October 2013
“The Sad and
Lonely Giant”:
using dramatherapy with a FASD client As
an
emerging
dramatherapist
my
experience of working with a thirteen year old client with Foetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder (FASD) was both life-enhancing and humbling.
This debilitating condition is caused by prenatal exposure to the mother’s consumption of alcohol during pregnancy. Ethanol in alcohol is a toxin that crosses the placenta and damages the developing brain and internal organs. Awareness of this preventable condition is alarmingly low and unlike Autistic Spectrum Disorders it has been a relatively under-researched area in the UK. Nor, to my knowledge, has dramatherapy been much used with this client group. My own research into FASD came about as a result of my clinical practice placement in a mainstream secondary school. One member of the group was a boy with FASD, which I knew next to nothing about. During the course of the group dramatherapy sessions I became so taken with his responsiveness and spontaneity that it prompted me to approach him and the school to see if he would agree to do some one-to-one sessions. Happily, they agreed and we began our ten week placement, which became the core clinical focus of my MA dissertation (Liddell 2013).
The characteristics of FASD vary enormously ranging from mild learning difficulties to facial and cranial deformity, brain damage, growth deficiency, malformation of internal organs and a dysfunction of the central nervous system. FASD can lead to social problems including addiction, depression, suicide and homelessness. In school settings, where it is little understood, children can suffer from loneliness and bullying and ultimately expulsion. Whilst prenatal alcohol exposure is rated as the most common cause of learning difficulties and behavioural problems in children (Willacy 2010), not all children born to heavy drinkers have FASD (The FASD Trust 2013). The severity of the alcohol-related disabilities depends on the age and health of the mother, the amount of alcohol consumed, whether it was daily drinking or binge drinking and other possible health problems, as well as at what stage of the pregnancy
the
drinking
was
done
(Streissguth and Kanter 2002). Research by Kellerman (2010) reveals the effects of alcohol exposure which include socially inappropriate behaviour, as if inebriated; inability to apply consequences from past actions; difficulty with abstract concepts and making choices; difficulty with processing information and storing or retrieving information; short-term memory issues and moody roller-coaster, exaggerated emotions. All very similar to problems experienced by individuals on the autistic spectrum. Often these characteristics can be misinterpreted as willful, stubborn or lazy when largely it is in response to stressful or stimulating situations. This cocktail of behaviours causes With only
ten sessions,
my aim for
my client
was to help
him develop
awareness of
self and
others,
increase his
attention
span, as well
as enable
him to
express his
emotions
and become
aware of
emotions in
others.
October 2013
problems for the individual throughout their lives and are exacerbated if not properly understood. In fact, quite often they are misdiagnosed as Asperger’s or Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). Although my experience of working with FASD has been so far limited to one client, I was able to build up a more fully-rounded picture of the idiosyncratic characteristics that I had read about, and the whole process made me realise just how much dramatherapy could help individuals with FASD. With only ten sessions, my aim for my client was to help him develop awareness of self and others, increase his attention span, as well as enable him to express his emotions and become aware of emotions in others. From the previous group sessions I knew that he enjoyed playing and slipped easily into
role-play
heaven-sent
for
dramatherapist! However, his cognitive levels were immature for his age as was his physical stature and he had the typical FASD flattened facial features. In addition he displayed anxiety about time and had problems with fine and gross motor control. Also, his teachers told me that he was beginning to show disruptive behaviour in class. All of this was making him easy prey for bullies.
The intended therapeutic outcomes were to develop boundaries for self-expression; learn about personal space and about judging responses from others by role-play and witnessing behaviours of characters in certain social situations, and reflecting on these
experiences.
The
over-arching
intended outcome was for him to find better ways to cope with the ever-increasing demands made on him at mainstream secondary school. To do all of this in only ten sessions was, as I discovered, quite ambitious!
For the natural playfulness and spontaneity of my client it seemed obvious to use Sue Jennings’ (1994) developmental model of embodiment, projection and role-play (EPR) to revisit developmental stages of play and to learn the complex social skills, negotiating skills and mastering of social interaction (Cattanach 1994). In addition, I used Developmental Drama (Booker 2011) activities to foster process and for my client to learn through play, as well as helping him to build up a narrative sequence. I used the story of ‘The Beauty and the Beast’ which contains the basic emotions of ‘love/happiness’, ‘sadness’, ‘anger/frustration’, and ‘fear’. Building the story up slowly and introducing the characters the same way at the beginning of each episode, as well as recapping on the previous week’s episode, helped to develop narrative sequencing (Booker 2011).
The story offered my client the opportunity to take on roles and re-enact parts containing the emotions to be explored. When in role, I noticed that he became more articulate and could express emotions, thus informing me that he could identify with the emotion but it was too abstract an idea for him to reflect upon. To counter this he used his body map to draw emotions onto the part of the body where he felt it was being held. On several occasions my client stunned me by his depth of perception. He often took the role of the ‘giant’ and in one session I asked him why he thought the giant was angry when encountering Beauty’s father stealing a rose from the palace gardens. He replied, “The ‘giant’ was angry because he was sad and lonely.” This response showed me how much he identified with the giant and that he too felt isolated.
