December 2016
It has been great to receive the latest editions of Dramatherapy this year – full and thought-provoking articles as ever. But I have a query regarding the dating of these two editions. Although both (Volume 37, Number 1 and Numbers 2–3) were published in 2016, they have the dates of March 2015 and July–November 2015 on them. In the March ‘2015’ edition, I co-wrote a clinical comment with Roundabout colleagues, and the project written about did not finish until March 2015, so for those who were part of the project, it would seem rather strange that it is written about in a journal with the same date that we had completed the work. However, I thought that this would only impact relatively few people, so did not query it. However, with the current edition, released in November 2016, but dated as July–November 2015, it is rather more obvious that the dates do not match up. Your editorial talks about Brexit – the UK referendum that happened in June 2016. There are also references in your editorial and in one of the articles, to information published in 2016. Unless we are time-travellers, this makes no sense, and although now it can be dismissed as me being rather pedantic, I think in years to come there could be confusion over these dates. I do appreciate that, with my editorial hat on, occasionally an edition of The Prompt has been dated the month earlier than it has arrived in members’ inboxes….. So my wondering is: what is the reasoning behind these anomalies of dates.
With kind regards and much thanks for all the work that you do in editing Dramatherapy.
Jane Jackson
Correspondence regarding
Dramatherapy, the Journal of BADth,
with permission to publish in The Prompt
Dear Anna,
December 2016
Thank you for writing to me and raising these concerns. Let me first say that I do not think your queries are ‘pedantic’ but a genuine expression of care for what we do. The reason for the anomalies with dates is that whilst there is a production schedule each year, if there is not sufficient publishable material available for the due date then the deadline cannot be met. This means that we go into a ‘backlog’ situation. Each year there is a requirement to produce three editions that form a volume and close that year. When we are behind, the system is still in operation so the edition numbers will correspond to the next editions in the sequence. This has meant therefore that editions have not corresponded with publication dates. I accept that has caused some confusion and needs thinking about for future editions. There are different points in the process where things can get held up. The review process can be time consuming since, as a peer reviewed journal, each article is normally looked at by two reviewers. Sometimes however the process becomes attenuated when one review comes in but another is either delayed or the reviewer takes time to respond to the request to review and then decides not to undertake it. There is then the process whereby the reviews are sent back to the author with recommendations made for changes in the article. The changes requested can range from addressing more closely the dramatherapy literature on a topic to attending to the structuring of the material to thinking further about the content and making it relevant to a Dramatherapy readership. Sometimes authors decide at this point to do no further work on the article which means it will not go forward to publication. There has also been an issue with the flow of articles and the editorial board is working on initiatives to encourage submissions, like the Writers’ Mentorship Scheme due to run in 2017 and a one day event in July 2017 on writing collaboratively. The training institutions are also encouraging their graduates to think about writing an article based on their final dissertations/portfolios. I hope this goes some way to answering your queries Jane and thank you for writing to me.
With all best wishes
Anna Seymour, Editor, Dramatherapy
Dear Jane,