What if our knowledge of Healing is a Myth

What if our knowledge of Healing is a Myth

The Prompt, December 2013 · page 22-27

December 2013

Introduction

I have worked in the NHS as a full-time Dramatherapist in adult psychiatry for over twenty-four years, (also for eighteen years a dramatherapy trainer that included nine years as course director at the Institute of Dramatherapy at the Roehampton Institute – now

the

University

of

Roehampton).

Additionally, for thirty years, I have been involved in annual action research into selfcultivation (personal

development)

with

Pathfinder Studio focused towards theatre making with everyday people. I am proud to say that I belong to the school of ‘reflective practitioners’ who engage in action research which is different from academic study. This school in modern times is led by such people as Brook, Fox, Grotowski, and Rebillot, to name a few and similarly to their inspiration I theorize from experience, by carefully appraising work done at the coalface. One of the major questions I have continually asked is: how do people change, and heal their psychological problems? I had found existing knowledge did not fully resonate with what I was observing clinically and began a search to discover, uncover, this dissonance between theory and practice. What I have discovered is an ‘evolving hypothesis’ to explain the subtle operations I have repeatedly witnessed taking place within the human organism: I have come to believe that ancient thinkers who have propounded ideas relating to Numinosity, Physis and Poiesis were very close to what the latest neurological research has recently revealed as biological brain function and that with a slight redefinition of these ancient concepts I can finally understand the mystery of the healing process.

The aim of this talk is to share with you in non-scientific language this ‘evolving hypothesis’ and how it came into existence and clearly explain the actions of these forces that I have redefined as Numinosity, Physis and Poiesis.

The background

My interest in change grew out of my work as a theatre director where I noticed that through my rehearsal methods, inspired by Peter Brook’s and Joan Littlewoods’s methods of stage production, actors and people I coached for drama school went through remarkable psychological journeys.

In 1977 at Dartington College of Arts where I took my ‘theatre’ degree I threw myself into the studies of psychology that were a central part of the course. I particularly felt an affinity BADth Conference 2013

What if our knowledge of Healing is a Myth and

other Forces are at Work?

(This is the first part of an article based on the talk given by Steve Mitchell at the BADth Conference 2013. Part Two will be in the next edition of The Prompt) “I think that what we’re all seeking is an experience of being alive, so that our life experiences on the purely physical plane will have resonances within our most innermost being and reality, so that we actually feel the rapture of being alive.” Joseph Campbell (1989)

December 2013

with Maslow’s vision of the ‘hierarchy of needs’ leading to ‘self-actualization’ and ‘peak experiences’. This Humanistic view was placed sharply in contrast when doing extra-mural training in psychodrama with the remarkable Marcia Karp. This approach I found along with many other “psychotherapy” models first focussed on negative issues implicit in an individual rather than promoting what was positive, and nurturing what was healthy that I had resonated with in Maslow. In the early nineteen eighties, following qualification as a Dramatherapist in 1981, I facilitated two dramatherapy groups of twenty sessions each at a day-hospital in Exeter. These two groups in 1984 and 1985 were to sow the ‘seeds’ that have developed into my current ‘evolving hypothesis’ concerning healing and change. The rationale for the first group was based on George Kelly’s ‘construct theory’ and his special techniques for group psychotherapy stated in volume two (1955) of his personality theory. His notion that people were “unique” I found a significant concept. At the time his theory and practice gave my aspirations for a dramatherapy group clinical veracity. The group titled Behaviour is an Experiment involved the group of eight outpatients warming-up to an enactment process that in essence involved experimenting through role rehearsal with future “anticipated” situations. The group ran for six months, lost two members in the initial phase, but all in all was successful in treating clients suffering from various forms of what was then termed neurotic disorders. At the close of the group, the clients all reported a greater sense of self-esteem and confidence. The appraisal of all the activities from the clients implied they got more from the creative warm-ups rather than the explicit work on their personal problems. They all reported, verbally, at the close of the group that the physical and voice exercises along with role-playing had initially been the most difficult, whereas sharing their problems and receiving group support had been valuable, as had taking turns setting-up personal enactments, but not as worthwhile as the activities in the first phase of the group, which despite their difficulty, they felt had been very beneficial. This feedback gave food for thought. It could have been rationalized in terms of group theory and opening group dynamics that confirms that the initial stages of groups are always the most difficult and sensitive times. However, my own observations of these introductions to the enactment process confirmed for me that engaging with these exercises was somehow at the heart of the later psychological changes.

