Play Therapy and Dramatherapy
compared: Part 3
By Nina Rye (Play therapist) and Gail Atkins (Dramatherapist) In our previous articles we told you about “Joe”, a fictional child fostered by Mary and Phil. In an effort to compare dramatherapy and play therapy, we separately imagined how we would work with him, and described first meetings, plans for therapy, the first six sessions and the first review. Nina works at Thurlow House, Tier III CAMHS clinic in King’s Lynn. Gail works at the Unthank Family Centre in Norwich. A version of this article was first printed in the Play Therapy Magazine and is printed here with their kind permission.
In this issue we bring the story to a close, describing aspects of the middle phase and the ending phase. We have imagined that Joe had 25 sessions over a period of about 9 months. Joe is 8 years old and in his third foster placement. He is restless, impulsive, has poor concentration, and is frequently physically and verbally aggressive. He was emotionally abused and neglected in his birth family until being removed at age 5. Play Therapy
The middle phase of Joe’s therapy, from the seventh to the twentieth session, included two more review meetings. At the first of these there was some cautious optimism. Joe had had a total of 13 sessions at that time. Mary reported that Joe was becoming affectionate with her and her husband, and that they had warm feelings toward him. I had noticed this when Joe came for play therapy: he had recently begun kissing Mary “goodbye” before coming with me, and Mary looked less wary, more relaxed, when this happened. Mary said that Joe still “lashed out” unpredictably but he usually calmed down more readily than before. When I asked what “lashed out” meant, Mary said that it was physical and verbal, but sometimes he pounded his fists on the sofa cushions and stamped his feet, instead of hitting or kicking her. Mary and I had discussed “safer ways for Joe to express angry feelings” at some length in a couple of phone calls, so it was encouraging to hear that Joe could occasionally make use of these. The social worker had visited Joe at school and talked to his teacher. Joe was still very restless, with a short concentration span. The teacher had also said that Joe seemed to have very little impulse control and had a lot of difficulty with delayed gratification. A promise of “golden time” if he completed (or attempted to complete) a task had little effect. Joe wanted it “now”, he was still unsettled, and even if he did manage to complete a task he often “spoilt everything” by punching another child, or swearing. When he lost his “golden time”, Joe flew into a rage. The teacher thought Joe might have attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). The social worker asked about an assessment. As this had been raised before, I said I would send a Conner’s Questionnaire to school, and would give one to Mary before she left. I explained that this was the preliminary stage of an assessment for ADHD. We needed to compare the scores from the questionnaires from home and school. When I had those results I would discuss them with one of the psychiatrists on the team, and a decision would be taken about whether Joe needed to have a referral to psychiatry. I outlined the process whereby the doctor would come to a diagnosis (or not) and emphasised that medication was not always prescribed. I talked a little about the effects of trauma on the developing brain, and the consequent difficulties with emotion regulation and impulse control. Mary said that this helped her to understand that Joe’s behaviour was not simply “being naughty” or “attention-seeking”. I talked briefly about Joe’s play therapy themes: “powerful
vs.
