April 2013
Laying a single
white lily
a Tribute to James Hillman
I arrive a little late and slip into the back of the hall. The audience in the hall watches an elderly man, his hand bandaged heavily, speak about Jung. He recalls visiting the coffin of the great man with a single white lily, how he heard Jung’s voice speak to him “Go and do my work.” The bandage suggests he has recently been on an intravenous drip in hospital, but his voice sounds clear and strong. He explains with patience, warmth and intelligence how Jung’s approach to the psyche is still revolutionary because Jung found a way of meeting with his images in a way that allowed the modern mind access to the ancient mind and to the reality of imagination. The audience watching the video is there to pay tribute to this man, James Hillman, the psychologist who died in October 2011. Hillman’s best seller, “The Soul’s Code”, was about how we find our soul through our calling. I felt a calling to train as a dramatherapist. Once the idea called me, it wouldn’t leave me alone until I successfully applied. It wasn’t until I began to read Hillman whilst training that I began to understand the nature of vocation. Now, it is hard for me to imagine dramatherapy without Hillman’s goldmine of complex inspirations, his refusal to compromise with a psychology that is not poetic. Hillman gave me permission to re-think experiences that I harboured deep inside me: the magical reality of playing as a child, the passion and nihilism of adolescence, the ongoing need for a creativity that connects both to the contemporary world and to a deeper source within it. Perhaps I had begun to feel a little ashamed of my desire for a magical reality in the light of the serious problems of the world. Yet here was a man who wrote “the unconscious produces dramas, poetic fictions, it is a theatre”. (Hillman, 1983a:36) A man that advocated speaking to your images, to the daimons and angels in them, and listening to what they said back. A man who, all the time advocating an imaginative approach, described the psyche as a way of engaging with the world. He wrote of the world as anima mundi, the world ensouled through human experience, rather than psyche as caged inside a mind. Hillman spoke of soulfulness in therapy and life, and its deep source in psychopathology and suffering. “The new age is trapped in the light” he once said. “Psychiatry is trapped in the dark, inside the body and its mechanisms, and the new age is trapped in the light.” (Tarnas, 2012) Hillman gave me
permission to
re-think
experiences that
I harboured deep
inside me
April 2013
So, I went to pay my respects. Alongside James and his video were presentations by Jules Cashford and Mark Sabin. Mark spoke of Hillman’s great contribution to Jungian thought in releasing it from Jung and back to the psyche as image. He spoke of the freedom that comes from locating the archetypal in the image rather than in an unknowable archetypal source. It is this move that allows us to understand the image be it in dream, art, conversation, or indeed a moment within life, as the best way of understanding psyche and our nature. “Stick with the image,” (Hillman, 1983b:54) is Hillman’s best known dictum, and as Mark says this is a masterstroke, as it frees us to let our imagination speak, rather than interpret it. After lunch Mary Smail facilitated a Sesame enactment of the myth of Er. She described Hillman slipping in through the side door to watch a Sesame enactment wearing a baseball cap and yellow trainers. “Perhaps that is how soul arrives, slipping in through the side door wearing a baseball cap and yellow trainers.” Soul was one of Hillman’s favourite words, his work devotes much time to the importance of imagining psyche as soul rather than mind. From this basis, he argued, an imaginative approach can follow, as soul is an imaginative concept. The participants entered into the soul of this Platonic myth of the soul with soul. Hillman used the myth as a key to re-visioning a kind of psychology that relies neither on genetic materialism, nor attachment, but on the sense that each person has something unique within them that they have the chance to find only in the opportunity of their specific life. Another gift of his – to allow his readers to have the confidence to articulate ways of thinking about others that allows each person their own uniqueness and does not reduce them to either parental attachments or genes. The enactment took shape, the souls return home after death, their celebrations, their journeying on, their becoming enwoven with daimonic substance and finally drinking of the rivers of forgetting. For Hillman, death and soul are companions, as he felt that soulfulness often comes from the realisation of one’s life in the face of death. The mythic enactment captured this as it reached a crescendo of deep human movement and theatrical image making.
The participants de-roled and fed back their experiences of entering into this mythic journey. Those that had watched expressed their sense of being moved. It seemed apt that there was this soulful moment in this day in a play about the soul – Hillman was Sesame’s patron and soulfulness his watchword.
Following the enactment, Ean Begg gave an account of his personal memories of Hillman that will live long in my memory as a masterclass in raconteuring. He gave a personal flavour to Hillman, whose dislike of biography or his personal history was legendary (see his book “Inter Views” – probably also the best introduction to his work.) I enjoyed hearing the stories of his flaws and brilliance that allowed me to glimpse the man behind the numinous ideas. Ean’s ability to reminisce so honestly, humorously and without judgement allowed a new dimension of Hillman to appear, as a man who had faced great personal crises. “Perhaps
that is how
soul arrives,
slipping in
through the
side door
wearing a
baseball cap
and yellow
trainers.”
April 2013
After this, the audience was given space to read their favourite extracts from the man himself. There were passages on the imaginal, and the creative, from his magnum opus Re-Visioning Psychology. I read from his essay “the Soul of the World” (Hillman 1992) which speaks to us now as dramatherapists faced with an unprecedented ecological, economic crisis. The “hard” real external crisis of oil, dying coral, flooded rivers, empty shops, dismantled welfare face us. We as dramatherapists can only face this crisis with our “soft” “unreal” imaginative tools – our ability to dramatise, improvise and play. This can seem so little, but perhaps only through them we can begin to understand Hillman’s final gift – his articulation of the anima mundi – the world as ensouled and living and our images as expressions of the anima mundi rather than creators of it. The world becomes ensouled through our images, or rather we become ensouled through our relationship with our images. The world then becomes more soulful through us.
Hillman gave us so much through his writing. In many ways, his writing exemplifies Jung’s approach to the Shadow – there is something in that darkness if you approach it right. Nearly all Hillman’s books approach things we have cast in the shadows – betrayal, war, the daimonic, masturbation – and he finds the shadow in the places we have cast light – the belief in neverending psychological growth, reliance on finding the inner child for healing, psychotherapy as a way of feeling we can change the world, humanistic hubris. His shadowing of light and lighting of shadow enrich and free us from the tyranny of unrealised assumptions. Thanks to the Jung Club for organising this day, and to everyone who participated and was there. I am glad I went and grateful for the chance to lay my lily at the great man’s coffin.
Toby Chown
References
Hillman, J. (1976) Re-Visioning Psychology. Harper Collins: New York Hillman, J. (1983a) Healing Fiction. Spring Publications: Woodstock Hillman, J. (1983b) Inter Views. Harper Collins: New York Hillman, J. (1992) The Thought of the Heart and the Soul of the World. Spring Publications: Woodstock
Hillman, J. (1996) The Soul’s Code. Warner Books: New York Tarnas, R. (2012) James Hillman and Archetypal Psychology. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ZHbDIqz620
Nearly all Hillman’s
books approach
things we have cast
in the shadows …
and he finds the
shadow in the
places we have cast
light