At this time I was also mounting action research projects with the public exploring the Para-theatrical form developed by Grotowski Laboratory Theatre in Poland, where I was also fortunate to participate in a number of workshops led by different members of his company in Europe (1992, 1993). The quintessential essence of Para-theatre is an improvisational form that engaged its participants in a search for a “meeting”. This meeting animated the here and now dynamics between people in different environments, employing a theatrical vocabulary. To achieve this, a certain state of psychological readiness was necessary, participants need to “disarm” from traditional roles and “respond”, rather than act to ‘here and now’ stimuli in what Grotowski termed creating “active culture” rather than representing what Moreno had termed old “cultural conserves”. The search for ‘meeting’ was also a search for the expression of pure creative interaction between people employing elements of theatre art. The chief practical exponent of this work was Grotowski’s previous principal actor during what became known as the ‘poor theatre’ period, Ryszard Cieslak. The reports of his indoor and outdoor workshops particularly resonated with my previous studies of Maslow and I participated in a workshop he facilitated in Frankfurt called ‘Labyrinth’ that both changed and inspired my future work as Dramatherapist.

My second dramatherapy group at the day-hospital, taking account of the evaluations of the first group and my experiences of Para-theatre, was based upon a Paratheatrical premise as facilitated by Ryszard Cieslak (for details see my chapter in Jennings 1992). The group was called A Creative Workshop, meeting for twenty sessions with a psychological focus on self-image and interpersonal communication employing Para-theatrical exercises and improvisations. Sessions took place in the evenings. It began with everyone transforming the main room in the day-hospital into a work area that was illuminated by candlelight. At the centre of the space a circle of floor cushions was arranged for group members to sit on before a patterned cloth which had various percussive instruments laid around the group candle at the centre. The duration of the group was three hours, beginning with a percussive improvisation that led into a candle ceremony where each client checked in. This was followed by taught physical and voice exercises. The group then had a twenty-minute break, for tea, cigarettes or a bathroom break. The second half of the group was concerned with the group either proposing or inviting other group members to engage in what Cieslak had termed ‘Experiences’. These were structured improvisations with a subject that held some meaning for a particular client in their search for well-being. The penultimate activity was a closing candle ceremony. BADth Conference 2013

December 2013

Finally the room was returned to its daily functional use as a day-room. Once again the review of the group (that this time included the group members both filling in a written evaluation form as well as individual post-group interviews with a member of the day-hospital staff not involved in facilitating the group) were very positive. Most members of the group felt that they had gained in self-confidence, a couple reported little changes, but nevertheless had enjoyed the group. As expected the physical exercises were the most arduous, whereas the voice work had been enjoyed and the creation and enactment

of

the

various

proposed

Experiences, the group members had found profoundly moving. The appraisal of this second group highlighted the importance of nurturing creativity as a primary healing process in dramatherapy.

These findings appeared to support Jennings ‘Creative / Expressive’ model of dramatherapy (1990). Yet I found this model instinctively challenging, significant when operating at a supportive level with inpatients and with disabled groups. However when working with outpatients this model seemed to lack a certain clinical gravitas that had made my day-hospital groups effective. This fascinated me and I went in search of the answer to this dilemma, on the one hand believing rekindling creativity was significant while also feeling it was not the whole story. Over the next ten years the results of this study first gave rise to the ritual theatre form The Theatre of Self Expression (1992, 1993, 1996, 1998, 1998a, 2003, 2012, 2012a) and second to a radical re-assessment of the nature of healing and understanding of the vital operations of Numinosity, Physis and Poiesis in determining lasting change (2012). The road of questions and