powerless”,
“in/out
of
control”,
“full/empty”, and “injury vs. restitution”. These themes had appeared at the start of therapy and were continuing. As yet I had not seen any real change, except in “full/empty”: Joe no longer needed to start the session by cramming the biscuit and sultanas into his mouth; he ate them at intervals and in a more relaxed manner. But he still did a lot of play about filling and emptying buckets and containers with sand, or sometimes water. Joe found this play soothing. I suggested that it was also regressive play, that Joe was using sensory play to revisit toddlerhood. Joe had suffered a fractured arm when he was a toddler, probably as a result of physical abuse. In the playroom he could safely experience toddler-type play, thoughts and feelings. He could also begin to experience selfregulation, as I was present as an empathic and attuned adult, able to contain his emotions and behaviour if these “overflowed”. The scores from the Conner’s Questionnaires were sufficiently high to warrant a psychiatric assessment for ADHD. In view of Joe’s difficulties in the school environment particularly, he was seen relatively
quickly, about a month after I had spoken with the consultant psychiatrist. I delayed my next review with the foster carer until after this had taken place. Mary continued to bring Joe and never missed a session. This in itself helped Joe enormously. He came into the room almost as if he had never left it. He began to remember what he had done the week before. His play became less fragmented. At last, some regular story lines began to emerge. One of these was about a mummy cow giving birth to a baby cow. We had to lie under the table, Joe under a cot sheet. Then he would emerge. I always wanted to greet him joyfully, but Joe would say, “No, you don’t know I’ve been born.” Sometimes we played this several times a session. A few days before the first psychiatric appointment Mary phoned me in some distress. Joe had pulled at a teaching assistant’s clothing and touched her breast, saying “boobies”. He could not say why he had done it. Mary said that he had been talking about “boobies” at home too, but had not so far tried to grab or touch. I talked her through how to set the limit, based on a play therapy/filial therapy approach. We talked about what the “acceptable alternative” could be, what his feelings might be, and what would “fit” as a consequence if he broke the limit after the warning. Afterward I sent Mary a written aide memoire. I said to Mary that I thought Joe’s interest in breasts might be linked to recent developments in his play therapy, and that he was using play to regress to infancy. Mary was somewhat reassured by this, but also glad to know how to set a limit on inappropriate behaviour. I suggested having the next review at school so that the teacher and teaching assistant could be present, if they agreed. I managed to speak to the teacher in her lunch break and we agreed a date and time. I talked about limit setting, and offered to talk to the teaching assistant. The teacher said she would do this. I decided to send her the same aide memoire.
Ten days later we all met in the Head’s office for a review of Joe’s progress. Unfortunately his social worker had to cancel at the last minute. Naturally enough, we began by discussing Joe’s challenging behaviour in school. The teacher and the teaching assistant had tried out the limit setting technique and found it useful. They had also tried it with other limits, with variable success. But both were pleased to have a strategy that did not result in Joe becoming “out-ofcontrol” with anger. I briefly reviewed with them how they applied the technique in different situations, emphasising the need to redirect the behaviour, and also to name his thought or feeling at some point or points in the process. On the positive side, Joe’s ability to concentrate had improved, and he had made a lot of progress with his reading. Mary said that he still “had his moments” at home, but that he was becoming less domineering with the younger children. His relationship with her husband had also improved, and they could enjoy a kick-about in the back garden together. I talked about developments in Joe’s play therapy, without giving specific descriptions of his play. The idea that the regressive play was helping Joe to “heal past hurts” appealed to everyone, and helped them to put his behaviour at home and school into the context of his early traumatic experiences. We agreed that Joe might well remain vulnerable to temper outbursts and unexpected, impulsive aggressive acts and words, but that he was, on the whole, showing real signs of progress. We agreed to continue with play therapy (I had already asked Joe if he wanted to continue) for a further eight sessions.
In the next two months, Joe had two more appointments with the psychiatrist, who decided not to prescribe ADHD medication, but to review in six months, after play therapy had ended. Joe continued to use every play therapy session to the full. His themes began to move toward resolution, or partial resolution. The theme “powerful vs. powerless” all but disappeared, to be replaced with “Fair vs. unfair”. In his penultimate session Joe moved further along with this, becoming a friendly “coach” to me, instead of a fierce competitor. The theme “injury vs. restitution” was still present, but there was rescue, healing and kindness in place of revenge. Joe’s play became more age appropriate and coherent. He could start a story and follow it for up to 30 minutes. He continued to enjoy soothing play with sand and water, but even this was more as an 8-year-old than a toddler. We had some shared giggles and jokes.
