One year on … the challenge of finding work in 2012

One year on ... the challenge of finding work in 2012

The Prompt, August 2012 · page 22-27

August 2012

Enduring the struggle of this last year, I felt unable to start another without reviewing the last 12 months in some way – continuing the act of writing a ‘reflective log’ perhaps – a process embedded in my practice from three years of training. The responses from others in the cohort add weight to the theme of challenge encountered, while exhibiting an array of individual work and personal experiences. What follows is my endeavour to string, weave, and mix this colourful journey. I hope, thereby, to interest you, while providing myself with a catharsis! Over the course of this last year, the initial excitement, relief, adrenalin and exhaustion of qualifying as a dramatherapist waned, and looking for work as a Newly Qualified Dramatherapist (NQD) in the current political and economic climate waxed, loomed and over-rode, creating a near full eclipse… © E M Chadwick 2012

… the challenge of finding work in 2012 This article is a presentation of findings from a questionnaire sent to my graduating cohort (anonymised), one year on. The impetus to engage with my fellow graduates in this way emerged while sharing, both with my supervisor and peer group, the barrage of challenges that were accumulating, as one year elapsed between qualifying and the next, less defined, began. To this purpose I have adopted the role of scribe and/or mouthpiece for myself and others of the cohort – 75% (10 out 15 graduates) of whom responded to the invitation to collate their thoughts and feelings, facts and figures. The eight questions asked of the cohort were an assortment, which looked at creative ways of describing practice, alongside questions that looked at statistics. They included: What story/myth or metaphor is representative of this last year? What roles associated with dramatherapy work the graduates have played? What number of paid dramatherapy days in a week? Freelancing and/or employed status? Rating the challenge in finding work? Plus anything else they wanted to say at this point in the journey. A graduate from another dramatherapy training, while informally discussing with me the challenges faced this year, requested to join in, and their data is included and presented in the overall findings. On

ea

…

© E M Chadwick 2012

August 2012

If I were to represent this year in metaphor for myself, it would involve deep-sea fishing … casting out the net, using the occasional harpoon, pulling it back in and seeing if anything came back … in all weathers, over and over again…

© E M Chadwick 2012

Additional water analogies from the cohort were: ‘Not being able to swim and being thrown in at the deep end … flapping around furiously, trying … to stay afloat’; ‘lost in a maze and searching for Atlantis’; and ‘a song: Wherever you will go’, which relates to ‘feeling lost at sea with a self that has been hard to connect with without the support of the peer group’.

While the metaphors above demonstrate some extremely challenging experiences, others like ‘A soaring eagle’, and between ‘every sunrise and sunset’ is ‘of our own making’ seem liberated, if not celebratory. As well as, perhaps, the story of ‘Theseus and the Minotaur’, which might symbolize a rich experience and call for a number of analyses, depending on the personal connection, which was not offered. Likewise, the awakening story of ’Rapunzel’, and ‘owning two gold rings and nothing else’.

Meanwhile, the story of ‘The Emperor’s New Clothes’, in which ‘this new outfit [which] took 3 years to make … has ‘not been noticed outside the palace!’, fills me with a kind of sadness, while ‘being pushed off the edge of a mountain with a blindfold on … free falling … waking up a few days later in a brighter place and clearer vision of the edges of things…’ seems to have a mixture of terror, fatality and redemption.

These analogies collectively reflect dramatic journeys, and lay testament to the impulse to write such an article – collating the diversity of experiences which reflect, meander and muse on the thoughts and feelings of post-qualifying and emerging potential and/or practicing dramatherapists. It seems evident, from recommendations made by Karen Middleton (Chief Health Professions Officer within the Department of Health), in the report by Barron and Bayley (2012), that the climate of change is affecting and/or will affect all dramatherapists in the field. This most unprecedented of environments, in which she suggests we ‘pitch our services’, (ibid,19:2012), is reflected in the challenges for the NQD cohort represented here. State of play for my graduating cohort currently is: 4 are working freelance as dramatherapists – accruing between ½–2½ days a week of paid clinical work

3 are employed – working between 3–5 days a week (though 1 post has just been halved), while 4 do not have any paid work as dramatherapists at present, and

1 (amongst other work) is doing ½–1 day unpaid clinical dramatherapy work.

I belong in the freelancing category, and, while not working directly as a therapist at present, am aware of all the other roles I’ve been playing towards establishing and securing work as a dramatherapist – many of which I share with my peer group: …

researcher,

marketer,

evaluator,

publicist,

administrator, sales-pitcher, consultant, promoter, self-promoter, fund-raiser, net-worker, artist, writer and report writer.