practical revelations

The investigation took a number of different forms, first scrutiny of my clinical dramatherapy practice,

where

made

different

experiments and examined the outcomes in supervision. I also investigated it in my action research projects, at that time pursuing the contribution of Anna Halprin’s ‘collective creation’ with everyday people and her alliance with Gestalt Therapy (1995). In addition, I researched a theoretical review of creativity as viewed by Henri Bergson, Silvano Arieti, Carl Jung, George Kelly, Arthur Koestler, Sigmund Freud, Kay Redfield Jamison, Carl Rogers, Rollo May, Irvin Yalom and Abraham Maslow’s work on Peak Experiences, amongst others. From these investigations, and specifically training with Paul Rebillot, I began to focus on the structure of practice rather than its psychological impact. Halprin’s ‘spontaneous rituals’ alerted me to my fascination with rite of passage that Peter Brook had first brought to my notice and Rebillot’s marriage of ritual with experiential therapies which became an important key to the development of my ‘evolving hypothesis’. I realised that in the facilitation of Para-theatre, in its structure of open-ended ‘organic improvisations’, and accompanying processes of ‘disarming’, it was in fact related to the Polish culture and their religious immersion in ritual. At the same time in clinical work I observed that when a client faced an affective obstacle, what would often help them move to another level was engaging in an activity that required physical effort. This exertion enabled a release to take place that ventilated withheld energy in a form I initially viewed as catharsis. A clinical example from individual dramatherapy stunningly occurred when working with a client who presented with a condition that leaned towards a schizoid defence, not allowing her to express anger towards her father, who rather than overtly sexualizing her during adolescence had instead resorted to physical abuse. The legacy for this client was now in adulthood she was attracted to men who mirrored this sexual violence. However, she had psychological insight, and was motivated to work to overcome this problem. She had found the creative tasks in dramatherapy obstacles, preferring to make rational statements, describing her anger rather than showing it. Yet at the same time she wanted to change and work through these

inhibitions.

Collaboratively,

we

designed what I call in the clinical arena a BADth Conference 2013

I realised that in

the facilitation

of Para-theatre,

in its structure

of open-ended

‘organic

improvisations’,

and accompanying processes of ‘disarming’, it

was in fact

related to the

Polish culture

and their

religious

immersion in

ritual.

December 2013

BADth Conference 2013

‘Transitional Event’. This is a structure based on the schemata of ritual process. It incorporated into its overall construction pushing cushions, that symbolically represented her barriers, as a means of enabling her to overcome these limitations. During its animation she engaged with increased motivation, as she holistically set about the task, succeeding in her intention, to have the right to show her anger.

This client many years later told me that it had been participating in this activity that had become the turning point in her two years of dramatherapy. So what happened? I believe that by intentionally using physical and affective energy to overcome this psychological inhibitive symbolic threshold she managed to breakthrough to what Clarkson has called her ‘first nature’ (1993.104). By employing, intentionally, her creative process and great effort, she was able to go beyond her usual limits, guarded by what Campbell (1989.154) has called our “thou shalts” (or what in Gestalt can be called the ‘ego ideal’ of the person we ‘should be’ to please our primary carers, peers and cultural imperatives). By engaging with the ritual she experienced an internal release to a more robust self that had the ability not to be overwhelmed by previous events. A state of being that Jennings writes about in her chapter ‘Theatre of Resilience – Ritual and Attachment

with

Marginalised

Groups’

(2012).

This highlighted three important factors: (1) how ritual process could be a significant structural template, (2) the importance of a client employing creative effort to go beyond existing psychological self-restraints and (3) the psychological implication of Maslow’s concept of Peak Experience in facilitating change (1954, 1970).

