October 2012
This conference, held on 19th September 2012, was jointly organised by London University’s Royal Holloway College and the Child and Family Refugee Service at the Tavistock Centre. It focused on young people – who are asylum seekers in the UK, from countries such as Afghanistan – and what happens to them when they move from the legal classification of child to adult, upon reaching 18 years of age. This was a day for trying to understand the complexities that were around in their worlds. Both in terms of the legal, historical, sociological, psychological and rights based aspects of their journeys to the UK seeking asylum, and crucially, what happens when young people are deported.
The day offered important learning about the history relating to asylum seeking via quantitative information gathered over the past couple of decades, detailing numbers of young people seeking asylum, numbers receiving asylum and those being deported, or the minority being granted leave to remain. It also offered insights into the lengthy and highly complex legal processes of appeals, qualitative accounts of the journey to find asylum, and the ramifications of being an asylum seeker. An impassioned keynote speech by Maggie Atkinson, Children’s Commissioner for England, framed the day and outlined key tensions and debates facing young people. Other presentations focused on further complexities from a range of perspectives. Testimonials from a group of asylum seeking young people made the day incredibly rich. A short one-man play, ‘Mazloom’, a portrait of experiences as an asylum seeker in the UK, was very moving. A screening of the award winning documentary by Sue Clayton, ‘Hamedullah The Road Home’, detailed a young Afghanistani man’s journey following deportation. Hamedullah had arrived here aged 13, built a happy life as a UK teenager, but one day found himself arrested, locked up and thrown onto a plane back to a war-zone. Sue provided him with a camera, and the film records his videos and emails over the year of his return. A link to information about the film is detailed below, which orientates further links via Facebook and Twitter. Perhaps more importantly, you can buy the film for £10 and this revenue is providing Hamedullah with a small income, in almost unbearably challenging circumstances. Facing the Abyss:
Exploring the challenges for separated children seeking asylum as they turn 18
‘Hamedullah The Road Home’
http://www.rhul.ac.uk/mediaarts/news/newsarticles/indiedocumentaryshortlistedforprestigiousaward.aspx
October 2012
Asylum seekers are granted discretionary leave for either 30 months or until they reach 17½ years of age, whichever comes first. After this time, young people seeking asylum are left open to the real threat of deportation back to their homeland. In a majority of cases, this can mean a homeland war-torn, where family and friends have been killed or have fled. A homeland desecrated of core essential services such as water, heating and lighting. Despite the fact that human rights law clearly protects all children from deportation to countries which would endanger their basic safety, as they move into the legal category of adult upon reaching 18 years of age, they become incredibly vulnerable to deportation, as these rights no longer apply.
As they approach 18, they are asked to report regularly to the authorities. They are living with the tension of the reality that the next time they report, they could be held for months, without a clear idea of their future, then placed on ‘ghost flights’ – flights that do not appear on departure boards and are not announced to the public in any way – which leave the UK every fortnight from major airports, to
return the young people to their
homelands. These flights are entirely populated by people being deported. In other words, a young asylum
seeker, having perhaps spent much of their childhood in hiding, then sent on a horrific journey to Europe, to safety (their family having often got into ‘debt bondage’ to send them), having arrived in London at the age of 13, been unintentionally humiliated over and over again by the immigration
authorities (asked questions they
could not possibly know the answers to e.g. show us where you were born on this map?), having attended
school possibly for the first time, made friends, developed concrete ambitions, supported a local football team, attended a youth club … at 18, are suddenly uprooted, and find themselves in an unrecognisable place, destroyed by war, unable to locate old friends or family, without infrastructure, and often targeted by kidnappers (if they’re from London they must be rich) or targeted for slavery by creditors calling in the original debt for their journey, or considered traitors to the country they had left.
It is clear from these descriptions that the opportunity to witness and unpack these young people’s narratives, is sorely needed. Many voluntary agencies are involved in doing so and representatives from a wide range of invested parties attended the conference. The majority spoke of the need for more funding, more interventions and alongside obvious changes in law and legislation to be effected, a call for the development of social and emotional interventions and research projects that can empower the young people, enable agency and mark their journeys, their lives and their futures in meaningful ways that develop wellbeing and positive futures. One initiative, facilitated by Gillian Hughes, team leader of the Tavistock’s Child and family Refugee Service, took young people to a large London park. This followed their request to experience an environment which mirrored that in which they grew up. In doing so, the young men experienced feeling safe and familiar and engaged in a rich therapeutic day of life story narratives, and past, present and future reflections that brought about closeness and connection between group members. This work, based on ‘The Tree of Life’ metaphor, aimed to integrate young people with their roots, as well as their current skills, passions, the supportive people and friends in the host country, and their own resilience, represented by the trunk, and the hopes and ambitions for the future, represented by the branches of the tree. Although it does not avoid trauma and loss, it is a model of empowerment, with the voices and
passions of the young people its
centre.
