘limbic resonance’, the precursor of a constructive therapeutic alliance. It is also quite normal that the first phase of short-term dramatherapy sees the entrance of an archetype of The Orphan: a figure or quality that personifies the client’s desolation. This anguish needs to be listened to, accepted for what it is and the Dramatherapist must not be tempted at this stage to do any more than contain it through offering appropriate tender loving care – and this must be genuinely given, otherwise the client will experience the therapist as posturing empathy and perhaps, as Anna had with previous therapists, feel patronized rather than the compassion that comes from what Rogers defined as authentic “unconditional regard”. So it was for Anna; she would come to the sessions full of pain, hurt, irritation, frustration and anger and simply need the time of the session to share her internal torment. The Dramatherapist needs to let any thematic development go and simply be there, knowing that this too is a significant therapeutic strategy which begins to develop the alliance to internalizing the archetype of The Caregiver: a figure when internalized is experienced as unconditional love and in so doing the psyche begins to develop a more robust self. This ‘orphan’ phase was followed by an impasse and into this I brought the ‘Stories through the Life Span’ exercise (see appendix) explaining to Anna that working at a rational level, though helpful, is only half the job and that if the purpose of short-term dramatherapy is to successfully sow seeds in the psyche which will move towards rekindling self-reliance, we needed to work in a more oblique manner employing positive metaphors and symbols from stories; to select and animate a character from a story would help through osmosis to work similarly to a poultice bandage on her psyche and draw out her own affirmative qualities that currently may be dormant and needed restitution. She understood this and went home to fill in the chart. Due to my annual leave a fortnight passed before the next session. When we reconvened and sat for our usual ritual opening, check-in and business, she began by making a disclosure stating that she had an ambition to become a counsellor and did I think her stupid? My genuine response was to state that following her own therapy I thought she could have the ability to be a brilliant counsellor and I whole heartedly supported her ambition. My genuine response to her disclosure moved the therapeutic alliance forward. We then turned to her story chart, which due to her literary sophistication, I had expected her list to be formidable classics from literature. There were some but the overwhelming majority were Shaftsbury Avenue musicals! The one she chose to work with was Lionel Bart’s Oliver and the character of Nancy.
In the following session her ‘intentional creativity’ was within the ritual structure of a session, and to ignite Numinosity and its companions Physis and Poiesis, she brought to a session a recording of the musical, Oliver, and uneasily stood behind a chair in the room’s Work Area. Here, with determination she went beyond her comfort zone and sang Nancy’s song. This was an achievement in itself and I congratulated her artistic rendition while at the same time suggesting it could be improved and the way to do this was to really immerse herself in the character of Nancy. I suggested that she read the libretto and find out as much as she could about the character, to supplement this reading by returning to Dickens’s and gleaning from the book any background material the author presents either in descriptive passages, through what other characters say about her, or from any part of the narrative. She left the session full of purpose. It is not uncommon for the archetype of the saboteur to enter at this time; this archetype attempts to impede therapy in many subtle and diverse ways. Therefore when she arrived at the session the following week in an emotional state I was not surprised. The focus of her account was a delay in her hoped for knee operation and she was both angry with the doctors and feeling hopeless. However she told me that she had completed her out of session task compiling Nancy’s history but wasn’t up to working on that today. When the saboteur enters therapy I have discovered that there are two important It is also quite
normal that the
first phase of
short-term
dramatherapy
sees the entrance
of an archetype of
The Orphan: a
figure or quality
that personifies
the client’s
desolation. This
anguish needs to
be listened to,
accepted for what
it is and the
Dramatherapist
must not be
tempted at this
stage to do any
more than contain
it through offering
appropriate tender
loving care.
