December 2011
This brief article describes a creative evaluation tool, which was devised in 2011, during my final year as a dramatherapy trainee, while working with an Early Intervention in Psychosis service (EIP) within the NHS. In sharing its development and current use, I invite you as the dramatherapy community to engage with the tool in your own practice and enter into dialogue with me in order to support its future enhancement and development. The tool aims to provide practice-based evidence of the dramatherapy intervention from a client/service user perspective by utilising a set series of statements which prompt creative responses. Used within the framework of the therapy session, the primary focus of the activity of self-evaluation is therapeutic.
Developed from the emerging practice of a weekly held dramatherapy group in a 10-month placement, with the EIP service, the tool yielded rich data and was considered by group members to be a helpful means of reflection and communication in the group’s process. The EIP provides a 3-year programme of care for people who have suffered ‘First Episode Psychosis’ (FEP). Interventions aim to minimise the impact of the illness, promote recovery, increase stability, and help them to achieve ordinary lives (EIP Declaration, 2005).
The five questions which make up the tool, were developed as a result of the emerging clinical work in the initial stages of the group’s process. This included a sense of dynamics present in the organization along with assessment interview data from group members. The main purpose of the tool was to measure how the service users benefited from the dramatherapy intervention. The design met the remit of the ‘recovery model’ – a conceptual framework for rehabilitation of mental health focusing on a holistic view of a person – supporting personal growth, collaboration and responsibility (mentalhealth.org; French et al, 2010).
This five-point self-evaluation questionnaire (opposite), was offered on a session-by-session basis. Service users chose a variety of ways to feedback their responses on a weekly basis which included the use of verbal and nonverbal techniques, sculpting, talking, drawing and the use of objects.
Session Evaluation
In the beginning I noticed…
Being in the group today was…
I will remember…
At the end I felt…
It was worth coming today because… This method also offered the opportunity to provide both qualitative and quantitative evidence of the practice, for example:
X amount of weeks
X amount of questions asked
X amount answered
The word X was cited X amount of times…contributing to the theme of Y
X Client answered question X, X amount of times…what might this tell us about his emotional world…? While this information was also presented in chart and graph form, providing qualitative evidence through analysis of the feedback highlighted client’s therapeutic process, for example:
The positive social experience was an overriding key factor in the group’s experience of dramatherapy. This discovery suggests that the course provided relief from the isolation experienced by psychosis sufferers, for whom it was, at times, simply:
‘Good to get out of the house…’ Service user X and/or
An awareness of the process and effect of the session: ‘It gave me time to think’ Service user Y ‘It took my mind off things’ Service user X ‘It gave me some distraction and enjoyment’ Service user Z
Developing practice
– a dramatherapy evaluation tool
‘…it made me feel happier on an anxious day’ Service user X, Session 4
December 2011
suggesting relief from anxiety, while demonstrating that they had been able to focus, enough to be able to have this ‘time out’, as XX articulated. Theoretical influences of the design were based upon formative
assessment
methods
(session-by-session),
humanistic psychology (collaboration), as well as involving a core process in dramatherapy (witnessing). Integrated ritualistically into the sessions, it was conceived of as a having a dual purpose:
Therapeutic
• Engaging and empowering the clients in observing and reflecting, through self-evaluation – involving the service users in their own discovery (Jones, 2010).
Evaluative
• A collaborative method of evaluation, illuminating the therapeutic process from a service-user perspective.
Key themes found through a post group thematic analysis, illustrated the service users engagement with the dramatherapy intervention, providing evidence of the benefit and relevance for the service. Tracking individual feedback illuminated progressions, within which themes emerged according to each client’s journey:
‘Attachment and Loss’
Service user A, a 25-yr old young man suffering from psychosis emanated a sense loss. Seemingly unable to fully engage with the group initially, he often sat in a ‘time out’ area, and presented detached or dissociated. In session 5, he eventually noted that he felt: ‘Sad’. Witnessed by the group, this seemed to be the starting point for his therapeutic journey. While being able to acknowledge this emotion made a strong impression on him: ‘it makes it a reality’, A seemed relieved, as if a weight had been lifted off. As A became more attached/engaged in the sessions through the safe environment cultivated – holding rather than pointing to objects, partaking in activities – he tentatively noted: ‘Feel part’. At the end of 25 sessions, having worked through an amount of issues, and becoming a vital and active member of the group he boldly wrote: ‘Happy to have been in such a good group but sad its over’. This statement suggests, that he had had a positive social experience, that he was able to reflect on how he felt, and at the same time contain the experience. For service users, such as A, whose propensity for psychosis is aggravated by emotional stress, A illuminates an element of his therapeutic journey, in which he was able to attach in the here and now and express his loss.
Findings
These emergent themes illuminated the support that the dramatherapy intervention offered to clients in recovery. Evidence suggested that using the creative evaluation tool promoted the therapeutic aims, while service users response was:
‘Liked the ritual’ of the activity. . . and ‘Enjoyed’ doing a re-cap of the session.
There was also evidence suggesting that it was an integrative activity in becoming conscious, identifying emotions, and owning the process.
Development
The research and development of this tool was undertaken during my training. Since then, interest has been forthcoming from arts therapists who have been keen to explore its potential with me and implement it in existing interventions. The creative application of the tool and its consistent and rigorous implementation have been of interest to others in the field, particularly as a means of providing service data and audit information. This article is in part both an explanation and request for more evaluations to be carried out using this tool, so that it can be developed and enhanced/adapted and /or changed for different client groups. I therefore invite dramatherapists to use this tool and welcome your responses. It would be interesting to know how other client groups respond to the questions or develop their own questions, as well as what themes emerge from their feedback.
I look forward to hearing from you. Eva Marie Chadwick
References
EIP Declaration (2005) cited in French et al (2010) Promoting Recovery in Early Psychosis, A Practical Manual, published by Wiley-Blackwell French, P.J. Smith, D. Shiers, M. Reed, M. Rayne (2010) Promoting Recovery in Early Psychosis, A Practical Manual, published by Wiley-Blackwell Jones, P. ed. (2010) ‘The nature of practice and practitioner research’ in Drama as Therapy, Clinical work and Research into Practice volume 2, Routledge Recovery
model,
Internet
page
WWW
at
URL:
http://www.mentalhealth.org.uk/help-information/ mental-health-a-z/R/recovery/ (accessed November 2011)
December 2011