The ancients had discovered that through the activities of rite of passage, consciousness could be transformed in the ritual candidate. The French ethnologist Arnold van Gennep (1960) identified what he termed the basic “schemata” of ritual as having three specific stages: ceremonies of separation, transition events and finally ceremonies of reaggregation, prior to returning into the community in a new status. The process of ‘separation’ can involve a number of different ceremonial activities that psychologically and physically marked crossing a threshold from normal community roles and spaces to that of becoming the ritual candidate. During the process of ‘transition’ the actions of a rite often followed the plot of a community’s mythology and required the candidate(s) to undergo ordeals that shifted everyday consciousness to another level, where, through the processes of ‘liminality’, union with their supernatural god was believed to take place. The final phase of ‘re-aggregation’ concerned relating what had been experienced at a transcendent level, through a process of ‘initiation’ to being reincorporated into the earthly life of the ritual candidate. This often engaged the returning candidate in moral instruction, emotional training and role rehearsal. The structure of ritual enables a dynamic to be triggered in the psyche: this I will re-define as Numinosity. Jung (1875–1961) employed the term ‘numinous’ in a letter to P.W. Martin (20 August 1945) stating:

“You are quite right, the main interest of my work is not concerned with the treatment of neuroses but rather with the approach to the numinous. But the fact is that the approach to the numinous is the real therapy and inasmuch as you attain to the numinous experiences you are released from the curse of pathology.” (Jung 1973.377).

In modern psychological research the therapist Ernest Rossi (2005) also employs the term Numinosum to denote a psychobiological arousal that generates gene promotion leading to ‘brain plasticity’. I believe that Numinosity differs

from

Peak

Experience

in

that

Numinosity is significantly located within the structure of ritual process and changes the biological status quo, something that may not take place with a Peak Experience. A distinguishing feature of ritual process as observed by (1982) is how it parallels its later development in theatre: there is a plot and its animation involves intentional creativity. Where ritual differs from theatre and has an affiliation with Para-theatre is that the ritual candidate does not immerse themselves in a

December 2013

character,

but

through

‘personification’

(Hillman 1975.1) of a persona is enabled to go beyond roles and touch a place that is egoless, what Grotowski called at his ‘Meeting with Grotowski’ in Cardiff (1981), “plugging into the great accumulator” and the peoples of early societies interpreted this as having contact with supernatural deities. Today we can discriminate between rituals that have a sacred intent and other forms of ritual that are secular, but in their inherent structural pattern offer a passage where what Jennings (1990) has termed ‘ritual / risk’ occur. It was in my work with Paul Rebillot that taught me of the importance of the Jungian ‘archetype’ as Rebillot believed that they became intense conductors enabling change at a psychological rather than transpersonal level. By identifying psychologically archetypal

forces

and

personifying these in ritual enactments a transformation can take place. It became my belief that this occurred through the Greek notion of Poiesis an ancient Pre-Socratic concept which links how poetic images generate a new particular meaning. The root of the word Poiesis is the Greek poieo meaning to “make” and in its current usage was first employed by Plato in his Symposium when speaking with Diotima about morals: “Such a movement can occur in three kinds of Poiesis: natural Poiesis through sexual procreation, Poiesis in the city through the attainment of heroic fame, and Poiesis in the soul through the cultivation of virtue and knowledge.” However, it was Martin Heidegger in his Introduction to Metaphysics (1935) who noted that the function of Poiesis was similar to that of “the coming out of a butterfly from a cocoon”. The transformative nature of Poiesis has also been validated by Murray Cox and Alice Theilgaard who, in presenting ‘The Aeolian Mode’ in their Mutative Metaphors in Psychotherapy not only view the mutation of metaphor significant in change but argue that Poiesis ‘takes central stage’ because “Poiesis may thus be a process whereby inner emptiness, initially experienced as insecurity, fragility, and hollowness, is gradually transmuted into affirmative depth.” (1987.24). For many years I believed that the mechanism of Poiesis was facilitated when ritual structure employed creative intention and personal effort which gave rise to what Maslow had previously termed a Peak Experience. That it was the psychological force of a Peak Experience that increased psychic robustness as well as facilitating a deep change of perspective in the client. This also illuminated an answer to my reservation in

Jennings

‘creative/expressive’

model.

