A Review of the 25th FATAG Conference

A Review of the 25th FATAG Conference

The Prompt, December 2010 · by Marian Liebmann · page 12-14

The 25th Arts Therapies Forensic Conference was held on Friday 12th November 2010 at The Institute of Psychoanalysis in Maida Vale, London. The theme for the day was an exploration of the role of art therapy in helping offenders with anger issues and the speakers had each written a chapter for the book, Art Therapy and Anger, edited by Marian Liebmann, published by Jessica Kingsley (2008). This was a new venue for the conference and it provided a very pleasant and interesting environment. It has a modern, spacious interior and the walls are lined with artwork and photographs commemorating a number of eminent psychoanalysts, notably a bronze head of Sigmund Freud and photographs of toys used by Melanie Klein. A small charcoal drawing depicting ‘The Accusation of Oedipus’ (1952) by Ismond Rosen, added to the psychoanalytic theme. The conference was opened

by the Chair, Ruth Goodman

who described the format for

the day and introduced the

morning’s speakers. There

followed a series of presentations by five of the authors who had contributed to the

above

publication.

Marian

Liebmann began by introducing her rationale for the book and

mentioned

her

own

personal journey with anger.

She talked about her anger management work with offenders and with mental health groups. This included setting up a group incorporating CBT and art therapy. Whilst engaged in research for the book, Marian had concentrated on art therapists doing practical work with clients, and interviewed the therapists through networking. She explained how she found so many different views of anger and anger management, that she devised her own classification from the material she found in the chapters. She discussed different ways of offering practical advice, including an exploration of what anger means to people, keeping anger diaries, challenging perceptions, relaxation techniques, assertiveness training and the need to include mind, body and behaviour. Marian highlighted the importance of having an awareness of physical symptoms, which she stressed is crucial to understanding anger and levels of arousal. She went on to discuss the contribution of art therapy, with reference to violent offenders within a Community Mental Health Team, and presented two case studies, taking a look at client backgrounds and early family patterns of behaviour. Sue Pittam had contributed a chapter entitled ‘InsideOut/Outside-In: Art Therapy with Young Male Offenders in Prison’. She talked about the complexities of anger in a prison environment; how it can sometimes be explosive and is often an expression of trauma caused by separation and loss. It can also reduce the ability to have relationships, which may be expressed through self-harm, especially following arrival into prison when an offender’s anger may often become compounded. Sue explained how working with anger issues can be effective in reducing anger, not only with the young offenders, but also between offenders and staff. Sue went on to discuss anger and the brain; how emotional response and

emotional energy is thought

to originate in the amygdala, a

small organ in the forebrain.

This primitive part of the

brain is believed to relate to

attachment and the fight or

flight reaction, triggered by

the survival function. Angry

behaviour is often manifested

when people have no other

way to express their feelings.

Sue

reported

that

when

clients

engaged

with

art

therapy, they were settled and were able to begin the cognitive learning process. She believes that by engaging that part of the brain, the work can help to reduce or even stop the offending behaviours as the orbital frontal cortex stores feelings such as sadness, shame and guilt. She finished with a short case study in which the client depicted himself inside the containment of a boat and became aware of his own change of feelings.

Hannah Godfrey presented ‘Androcles and the Lion: Prolific Offenders on Probation’ in which she described individual art therapy work with young and adult offenders. Hannah’s young clients were referred for offences such as repeated car theft and drug issues. She used Aesop’s fable as a metaphor to highlight the painful and debilitating nature of unresolved anger which, like the thorn in the lion’s paw, needs handling with care and delicacy so as not to cause further pain and anguish to already damaged clients. Hannah discussed anger and offending as a social construction A Review of the 25th FATAG Conference by Jill Ogilvy (A 3rd yr art therapy student at University of Hertfordshire, currently on placement at a medium secure private hospital.)

of masculinity and how this is inherent in offending; for example, a young male offender who has limited access to legitimate forms of wealth and status may steal or be violent in order to meet his gender role expectations to ‘provide’ and ‘protect’. Violent and destructive offences may be viewed as a form of ‘acting out’, or a ‘replacement of thought by action’. Clients may sabotage their progress through inappropriate and passive expressions of anger, such as non-compliance with a probation licence, substance misuse, self-harm etc. and could be seen as an expression of angry feelings that cannot be easily articulated elsewhere. Two case studies illustrated different aspects of the work; the first described the assessment of a violent offender who was not ready to give up his anger and was therefore unsafe to work with; the second described the way art therapy was used to help a client explore his family dynamics and become aware of the anger which lay behind his offending. In assessment, Hannah asks herself the question, ‘how useful and instrumental has anger been to the client and can they really choose to give this up?’ I liked the way she described the paradox of anger as being like ‘trying to extract a tooth without opening the mouth’, or ‘dredging a pond without disturbing the surface’ because it is difficult to engage a client without him becoming angry.

