December 2012
Beail proved a highly engaging, witty and dynamic speaker, frequently seasoning his presentation with colourful anecdotes from his professional life. However, his talk struck a meaningful balance as he eloquently offered a persuasive argument for why the psychodynamic field needs to move beyond the realm of the case study and into the brave new world of facts, figures and quantitative assessment to substantiate what we do; despite the difficulties this form of research inherently poses for the therapeutic process. The presentation neatly guided us through the evolution of the research base surrounding working with clients with intellectual disabilities; from case reports and case studies to open trials and experimental studies. Despite this seemingly wide spectrum, the talk clearly demonstrated how thin the evidence base currently is. Beail and his colleague’s commitment to the field ensure that progress is being made in the area, but the developments are relatively slow. Partly, this is due to methodological issues and a lack of controlled studies being completed, but much of the limited headway appears primarily to be down to attitudes within the therapeutic community. A large contributory factor is the inadequate regard from funding bodies which support the research taking place, who, in the current climate often prefer to lay their money down at the door of CBT (Cognitive Behavioural Therapy) practices. But Beail also gently and courageously criticised the resistance of those practicing within the psychodynamic and psychotherapeutic communities to outcome their research, voicing how important it is that those working in the field begin to do so if we are to validate what we do. Crucially, this lack of existing evidence also seems to mirror society’s attitude towards those living with intellectual disabilities, who so often get overlooked and forgotten in today’s world.
The concluding aspect of the presentation focused on Beail’s efforts to develop a research scale specifically designed to measure the role of psychological therapies in addressing key presenting problems in clients with intellectual disabilities. In discussing this next phase of his research, Beail highlighted many of the fundamental difficulties encountered when embarking upon the quest to quantify. Some vital, challenging, even existential questions come into play when attempting to measure outcomes of psychotherapeutic work. How do you break down a person’s experience of their internal-world into dependent variables? How do you quantify quality of life or wellbeing? Perhaps most significantly, in a practice that is wholly focused on process, how do you begin to demonstrate how ‘satisfaction’ and ‘results’ relate to outcome, without moving away from the humane core of our work being client-led? At a time when funding remains scarce, Beail’s reflections provided us with a sensitive and thoughtful meditation on the dilemma of funding bodies demanding our long-term work be condensed into a short term process. There are no easy answers to the questions posed by this research, but Beail offered an articulate exploration which challenged our immediate and ingrained reactions to an age-old inflammatory topic.
After a well-earned and enjoyable lunch, the afternoon’s presentation was by Art Psychotherapist Jessica 29th FATAG (Forensic Arts Therapies Advisory Group) Conference Review Alongside the generous refreshments laid on, the 29th FATAG Conference (held on 16th November) provided much food for deliberation and reflection. The day opened with a thought-provoking and timely presentation by Professor Nigel Beail on using psychodynamic psychotherapy with clients who have intellectual disabilities and putting an evaluative framework around therapeutic practice. The focus of the discussion was on how to integrate practice based research measures to help assess the effectiveness of psychodynamic interventions. Much of the contemporary literature in this somewhat neglected but vital field has been written by Beail throughout the course of his long career working as a clinical psychologist in South Yorkshire. Ruth Goodman and Kate Rothwell at lunch
December 2012
Collier on her work at HMP Holloway using art psychotherapy with a woman with Severe and Dangerous Personality Disorder. The discussion was enormously moving and encompassed many facets of a difficult topic, crucially questioning whether prisons can provide a psychologically secure base as well as physically secure one. Collier’s talk proved a fascinating counterpoint to the morning’s offering, for it was presented in the form of an extraordinarily absorbing case study. The material perfectly demonstrated why the nature of our work often becomes so hard to quantify – as well as demonstrating how the personal aspect can prove valuable – in deepening our understanding of the therapeutic relationship through the examination of counter-transference. Collier spoke of the need for therapists to be mindful of their own feelings and attitudes within their work and beautifully described the intensive therapeutic journey she undertook with her client.
She artfully drew us into their demanding and sometimes destructive dialogue. Particular highlights were her portrayal of the importance of image-making in holding overwhelming experiences of trauma and neglect and the power of allowing those experiences to be witnessed, as well as her detailed account of the complex issue of negotiating internal constellations of institutional transference, and the dangers of organisation-wide acting-out. The impact of the effect of working so intimately with a client with such acute and involving needs was evident at many points throughout Collier’s presentation, when she appeared visibly moved by the events she was describing, which was extremely touching and added depth and authenticity to her presentation. Interestingly, the significance of thinking was a major recurring theme in Collier’s material, particularly in reference to working in a secure environment where thinking is often replaced by concrete action. This seemed especially significant in light of the day’s presentations, which perfectly encapsulated our current climate. How do we capture the depth and essence of Collier’s experiences working with her client in an effective outcome measure that doesn’t become reductive? The day’s discussions, though on the surface very different in substance, are intrinsically and urgently linked by their relevance to today’s professional world. Our task must be to find the midpoint between the two, so that we can keep offering clients our unique, creative models of therapy, which provide precious spaces other modalities cannot. Roanna Bond
Addendum: FATAG Business
After the first presentation, some important FATAG notifications and updates were next on the agenda. This firstly involved a number of general acknowledgements, including recognition and credit for Simon Hackett’s publication of his recent research into ‘reduction of aggression using art therapy’. This was followed by an announcement of a reshuffle of the committee, including the addition of Lorna Downing to the panel as the new representative of Dramatherapy for FATAG. Jessica Collier also announced that the Saturday Forensic Forum she runs will be hosting talks by Pamela Stewart, a psychotherapist at HMP Holloway and Kate Rothwell in December. Additionally, the Saturday Forensic Forum, which has regular meetings in Hampstead, is always looking for new papers to be presented and so a call was put out for practitioners looking to present any work to get in contact with Heidi at contact form to suggest any new and interesting reflections which would benefit from being shared. David Cameron’s recent efforts regarding a push for the rehabilitation of offenders was also discussed, alongside an acknowledgement of the difficulties experienced by those affected by the cuts made to arts therapy services in West London NHS Trust.
The next FATAG Conference was also confirmed as being held in June 2013, specific date to follow. Jessica Collier and Kate Rothwell (Art Psychotherapists)