In

pursuing

my

aims

as

Dramatherapist, I came to understand a client’s need to weave between the realities of their daily situation and creative enterprises. To simply work either at a rational level (similar to psychotherapy models) or only with metaphorical symbols was not enough. I came to realise that the work metaphorically needs to be placed in the context of the client’s life experience. If there is a combination of moving between the client’s actual world and metaphorical exploration, then in in-depth dramatherapy the client will understand the process and the metaphorical symbols have psychological potency to transform previously held preconscious views. To achieve these goals as a Dramatherapist, I also discovered that clinical work required following a number of identifiable steps. These steps gave rise to the seven approaches of the ritual theatre form of dramatherapy The Theatre of Self Expression. For a brief summary of these steps see my chapter in Claire Schrader’s (editor) Ritual Theatre: the Power of Dramatic Ritual in Personal Development Groups and Clinical Practice (2012).

Over a period of fifteen years work as a Dramatherapist and producer of self-cultivation through theatre making, this became my understanding and subsequent aim in work. This changed when I experienced a mid-life crisis that led me to re-enter therapy for a further six years. This therapy not only changed my personal life but held a key that revealed to me the intriguing functions of Numinosity, Physis and Poiesis in the therapeutic encounter that went beyond my previously held beliefs concerning Peak Experiences.

Steve Mitchell

BADth Conference 2013

In pursuing my

aims as a

Dramatherapist,

I came to

understand a

client’s need to

weave between

the realities of

their daily

situation and

creative

enterprises. To

simply work

either at a

rational level

(similar to

psychotherapy

models) or

only with

metaphorical

symbols was

not enough.

December 2013

References

Campbell, J. with Moyers, B. (1989) The Power of Myth, Canada: Doubleday.

Clarkson, P. (1993) On Psychotherapy, London: Whurr Publishers.

Cox, M. and Theilgaard, A., (1987) Mutative Metaphors in Psychotherapy: the Aelion Mode. London: Tavistock Publications.

Gennep, A. van, (1960) Rites of Passage, Trans. Vizedon, M. and Caffee, G., Chicago: Chicago University Press (Originally published Les Rites de Passage 1909). Halprin, A (1995) Moving Toward Life: Five Decades of Transformational Dance, [Ed. R Kaplan], London: University Press of New England. Heidegger, M. (2000) Introduction to Metaphysics, Trans. Gregory Fried and Richard Polt. New Haven and London: Yale University Press (Originally published Einfuhrung in die Metaphysik 1935).

Hillman, J. (1975) Re-Visioning Psychology, New York: Harper Perennial.

Jennings, S. (1990) Dramatherapy with Families, Groups, Individuals: waiting in the wings, London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.

Jennings, S. (2012) ‘Theatre of Resilience – Ritual and Attachment with Marginalised Groups’ in Ritual Theatre: the power of dramatic ritual in personal development groups and clinical practice. [Ed. C. Schrader], London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers. Jung, C. (1973) C.G. Jung Letters, Selected, [Ed. G. Adler with A. Jaffé], 2 vols, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Kelly, G. (1955) The Psychology of Personal Construct Theory (vol.1&2), New York: Norton. Lewis, T., Amini, F., Lannon, R. (2001) A General Theory of Love, New York: Vintage Books. Maslow, A. (1954) Second edition, Motivation and Personality, London: Harper & Row Publishers. Maslow, A. (1970) Religions, Values, and Peak Experiences, New York: Penguin. Mitchell, S. (2012) The Significance of Ritual Theatre in Healing and (Drama) Therapy: the essential functions of Numinosity, Physis and Poiesis, paper given at the University of Aberystwyth’s international conference Ritual / Action / Performance. Mitchell, S. (2012a) ‘Theatre of Self Expression: a brief introduction to the theory and practice of this ritual theatre form in clinical dramatherapy’ in Ritual Theatre: the power of dramatic ritual in personal development groups and clinical practice. C. Schrader, ed. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers. Mitchell, S. (2003) ‘The need to make adaptations to inspirations when working clinically as a Dramatherapist or how Paul Rebillot’s work gave rise to the theatre of self-expression a ritual theatre form of dramatherapy’ in

Dramatherapists, winter 5-7. Mitchell, S. (1998a) ‘Reflections on dramatherapy as initiation through ritual theatre,’ in Arts Therapy Process, (Ed. A. Cattanach), London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers. Mitchell, S. (1998) The Theatre of Self-Expression: seven approaches to an interactional form of ritual theatre for Dramatherapists, The Journal for the British Association for Dramatherapists, (spring 1998). Mitchell,

S.

