International Centre for Research in Arts Therapies event – Wednesday 13th July It was my pleasure to represent the Executive Committee at the International Centre for Research in Arts Therapies (ICRA) one-day conference held at the Conway Hall in London. The programme tended to focus on art therapy and music therapy but there was much content applicable to our modality. I found in particular the contribution from Dr Helen Killaspy on outcome measurement (contrasted with process evaluation and
combined
with
quality
evaluation)
particularly clear and pragmatic regarding opportunities for arts therapists to demonstrate evidence of our work contributing to broad, outcomes-based policy objectives (as outlined for example in ‘No Health Without Mental Health’ HMG/DH Feb 2011). The afternoon was dominated by preliminary feedback on the MATISSE project, which included the largest randomised controlled trial (RCT) of art therapy yet undertaken (due for publication in December). There was palpable disappointment that the RCT in itself does not appear to show a clear-cut positive result, in contrast to some of the qualitative material in a parallel PhD research project, which concentrated on the lived experiences of individuals, both clients and practitioners. Dr Mike Crawford, leading the research, mentioned that he would not undertake a similar study without including a ‘client defined’ measure in future, which I connected with the ideas around ‘client satisfaction’ in the previous presentation. For example, one of the objectives in ‘No Health Without Mental Health’ is that “More people will have a positive experience of care and support”. BADth Research Sub-Committee Convener Madeleine Andersen-Warren did a valiant job facilitating the closing segment of the conference – billed as a panel discussion focussing on future research, but in fact dominated by the need to process reactions to the MATISSE presentations. My feeling was that her job would have been much easier had she been able to chair the whole day consistently rather than just being handed it at the last moment. There were a number of promising ideas for future research aired nevertheless, both in the hall and in informal conversations during breaks. As with the recent Diversity event run by Mandy Carr and colleagues, I found the opportunity to spend time and effort with practitioners from other modalities, sharing similarities and differences, both stimulating and affirming.
John Bowtell
Vice Chair BADth