Mary and I met once more a couple of weeks before Joe’s last session. We celebrated his progress and were realistic about his remaining difficulties and vulnerabilities. Joe’s presenting problems had all decreased in intensity and frequency, but there were occasional “blips”. Mary said she would be pleased if he did not need medication as she did not believe it was the answer. I said it was part of the answer for some children, that there was a huge variation. Joe’s needs might change as he grew older. Mary said she would like to do “feelio therapy” but just couldn’t see how right now because of the younger children. I said that it could be an option for the future. If Joe needed more play therapy, then filial therapy could be very helpful. In his penultimate session Joe talked to me about home and school more than ever before. He said he was a bit bored with play therapy and did not need to come any more. Then he helped me with my ball skills and goalie skills. He came for his final session and revisited all his main themes and play stories. A mummy teddy had a baby teddy and they had a brief cuddle – I was so happy for that baby! Joe’s play had a different quality to it now: even when revisiting themes, he was relaxed and truly playful. Joe skipped from the room at the end, and as he and Mary left, he gave me a quick hug.
Dramatherapy
Joe had eighteen further sessions with two reviews during that time. He seemed to be calmer in sessions and at home and, while he still had outbursts of anger, he recovered more quickly and was beginning to be able to talk about his feelings. His outbursts seemed to happen most when he experienced feelings of failure or rejection. Children like Joe often experience powerful feelings of shame, linked to their early experiences, which may be projected outwards towards others in anger. Joe continued to find school difficult. He would refuse to do work, throwing equipment onto the floor; he quickly got frustrated and became verbally or physically aggressive if children did not want to play with him or if they did not follow his directions in games. I talked with Mary and with Joe’s teacher about managing Joe’s feelings of shame and naming the difficult feelings he might be experiencing when he was unable to complete a task at school or when he broke a toy at home. This strategy avoided re-shaming him by using behavioural consequences for actions resulting from emotions that he struggled to manage. It also helped him learn to identify and regulate his powerful feelings.
In sessions, Joe continued to start the session by hiding things in the sand although sometimes only in passing. At other times became absorbed in playing with the sand and would remain focussed on it without speaking for long periods of time. This was a change from the ‘busyness’ that Joe had demonstrated in earlier sessions. It suggested lower levels of anxiety and decreased vigilance.
I encouraged Joe to become more aware of his emotional state during the sessions by asking him the colour of the feelings in his tummy. As a dramatherapist, I work with images, characters and stories created in the unconscious. By asking Joe about the colour rather than the name of the feeling, Joe was able to remain working in his unconscious rather than trying to answer a question about feelings which he often struggled to articulate. There were times in the work when it felt appropriate for me to name the feeling I thought was associated with the colour, at other times, I stayed with the metaphor of the colour and perhaps linked it with a physical movement or sensation. An aspect of the work with this client group is to facilitate the development of emotional awareness, of linking the physical sensations related to feelings to the name of the feeling, enabling the child to begin to communicate with words rather than behaviour. The body holds memories and emotions and part of the work of a dramatherapist is to facilitate connection between the body and the mind and to release feelings held within the body.
Joe’s ‘fill me up’ theme moved into ‘containing the mess’. Joe would pour paint into containers until it overflowed. Joe explored the physical sensation of his hands in the paint and smearing the paint around paper, often sliding off the edges onto the table. I would physically contain the mess using a piece of paper, a tray or a larger container; this containment of the mess was important, through the metaphor, giving Joe the message that I could contain him and hold his big ‘messy’ feelings.
Joe returned frequently to familiar stories which altered slightly over the time we worked together. Joe’s monster appeared often in sessions; Joe drew the monster, named it and we explored what colour it was, how it moved and what noises it made. He sometimes inhabited the monster in role and sometimes played with the monster projectively. Through play, he explored caging the monster, feeding the monster and stroking it. Joe had externalised and given a separate identity to an aspect of himself which was very powerful and at times, when he was angry, seemed to take him over. Through externalising the monster, Joe was able to separate the monster from himself and not overwhelmed by it. He could explore what the monster needed and wanted and ways that he could gain mastery over it. This work was all done through metaphor, again avoiding the re-shaming experience of talking about Joe’s behaviour when he was angry. After one session, Joe spoke about the monster to Mary in the waiting room; Mary and I had spoken about the monster’s significance for Joe and she was able to show her support to show in managing the monster and also wonder about why the monster was so angry and what he might need to feel less angry. Mary was able to demonstrate some empathy with the angry monster and did not reject it, reflecting to Joe that she understood why the monster might be so cross sometimes.
