June 2015
As a UK multi-professional regulator of 16 professions with more than 332,000 individuals on our Register, the Health and Care Professions Council (HCPC) has over the years worked to build a record in ‘proactive’ regulation. This includes a focus on research and data analysis to help prevent issues from arising in the future. We have recently published a report ‘Preventing small problems becoming big problems in health care’ which illustrates this approach. This work aimed to explore in more detail the reasons behind some of the complaints against health and social care professionals. Evidence from across health and care regulators shows that around half to three quarters of complaints are conduct related, for example, poor communication, or issues of probity, and the number of these kinds of complaints are rising across all health and care professions in the UK. We know that there are negative consequences for both the complainants and the professionals
involved
in
bringing
complaint of this sort to the attention of a regulatory body. These include emotional and psychological costs, as the professional may not return to the work for which they have been trained, and the complainant may never feel able to trust the health care system again.
Looking at competence
in a different way
The first part of the report is a literature review by Professor Zubin Austin of the University of Toronto. His review explored the
complexities
of
competence,
and
concluded that the dominant narrative in the field is frequently around technical aspects rather than the interpersonal and ethical aspects of competence that so often give rise to complaints.
Austin demonstrates how constructs around teamwork,
emotional
intelligence
and
engagement may enable health and care to shift closer to a model that is fit for purpose in the twenty first century. He suggests that traditional checklist approaches to assessing competency may still be necessary, but are not sufficient as the complexity of health and care increases and patients and service users expect a different relationship with professionals. The review also points to an important message about staff engagement: where professionals are supported and engaged, patient and service user outcomes are better and quality improves. An exploration of
professional disengagement The second part of the work by ChristensenMoore and Walsh at the Picker Institute was a qualitative mixed method study. This comprised a retrospective analysis of a sample of fitness to practise cases, and interviews with users and professionals about the triggers for disengagement in the workplace and the potential ways in which these might be mitigated.
The study identified links between poor supervisory
structures,
lack
of
peer
support, professional isolation, workload management problems, and incremental disengagement
from
practise.
The
researchers observed a continuum of disengagement, for example, in routine elements of practice such as absence of note taking and poor record keeping, to long standing dysfunctional working relationships and lack of peer support, all of which could give rise to more serious consequences. Preventing small problems
becoming big problems in
health and social care
June 2015
Participants believed it was possible for personal engagement to impact on competence, and for this to have consequences for practise. And they also thought that the character, nature or personal values of a professional, as well as the support, supervision and workload pressures could all have an impact.
Christensen-Moore and Walsh concluded that identifying triggers for disengagement early on was possible in the right circumstances, for example where a culture of no blame was encouraged, where professional networks were strong and where managers were offering support for staff. Understanding ‘flow’
Another important influence on our work in this area comes from Csikszentmihilyi (1990), who has looked at the connection between
environment,
motivation
and
performance. He suggests that human beings experience ‘flow’ when environmental challenges and opportunities align with personal skills and interests. Where professionals experience high levels of challenge and limited use of skills then apathy and disengagement are more likely to arise. If a professional experiences no ‘flow’ in their work, this can often spill over into incompetency, and lead to a complaint. This can often be related to poor support and supervision.
Next steps
We will be using the outcomes of this research in our workshops with employers, educators and professionals to generate debate about how disengagement might be prevented. Our previous workshops on professionalism have been welcomed as a catalyst for change and as a contribution to wider discussions on ways of promoting professionalism (Morrow et al, 2009). It is often the difficult conversations with clinicians – the conversations about ethical aspects of practise – that uncover long standing contextual,
interpersonal
or
communication issues which may well prevent small problems from becoming big problems later on.
My hope is that this new research will help to generate more activities at the reflective end of the spectrum, and reduce the activities at
the
regulatory
end.
Creating
opportunities for reflection and honest conversations with trusted colleagues can be a means of addressing problems early on. It is in everyone’s interest to prevent harm, to reduce complaints, and to see more emphasis on support, kindness and compassion in health and care. This is just as important for professionals as it is for service users, patients and their families. Anna van der Gaag
Acknowledgements
The HCPC would like to thank Professor Zubin Austin at the University of Toronto and Carol Christensen-Moore and Joan Walsh at the Picker Institute Oxford, for collaborating with us on this work. References
Austin, Z., Christensen-Moore, C., Walsh, J. (2015) Preventing small problems from becoming big problems in health and care. www.hcpc-uk.org
Csikszentmihilyi,
M.
(1990)
Flow:
the
psychology of optimal experience. New York: Avon Books.
Morrow, G. et al, (2009). Professionalism in healthcare professionals www.hcpc-uk.org
June 2015
MANY CONGRATULATIONS TO OUR STUDENT MEMBERS WHO HAVE NOW GRADUATED AND REGISTERED WITH THE HCPC. THEY ARE NOW FULL MEMBERS OF BADth: Jade Gillies, Wheatley, Oxfordshire BADth WELCOMES THE FOLLOWING NEW MEMBERS Full members
Paria Motiee-Tehrani, London Elizabeth Palmer, London
Rachel Perry, Bath, Somerset Laura Scott, Cirencester, Gloucestershire Larissa Sherman, London
Student members
Alison MacDonald, Hampton Wick, Surrey Dorcas Ore-Ofe Olatunji, Dagenham, Essex Jennifer Pullan, London
Frederick Smith, London
Juliet Stephens, London
Victoria Townsend, Canterbury, Kent
June 2015