February 2013
Dramatherapy and
Drama for Health
A working exploration of the relationship, distinctions, opportunities and risks for Dramatherapists who work in the area of drama for health Changes that are being brought about in the NHS, the developing third sector, and renewed interest in the arts as developmental activities, are all opening up new opportunities for dramatherapists, and hopefully, dramatherapy as a respected, well resourced and well used intervention for both medical and social conditions. Health,
Social
Care
and
Education
Commissioning bodies throughout the UK are working in collaboration with community artists, arts in education companies and arts and health organisations, opening up opportunities for these organisations to develop working practices, relationships and professional reputations within these fields.
Exciting Stuff.
Meanwhile, drama and psychology graduates invest large amounts of time and money on Masters Degrees in dramatherapy, often to find that there aren’t any paid posts out there in the world for them once they have qualified.
What’s the point? Why not just become a drama for health worker? What is the difference, between dramatherapy and drama for health anyway? Is a dramatherapist just an overpaid drama for health worker? Could a drama for health worker be employed as a budget dramatherapist? These questions are relevant to us, and we need to respond to them, and clearly define our role and purpose, if we are to survive in an ever more competitive world.
Two years ago, I graduated as a dramatherapist, and started a drama for health enterprise. We are just about to provide our first
dramatherapy
service
in
South
Staffordshire. Over the time we have existed, I have spent much time developing my own work style, and my own way of viewing the relationships
and
distinctions
between
drama for health and dramatherapy. The questions now that I offer for discussion, and give some brief responses of my own to, are: What is the relationship and distinctions between drama for health and dramatherapy? Should dramatherapists take up work as drama for health workers? And what are the risks, challenges and benefits involved? What is the relationship and distinctions between drama for health and dramatherapy?
Technically, dramatherapy is a specialist form of drama for health. Drama for health is a form of social intervention, as is dramatherapy; however dramatherapy can also be seen as a form of medical intervention. The features that set it apart from other forms of drama for health, are those that make it a very specialist area:
1.Dramatherapists are trained to use drama as a tool to bring about, or directly mediate, improvements in mental and physical health and wellbeing. Drama for health
offers
training
or
education
designed to enable the client to make life changes that will improve their mental and physical health and wellbeing. 2.Dramatherapy is safe to use with clinical and non-clinical groups, due to the fact that the dramatherapist is trained to provide a safe, client-centred form of Drama for
health is a
form of social
intervention,
as is
dramatherapy;
however
dramatherapy
can also be
seen as a form
of medical
intervention.
February 2013
drama intervention, and is able to work within the scope of the clients potential, perhaps offering challenges, but without the risk of alienating or traumatising vulnerable people. Drama for health, on the other hand, can be used with any group, but is offered as an education, or behavioural facilitation, rather than a therapy. 3.Saying that, whilst a drama for health worker cannot, and should not, attempt to provide any form of dramatherapy, a dramatherapist, can certainly provide drama for health interventions, as long as they are clear themselves of the distinction, and are not blurring the role/action boundaries of the two occupations. I would, in addition, suggest that a trained dramatherapist would have skills and abilities that would make her or him an excellent drama for health worker and able to compete in any health/education market. 4.The way that I would differentiate between a client that is suitable for attending a drama for health group, and one that requires a therapeutic intervention would include the following:
a) What is the purpose of the group? If it is for learning skills or raising social or health awareness, then it comes under drama for health. If it is for deeper work – as a direct health intervention, raising self
awareness,
or
working
with
personal relationships – then it should be done by a qualified therapist. b)How vulnerable is the client group? Some groups, generally non-clinical groups, will consist of clients who are deemed to be able to take responsibility for themselves and to be at low risk of becoming ill, or traumatised, directly or indirectly, in connection with any activities that they undertake. These groups are ideal for drama for health projects. An example would be a non-clinical group of carers who are attending mental
health
awareness
sessions.
However, groups consisting of people who have disabilities or life experiences that leave them vulnerable to abuse or traumatisation, should attend groups run by a qualified therapist, who is trained to work within boundaries of safety and client’s current potential ability, to use their skills to bring about internal change at a personal level and to be aware of signs that individual clients may be at risk at any time. Should dramatherapists take up work as drama for health workers, and what are
the risks/benefits and
challenges involved?
1.My own response is yes, definitely, dramatherapists can take up work as drama for health workers, to the advantage of themselves and their clients, but that they should be fully aware of the risks involved.
2.Lack of dramatherapist opportunities in private and public health sectors mean that many qualified dramatherapists find themselves without work for months or years after qualifying, at best becoming “rusty” practitioners, losing confidence and falling behind in knowledge and learning opportunities; at worst, giving up all together, and ending up working in a field not related to dramatherapy sometimes not even related to health. Drama for health posts may, in the short term, be easier to find, or projects easier to set up. Whilst working in a relevant field, the dramatherapist is able to keep their skills and confidence honed, and their knowledge and learning up to date. 3.However, the dramatherapist should be very clear that they are not providing dramatherapy. To provide drama for health and allow people to believe that they are having dramatherapy is to do a disservice to both the client and the field of dramatherapy. In addition, to provide dramatherapy, when people think that they are attending a drama for health group, would be unethical and risky to the clients wellbeing.
The distinctions that I have outlined are extremely important. They are important to the dramatherapist, who needs to positively promote dramatherapy, avoid underselling it, and avoid blurring the boundaries of their own practice. They are important to funders and employers, who may misunderstand the nature of what they are buying into, and finally, they are important to clients, who need to know what they are actually doing and why. Informed consent and awareness of purpose of any intervention are paramount in providing not just an efficacious service, but also an ethical one.
Nicky Barron
… groups
consisting of
people who have
disabilities
or life experiences
that leave them
vulnerable to
abuse or
traumatisation,
should attend
groups run by
a qualified
therapist, who is
trained to work
within boundaries
of safety and
client’s current
potential ability …
February 2013