Arts in Health Meeting:
Oxford – 22nd February 2012
I represented BADth at this meeting which was designed to consult with interested parties about the creation of the National Alliance for Arts, Health and Wellbeing. The discussions were intended to inform those drafting a founding charter for the organisation. Below are the notes from Alexandra Coulter, Director of Arts and Health South West who organised the meeting.
As a dramatherapist in this context I became aware of some key issues which affect us as professionals: (i) What are the boundaries of practise between arts in health practitioners and arts therapists? Who defines these differences and why do they matter?
(ii) Employability. Why employ an arts therapist rather than an arts in health practitioner? As we see increasingly, the commissioning process opens up these questions as employment opportunities become
more
competitive.
How
do
Dramatherapists argue the importance of difference without becoming proprietorial? How do we collaborate with professionals from other disciplines and practices but maintain the significant contribution that we can make?
These questions create practical and theoretical challenges which we cannot avoid. Anna Seymour
April 2012
National Alliance for Arts, Health and Wellbeing Current developments and common ground February 22nd 2012 – Oxford
Notes from the morning session
What is surprising you?
v Surprising that ACE (Arts Council England) is still putting money into strategic work v Seem to be opportunities opening up, perhaps because of well-being agenda v More health organisations are seeing the benefits and buying in v Prevention agenda and management of long-term conditions an opportunity – well-being even if you are ill
v More people prepared to move outside professional silos (silos refers to people working in their own field with colleagues, but not communicating across sectors or even departments within the same organisation) v Realising that Arts and Health is not on the edge anymore v Better positive coverage in the media – more confidence v Practitioner interest
v Student interest and understanding v Tipping point – public demand v Greater understanding of prevention and recovery – fits with what we do v Increased offers of voluntary support v ACE not willing to lead – have passed this to the alliance v People accept the connection between art and situations of crisis v Arts and community health is well established v Institutions accept the benefit to patients and in some cases fund it v Has evidence base made the difference? v Governments interest in happiness/well-being v Participation and collaboration between sectors v Buoyancy of debate – range of work happening not funded through arts
v Localism and communities driving movements v Making bridge ‘health and ‘arts’ worlds v Zeitgeist – interest in this work – how do we harness this? What is challenging you?
v Budget cuts in the NHS
v Medical model
v Pressures on NHS staff
v Narrow definition of evidence v Making own tools fit evidence needs v Putting back creativity in education v Multiplicity of cultures and visions of health and of arts v No strategic or national leadership v NHS jargon
v ACE definitions
v Move to GPs control challenges preventative model and encourages conservatism v Recognition of culture as worthwhile activity v No reference in planning – O.N.S (Office of National Statistics) v Arts are in a silo
v Value placed on product not process v Unwillingness of Government/ACE to commit funds v Identifying champions/advocates and getting them into the same room v Finding ways to speak and be heard v Cuts to arts projects
v Evidence base – developing methodologies v Capacity
v Tension between local and national What are your priorities?
v Research evidence
v Inspirational research
v Excellence in quality of practice & training investment v Advocacy with the health sector and public attitudes v Every arts organisation should see well-being as a priority v Looking for useful models e.g. Creative Scotland v A national role inclusive across the arts links with health and well-being v Challenging GP/patient relationship v Getting info to GPs
v NICE to help put tools in front of GPs v Policy/lobbying
v Arts Development is developing an arts consortium for GPs to access v Get the powers that be to meet v Doors open with cross-bench peers in Lords v Development / growth of the evidence base – challenge how it is presented v Widening recognition – press – public campaigns v Grassroots movements and work v Lobbying
v Evaluation – in an easily searchable format v Directory of work done / network v Broadening scope of well-being v Platform for the argument
v A continuum – showcasing and emphasising the value – seen as one sector v The case is being made but we need to make sure culture is included in agendas v Balanced evidence base that appeals to different audiences v Tipping point – greater awareness – moment to seize! v More cost benefit analysis / social return as standard practice v Unpicking ‘quality’ and ‘excellence’ in practice – professional skilling
April 2012