In her chapter, Kate Rothwell posed the question, ‘What Anger? Working with Acting-out Behaviour in a Secure Setting’. She sees the role of art therapy as preparing her client to address the issues surrounding their anger, since they often have dissociated themselves from it. Kate described how it can take a good length of time for a client to arrive at the point of recognising their anger through art therapy work. Rather than discuss her book chapter, Kate chose to present a film in which she reviews the work of a male client, a participant in an arts and drama recovery group. In the film, the client is articulate in discussing his work in an exhibition. He was an arsonist, so fire was a recurring theme in his work and he used this to express anger and difficult issues that had built up over several years. Most of his images represented different aspects of a volcano with ash spurting out into the air, explosions, fires burning, etc. Some depicted droplets of water, like a fountain extinguishing the fire and Kate wondered whether the anger has to be extinguished, or whether it can still exist without this. The film showed the client calmly discussing aspects of his work with the therapist and it was clear that he had been able to distance himself from the artwork and reflect back on his feelings of anger. Kate described how he had covered a lot of ground over a four-year period and had arrived at a point at which he was able to recognise his anger and has a safe space in which he can be angry without losing control. The image came to define the moment where he made connections to his index offence and to his personal relationships.

Simon Hastilow presented ‘Avoided Anger; Art and Music Therapy in a Medium Secure Setting’. This involved looking at the way in which art therapy and music therapy are used in parallel with a client who expressed anger through arson. Simon also looked at the changes in the use of these two therapy methods before and after a decision to transfer the client to a long-term unit, and the way in which the therapies could be used to facilitate endings safely. The client was a man in his 50’s who denied having angry feelings. He drank heavily to get in touch with his feelings rather than to mask them, but denied being an alcoholic. His referral to another unit enabled him to develop his engagement in both art and music therapy before the move took place. Initially, he used the art materials to make huge pencil drawings of buildings with lots of detail over several weeks. His discussion, like his drawings were about trivial things. He progressed to chalky pastels to make landscapes, which became more communicative of affect in his attempts to describe feelings. In music therapy, his playing was tentative, but he stopped playing when his father died. He was able to tolerate silences and began to rely on verbal interaction. He made tentative connections between childhood events and self-harm, although he did not make a conscious link between the transfer and being sent away to boarding school. He used both therapies to process suicidal thoughts arising from the decision to move him, also to explore the loss of the therapists and feelings of anger about being transferred. In this way he had the opportunity to process the ending of his therapies. FATAG Business

Before moving on to FATAG business, delegates took time out to catch up with friends and colleagues over lunch. A delicious spread was provided by vegetarian specialist Leon Lewis.

Kate Rothwell then reported that she had recently attended the seminar; Quality Network for Forensic Mental Health Services: Forensic Psychiatry in the Economic Downturn: Efficiency savings and maintaining quality. It was run by the Royal College of Psychiatrists. The commissioner had predicted Arctic conditions over a 4-5 year period. She said we should know that working groups are being sent out to review NHS and private hospital establishments and that they were looking for the delivery of quality, user satisfaction and developing useful outcomes. The Commissioning for Quality and Innovation (CQUIN) relates to payment by results and each contract needs evidence of how we are fulfilling that contract, so there is a strong need to evidence the work. The report to be

aware of from the Royal College of Psychiatrists is the ‘Looking Ahead’ report.

Kate then drew our attention to some forthcoming conferences next year, notably The International Association for Forensic Psychotherapy in association with Respond, entitled Strange Fascination: Disability Psychotherapy in Forensic Settings, to be held on Friday 11th February 2011.

Everyone then joined the committee in congratulating Marian on completing her doctorate; Dr Marian Liebmann was presented with a bottle of champagne and an orchid, with a card signed by the members. Following her acceptance of these items, Marian announced that she had also been delighted to be honoured by her NHS Mental Health Trust who had presented her with a lifetime achievement award. Ruth Goodman was then presented with an orchid in appreciation of her work as Chair of FATAG. Afternoon Workshops

Delegates were offered a choice of three workshops held in the adjoining rooms; ‘Art therapy and Anger’, with Marian Liebmann, ‘Using Masks in Anger Work’ with Hannah Godfrey and a discussion based on the morning’s presentation with Kate Rothwell and Sue Pittam. I attended the first workshop, as I was interested to learn how Marian’s anger exercises worked in practice. She began by asking us to consider ‘What is anger?’ then we made artwork in response to this, before discussing it with a partner and in group. After this, Marian took us through a meditation, asking us to think about a recent incident that made us feel angry. We unpeeled the layers of feeling and considered what had caused the anger. We then made another artwork and discussed it with a different partner, before returning to group for a more open discussion. The workshop was held in a space adjoining the auditorium. It had soft lighting and was decorated with large cool images of the Arctic by photographer Dan Welldon, in stark contrast to the hot and fiery images of our anger artwork!

