August 2013
On May 17th 2013, The Royal Central School of Speech and Drama launched the report of their research on the Black and Minority Ethnic (BME) student experiences at Central (2012). This research was funded by the Higher Education Academy (HEA) and included 15 student interviewees from the three undergraduate degrees: BA acting, BA Theatre Practice and BA Drama, Applied Theatre and Education as well as 5 staff from these programmes and the Learning Centre. Due to funding restrictions, this could not be extended to graduate programmes, and thus to the programme of Dramatherapy. Central looked at previous studies of HEA and saw that there was an attainment gap of 18.3% between White and BME students. This is defined by the difference between those who attained a first class or upper second class honours. They compared this to Central between 2008–2011 and reached similar results. Also, the BME student population shows a higher drop rate of 5%, compared to the White students at 2%. As quoted in the report, Singh (2011, p. 11) suggests a number of potential causes for this lower attainment: racism, [institutional/direct/indirect] segregation, low teacher expectations, lack of role models, under-valuing/under-challenging, discriminatory practice, student and staff attitudes and expectations. The research also considers how individuals may belong to more than one social group and how achievement may be affected by class, socio-economic factors and educational inheritance by parents (Reay, David & Ball, 2005, p. 11). The research findings touches upon a number of these. Although they noticed there was a large body of research already existing around the experiences of BME students, they found few that were conducted in drama schools. Thus, the overall intention of this research was to look at the BME student experiences, to; ‘listen and then to develop practice on the basis of the information gained’ (p. 8). Central also aimed to ‘improve and enhance the experience of BME students’ (p. 9).
At the launch, six speakers shared their responses to the report. This comprised of relevant professionals in educational roles from this university and elsewhere, they were also authors on the subject, theatre practitioners and a graduate from the Applied Theatre programme. Here, I will mainly look at the report, the issues it raised, interviewees’ recommendations and I will refer to comments made by the panel when appropriate. Although most interviewees appeared to have a positive experience overall, a number of issues and challenges arose which affected their experience. As Central said ‘this should not be seen as reflecting negatively on the institution, as increasing knowledge of these experiences can only lead to a greater opportunity to improve the culture for BME students’ (p. 4). In looking at what Central could continue and/or increase, this included activities as in Black History Month performances, Black and Asian Alumni network events, opportunities to explore themes around culture and race, extra-curricular activities and the services offered by the university. While those felt the services were helpful, many did not realize the extent of the support that was available.
Suggestions? To re-consider the inclusivity of social events (i.e. alcohol free events, perhaps for Student Union to work with this), sources of support for students (i.e. raising awareness of services available in the university). Another point that was explored was people’s reasons for applying at Central. Interviewees often felt there was a lack of BME role models in theatre/drama schools and as quoted by Singh (2011), they mention that this lack is a potential cause of lower attainment in BME communities.
Suggestions? To continue to support the aspirations of BME people (i.e. to continue to monitor ways that Central attracts BME and seek ways to improve this), employ more BME teaching staff (and if there aren’t enough employed BME, to consider other strategies such as increasing BME visiting professionals). Patterns and Cellars
Although they noticed
there was a large body
of research already
existing around the
experiences of BME
students, they found
few that were
conducted in drama
schools.
August 2013
Interviewees often spoke about their feelings of isolation and alienation. Peer attitudes and behaviours also demonstrated a lack of awareness and understanding of cultural differences and a stereotyping around ethnicity. The majority of the interviewees also experienced racism. The graduate speaker on the panel related to this challenge. She wondered who’s responsibility it is to challenge the prejudicial comments. Lumpkin (1998), an Art Therapist who researched the experiences of Black Art Therapy students in America, found this similar feeling in her study. Students felt torn between feeling a need to make others more culturally aware, yet had a resentment towards an expectation that they were spokespersons for all BME. Another speaker on the panel, a BME theatre director said it is all our responsibility, in university like in the arts. Suggestion? To understand more about race and ethnicity (i.e. develop an e-forum or information source). The curriculum content also raised several issues. The graduate on the panel agreed with the interviewee’s recommendation to increase BME content to provide opportunities for BME students to relate and find the material accessible. In addition, the director and principal at the Academy of Asian and Ethnic Dramatic Arts said that he sees how the students do not know the arts of their culture due to their experiences in a UK education system, thus potentially inhibiting options in independent learning. Another member on the panel is a lecturer of theatre and she mentioned using role play to engage white students in the subjects of Black British playwriting and racial issues. Suggestion? To increase focus on cultural diversity, race and ethnicity. In regards to the staff experiences, it appeared that for some of them, ethnicity was less important than to the majority of BME student interviewees. Some also felt unequipped to tackle these subjects.
Suggestion? A clearer position on racism (i.e. a clearer zero tolerance, having specific staff available to discuss challenging experiences related to equality and diversity). The report will be distributed within Central and many will engage with it, particularly with the section on suggestions for improvements. Central’s Equality and Diversity Committee will monitor the progress and information will be added to Central’s website. As Lumpkin (1998) observes, there is a failure for Art Therapy programmes to reflect the cultural diversity of its host cities and this may reflect the lack of ethnic and cultural diversity in the faculty and field. With this recurring image in mind, I feel this research may allow us to reflect on our individual and professional roles within this frame. It may also allow us to question societal and institutional positions and the relationship between all of this systemic fabrication. Finally, it might enable Dramatherapists to notice how these dynamics arise in our interactions with clients and colleagues (or in those we witness) and may create possibilities for these patterns of inequality to be addressed. The report is available on the HEA website: www.heacademy.ac.uk
Sarah Bilodeau
Member of BADth Equality & Diversity SubCommittee References
Lumpkin, C.L. (1998). We Wear the Masks: A Study of Black Art Therapy Students. In: Hiscox, A.R., Calisch, A.B (eds). Tapestry of Cultural Issues in Art Therapy. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers pp. 221–228 McNamara, C., Coomber, N. (2012). BME Student Experiences at Central School of Speech & Drama. York: Higher Education Academy
Reay, D., David, M., Ball, S. (2005). Degrees of Choice: Class, Gender, Race and Higher Education. Trentham Books
Singh, G. (2011). Black and Minority Ethnic (BME) students’ participation in higher education: improving retention and success, A synthesis of research evidence. York: HEA Students felt torn between feeling a need to make others more culturally aware, yet had a resentment
towards an expectation that they were spokespersons for all BME.
August 2013