BADth Conference 2013
March 2014
approaches the Dramatherapist needs to attend to: first, accepting the issue in reality with ‘unconditional regard’ that is disturbing the client; second, when this has been initially contained, to only then transpose the issue and find another character in the story to represent this development. I explained this to Anna and once more she could comprehend and the session ended with her stating that she would give this some thought. There was a two week break as I always take annual leave to watch Wimbledon on TV and when I can visit SW11. When Physis is touched in a session and Poiesis takes place it is not uncommon for work to take place outside of sessions, the sessions themselves being the catalyst and the holding container for a client as both implicit and explicit memory is reconfigured. A client can be carried away with new enterprises or find their new emerging world view as strange as wearing in a new pair of shoes. When I returned from my holiday and met Anna, she sat in her chair grinning like a satisfied Cheshire cat. When I asked her ‘How she had been during the break?’, it was her turn to pull the rug from underneath me. She informed me that she had made major changes. She had decided to take up a counselling and psychotherapy course in the south of England. She had not only enrolled on the course, but found a new school for her daughter and a house to rent and was moving back to her home county in three weeks!
It is normal not to encourage major life changes in a client’s life during a process of therapy as the process can generate a loosening of previously held beliefs and a client might take flight into new ones, which when given more time to balance the psyche, can be regretted. In Anna’s case I also had to consider whether a manic component of depression was coming to light. Yet, Anna had presented me with a ‘fait accompli’ and it was one of those moments in therapy, where what the therapist might think has to be superseded by following the client. This was my clinical judgement based upon both her delivery of the news and what had previously taken place within dramatherapy, where before my eyes she had moved from a place of hopelessness and despair, to risking a therapeutic alliance with me and through the implicit dramatic ritual of personifying Nancy’s energy, one she saw as a persona that was affirmative, courageous and compassionate. She had ignited Numinosity that in turn had opened the portal to Physis, and Poiesis had taken place. Due to Anna’s personality structure, her response was to make robust changes; selfreliance had been rekindled, and as is in her inherent ‘first nature’ she went on to make things happen practically.
Four weeks later we had our final session. She had sustained the psychological changes and was genuinely grateful for what had taken place in dramatherapy and looking forward to continuing her therapy as part of her training course to become a counselling psychotherapist. The fact that I knew that she would be continuing therapy as part of her training was another factor in my decision to support her dynamic changes. From the first I had respected Anna, even when she first arrived and was deeply hurt and hostile towards me – perhaps I saw part of myself – and I was deeply compassionate to the anguish she was then experiencing. My respect never waned and she helped me to consolidate at an intellectual level the clinical power of facilitating work as a Dramatherapist that goes beyond the rational mind, and to envision biological mechanisms that I have defined as Numinosity, Physis and Poiesis, a triumvirate of subtle forces that in their operations have the potency to transform and nurture wellbeing.
Steve Mitchell
References
Campbell, J. with Moyers, B. (1989) The Power of Myth, Canada: Doubleday.
Clarkson, P. (1993) On Psychotherapy, London: Whurr Publishers.
Cox M. and Theilgaard, A., (1987) Mutative Metaphors in Psychotherapy: the Aelion Mode. London: Tavistock Publications. Gennep, A. van, (1960) Rites of Passage, Trans. Vizedon, M. and Caffee, G., Chicago: Chicago University Press (Originally published Les Rites de Passage # 1909).
Halprin, A (1995) Moving Toward Life: Five Decades of Transformational Dance, [Ed. R Kaplan], London: University Press of New England. Heidegger, M. (2000) Introduction to Metaphysics, Trans. Gregory Fried and Richard Polt. New Haven and London: Yale University Press (Originally published Einfuhrung in die Metaphysik 1935). Hillman, J. (1975) Re-Visioning Psychology, New York: Harper Perennial.
Jennings, S. (1990) Dramatherapy with Families, Groups, Individuals: waiting in the wings, London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
BADth Conference 2013
March 2014
Jennings, S. (2012) ‘Theatre of Resilience – Ritual and Attachment with Marginalised Groups’ in Ritual Theatre: the power of dramatic ritual in personal development groups and clinical practice. [Ed. C. Schrader], London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Jung, C. 1973. C.G. Jung Letters, Selected, [Ed. G. Adler with A. Jaffé] 2 vols, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Kelly, G. (1955) The Psychology of Personal Construct Theory (vol.1&2), New York: Norton. Lewis, T., Amini, F., Lannon, R. (2001) A General Theory of Love, New York: Vintage Books. Maslow, A. (1954) Second edition, Motivation and Personality, London: Harper & Row Publishers.