(1996)

‘The

Ritual

of

Individual

Dramatherapy’, in Dramatherapy Clinical Studies [Ed. S. Mitchell], London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers. Mitchell, S. (1993) ‘The Dramatherapy Venture Project’, in The Handbook of Dramatherapy. S. Jennings, A. Cattanach, S. Mitchell, A. Chesner, and B. Meldrum. London: Routledge.

Mitchell, S. (1992) ‘Therapeutic Theatre: a Para-theatrical model of dramatherapy’ in Dramatherapy Theory and Practice (Vol. 2) S. Jennings, ed., London: Routledge. Rogers, C. (1951) Client Centred Therapy, (1999 reprint) London: Constable.

Rossi, E. (2005) ‘Creativity and the Nature of the Numinosum: the psychological genomics of Jung’s transcendent function

in

art,

science,

spirit,

and

psychotherapy’ in the Journal of Archetype and Culture. 72 . Also at Google accessed 2011, Key Papers. Schore, A.N. (2012) The Science of the Art of Psychotherapy, New York: W.W. Norton & Company. Teilhard du Chardin, (1965) The Phenomenon of Man (Trans. B. Wall), London: Fontana Books (originally published ‘Le Phénomène Human’ 1955). Turner, V. (1982) From Ritual to Theatre: The Human Seriousness of Play, New York: PAJ Publications. BADth Conference 2013

More posts

edition Diary Dates

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 32-33 DIARY DATES 2023 January 2023 Closing date for the BADth Gordon Wiseman Trust Fund. Details in Members’ area.…

The Prompt – final

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 22-31 Dear Jane, As a long-standing supporter of the publication, I write this open letter to thank you for…

people-caused climate destruction A Farewell Scenario

The Prompt, December 2022 · by EXCLUSIVE TO ARTS THERAPISTS · page 17-21 A FAREWELL SCENARIO 1996–2022 Scenario Arts in Personal Development was founded in…
account android arrow-alt-circle-down arrow-alt-circle-left arrow-alt-circle-right arrow-alt-circle-up arrow-down arrow-left arrow-right arrow-up author bars behance blogger bluesky buffer caret-down caret-left caret-right caret-square-down caret-square-left caret-square-right caret-square-up caret-up cart-menu-1 cart-menu-2 cart-menu-3 cart-menu-4 categories chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right chevron-up clock close comments cookies copyright coupon-discount date-modified date-published discord double-arrows-down double-arrows-left double-arrows-right double-arrows-up dribbble envelope-open envelope eye facebook fax flickr foursquare github gmail google-drive grid-view hashtag hollow-ring homepage instagram ios level-down-alt level-up-alt line link linkedin list-view login logout long-arrow-alt-down long-arrow-alt-left long-arrow-alt-right long-arrow-alt-up mastodonmedium messenger mobile-menu mobile phone pinterest place qq quote-left quote-right quotes reading-time-hourglass reading-time-stopwatch reddit rss scroll-to-top search shazam shopping-bag shopping-cart side-panel-opening-2-left side-panel-opening-2-right side-panel-opening-left side-panel-opening-right skype slack small-arrow-down small-arrow-left small-arrow-right small-arrow-up sms snapchat soundcloud spinner spotify stackoverflow sync telegram threadstiktok times-circle tinder trello tripadvisor tumblr twitch twitter viber vimeo vine vkontakte website wechat whatsapp windows wishlist xing yelp youtube zoom