Joe also engaged with baby play, initially with toy animals and then with dolls. He would give a baby doll to me and tell me it was crying and that I should make the noise. I would cry for the baby, and I would hold the baby and comfort it, speaking softly and gently. Joe watched these moments intently, he did not want to hold the baby or make crying noises; these painful experiences were projected into me so he could experience them at a safe distance. Mary reported that at home he had taken a baby bottle belonging to one of her younger children and wanted a drink in it. Mary was sensitive to Joe’s needs and offered him time cuddled up with her drinking from the bottle. Joe was beginning to explore some of his unmet early needs and was seeking out experiences to meet these needs. Joe’s increasing capacity to regulate his feelings and his desire to have ‘baby time’ with Mary suggested an increasing attachment to her that was helping him feel more secure. I explored with Mary the possibility of
giving him something of hers that he could take to school with him and keep in his pocket; a transitional object to help him experience being held in mind whilst away from her. She agreed this with Joe’s teacher and Joe started to take a frog finger puppet to school in his pocket (Mary collected frogs of all shapes and sizes). If he was having difficulties at school, he was encouraged to put the puppet on his finger and know that Mary was thinking about him1. There were ongoing discussions about whether Joe had ADHD. As mentioned previously, the presenting behaviours for ADHD are very similar to behaviours shown by children who have traumatic attachment histories. Joe had an appointment with a paediatrician who diagnosed Joe as having ADHD but, as Joe was showing some progress, did not prescribe medication but arranged a review session for Joe in 6 months time. Through our conversations, Mary was able to view Joe’s ADHD type behaviours as serving a purpose and a need in him and was better able to help him manage. Mary’s commitment to Joe, supporting his regular attendance and her willingness to take on different ways of thinking about Joe’s behaviour were significant in the progress he made during the sessions. There is not a dramatherapy equivalent to filial therapy but as a dramatherapist, I work closely with parents or carers who are not present in sessions to contain them and support them to understand the child’s internal world and to help them unpack the emotional impact of parenting a child with needs like Joe’s. Within this work, there is an ongoing balance between
maintaining
client
confidentiality
and
working effectively with parents and carers to support the children in their care.
After 20 sessions, it was decided that Joe had made good progress and that the work would end. Initially, Joe’s response to this was anger and hurt. He experienced the ending as being rejected by me as he had been rejected by others in his life. Joe stood by the door, threatening to leave and shouting at me that I was leaving him, just like all the others and that I hadn’t ever liked him. Previously he had been left with these painful, rejected feelings without any space to process them but we had a further 4 sessions to work with these feelings and prepare to end. Joe ‘practised’ the ending through his stories; characters left, went away and disappeared. Sometimes Joe’s stories did not end and would carry over into following sessions and I wondered with Joe if there would be any unfinished stories. Joe responded saying that he would keep thinking about his stories and that I would too. I understood from this that Joe knew he would be held in mind by me, even when he was not coming for sessions anymore. I was able to explore with Joe his increased resilience and his increasing capacity to know what he needed to do in sessions. Our last session was a party, a celebration of the work and our relationship; Joe revisited favourite activities and toys. At the end Joe very officially shook my hand and stated that we’d had some good times and he left smiling.
Conclusion
It was not our expectation or hope to be able to make clear and bold statements about what is the same and what it different in the practice of these two therapies. What is clear is that at the centre of both therapies is the belief that if children are given a space and an attuned therapist, they will follow their own process, they will do what they need to do to make sense of their experiences and their relationships. It is what play therapists and dramatherapists do with the child’s material that seems to be different. Could it be said that a play therapist bears witness, observes, notices and reflects the feelings and themes in a child’s play? And a dramatherapist enters the play and engages with the child’s unconscious material dramatically through working projectively or in role; the dramatherapist is a container for and provides structure around the child’s unconscious projections? Reading back over our articles it is clear that at times, either of the descriptions above could fit either therapist. In conclusion, there is no clear conclusion, so let us actively engage with the not knowing and long may the discussions continue …
References
1 Attachment, Trauma and Resilience (2002) Kate Cairns