Maslow, A. (1970) Religions, Values, and Peak Experiences, New York: Penguin. Mitchell, S. (2012) The Significance of Ritual Theatre in Healing and (Drama) Therapy: the essential functions of Numinosity, Physis and Poiesis, paper given at the University of Aberystwyth’s international conference Ritual / Action / Performance.
Mitchell. S. (2012a) ‘Theatre of Self Expression: a brief introduction to the theory and practice of this ritual theatre form in clinical dramatherapy’ in Ritual Theatre: the power of dramatic ritual in personal development groups and clinical practice. C. Schrader, ed. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Mitchell, S. (2003) ‘The need to make adaptations to inspirations when working clinically as a Dramatherapist or how Paul Rebillot’s work gave rise to the theatre of self-expression a ritual theatre form of dramatherapy’ in The Prompt, the magazine
of
the
British
Association
of
Dramatherapists, winter 5-7.
Mitchell, S. (1998a) ‘Reflections on dramatherapy as initiation through ritual theatre,’ in Arts Therapy Process, (Ed. A. Cattanach), London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Mitchell, S. (1998) The Theatre of SelfExpression: seven approaches to an interactional form of ritual theatre for Dramatherapists, The Journal
for
the
British
Association
for
Dramatherapists, (spring 1998). Mitchell, S. (1996) ‘The Ritual of Individual Dramatherapy’, in Dramatherapy Clinical Studies [Ed. S. Mitchell], London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Mitchell, S. (1993) ‘The Dramatherapy Venture Project’, in The Handbook of Dramatherapy. S. Jennings, A. Cattanach, S. Mitchell, A. Chesner, and B. Meldrum. London: Routledge. Mitchell, S. (1992) ‘Therapeutic Theatre: a Paratheatrical model
of
dramatherapy’
in
Dramatherapy Theory and Practice (Vol. 2) S. Jennings, ed., London: Routledge. Rogers, C. (1951) Client Centred Therapy, (1999 reprint) London: Constable.
Rossi, E. (2005) ‘Creativity and the Nature of the Numinosum: the psychological genomics of Jung’s transcendent function in art, science, spirit, and psychotherapy’ in the Journal of Archetype and Culture. 72. Also at Google accessed 2011, Key Papers.
Schore, A.N. (2012) The Science of the Art of Psychotherapy, New York: W.W. Norton & Company.
Teilhard du Chardin, (1965) The Phenomenon of Man (Trans. B. Wall), London: Fontana Books (originally published ‘Le Phénomène Human’ 1955).
Turner, V. (1982) From Ritual to Theatre: The Human Seriousness of Play, New York: PAJ Publications.
Appendix
Positive Qualities Chart
The client fills in this form to elicit, through their projections on to others, existing or latent affirmative persona qualities in their own psyche. Step One: fill in the name of the subject selected in the first column (this preferably is someone they know or have known – if not someone from public life).
Step Two: in columns 1–3 identify the specific affirmative quality associated with the subject chosen.
Step Three: in the fifth column select one important quality associated with the subject from the previously three selected.
Step Four: when the form is complete, select from the ‘Leading Personality’ column four affirmative qualities the client would like to bring into their own life, through experimenting with these traits by inhabiting them in their chosen ‘Warrior’ character – selected from a work of fiction. These positive character traits will then be animated as core components of that character’s persona, in so doing creating a personal connection to the character.
It is normal not to
encourage major life
changes in a client’s
life during a process
of therapy as the
process can
generate a
loosening of
previously held
beliefs and a client
might take flight into
new ones, which
when given more
time to balance the
psyche, can be
regretted.
BADth Conference 2013
March 2014
1.
Fictional
Childhood
Hero
2.
Film Star
(male)
3.
Film Star
(female)
4.
Animal
5.
Significant
Person
6.
Adventurer
7.
Teacher /
Mentor
8.
Fictional
Character
(male)
9.
Fictional
Character
(female)
10.
Historical
Character
11.
Celebrity
12.
Another
Choice
Category
Name of
Affirmative
Affirmative
Affirmative
Leading
individual
personality
personality
personality
Personality
(subject)
quality 1
quality 2
quality 3
quality
in life
BADth Conference 2013
March 2014