December 2013
Dramatherapists are already using technology in their services to clients in a number of ways. However, we need to state some fundamental difficulties we have with this agenda: Arts Therapists have repeatedly re-iterated at AHPF Meetings and NAHPIST Workshops that there are issues of disparity between considerations of Physical Health and Mental Health that have not been sufficiently addressed. There are strongly felt concerns we have within the British Association of Dramatherapists as to the appropriateness or not of aspects of electronic recordkeeping in the manner envisaged. These concerns are informed by the following: The embodied/performative/psychological nature of Dramatherapy practice depends on face-to-face intervention between therapist and client and needs to incorporate both pretherapy assessments and post-therapy evaluations; a minimum of technology is used so that it doesn’t get in the way of and contaminate the therapeutic relationship – unless the technological medium is substantive to the form and process of the therapy delivered – video playbacks, music recordings, voice and speech taping etc. The sensitivity to Confidentiality and Trust which is the fundamental psychological basis of the therapist/client relationship and which impacts on the treatment may be jeopardized; Substantial amounts of our work are with people with severe to mild LD who often have complex physical and mental health needs – communication with such clients via electronic means (e.g., email or phone) is very limited if not impossible; Due to the confidential and often sensitive nature of client information, emails and phone calls with parents/carers are not always appropriate;
The disturbing and anti-therapeutic impact that the use of electronic records and the remote accessibility of these records could have on clients (e.g., those with psychotic/schizophrenic conditions) – whether or not there are secure mechanisms in place to ensure safety and confidentiality; Uploading drawings, stories and maps of clients’ ordered objects, pictorial symbols or words may not be acceptable to them and the necessary projective work would be inhibited if there was a chance that someone other than the therapist and client might view them (e.g., in Early Intervention Psychosis).
However, our members are already engaging positively with technology and tele-health in a number of ways:
Members working within NHS Posts:
Contact with clients by landline and mobile telephone, email and text message – but not for delivery of therapy sessions which need to be face-to-face; Contact other professionals by landline and mobile telephone, email and text message; Send confidential information through nhsmail (nhs.net addresses); Store letters, reports etc. on secure computer drive;
Access general information e.g., meeting minutes on secure shared drive; Use ipad with clients to help in psycho-educational work; Current usage of technology
in the delivery of
Dramatherapy services
(Collated by Bruce Howard Bayley, BADth ELO, from members responses and presented to the AHPF sub-group at the meeting with Dan Poulter, MP for Central Suffolk and North Ipswich)
December 2013
Use “Framework” a package which is only connected to social workers, mental health workers which all professionals can see and alert others. Doctors, Police send information to social workers to put on clients files; schools are not on it and so reports are printed and sent to them. All calls and emails are documented. This is not working as well as it is somewhat restraining and limited;
Where available, use Civica’s PARIS System (designed by mental health professionals to provide a fully integrated health and social care system) which is complex, but some services do not seem to consider it a good use of money to train practitioners to use the PARIS system considering that they wouldn’t use it enough to be independent and would end up asking for help and spending longer periods of time on it, given that therapists are paid to maximise client face-to-face time;
Dramatherapists working within the NHS are adapting well to RIO; The cross-discipline support and communication that becomes available through electronic record keeping is of value to Dramatherapists who can offer useful guidance to other teams as well as for their selves, and need to be kept informed of significant factors and progress in client development;
The use of electronic records by all will support input from Dramatherapists in criminal, ethical and legislative proceedings where valuable and necessary; As it is useful to record therapeutic notes as well as the therapist’s own relations to the client’s progress, it will be important to consider who will be given access to such sensitive information. It may not for example be appropriate for those without appropriate therapeutic or clinical training, for their own benefit and for the benefit of further communication with clients. It must remain paramount that any access given to other health professionals does not result in an inappropriate breach of confidentiality across differing parts of the health sector.
It is also important to consider the nature of therapeutic notes and how these should be recorded if the client is to have full access to their personal records. Once guidance and protocols are in place to enable broad and fair access to appropriate electronic records then dramatherapists will be able to play a key role in the development of many services. Adept in low intensity to high intensity therapeutic work, assessment and referral, the benefits are there to be welcomed.
Members in Private Practice or Freelance Employment:
Contact with clients by landline and mobile telephone, email and text messaging – but not for delivery of therapy sessions which need to be face-to-face; Notes and session records written and logged in electronically on password protected computers – some anonymized;
Contact other professionals by landline and mobile telephone, email and text message; Email other professionals and care workers after each session providing basic/generic information relevant to clients’ care; Store Reports (Pre-therapy, Mid-Therapy, End-Therapy, CORE Evaluation etc.) on a central ‘Shared Drive’ – a locked online database;
Use substantial levels of technology – Phone calls, texts, ‘whatsapp’ or ‘BB’ – in work with Young People which has come to play a substantial role in service delivery and outcome measures – acknowledging that young people have little or no routine and are not time aware and struggle with appointments;
Upload photos of artworks created by clients, and sometimes email these to them on special designated internet accounts – clients are aware of the level of risk involved in having insecure emails, but tolerate this is if there is no reference to the content of a session or anything confidential – just an image; delete records after 5 years; Use Skype for Supervision and Coaching but which need to be face-to-face; Video, films made with clients that have proved to be useful technologies for people with severe social anxiety (e.g., schizophrenia);
Recognize that computer generated imaginary worlds and avatars may help clients and be a positive development in Dramatherapy services in the future.