Though the above roles inhabited exhibit an array of busy functions played out over this last year, the context in which they’ve lived and worked looks something like this:

© E M Chadwick 2012

Banner titles:

‘Dramatherapy is Great! ‘Austerity Cuts’ ‘No Jobs’ ‘Funding Cuts’ Asking the group the question of how challenging it has been to find dramatherapy work this last year, I gave the provocative criteria of anything between … ‘f***ing nightmare!’

‘easy-peasy!’

… choosing to use an expletive to see if it stirred a similar ‘primitive emotional’ response to my own (Pinker, 2008):

August 2012

Over half ticked ‘f***ing nightmare’, while only One person qualified ‘easy-peasy’ being down to the extension of a job ‘already held’, and one other associated this category with an easily acquired ‘teaching post’

Another, similarly, felt ‘lucky’ that a placement extended beyond the honorary contract What qualifies as dramatherapy work perhaps inhibited others from exacting a direct response. Let me explain what I have just said by demonstrating the response to another question, which asked whether the dramatherapy training was being implemented into other work practices, to which the overwhelming and unanimous response was: © E M Chadwick 2012

The qualitative responses accompanying ‘yes’ were exuberant in both detail and depth, giving me the sense that there was some form of celebration and relief in giving this positive affirmation at this point in the journey. Indeed, one person suggests that attending to these questions enabled them to ‘think’ of themselves as ‘a dramatherapist’ now in ‘every job’ they do, where, this might infer, previously they had not. As a rough 40% have no paid clinical work at the moment, I’m wondering if some of us are unsure whether we can carry/uphold the title ‘dramatherapist’? Is it not still ‘potential’ dramatherapist, another suggests, posing the question of identity perhaps, adding how much ‘better’ it would be to be a ‘practicing dramatherapist’ and of course, thereby paid! However, recognizing the ways in which having a dramatherapy training influences and promotes ‘another level and focus’ to all our work, suggests that this may be sufficient for some to reconcile themselves with at this point, as well as feel secure and confident enough to call oneself ‘a dramatherapist’ as a result. But there are problems that everyone has noted, with the words drama and therapy being entwined … … as well as the cohort’s general experience that the modality itself – dramatherapy – seems to be unknown to the general public, as well as an amount of institutions where many of us already work – schools, NHS, and other work environments. Thus, it would seem that taking a gamble, a long-shot, a risk, by employing a dramatherapist, with all the prejudice associated for so many (in the title) is beyond most people’s/institutions capabilities at the moment, especially in the light of the draconian austerity measures being executed in the UK at this time, due to the financial downturn. To all intents and purposes, it seems it’s been a tough year, or as one person put it: ‘Anyone who thinks being a dramatherapist is a bit wishy washy has never experienced the year after graduation and the sheer blood, sweat and tears that go with it …’.

I also share the premise of another, however, in stating that the training enabled a rich voyage of personal growth, which in itself has been ‘life changing’. Thus, the emergence of myself as a dramatherapist – whether practicing as a clinician or not at this point – has provided me with a fundamentally altered outlook and affects all the other (paid) work and roles I and others have performed this year: Teacher,

workshop

leader,

coach,

trainer,

actor/storyteller …

In retrospect, words of advice for the new qualifiers that we were, would have been:

… ‘take a break’ … ‘don’t panic’ … ‘keep the day job’ … ‘practice filling in application forms’ … ‘learn to define your dramatherapy practice’ … ‘provide outcome measures’ … ‘hold some money back’

But more loudly than anything else from this section of the data, was the advice to keep your hand in – continue your placement as an honorary contract! Only one person did this (that took part in this article) Yes

A what?

I’m a

dramatherapist

August 2012

and I feel it’s a tough call in the current climate … unleashing contradictory responses from arts therapists across the board, as is evident in the many articles and debates in previous articles in The Prompt (Ramsden, 2011). In addition, I’m sure I’m not alone in receiving many positive responses to my solicitations for dramatherapy, that welcome the service under the proviso that it is free of charge! In summary, the findings of the questionnaire reveal that seeking paid work in 2011–2012 has been a veritable struggle for the majority. Everyone seems to have worked extremely hard in a difficult climate, creating all sorts of work – clinical and creative – holding onto posts, writing articles and, alongside formal clinical supervision, supporting each other through regular peer supervision groups, which, in one person’s words is a ‘must’ for any NQD – though the dilemma of travel and cost has been an issue for some. The challenge is particularly exacerbated, it is suggested, by the ‘catch 22’ that exists where the very few jobs that are advertised ‘request 1–3 years post-qualifying experience’. Perhaps this is another argument for securing unpaid work if that is all that is on offer. But it seems somewhat of a sacrifice, both on a personal and professional

level,

and

could

be

seen

as

‘undermin[ing] the integrity’ of the dramatherapy profession (Ramsden, 20:2011) – particularly in the current climate when the arts therapies, not seen as core, suffer financial cuts to service provision. Equally, it disregards the pioneers of our profession who strove for the meaningful integration of dramatherapy into mainstream services.