The principal achievement of this work with my client was nurturing and acknowledging his natural friendliness. By creating a joyous environment and having unconditional regard for him meant that he could safely be himself so that he could express his innate warmth and happy disposition without fear of any retribution.
It is my belief that dramatherapy is exceptionally suitable for working with fluctuating adolescent emotions, something that Susan Fleisher, the Executive Director of the National Organisation for Foetal Alcohol spectrum concurs with. As the adoptive mother of a child with FASD she says that because of their memory deficit, it is easier for people with FASD to express their emotions through drama. She went on to say she has not heard of any drama work being done with FASD sufferers (Fleisher 2013). The story offered
my client the
opportunity to
take on roles and
re-enact parts
containing the
emotions to be
explored. When in
role, I noticed
that he became
more articulate
and could express
emotions, thus
informing me that
he could identify
with the emotion
but it was too
abstract an idea
for him to reflect
upon.
October 2013
At the BADth conference in September, I attended the FASDs experiential workshop run by John Hazlett Dickinson which was informative and enlightening. I was heartened to find that there were at least two other dramatherapists who were working with clients with FASD but the word needs to be spread. Therefore, I would like to shout from the rooftops to dramatherapists countrywide to encourage more awareness and research into working with this client group. For more information on the condition of FASD, I recommend the following websites: www.nofas-uk.org/ and www.fasdtrust.co.uk/. I would also recommend reading The Broken Cord by Michael Dorris (1989) which is a heartwarming, inspirational and unforgettable story of a father’s experience of bringing up his adopted son with FASD and gave me a deeper understanding and insight into this unfortunate condition. Alice Lidell
Acknowledgement: I would like to acknowledge the advice and help I received from Kim Diment when writing this article for which I am very grateful.
References
Booker, M. (2011) Developmental Drama: Dramatherapy Approaches for People with Profound
or
Severe
Multiple
Disabilities,
Including Sensory Impairment. UK, USA, Jessica Kingsley Publishers Cattanach, A. (1994) ‘The Developmental model of dramatherapy’. In: Jennings, S., Cattanach, A., Mitchell, S., Chesner, A., Meldrum, B. The Handbook of Dramatherapy. Sussex, USA, Canada, Routledge, p.38 Dorris M. (1989) The Broken Cord. NY. Harper Collins Publishers
Fleisher, S. Executive Director of NOFASUK. Founder of the International FASD Medical Advisory Panel. (Personal communication, 28th May, 2013) Hazlett Dickinson, J. (2013) Changing Our Understanding, Renewing our Practice: Loving the Children of Pregnant Drinkers: The Potential of Dramatherapy as an intervention for People Living with FASDs. British Association of Dramatherapists
Annual
Conference,
Cirencester, September 8–10th Jennings, S (1994) ‘The theatre of healing’. In: Jennings, S., Cattanach, A., Mitchell, S., Chesner, A., Meldrum, B. The Handbook of Dramatherapy.
Sussex,
USA,
Canada,
Routledge, p.93
Kellerman, T. (2004) Behaviour Environmental Adaptation Model: The 15 BEAM Rules of FASD Behavior Management Also known as the FASSTAR Trek Model. Toolbox Parenting Tips for tough Kids [Online] Available from: http://toolboxparent.com/Articles/FASD/Beh aviorEnvironmentalAdaption.aspx [Accessed 12th December 2012] Liddell, A. (2013) A Harmony of Souls: A hermeneutic-phenomenological study
of
dramatherapist’s experience using dramatherapy informed by a developmental model of emotional literacy with a year 8 special educational needs (SEN) pupil with Foetal Alcohol Syndrome Disorder (FASD). Unpublished MA dissertation: University of Worcester, Southwest School of Dramatherapy
Streissguth A. Kanter, J. (2002) The Challenge of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome Overcoming secondary Disabilities. Third edition. University of Washington Press, Seattle and London The FASD Trust (2013) Mukherjee, J. (ed.) Consensus Statement Regarding the Recognition and Diagnosis of Foetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders Across the Lifespan in the UK: Development of Proposed UK Clinical Pathways. [Online] Available from:
www.fasdtrust.co.uk [Accessed 2nd April 2013]
Willacy, H. (2010) Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. Patient Plus Articles.
[Online] 2146, 21
Available from:
http://www.patient.co.uk/Search.asp?search term=&collections=Prof_Ref&x=14&y=6 [Accessed 20th November 2012]
October 2013
HCPC Registered Dramatherapist BADth Registered Supervisor Pam Marshall
Dramatherapist and Registered Clinical Supervisor
Offering individual dramatherapy and clinical supervision (individual and group) Over 12 years clinical experience in a range of settings: education, adult mental health and adoption Specialising in work with children and families, trauma, neglect and loss Based in the Lewisham area, SE London Student concessions available 07967 372627