Plenary

Mario Guarnieri facilitated the large group discussion about the day, which included reflections about the complexities of anger and its’ many layers of meaning, which often caused it to be misunderstood. It was observed how anger may be felt not only by our clients but also by therapists and the wider community. A discussion developed surrounding anger in the workplace, and how it can manifest itself between management and staff. A parallel was drawn between the issue of anger and the recent student protests surrounding the proposed increase in university fees. It was noted how there seems to be a lot of anger and anxiety in the community, as people are generally worried about their jobs with the proposed funding cuts. Students like myself in their final year of study expressed their concerns and wondered how long they may take to find work following graduation. We were reminded that arts therapists have always been encouraged and indeed successful in finding their own niche and creating a role for themselves, and it was hoped we would continue to succeed in this. Conclusion

I was struck by how often the image of a volcano came up in client’s artwork and how appropriate a metaphor it is for anger. It seems to fit with people’s perception of the emotion of anger and how it can best be represented visually. Anger like the volcano, can brew beneath the surface for some time, before suddenly erupting. As it explodes outwards, spreading mayhem and wreaking havoc in its wake, it can present an extremely frightening image, and understandably could be very scary for the client to consider. A volcano will spurt its angry lumps of molten rock and red-hot lava over a considerable period of time, before lying dormant, perhaps to erupt again or eventually burn itself out, which could take some years. Art therapy can provide a powerful solution to helping clients with issues surrounding the highly complex and forceful emotion of anger. The presentations and workshops demonstrated a diversity of approaches to anger management since art therapists differ in their theoretical orientation and in their practice. Many work from a psychodynamic perspective but there are also those who work in humanistic and cognitive ways. As the presentations illustrated, the use of art materials is a common denominator in bringing together all the contributors and can make an effective difference in working with anger. Thanks are due to Katie Smith for her superb chairing of this conference.

More posts

edition Diary Dates

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 32-33 DIARY DATES 2023 January 2023 Closing date for the BADth Gordon Wiseman Trust Fund. Details in Members’ area.…

The Prompt – final

The Prompt, December 2022 · page 22-31 Dear Jane, As a long-standing supporter of the publication, I write this open letter to thank you for…

people-caused climate destruction A Farewell Scenario

The Prompt, December 2022 · by EXCLUSIVE TO ARTS THERAPISTS · page 17-21 A FAREWELL SCENARIO 1996–2022 Scenario Arts in Personal Development was founded in…
account android arrow-alt-circle-down arrow-alt-circle-left arrow-alt-circle-right arrow-alt-circle-up arrow-down arrow-left arrow-right arrow-up author bars behance blogger bluesky buffer caret-down caret-left caret-right caret-square-down caret-square-left caret-square-right caret-square-up caret-up cart-menu-1 cart-menu-2 cart-menu-3 cart-menu-4 categories chevron-down chevron-left chevron-right chevron-up clock close comments cookies copyright coupon-discount date-modified date-published discord double-arrows-down double-arrows-left double-arrows-right double-arrows-up dribbble envelope-open envelope eye facebook fax flickr foursquare github gmail google-drive grid-view hashtag hollow-ring homepage instagram ios level-down-alt level-up-alt line link linkedin list-view login logout long-arrow-alt-down long-arrow-alt-left long-arrow-alt-right long-arrow-alt-up mastodonmedium messenger mobile-menu mobile phone pinterest place qq quote-left quote-right quotes reading-time-hourglass reading-time-stopwatch reddit rss scroll-to-top search shazam shopping-bag shopping-cart side-panel-opening-2-left side-panel-opening-2-right side-panel-opening-left side-panel-opening-right skype slack small-arrow-down small-arrow-left small-arrow-right small-arrow-up sms snapchat soundcloud spinner spotify stackoverflow sync telegram threadstiktok times-circle tinder trello tripadvisor tumblr twitch twitter viber vimeo vine vkontakte website wechat whatsapp windows wishlist xing yelp youtube zoom