While there has been evident shock at the prevailing lack of recognition that dramatherapy has in the wider community, coupled with the lack of work available for NQD’s (in particular), 80% offered up the notion that the most pressing job was to ‘raise the profile of dramatherapy’ itself, suggesting more active promotion (especially) ‘from BADth’, for the universities to offer tuition in the form of ‘a module’ – educating us towards this end – and/or a notable ‘patron’ as advertisement for the field.

After a year since qualifying, feelings that define what it is to be a dramatherapist at this point were invited, which are contradictory and in ‘limbo‘, or, like ‘something liquid seeping through the rock and the hard place’. Also …

‘Frustrated’, ‘isolating’, ‘marginalized’, ‘hard’, ‘difficult’, ‘challenging’, ‘demanding’ …

‘Proud’, ‘positive’, ‘flexible’, ‘excited’, ‘hopeful’, ‘inspiring’, ‘grounding’, ‘meaningful’ …

The above evidence suggests that there is an energy and optimism for 2011–2012 NQD’s in looking to the future and/or desire and enjoyment of meeting the demands of the workplace. However, the present political climate, with the additional lack of a profile that dramatherapy seems to have, concludes a palpable challenge for which we were not prepared. Thus, this time last year there was little knowledge of the uphill climb, and reaching the finishing line was the primary goal. Little consideration was given to taking ’a break’

(as was previously suggested).

However, after three years of financially paying out, for some of us this was, in itself, not a viable option … © E M Chadwick 2012

So, we need to ‘make a plan’, another suggests. How to proceed? A question, no doubt, many current NQD’s as well as seasoned dramatherapists amongst us are asking at this time. Some suggest that ‘disguising’ our work might get us through the door, and/or taking the word ‘drama’ out of the title of the therapy. However, with 75% of the members of this cohort either involved in research and writing articles, extending to those who would like to, I wonder, and indeed hope, that this positive drive to explore the modality might extend to an arena that one suggests: ‘puts it on the map’ for the benefit of us all, and the longevity of the profession.

Please note: I’d like to thank my year group for allowing me the pleasure of writing this review, and for their time, reflections and honesty. I’m sure they’ll be with me in celebrating that we do not have to do this first year as an NQD again!

Eva Marie Chadwick

References

Barron, N., B.H. Bayley (2012) ‘AHPs – delivering better care, delivering better value’ The Prompt, April edition Pinker, S. (2008) ‘The Seven Words You Can’t Say on Television’, in The Stuff of Thought: Language as a window into human nature (pp323–373), UK, Penguin Ramsden, E. (2011) ‘Volunteer dramatherapy posts – collusion or survival?’ The Prompt, April edition

August 2012

August 2012

More posts

edition Diary Dates

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 32-33 DIARY DATES 2023 January 2023 Closing date for the BADth Gordon Wiseman Trust Fund. Details in Members’ area.…

The Prompt – final

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 22-31 Dear Jane, As a long-standing supporter of the publication, I write this open letter to thank you for…

people-caused climate destruction A Farewell Scenario

The Prompt, December 2022 · by EXCLUSIVE TO ARTS THERAPISTS · page 17-21 A FAREWELL SCENARIO 1996–2022 Scenario Arts in Personal Development was founded in…
account android arrow-alt-circle-down arrow-alt-circle-left arrow-alt-circle-right arrow-alt-circle-up arrow-down arrow-left arrow-right arrow-up author bars behance blogger bluesky buffer caret-down caret-left caret-right caret-square-down caret-square-left caret-square-right caret-square-up caret-up cart-menu-1 cart-menu-2 cart-menu-3 cart-menu-4 categories chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right chevron-up clock close comments cookies copyright coupon-discount date-modified date-published discord double-arrows-down double-arrows-left double-arrows-right double-arrows-up dribbble envelope-open envelope eye facebook fax flickr foursquare github gmail google-drive grid-view hashtag hollow-ring homepage instagram ios level-down-alt level-up-alt line link linkedin list-view login logout long-arrow-alt-down long-arrow-alt-left long-arrow-alt-right long-arrow-alt-up mastodonmedium messenger mobile-menu mobile phone pinterest place qq quote-left quote-right quotes reading-time-hourglass reading-time-stopwatch reddit rss scroll-to-top search shazam shopping-bag shopping-cart side-panel-opening-2-left side-panel-opening-2-right side-panel-opening-left side-panel-opening-right skype slack small-arrow-down small-arrow-left small-arrow-right small-arrow-up sms snapchat soundcloud spinner spotify stackoverflow sync telegram threadstiktok times-circle tinder trello tripadvisor tumblr twitch twitter viber vimeo vine vkontakte website wechat whatsapp windows wishlist xing yelp youtube zoom