The vitality of the day was delivered in part and most notably by a group of young Afghanistani men, whose ‘slot’ appeared rather impromptu and their apportioned time overran by half an hour. The organisers may have not
given much time, for fear of their vulnerability. However, what we experienced was their striking need to be heard. They spoke with dignity,
sadness, humour and frustration
about the system, which initially was lost to them, and created more frustration and anxiety. They spoke of the people who helped them as well as
the help they gave to each other. In many cases, they had left in a hurry, been smuggled for months, living in boxes in the back of vans. Many had seen their families, loved ones, close friends, killed in front of them. Some had been in the UK since they were 4 years old – currently under the threat of deportation to a country they hardly know. Their issues were complex and multi-layered. The blog www.lifeafterdeportation.com set up by one of the young men, enables him to develop a network and to profile these events, find a voice and be heard. Sue Clayton’s research and the use of film, as well as Gillian Hughes’ ‘Tree of Life’ approach, had clear relationships with some of the creative methodologies in the arts therapies research field. By engaging young people with creative methods, which emerge from their own interests, they were able to explore and find ways to be heard and … After this time, young
people seeking asylum
are left open to the real
threat
of
deportation
back to their homeland.
In a majority of cases, this
can mean a homeland
war-torn, where family
and friends have been
killed or have fled.
October 2012
have a voice, across language barriers, country lines and border controls.
One of the most important points made was the role that professionals could play in supporting young asylum seekers at this crucial age, and even helping them avoid deportation altogether. The limitations of the Legal Aid System, means that immigration lawyers are of variable quality. Often young asylum seekers discover too late that they have been given poor advice. The Coram’s Legal Centre (see below), provide a folder, outlining the process and how and where young people can get good support. Appeals are often turned down, because judges argue not only that the young person’s life will not be at risk, should they return, but that their successful and full life in the UK, their GCSE results, their good state of health, their friendship networks … these things, they argue, demonstrate that the young asylum seeker is resilient enough to return to create a new life in their homelands. However, arts therapists, counsellors, teachers and other professionals, have successfully attested in court that the young person with whom they have worked for a considerable amount of time, is much more vulnerable than they may seem. They have given evidence to that effect … and as a result, appeals have been upheld.
This conference was challenging on many levels. Particularly striking was the way the ‘system’ routinely views complex situations through the lens of its own cultural perspective. Partly as a result of this, the lack of care and compassion often shown by our legal and immigration systems as young people approach 18, can be deeply shocking. The need for other conferences, which bring together a wide range of involved professionals, together with young asylum-seeking people, to explore ways forward, is paramount. The emotional needs of this group, the importance of all professionals in questioning their own assumptions in order to understand issues in different social and cultural contexts, underpinned the day. But perhaps above all, the conference challenged us to take not just a therapeutic, but also a practical interest in the lives of young asylum seekers, who may face deportation. Arts therapists and other professionals can make a real difference. Emma Ramsden and Mandy Carr
Further information and support:
Baobab Centre for Young Survivors in Exile http://www.baobabsurvivors.org/
Blog: Life After Deportation
http://www.lifeafterdeportation.com/ Coram Children’s Legal Centre
Migrant Children’s Project: 020 7636 8505 contact form
Freedom from Torture (formerly called the Medical Foundation): therapeutic support, medical and legal advice
http://www.freedomfromtorture.org/ Refugee Support Network
http://www.refugeesupportnetwork.org/ The Tree of Life – Ncube & Denborough (2008) http://www.dulwichcentre.com.au/tree-of-life.html And…
The play, ‘Khadija is 18’, concerning two ‘unaccompanied’ teenagers nearing 18, runs at The Finborough Theatre for 4 weeks, starting on Tues Oct 30th. http://www.finboroughtheatre.co.uk/productions/2012/kh adija-is-18.php
October 2012
!”#$ %&'(&)&'(*
+ ,!#$-,.$.” $/$$+ $#$.” $0
1/ ,$.”+ $2$.#3 ,+ $+,.0% $ ..+2 ! – .#14 ..!&5-6″ , 78 +7 $.#!#$/! ,$.,$ !$7 $. “” +9 $ 4 For Further Information Please Contact: Briar House Resources,
Club Chambers, Museum Street, York, YO1 7DN Tel: 01904 679 868/07793 819825
E-mail: contact form . :!#$ 3; :!#$ +; 78.” +.$ #$.- ,$ !#!#$! ,78.”9-4 +4. #$.78.” ” ” !”#$ 3 + “”,. 7 # , !#$ -,.$.”-/#$.”-/
$. , + ++4.:!#$
3; 78.” 6″$ !<3-$.3+.$.,3″,$3#$.3+.++#$7 $. $+$ +,$ !# ,3 +#!#$/ ,/+/ + +/! ,/$-/ ! 3 #+/ 7 $ +4 . :!#$ +; 78.” 6″$ ! <3- $.3+. $. = # $ $. , 3 , , $.3+. ++#$ 7 $. $+$ + ,$ ! # ,3 + + + !, #”! $ / #!#$/ ,/$-/! 3 #+/7 $ +4 .$778.” 7 9. ,,3$ !- 3 – #$. # ,$9 &'(&)- &'(*4 $ ,- $ 98 $. 7. 78.” > $ ” 9$< 9$.+3″4.-,+3″3 $9″” 7 $.7 $.3$” 6″ ,4$$.78.” 7?
3 – ,$9&($&'(&
3 –
!#9(@$.&'(&
3 -,#9(A$.&'(&
3 -B3-&’$.&'(*
3 -93-(=$.&'(*
3 -,.(=$.&'(*
3 -” &($&'(*
3 –(C$.&'(*
.,$$$ +$.78.” ?DE”03 1/D*A’0,,414 .,$$$ +9$.78.” ?D=A’03 1/D=”0,,41