June 2013
From the balmy Mediterranean landscapes of Ancient Greece, the Gods and Heroes looked down upon us on a chilly March Saturday in London’s Conway Hall. Their images adorned one of the usually bare walls, bearing witness to our journey of exploration at the joint BADth/Sesame Institute Workshop ‘Beyond Value – Evidencing the Unmeasurable’. Billed as an ‘experiential workshop’, Bruce Howard Bayley and Mary Smail began by asking each of the participants, drawn from all walks of the dramatherapy community, what had drawn us there. The answers were as varied as we were. I had been intrigued by the questions the flyer had posed – in essence asking how dramatherapists describe their beliefs and values in language that is heard and valued – as they chimed very much with my own research interests. How do we reconcile the tension between our implicit knowledge, “we know it works”, and the requirement to provide
explicit
evidence
of
measurable
outcomes to ‘the courts of doctor, academic or funder’? In raising this question we were also looking at our core identity as dramatherapists and how we find a language to express our inner creativity, the work of the soul that makes us what we are?
Bruce and Mary framed the day by drawing upon The Odyssey and in particular Athene’s mediating role between Gods and men. Athene has taken pity upon Odysseus and his long delayed return to Ithaca, his homeland. Having lost all his crew, he now languishes on the goddess Calypso’s island. Here she strives “to spellbind his heart with suave, seductive words/and wipe all thoughts of Ithaca from his mind” (The Odyssey, Book 1). However, Athene’s plea to the Gods to release Odysseus is heard and Calypso is commanded to obey, providing him with a raft and clothing but his ordeal is not yet over. The vengeful Poseidon brings about a storm to drown him. The seagoddess Ino comes to his aid, urging him to abandon raft and heavy cloak and wrap himself instead in her veil. Odysseus has to make a choice, relinquish all that he believes makes him safe – the raft, the cloak, even Calypso’s island – and trust to Ino’s Veil, so seemingly insubstantial, and her promise that with it he will come to shore safely.
As dramatherapists how do we reconcile the tensions between the different environments we encounter? Calypso’s Island – initially a place of refuge but one that can become a prison in which we are beguiled into giving up the struggle to find work; Ithaca – our place of origin – the wellspring of our creativity which gives us sustenance; Olympus – the home of the Gods who have power and authority, just like those who can provide or withdraw funding; Ino’s ocean – that liminal space between where we are and where we long to be. Do we have the courage and conviction to get there? Such is the metaphorical potential of working with a text like The Odyssey, that when we began work in small groups responding to each of the four environments, a fifth one emerged. The tug between Calypso’s Island and Ithaca was strong enough for one participant to create a sort of land bridge between the two, thrumming with tension. As dramatherapists, we can identify with Odysseus’s struggles to survive and to return to Ithaca – but he doesn’t do it alone. We looked Beyond Value
– Evidencing the Unmeasurable BADth/Sesame Institute Workshop: London 2nd March 2013 facilitated by Bruce Howard Bayley (BADth) and Mary Smail (Sesame Institute) How do we
reconcile the
tension
between our
implicit
knowledge, “we
know it works”,
and the requirement to provide explicit
evidence of
measurable
outcomes to ‘the
courts of doctor,
academic or
funder’?
June 2013
at the roles the Gods played and in particular that of Athene as advocate.
What does it mean to have an advocate and how can we locate and embody our inner advocate who will help us to confront those in power? Working initially on our own we were invited to explore these ideas, both internally and physically and then, in pairs, re-enact an encounter between Advocate and Authority. The power of this exercise was in enabling each of us in that room on that day to access and summon our Inner Advocate – a summoning that each of us can now re-call when we need to. During the plenary discussion we tussled with the tension between these ideas of the inner and the outer. It may be that Authority/the Gods don’t acknowledge what it is we do, “oh dramatherapy, it’s all arty farty!” but we must hold on to this inner conviction and sustaining belief in both ourselves and what we can achieve through the work we do. If we are disconnected from our own knowingness/ creativity, how can we help our clients to access and articulate their own knowingness for it is in that knowledge and understanding that transformation emerges? As dramatherapists, we have a knowledge base that is rooted in the imaginal but this other way of knowing, this gnosis, is one that is not wholly recognised in the legitimated discourses of the medical, academic, social policy-makers etc. So how do we speak to the status quo? Do we ally ourselves more closely with other creative arts professionals? Or with other health professionals? And if they won’t listen, perhaps, we are speaking to the wrong people!
Can we reformulate our research as ‘in-search’ by which we give place and authority to the inner world? In doing so how can we work with existing models of research? So the day ended with more questions, which was intentional as they will contribute to an on-going dialogue within the dramatherapy community that Bruce and Mary plan to continue. This snapshot of the London workshop cannot hope to present a full picture of all its richness and complexity but I hope it gives a flavour of the experience. Finally, we can all claim that we reflect in and on our practice, but what this day gave to me was a real sense of reflexivity-in-action; it was a day that was troubling, scary, illuminating and transformative. Just like dramatherapy! Kim Diment
… we tussled with the
tension between these
ideas of the inner and the
outer. It may be that
Authority/the Gods don’t
acknowledge what it is we
do, “oh dramatherapy, it’s
all arty farty!” but we
must hold on to this inner
conviction and sustaining
belief in both ourselves
and what we can achieve
through the work we do.